Outrageous said: That would be way too much troubleWell I think if you wanna keep track of the hentais you watched, but you don't want that certain ppl would see them or be embarrassed about it, you can always creates another profile with only hentai anime entries, that only you know about or smth like that. |
| Hey guys, just trying to save you some time. From page 2: Xinil said: jacobpaige said: not really sure where i stand on this one, but i do wonder i do think it would be a pain to code since you'd also have to tweak the "Last List Updates" section for your list, your friends "Recent Friend Updates", the anime pages themselves,"All My Friend's Entries" on the statistics page for the anime, "Strife91 History" section on your profile and "Anime You Share". and chances are i'm forgetting someplace where this information is also listed and not even mentioning all the changes that would need to be made for manga. Thank you. Someone actually understands the huge amount of work this suggestion would require. I don't need to write anything now. This hasn't changed and the suggestions don't address this, so.... Oh and shinkeikaku said: Own up to your porn or don't list it. |
kei-clone said: Ah a moderator who understands and not so lazy Even though this isn't completely "necessary" as some people are saying, and even though there are "alternatives", I think a great number of users would benefit from this feature anyway, especially since we discourage making second accounts in our TOS. If this option was implemented, users can keep track of their hentai, and not face social awkwardness when showing off their animelist. windy said: What? I am but not with showing EVERYBODY.BE PROUD OF YOUR PORN!!!!!!!! List it with pride! Don't really think this is all that necessary. As illdoya said, just don't list it if you're uncomfortable with it. |
| O thanks shin, I was just going to quote that myself~ |
| wow the mods on this site are real nice |
DrknownothingDec 13, 2010 2:42 PM
| yea lazy didn't make sense, i guess. but I was just shocked too see a nice young man suggesting a good comment and then attacked by rude mods. never seen anything like it |
| Actually, it was a pointless bump (against forum rules) and mods are so rude by letting users know how this site works. Xinil is the only one who codes, thus the only one you have to convince. And he said no a long time ago. Since no one has addressed his comments/concerns, case closed. You'll see rude with continued pointless posts (a few others are just fine as they technically tried to add to the discussion, which is long since dead). Actually, you'll likely just see a forum mod doing their job then.. |
| What's there to be ashamed of really? Sounds more like this is a personal issue. You're ashamed of your personal tastes since they're more exuberant in the H department than most people. Now you want to hide what you are? Seriously any man who doesn't have H on his list is lying or under the age of 13. I guess it could be implemented if it was feasible. Then we could all see who are secret monkey spankers. |
| I'm a little late to the party, just something like two years, lol. You shouldn't feel ashamed of having hentai on your list, even if you're going to show it "non-hentai-lovers" I have it too, actually I watched two hentai movies so far, and I'm not ashamed to admit it. But it pales in comparison to the amount of non-hentai on my list, so it's ok. |
 |
| I think the suggestion is a good one. I, personally will not use it, however there is obviously good intent behind it. Though I never see it happening. There are plenty of other things this site needs fixed, just like any other large site, before further implementation of features should happen. It's unfortunate the thought process of this world we live in... The judgmental status of "You like something I don't understand/agree with, therefor you are below me.' is something we all deal with on a regular basis even in this day and age(Happy New Year!). My only suggestion is, turn that very thought against them. You like something they don't know about, or agree with? Then they are uneducated fools whom should be educated in a topic before making an unjust opinion of it. In all reality, you have the advantage, use it. Or, just DGAF. |
| I would like this implemented. |
Sorry my bad english :( |
| i suport the idea but if they decide not to do it you can also do wath i tell down unless your list full of hentai i think you should not be embrased or just don't add them and make a notepad. with all the serries for your self i do that with my comments and stuf or you could remove rate setting then no one can see it only when they click the anime wich people hardly do i think and you shouldn't be bothered by it to much you can also make it only visible for friends this will make the watchers less |
RobertovkOct 4, 2012 2:35 PM
| "When a flat-chested loli hugs you, she holds you closer to her heart" "--I am a single bullet. It has no heart. Therefore, it does not think. It just flies straight towards its target."  |
| I'm supporting this too. I kinda want to keep track of my hentai but I don't want every random dude asking for anime suggestions to see loads of hentai. I want to make them visible to selected users only as I have friends who would be interested in seeing them but 80% would be just disturbed :| (yes this was a necessary bump) |
| If you want to hide your hentai, just don't add it in the first place. |
 "Only one with the courage to shoulder the burden of their own fate can be called a hero.." |
| We only allow open sukebes here, if you want to be a mutsuri sukebe then you can get out. |
     Short of the day: Monotonous Purgatory(MAL) ✰Public Domain Club | One Piece Club✰ |
