| I can't find it in the FAQ or main page, is there a minimum length for manga? |
Pyrii said: I can't find it in the FAQ or main page, is there a minimum length for manga? No, there isn't unless stated like #70 Read a manga series you can finish in one day, you can't use oneshot for this item but others are acceptable. |
  |
| Hello! Can someone recommend me a manga for challenge 60? Any genre is fine. |
 |
Ecstrinsic said: Hello! Can someone recommend me a manga for challenge 60? Any genre is fine. Hello, if you don't mind with quite long chapters, these are my recommendations! https://myanimelist.net/manga/35171/Cant_See_Cant_Hear_But_Love https://myanimelist.net/manga/12888/Hapi_Mari__Happy_Marriage https://myanimelist.net/manga/33031/Imawa_no_Kuni_no_Alice https://myanimelist.net/manga/407/Life https://myanimelist.net/manga/77891/The_Friendly_Winter |
xichengsApr 19, 2017 2:15 AM
| |
makotoed said: Ecstrinsic said: Hello! Can someone recommend me a manga for challenge 60? Any genre is fine. Hello, if you don't mind with quite long chapters, these are my recommendations! https://myanimelist.net/manga/35171/Cant_See_Cant_Hear_But_Love https://myanimelist.net/manga/12888/Hapi_Mari__Happy_Marriage https://myanimelist.net/manga/33031/Imawa_no_Kuni_no_Alice https://myanimelist.net/manga/407/Life https://myanimelist.net/manga/77891/The_Friendly_Winter I might try out Imawa no Kuni or The Friendly Winter. Thanks for the recs! |
|
| Hey looking for suggestion to number 31: Read a manga that has inspired or been adapted to cd drama Something nice and good... thanks for the help in advance. |
PunkChinaDollApr 21, 2017 10:31 AM
TakeruChan said: Hey looking for suggestion to number 31: Read a manga that has inspired or been adapted to cd drama Something nice and good... thanks for the help in advance. 7 seeds, Ouran host club, onanie master kurosawa, Seven Days(shounen Ai), Aria, Pandora Hearts, Hana to Akuma, Taiyo no Ie, Haruhi Suzumiya, Koukou Debut most everything else is yaoi. |
| Can I get a recommendation or two, please? Thank you! |
 |
AudioTsunami said: TakeruChan said: Hey looking for suggestion to number 31: Read a manga that has inspired or been adapted to cd drama Something nice and good... thanks for the help in advance. 7 seeds, Ouran host club, onanie master kurosawa, Seven Days(shounen Ai), Aria, Pandora Hearts, Hana to Akuma, Taiyo no Ie, Haruhi Suzumiya, Koukou Debut most everything else is yaoi. lady_freyja said: TakeruChan said: Hey looking for suggestion to number 31: Read a manga that has inspired or been adapted to cd drama Something nice and good... thanks for the help in advance. Since you've already read Zankoku and Hanshin, if you want to continue with the author : 11-nin Iru, Marginal and Poe no Ichizoku. For Poe, the scanlation is incomplete, but the manga is 100% episodical, meaning each chapter is independant from each other, so it's not really an issue. Other than that, I know that Girl Friends also has a drama CD. And I'm pretty sure there is plenty more manga valid for that challenge, even outside yaoi. Thank you very much both of you! |
| Hi, I would like to read a manga for this point Read a Historical, Military or Police manga as is not one of my favorite genres Thanks and XOXO |
FuyuNoHanaApr 22, 2017 12:57 PM
| @Toasted-Reason I'd recommend Annarasumanara , Hoshi no Samidare , Solanin and The Breaker from your plan to read list @FuyuNoHana Sanctuary is the best choice in my opinion other good mangas that I read: Shin Angyo Onshi , Innocent and Koukoku no Shugosha And I'd Also like a recommendation for challenge 60 preferably a completed manga no more than 16 volumes Thanks (: |
MegaMan-ZeroApr 22, 2017 1:41 PM
 |
MegaMan-Zero said: @Toasted-Reason I'd recommend Annarasumanara , Hoshi no Samidare , Solanin and The Breaker from your plan to read list @FuyuNoHana Sanctuary is the best choice in my opinion other good mangas that I read: Shin Angyo Onshi , Innocent and Koukoku no Shugosha And I'd Also like a recommendation for challenge 60 preferably a completed manga no more than 16 volumes Thanks (: Id recommend https://myanimelist.net/manga/39325/Boku_dake_ga_Inai_Machi 9 volumes and thanks |
Maffy said: Maffy said: Question! Do dancing and acting count for the "food, music or art" challenge? Since no one is answering, I'll take it as a yes since acting is part of the arts! *wooshes* Sorry for the wait, but sure. I'll count it. |
密室殺人はなぜ美しいのか。 |
