| Samurai Champloo, Gintama, Shigatsu wa Kimi no Uso are Masterpieces of the masterpieces, not exaggerating but they really are tho |
 |
| Hunter x Hunter. Or it will be anyways. :P |
| Sorcery made this thread unintentionally worth reading; Grats. |
 |
| It's extreamly difficult to give an anime 10 for me, even for my all time favorites. No anime has done EXACTLY what I wanted it to and I definitely don't expect them to because nothing is perfect, and caters to my exact taste. Never the less, I just made an account here and just filled out some of my stats. The hights ranking animes for me so far are Psycho Pass and even, maybe, above that, Samurai Champloo! Now I'm quite new to the anime community and havent seen that much at all and I know there are so many more great ones out there. Too much anime too little time. |
[url=http://myanimelist.net/animelist/Beckllund&sclick=1] [/url |
| Code Geass: Hangyaku no Lelouch ... |
 |
| Monster. My favourite anime and always will be my favourite anime! |
| Trigun or FMAB, honestly forgot which I seen first! But both are great :) |
  |
Senpaoi said: Well my first 2 anime, Toradora and Anohana, were both 10's in my opinion. Hence why I love slice-of-life anime so much. And you haven't lowered them since? That's some impressive resolve or the animes in question have more staying power then I remembered. |
Senpaoi said: Veredin said: Well they both kept me in love with slice-of-life, why not?And you haven't lowered them since? That's some impressive resolve or the animes in question have more staying power then I remembered. Also, I started anime in December of last year, so it hasn't been very long. Ah I see. Will you lower them if the standard quality of anime you watch rises? |
| Maison Ikkoku, I rated it 10/10. This is also the point where I feel that i've become better at rating things, but re doing ratings is too much work. |
Senpaoi said: Naw, they will always have a special place in my heart. So it's sentiment then? Fair enough. |
| My first anime that I rated nearly a 10 is Angel beats, if I remember right. |
| Either FMA:Brotherhood or Code Geass, not sure which one was first though... |
"At some point, I stopped hoping." |
| I gave brotherhood a 10 first, but Your lie in april is the best 10 now in my opinion |
| I probably rated 10 something stupid like Amnesia I changed it now tho lool a 11/10 would be Shinsekai Yori or Neon Gen. Evangelion now. |
| My first anime I'm rated a 10 was Accel World, them, Mobile Suit Gundam 00 |
escapingreality said: Definitely HxH! I got 'anime hangover' after finished watching it, if that even makes sense. Cross Game is also a 10 for me. A lot of people tend to have an "anime hangover" after finishing Hunter x Hunter, because it's that good :P I didn't have it myself though |
| Baccano!! an is still a 10 for me to this day( i really love that series, i should start reading the novels soon). |
| Probably some studio ghibli shit.. |
 |
| The first one that I've rated a 10 is FMA B. Later on only Gintama, Gintama' and Hotaru no Haka made it. And well, a favourite doesn't necessarily mean a masterpiece in my opinion. |
| Clannad After Story. Was also the 2nd anime I've watched as an adult. Still even after multiple viewings I consider it a masterpiece. |
 |
| Mine would be Puella Magi Madoka Magica. And it's STILL my favorite anime of all time. |
| gintama if we are talking about my list on mal. if we can including what shows i consider 10 in my childhood. it was simba the white lion and hutch the honey bee. |
 "If taking responsibility for a mistake that cannot be undone means death, it's not that hard to die. At least, not as hard as to live on." |
Kousuke-shii said: Gabagool said: Definitely agree with this. That anime will make even the manliness person cry.Clannad After Story. Was also the 2nd anime I've watched as an adult. Still even after multiple viewings I consider it a masterpiece. Truth be told I never cried watching anything before this.. I haven't really cried much in my life but this show not only opened up my tear ducts but also my eyes as to how great anime could be :') |
|