| Be a man and show your perversion to the world, it's only the internet. |
 |
| I don't watch heantai but I support the idea. If I puti me in your place I would like to place all I had seen in one single list. Is always good and easier to show your list to your friends, and I'd be uncomfortable that your friends know what porn titles you have seen. |
 |
| personally think you should just be proud of it just like any other anime/manga on your list..just seems like your insecure if you can't admit you watch/read hentai |
 |
| If you're embarrassed about it, then just don't add it to your list? |
NonOtaku said: XDmeat rod |
 .. |
| be proud that you fap to 2D sexy girls!!! |
SlothNamakemono said: Be a man and show your perversion to the world, it's only the internet. ^ This is the right thing to do. :D |
| The idea is interesting and wouldn't require much effort to be implemented but it could make the servers slower. |
 |
| I'm all for this idea. Some of us have shown our MAL accounts to people we know IRL and its awkward as hell when they notice that you've got hentai in your lists and then give you shit about it. People typically are prejudiced when it comes to hentai and will often jump to all sorts of false and outlandish conclusions. So I'd really like to have a way to easily share a list of the anime/manga I like without the hentai series being visible. Hopefully some sort of feature to hide them at will will become available. |
| Salmon is delicious. |
NFH said: Exaccus said: I'm all for this idea. Some of us have shown our MAL accounts to people we know IRL and its awkward as hell when they notice that you've got hentai in your lists For Heaven's sake people, is it so hard to just keep a separate list for everything you are ashamed to have watched? I would understand if MAL was a site like Facebook, where you use your real name but here you use pseudonyms as usernames. Even if MAL were to implement the feature you are asking, it would be far more practical to just have a separate list. Imagine how bothersome it would be to go to every individual entry if you have 50 or 100 titles you want to hide, and how impractical this would make things like asking for recommendations for adult series. Having two separate accounts would be a pain to be constantly logging in and out of. It would be much more convenient to have everything all in one place. So I don't see how your solution would be very practical at all for the considerable number of MAL users who want to keep adult series hidden from view on their lists. All I'm asking is that there be the option to hide hentai titles on our MAL lists from public viewing if we so wish. It would be a really nice feature to have implemented. Since it would make a website founded upon the intention to be helpful even more helpful to its users. |
| Salmon is delicious. |
Exaccus said: It's also against the rules to have two accounts and you can be banned.NFH said: Exaccus said: I'm all for this idea. Some of us have shown our MAL accounts to people we know IRL and its awkward as hell when they notice that you've got hentai in your lists For Heaven's sake people, is it so hard to just keep a separate list for everything you are ashamed to have watched? I would understand if MAL was a site like Facebook, where you use your real name but here you use pseudonyms as usernames. Even if MAL were to implement the feature you are asking, it would be far more practical to just have a separate list. Imagine how bothersome it would be to go to every individual entry if you have 50 or 100 titles you want to hide, and how impractical this would make things like asking for recommendations for adult series. Having two separate accounts would be a pain to be constantly logging in and out of. It would be much more convenient to have everything all in one place. So I don't see how your solution would be very practical at all for the considerable number of MAL users who want to keep adult series hidden from view on their lists. All I'm asking is that there be the option to hide hentai titles on our MAL lists from public viewing if we so wish. It would be a really nice feature to have implemented. Since it would make a website founded upon the intention to be helpful even more helpful to its users. How much is considerable? And would people be able to hide non hentai titles? Why only hentai? What about childrens anime or even ecchi? There are also probably certain anime, genres, etc that people wouldn't wanted to be seen on their list. And in that case, would their score count? That would make it extremely easy for rating trolls to hide. |
Short of the day: Monotonous Purgatory(MAL) ✰Public Domain Club | One Piece Club✰ |
| This is one of those things where nobody would really be complaining about it if this was already implemented. I mean, those like me telling the OP to grow a pair would show all of what we've watched on our lasts, and those who hide the hentai would be the only ones to know about it unless they tell on themselves. So in a way, I'm for the idea even though I'm sure that I would never it. |
 |