| "44. Read a manga that deals with something related to Japanese culture" Does Me de Shireru Yoru no Junjou count, since it has to do with Edo period Yoshiwara and the whole red light district thing? |
xalistorxxApr 24, 2017 6:29 PM
| Thanks @tsuyokunaru c: Another question: https://myanimelist.net/manga/5968/Anastasia_Club This revolves mostly around real events and people (such as Russian royalty, Anastasia, Rasputin, Tchaikovsky) and using historical references to bring to light some "mysteries". Can it count for "51. Read a manga based on real event or person"? The main characters are fictional, but there are a lot of ties to real people and events which are explained throughout the story. |
   |
| @tsuyokunaru When I planned to read it, I didn't think it'd apply to this kind of challenge myself, but it was surprising that most chapters showed flashbacks or deductions of real people's actions, such as Russian royalty's downfall, Tchaikovsky's death, the existence of Anastasia, the Rasputin icons, relics here and there... Some things I hadn't really ever known myself, which made me wonder. Thanks for the answer <3 |
|
| Hey there, I need some help with these: 51. Read a manga based on real event or person 60. Read a manga recommended to you by another Manga Reading Challenge participant in the discussion thread I need stuff that's 5 or more volumes long for my length restriction on the challenge. I'd prefer stuff that's Slice of Life, Josei, or Seinen but I'll take a shot at anything if it catches my interest. Thank you in advance c: |
 |
Fresh_Mint said: Hey there, I need some help with these: 51. Read a manga based on real event or person 60. Read a manga recommended to you by another Manga Reading Challenge participant in the discussion thread I need stuff that's 5 or more volumes long for my length restriction on the challenge. I'd prefer stuff that's Slice of Life, Josei, or Seinen but I'll take a shot at anything if it catches my interest. Thank you in advance c: 51. Innocent, Adolf, Thermae Romae , Kingdom, Drifters 60 Natsu no Zenjitsu, Ran and the Grey World, |
Nekoutsu said: Barajou no Kiss. It's 42 chapters and got magic and really weird scenes that make it really fun and interesting.Hey can anyone recommend me your favorite mangas? |
  |
| Does this manga Shouwa Genroku Rakugo Shinjuu qualify for one set in Japan? Thanks! |
 |
only the first 11 chapters are translated, just so you know. IMO, you'd be better off watching the anime and reading something else for that challenge. |
AudioTsunami said: only the first 11 chapters are translated, just so you know. IMO, you'd be better off watching the anime and reading something else for that challenge. Oh thanks for that! :D |
|
| Can someone please recommend me something for #60 "Read a manga recommended to you by another Manga Reading Challenge participant in the discussion thread"? I would prefer a comedy manga with ten volumes or less. Thanks |
  |
| @extremeplant If you don't mind comedy not being the main genre then I'd recommend Spirit Circle or Hoshi no Samidare I'd also recommend Doubt! its got one of the best arts I've seen in a manga |
|
| Just another person dropping in for a rec from someone. I'd prefer a somewhat short horror or psychological manga. I don't care if it's on my plan to read, as you can tell there's so many on there anyways. |
 |
| Recommend me a manga |
ArmSt said: Recommend me a manga I highly recommend Imawa No Kuni No Alice! The atmosphere of tension is quite high so it's really enjoyable. It's a psychological-survival kind of manga so it won't get you bored. |
| |
| Hey there, I need some help with this: 60. Read a manga recommended to you by another Manga Reading Challenge participant in the discussion thread. |
thewilker said: Hey there, I need some help with this: 60. Read a manga recommended to you by another Manga Reading Challenge participant in the discussion thread. Read Waters, Wilker-san |
02 Read a manga that is a collection of short stories 20 Read a manga published between the 1970s and the 1980s 27 Read a manga one-shot that became a prototype for a longer series 41 Read a manga with a child MC I'm kinda new to the manga and I have no clue what to read for these tasks. Can you guys recommend me some finished manga? If possible, I'd like something well-received that is liked by most people who decide to read it, to put it bluntly something with a good score on MAL (but if you know any underappreciated manga that you think would suit my taste then feel free to recommend them too). Anything will do except adventure shounens (like Naruto or FMA). |
fuyukiMay 7, 2017 12:45 PM
