No Game No Life (light novel)
| I mean, NGNL has some good aspects (animation, OP), but also a ton to hate on, let me just list them: it's an ecchi, harem, lolicon anime; furthermore, the show is about the genius of two NEETs, but the show itself is rather unintelligent. |
| your waifu is shit |
| because it's "pandering" and therefore you have bad taste if you like it and you need to show that off by letting everyone know your standpoint or something like that, idk |
  |
| Actually NGNL was one of the most enjoyable animes I have seen. I completely understand that the characters are stupid, it has no ending but I get that this anime is meant entertainment and I just don't give a damn about other things. So all the 3,4,5 reviews are from people who wanted something intelligent and serious. |
 |
DrGeroCreation said: BlueXRam said: For real. I have been called an elitist, hipster and a person who doesn't like fun simply because I don't think it's that great.And people who enjoy the show call out anyone who doesn't like it. What point are you trying to make? It goes both ways. Hardly surprising. You're one of the most vocal 'haters' of NGNL on MAL. It's like you can't let it go and move on with your life. |
zetsubousei_hero said: By that logic, your opinion is just as pointless.Review mean little to nothing because it's based on the person opinion. |
 |
| lol@people saying NGNL is average; other than being a 13 episode incomplete adaptation, there's nothing average bout it if the average show was as awesome as NGNL, the world would be a better place |
 |
robis798 said: Actually NGNL was one of the most enjoyable animes I have seen. I completely understand that the characters are stupid, it has no ending but I get that this anime is meant entertainment and I just don't give a damn about other things. So all the 3,4,5 reviews are from people who wanted something intelligent and serious. I didn't want something intelligent and serious going in but I didn't want otaku pandering with lolis and reasoning that makes no sense. The characters are annoying not fun. Blank winning each round with logic pulled out of their ass is stupid, not fun. The only fun about the anime to me was the animation itself, nothing else. I don't find bath scenes with little girls fun, sorry. |
| Previously: BlueXRam |
| I will never understand why apparantly pandering = crap I mean every work of media is aimed towards a certain audience, why is that so weird or in any way a bad thing? |
| |
| Why is this thread not moved to NGNL box ? mod pls ... anyway no matter what score or rank NGNL will get in the end, it will be the cancer of 2014. The negative reviews are made to prevent it happening, so we should be happy if we really like the show |
BlueXRam said: robis798 said: Actually NGNL was one of the most enjoyable animes I have seen. I completely understand that the characters are stupid, it has no ending but I get that this anime is meant entertainment and I just don't give a damn about other things. So all the 3,4,5 reviews are from people who wanted something intelligent and serious. I didn't want something intelligent and serious going in but I didn't want otaku pandering with lolis and reasoning that makes no sense. The characters are annoying not fun. Blank winning each round with logic pulled out of their ass is stupid, not fun. The only fun about the anime to me was the animation itself, nothing else. I don't find bath scenes with little girls fun, sorry. Lol, read the tag 'ecchi'. At least all ecchi shows I have seen have been everything you just described. So why on earth would anyone go watch ecchi anime if you don't find anything fun in it. Besides it was a complete comedy from the start, no need to take everything seriously. And ecchi also. |
goodshitgoOdshitSep 28, 2014 6:54 AM
|
robis798 said: BlueXRam said: I didn't want something intelligent and serious going in but I didn't want otaku pandering with lolis and reasoning that makes no sense. The characters are annoying not fun. Blank winning each round with logic pulled out of their ass is stupid, not fun. The only fun about the anime to me was the animation itself, nothing else. I don't find bath scenes with little girls fun, sorry. Lol, read the tag 'ecchi'. At least all ecchi shows I have seen have been everything you just described. So why on earth would anyone go watch ecchi anime if you don't find anything fun in it. Besides it was a complete comedy from the start, no need to take everything seriously. And ecchi also. It wasn't doing anything new, all the show did was follow common tropes. And if it does what all other ecchi shows do then why does such a show deserve such amazing praise? You're describing it as being like every other ecchi show. That means its average. An average on MAL is a 5. From all the praise I thought it would be better than your average ecchi show (and not every ecchi show has to be bad, I'm sure there are many ones that are actually entertaining), but I couldn't find anything that stood out. I went in it knowing it knowing it was supposed to have comedy but I can't recall a single part where I ended up laughing. That in all is not a good anime for me. |