Kousuke-shii said: Gabagool said: Me as well. Never really cried on movies, stories, books even funeral... That might be going too far but you get the point. The thing I loved the most about this anime is that it gave me a new perspective on how life can turn out.. It's just beautiful.Truth be told I never cried watching anything before this.. I haven't really cried much in my life but this show not only opened up my tear ducts but also my eyes as to how great anime could be :') Damn.. all these comments about Clannad.. I really should watch it :P |
| It was either the first Hunter x Hunter series or Yu Yu Hakusho. I can't really remember atm but they are two of my favorite series, and I re-watch them both every few years. What I wouldn't give for a Yu Yu Hakusho remake! |
         |
| Rurouni Kenshin: Trust and Betrayal. And Hunter x Hunter 2011. I just can't bring myself to give something a 10, at least yet. :o |
  |
| ,,death note of course still my fave |
| Higurashi was my first 10 and will always be my fav. @Theatro Yup, you pretty much nailed it on the head to what Higurashi was to me. But by no means was it my first anime. You know Ryukishi07 is writing (and I think animating) a new series called "When the Fireflies Fly" which is after Umineko and talks about Higurashi and is another maze made by the witches. There is actually a character named Miyo Takano (or its spelled differently, since she's supposed to be a different chess piece, but still has her "conspiracy theories" notebook with her). The prologue is out for the manga, you should check it out. Also there is an epilogue story for Umineko that connects it to the prologue of this manga :D! I bet you will thoroughly enjoy this. |
CejaraMar 15, 2016 5:55 PM
| First 9 I ever gave was a 9 to Shiki.... I hate vampire anime but that show was insane I'll never forget those last few episodes, jaw dropping at times I need to re-watch that show |
Gator said: Probably One Piece since it was the first one. This .................................. |
 |
| The first show I gave a ten is Cowboy Bebop. It's since been dethroned as my favorite anime, but to this day I still think it's a classic (also, it tends to be the show I use to introduce friends to anime. It has a western appeal). |
sorcery said: Not a single one. Only tasteless millennials rating 10 solely on enjoyability or because "they cried" do that. I can find flaws even in the best Ghibli and to get a 10, a workpiece got not only to be technically flawless but also have that timelessness which could make anyone relate. The title must be enough as a standalone. It mustn't pander to anyone's fantasy, be coherent with its thematics, have coherent world building, not have yet another nice premise thrown out, not hide its lazy writing with pseudo sense of mystery (plot holes which hinder full comprehension is never a mark of quality; subtlety in narration is), have flawless characterization (archetypes aren't a problem but one dimensional protagonists are) and get quality plot staging (fine production value: artwork, art direction for sceneries, artful angle of views), and benefit from fine chara design and sound of course. It mustn't resort in excess to the following cop out Joker: - the magic/paranormal element - the alien scientific plot point (introducing technobabble and infodump) - pseudo depth (never confuse for the sake of posing as a meaningful masterpiece! Rahxephon, anyone?) - blurry symbolism (I am looking at you Evangelion) - Surrealism These last point don't exclude shows to be good. They just cannot be objectively perfect if they hack their way cheaply. You must not be fun at parties, just answer the question *hint* He said close to a 10* |
"It's ANIME TIME" |
| The first anime I rated a 10/ nearly a 10 would probably be Samurai Champloo/Drrr!. (Since I have actually been updating MAL). |
More topics from this board
» Why are prudes trying to censor anime?GoatPieceLuffy - 9 minutes ago |
2 |
by GoatPieceLuffy
»»
6 minutes ago |
|
» Dumb narcissistic perverts is supposed to be funny?Ri-KoRin - Yesterday |
43 |
by GoatPieceLuffy
»»
8 minutes ago |
|
» I made a fake anime seasonal chart using AI. Which of these sounds interesting to you? ( 1 2 3 4 )FFandMMfan - Apr 13 |
154 |
by FFandMMfan
»»
20 minutes ago |
|
» Since anime fans today are weaklings and easily triggered, if Berserk were to be adapted properly today, do you think it would receive many complains? ( 1 2 )Rinrinka - May 17 |
52 |
by GoatPieceLuffy
»»
23 minutes ago |
|
Poll: » Do you watch Anime EDs?TheSunLife - 9 hours ago |
29 |
by TitanOfPlasma
»»
27 minutes ago |