 |
| @lady_freyja Thanks! It helps a lot. Now, this one's left, anyone? 27 Read a manga one-shot that became a prototype for a longer series |
|
fuyuki said: @lady_freyja Thanks! It helps a lot. Now, this one's left, anyone? 27 Read a manga one-shot that became a prototype for a longer series Love Letters by Seo Kouji(Second story got adapted into a full length story), Naruto(one shot), haikyuu(one shot), Tokyo Ghoul(one shot), i'm sure there are some more in the FAQ. More options for your first question: 02: Akai Mi Hajiketa, Terrarium in Drawer 20 Lady Snowblood, Claudine 41: RRR(Aozora), Suiiki(i think chinami qualifies and Sumio definitely qualifies), Inai Boku wa Hotarumachi ni Iru |
| @AudioTsunami Thanks! I'll use the Tokyo Ghoul one-shot then (I totally didn't notice that they listed those one-shots in FAQ..I see it now). And thanks for other suggestions too, I've already chosen manga for 02, 20 and 41 but the manga you recommended sound interesting so I'll use some of them for other tasks. |
|
| I have a question in regards to the "set outside of Japan" category. I've been thinking about picking up Billy Bat and starting it from the very first chapter now that it is published in its entirety. But from what little recollection I have about the first 90 chapters or so, the story had flashbacks that take place in Japan. Still, the story takes place primarily in the United States, does it not? Does it qualify or should I look elsewhere? |
Eelyan said: I have a question in regards to the "set outside of Japan" category. I've been thinking about picking up Billy Bat and starting it from the very first chapter now that it is published in its entirety. But from what little recollection I have about the first 90 chapters or so, the story had flashbacks that take place in Japan. Still, the story takes place primarily in the United States, does it not? Does it qualify or should I look elsewhere? From the synopsis, it sounds like the story is primarily set in Japan. "The story is set in 1949 and follows Japanese-American comic book artist Kevin Yamagata as he draws the popular detective series "Billy Bat" for "Marble Comics." When he learns he may have unconsciously copied the character from an image he saw while serving in occupied Japan, he returns to Japan to get permission to use Billy Bat from its original creator. Upon arriving there, however, he becomes embroiled in a web of murder, cover-ups, and prophecy that all leads back to Billy Bat." |
| I have a large amount of manga on-hold and I was thinking of using this challenge to clear it out. If it makes any difference, for lots of them I've only read the first chapter or two. Can I use those manga? |
 Since I was young, I had believed that A princess in picture book is a strong person Things to be protected, and things I want to protect Will never be fulfilled, no matter how long, if I just kept dreaming Go ahead.jpg |
| @tsuyokunaru Ah, I see. Thanks for explaining! I think I'll just put them aside for now then haha. On another note, could someone suggest manga that has inspired/has been adapted to a CD drama and another one for number 60(read a manga recommended to you by another MRC participant)? |
| Since I was young, I had believed that A princess in picture book is a strong person Things to be protected, and things I want to protect Will never be fulfilled, no matter how long, if I just kept dreaming Go ahead.jpg |
| @Arasy Since you didn't mention length restrictions, I'll suggest https://myanimelist.net/manga/4/Yokohama_Kaidashi_Kikou It has been adapted to CD drama. If that's too long/doesn't interest you, you can also check this tag in Baka-Updates https://www.mangaupdates.com/series.html?category=Adapted+to+Drama+CD |
密室殺人はなぜ美しいのか。 |
AudioTsunami said: Eelyan said: I have a question in regards to the "set outside of Japan" category. I've been thinking about picking up Billy Bat and starting it from the very first chapter now that it is published in its entirety. But from what little recollection I have about the first 90 chapters or so, the story had flashbacks that take place in Japan. Still, the story takes place primarily in the United States, does it not? Does it qualify or should I look elsewhere? From the synopsis, it sounds like the story is primarily set in Japan. "The story is set in 1949 and follows Japanese-American comic book artist Kevin Yamagata as he draws the popular detective series "Billy Bat" for "Marble Comics." When he learns he may have unconsciously copied the character from an image he saw while serving in occupied Japan, he returns to Japan to get permission to use Billy Bat from its original creator. Upon arriving there, however, he becomes embroiled in a web of murder, cover-ups, and prophecy that all leads back to Billy Bat." Aww, dang. My menory is fuzzier than I thought, it would seem. I was pretty sure the story jumped a lot and all over the globe, with little time actually being spent in Japan. Would any of you guys be willing to recommend me some titles for the "set outside of Japan" category, then? No genre preferences, but I would like for the manga to be fully published. I appreciate your time, thanks! |