| Previously: BlueXRam |
HaXXspetten said: The problem is that NGNL is basically nothing but otaku pandering, it's a show that is the epitome of style over substance. It's basically everything that is wrong with the anime industry at the moment, but it was executed very well so it was hard to hate.I will never understand why apparantly pandering = crap I mean every work of media is aimed towards a certain audience, why is that so weird or in any way a bad thing? |
| Do NGNL fans get mad at "Hurr Durr Mondaiji Tachi clone fak NGNL not orgienal"? |
 |
xRatatosk said: Do NGNL fans get mad at "Hurr Durr Mondaiji Tachi clone fak NGNL not orgienal"? You're a fan, tell us. |
| Previously: BlueXRam |
BlueXRam said: xRatatosk said: Do NGNL fans get mad at "Hurr Durr Mondaiji Tachi clone fak NGNL not orgienal"? You're a fan, tell us. Not really a fan. I just enjoyed it. I'm not explaining my rating scale though. But to answer your question, no I wouldn't give a shit if I was a fan. |
|
JumpinJackCrash said: Praland said: Nothing weird here. |
"Hi!" |
xRatatosk said: Well there were many parallels to be drawn between them but Mondaiji-tachi's only real outstanding factor was the MC himself, whereas NGNL was more about the games themselves since the very laws of the world was based around it. Though they might have done roughly the same thing, NGNL does it so much *more* and more importantly a hell of a lot better. In the first place Mondaiji-tachi's conflicts weren't really much in the way of games.BlueXRam said: You're a fan, tell us. Not really a fan. I just enjoyed it. I'm not explaining my rating scale though. But to answer your question, no I wouldn't give a shit if I was a fan. |
| |
HaXXspetten said: xRatatosk said: Well there were many parallels to be drawn between them but Mondaiji-tachi's only real outstanding factor was the MC himself, whereas NGNL was more about the games themselves since the very laws of the world was based around it. Though they might have done roughly the same thing, NGNL does it so much *more* and more importantly a hell of a lot better. In the first place Mondaiji-tachi's conflicts weren't really much in the way of games.Not really a fan. I just enjoyed it. I'm not explaining my rating scale though. But to answer your question, no I wouldn't give a shit if I was a fan. I wasn't really serious, and if I was that doesn't really answer it anyways. |
|
xRatatosk said: well there are quite a few people who do think like that seriously at least :3HaXXspetten said: Well there were many parallels to be drawn between them but Mondaiji-tachi's only real outstanding factor was the MC himself, whereas NGNL was more about the games themselves since the very laws of the world was based around it. Though they might have done roughly the same thing, NGNL does it so much *more* and more importantly a hell of a lot better. In the first place Mondaiji-tachi's conflicts weren't really much in the way of games. I wasn't really serious, and if I was that doesn't really answer it anyways. |
| |
| So its ok, everywhere have to be balance. |
Well I feel bad for those people. |
|
BlueXRam said: robis798 said: Lol, read the tag 'ecchi'. At least all ecchi shows I have seen have been everything you just described. So why on earth would anyone go watch ecchi anime if you don't find anything fun in it. Besides it was a complete comedy from the start, no need to take everything seriously. And ecchi also. It wasn't doing anything new, all the show did was follow common tropes. And if it does what all other ecchi shows do then why does such a show deserve such amazing praise? You're describing it as being like every other ecchi show. That means its average. An average on MAL is a 5. From all the praise I thought it would be better than your average ecchi show (and not every ecchi show has to be bad, I'm sure there are many ones that are actually entertaining), but I couldn't find anything that stood out. I went in it knowing it knowing it was supposed to have comedy but I can't recall a single part where I ended up laughing. That in all is not a good anime for me. Well, it's a matter of opinion. You don't enjoy these things, some of us do. You went into the series with an attitude, I went into the series not even knowing the genre properly and I actually loved it. Soo, to sum up, there are people who like this type of comedy and can enjoy the stuff that is shown there, some of the people cannot, because they have seen god knows how many anime and are not impressed by it. I guess I am lucky I am not one of those people. And then there are people who genuinely hate this stuff. |