Eelyan said: AudioTsunami said: From the synopsis, it sounds like the story is primarily set in Japan. "The story is set in 1949 and follows Japanese-American comic book artist Kevin Yamagata as he draws the popular detective series "Billy Bat" for "Marble Comics." When he learns he may have unconsciously copied the character from an image he saw while serving in occupied Japan, he returns to Japan to get permission to use Billy Bat from its original creator. Upon arriving there, however, he becomes embroiled in a web of murder, cover-ups, and prophecy that all leads back to Billy Bat." Aww, dang. My menory is fuzzier than I thought, it would seem. I was pretty sure the story jumped a lot and all over the globe, with little time actually being spent in Japan. Would any of you guys be willing to recommend me some titles for the "set outside of Japan" category, then? No genre preferences, but I would like for the manga to be fully published. I appreciate your time, thanks! That might be true? Idk man, I haven't read it, I'm just judging from the synopsis, you can give it a read and make your own call, as long as you have a back up plan, but i havent read it and i'm not sure of @tsuyokunaru has. As far as other suggestions, Innocent(Sakamoto, Shinichi) is definitely not set in Japan and I think most of Subaru is not set in Japan. ColdNobility said: #61. Read a manga that another user has read for this challenge Has anyone read something on my plan to read list for this challenge or can recommend me something similar to my taste that they read? Unfortunately, I've read most the stuff on your PTR that I'm interested over the last 2 years and a couple are tough to get a hold of in English There's a lot of pretty popular stuff banging around on your list though so if you check a few sign up sheets you might find it? I know Yokohama Kaidashi Kikou was recommended two posts ago, so you might want to check with Arasy and see if they are using it. As for stuff I've already completed for this year's challenge you can look into Imawa no Kuni no Alice, Glaucos, Boku no Hero Academia, Kyuusen no Shima, I am a Hero, or Inai Boku wa Hotarumachi ni Iru And I'm currently readng Happy! by Naoki Urasawa and going to be reading Genkaku Picasso and Goggles. |
ColdNobility said: #61. Read a manga that another user has read for this challenge Has anyone read something on my plan to read list for this challenge or can recommend me something similar to my taste that they read? If you want i'm starting Billy Bat, which is on your PtR. (link to my challenge post) |
| @Eelyan I would say it's safer to not have the setting include Japan at all. As for suggestions for a manga that takes place outside of Japan, Emma and JoJo no Kimyou na Bouken Part 1: Phantom Blood both take place in Victorian England. Nineteen, -Sayonara Sorcier takes place in Paris in 1885. Twenty-One and Annarasumanara take place in South Korea. Monster takes place mostly in Germany, though maybe you've read that already. These are just suggestions though, you can choose something else, but if it doesn't include Japan at all, better (That's why I'm not mentioning Beck and Nodame Cantabile, for example). |
密室殺人はなぜ美しいのか。 |
#60. Read a manga recommended to you by another Manga Reading Challenge participant in the discussion thread So, ¿any recomendations? I really haven't any preferences so anything goes, i suppose. |
 |
More topics from this board
» Manga with nice double spreadRissio - 5 hours ago |
0 |
by Rissio
»»
5 hours ago |
|
» Thoughts on long manga?Chuckiemuffin - Feb 29 |
39 |
by 0am
»»
6 hours ago |
|
» Why do you think MAL users don't read manga? ( 1 2 )Nyron - Feb 7 |
58 |
by pludel2
»»
6 hours ago |
|
» How do I open up a chapter discussion for a manga?MedK001 - Today |
1 |
by Dumb
»»
Today, 2:37 AM |
|
» D.Gray-ManArhang - Jan 9, 2009 |
8 |
by orihihc
»»
Yesterday, 7:19 PM |