|
| Thread moved. |
| There should be a law against people having different opinions... then everyone would get along and we could live in peace :D |
 |
hybreezy said: Maybe I gave NGNL a 5 because that's the score it deserves (average) crazy I know +1 |
SolviteSekai said: Akito_Kinomoto said: ...You've been reviewing for a year, have a decent number of posts for the short time you've been on the site, and you're actually wondering about this? Wut? hahaha at 1k being decent. OP clearly has a life. Casual. Someone actually responded after x amount of time? Btw, nice reading comprehension. Anyway, like others have said, stuff like this tends to happen with divisive anime. What I notice is the flaws are usually blown out of proportion in negative reviews while the strengths are played to 11 on more glowing pieces. Take the enigma of SAO, which I cannot for the life of me figure out why it's so hard for level assessments to be reached. |
 |
Omumiruma said: hybreezy said: Maybe I gave NGNL a 5 because that's the score it deserves (average) crazy I know Score 5 puts NGNL on the 7160. place on MAL. Is that the place it deserves? Yeah. because people rate shows on where they will end be in the ranks. not because of what they thought of it. |
| Kinda glad it got down-voted so much. Don't get me wrong, I love NGNL and enjoyed the hell out of watching it but I don't think it deserved to be in the top 20. |
| Well we can all say the same to SAO... |
 |
OppaiSugoi said: Well we can all say the same to SAO... But SAO takes itself seriously, like a serious anime. I mean there are drama moments and etc. NGNL is just a plain comedy and never was anything more. Though it has more plot than Gintama, for example, but it shouldn't be considered as something more than just pure entertainment. |
|
BRK25 said: My anime List is based on viewers ejoyment, not reviews. So Madoka magica, I didn't like it and my enjoyment level was a seven. You must be saying what the hell, a seven is good! No, my ratings are. 10-Masterpiece 9-Phenomenal 8- Great 7-Good 6-Average 5 and Below- Sucked or dropped In comparison, it reaches the lower spectrum and while I give it a seven, I can outright say that madoka deserves its score but I couldn't connect whatsoever. But this show, on a critical standpoint, it should be given a six for what it is and maybe a 7.5 for those it caters to, and that's it. But my enjoyment dropped below five and I decided I'd have more fun being struck with a chainsaw than watch the show. IT was terrible. In enjoyment and fun, I couldn't believe I lasted more than three episodes. A friend compelled me to stay but no longer, no more. Yeah sure, u are clearly hating based on hype. SAO, AOT and NGNL 1, 1 and 2. |
 |
| eh to be fair it's not like anyone with an ounce of common sense takes the rating seriously anyway.. you have troll voters, people who vote at random, haters, hypers and then people who apparently just don't understand how a 1-10 rating system works (like people who think 5 means horrible instead of average) even if we all used the system properly and all the haters/hypers/trolls magically disappeared the ratings still wouldn't actually mean anything worth carring about because it's just a collection of random opinions from a bunch of anonymous nobodies that said I say let anyone vote however they want for any or even no reason if they feel like it... they're not hurting anyone, or affecting anyone really |
LiquidacidOct 4, 2014 12:38 PM
|
LigoPriest said: Overall you're just a contradicting hypocrite who just yells for attention. you just described 95 percent of the posters on this board... maybe the internet as a whole... lol |
|
Liquidacid said: LigoPriest said: Overall you're just a contradicting hypocrite who just yells for attention. you just described 95 percent of the posters on this board... maybe the internet as a whole... lol  You blew my mind. :) |
More topics from this board
» No Game No Life’s Original Creator Pleads For A Second Season Of The Anime ( 1 2 )deg - Apr 10, 2024 |
62 |
by tonemao85243
»»
Today, 1:45 AM |
|
Poll: » No Game No Life Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Cheesekao - Jun 25, 2014 |
1045 |
by ejleon
»»
Sep 23, 8:01 PM |
|
Poll: » One decade later and still no Season 2 ( 1 2 )JustSomeone15 - May 16, 2024 |
52 |
by Krebskulm_666
»»
Sep 17, 2:32 AM |
|
Poll: » No Game No Life Episode 2 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Apr 16, 2014 |
516 |
by AYsFAR19
»»
Sep 11, 10:56 PM |
|
Poll: » No Game No Life Episode 9 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Jun 4, 2014 |
507 |
by shingeki_no_tea
»»
Aug 13, 9:17 AM |