IntroverTurtle said: Exaccus said: It's also against the rules to have two accounts and you can be banned.NFH said: Exaccus said: I'm all for this idea. Some of us have shown our MAL accounts to people we know IRL and its awkward as hell when they notice that you've got hentai in your lists For Heaven's sake people, is it so hard to just keep a separate list for everything you are ashamed to have watched? I would understand if MAL was a site like Facebook, where you use your real name but here you use pseudonyms as usernames. Even if MAL were to implement the feature you are asking, it would be far more practical to just have a separate list. Imagine how bothersome it would be to go to every individual entry if you have 50 or 100 titles you want to hide, and how impractical this would make things like asking for recommendations for adult series. Having two separate accounts would be a pain to be constantly logging in and out of. It would be much more convenient to have everything all in one place. So I don't see how your solution would be very practical at all for the considerable number of MAL users who want to keep adult series hidden from view on their lists. All I'm asking is that there be the option to hide hentai titles on our MAL lists from public viewing if we so wish. It would be a really nice feature to have implemented. Since it would make a website founded upon the intention to be helpful even more helpful to its users. How much is considerable? And would people be able to hide non hentai titles? Why only hentai? What about childrens anime or even ecchi? There are also probably certain anime, genres, etc that people wouldn't wanted to be seen on their list. And in that case, would their score count? That would make it extremely easy for rating trolls to hide. Yep. Apparently quite a few people, since there have been threads like this one in the past asking that there be some way to hide hentai series on one's lists from public view. Hentai obviously is the demographic most prone to prejudice and bringing ridicule among those who consume it. But sure, including ecchi might not be a bad idea either, especially given the existence of ones like ToLoveRu or KissXSis. |
| Salmon is delicious. |
| why not just create a separate account where its a hentai/doujinshi list only. Seriously, so no reason for the hidden thing. woops, this thread was made in 2008, lol. |
waalex11 said: Because it's against the rule to have two accounts. You will get banned and have the account deleted.why not just create a separate account where its a hentai/doujinshi list only. Seriously, so no reason for the hidden thing. woops, this thread was made in 2008, lol. Exaccus said: I guess a number of people. But I don't know about a considerable amount, there's 1.5 million users on this site and I've seen maybe 5 threads on it.Yep. Apparently quite a few people, since there have been threads like this one in the past asking that there be some way to hide hentai series on one's lists from public view. Hentai obviously is the demographic most prone to prejudice and bringing ridicule among those who consume it. But sure, including ecchi might not be a bad idea either, especially given the existence of ones like ToLoveRu or KissXSis. Well you would think so, but who and why would they ridicule you? It's an anonymous site and plenty of other people would get ridiculed for watching ecchi, shoujo, shounen, children's, etc. So just ecchi and hentai? Why not any of the others. And that's what I'm saying, even though ecchi doesn't have sex which would make it a hentai, that shows that there are things in regular anime that are equally as embarrassing or something they wouldn't want to show to someone. That includes anime meant for another gender, for a different age group, gore(violence in general), things that might be frowned upon by your culture or religion, etc. And still what about rating trolls? If someone couldn't see certain parts of your list, they wouldn't know if you were legit. Troll rating accounts are reported by users, the mods don't go through. |
Short of the day: Monotonous Purgatory(MAL) ✰Public Domain Club | One Piece Club✰ |
IntroverTurtle said: waalex11 said: Because it's against the rule to have two accounts. You will get banned and have the account deleted.why not just create a separate account where its a hentai/doujinshi list only. Seriously, so no reason for the hidden thing. woops, this thread was made in 2008, lol. Exaccus said: I guess a number of people. But I don't know about a considerable amount, there's 1.5 million users on this site and I've seen maybe 5 threads on it.Yep. Apparently quite a few people, since there have been threads like this one in the past asking that there be some way to hide hentai series on one's lists from public view. Hentai obviously is the demographic most prone to prejudice and bringing ridicule among those who consume it. But sure, including ecchi might not be a bad idea either, especially given the existence of ones like ToLoveRu or KissXSis. Well you would think so, but who and why would they ridicule you? It's an anonymous site and plenty of other people would get ridiculed for watching ecchi, shoujo, shounen, children's, etc. So just ecchi and hentai? Why not any of the others. And that's what I'm saying, even though ecchi doesn't have sex which would make it a hentai, that shows that there are things in regular anime that are equally as embarrassing or something they wouldn't want to show to someone. That includes anime meant for another gender, for a different age group, gore(violence in general), things that might be frowned upon by your culture or religion, etc. And still what about rating trolls? If someone couldn't see certain parts of your list, they wouldn't know if you were legit. Troll rating accounts are reported by users, the mods don't go through. I did mention in a previous post that my concerns are about sharing my lists with people IRL, not people I encounter only online. I'm not familiar with rating trolls and what they are/do (I'm still relatively new here). |
| Salmon is delicious. |
Exaccus said: Yes I did notice that, but my point still stands that there are many other genres and things that you wouldn't want other people to see.I did mention in a previous post that my concerns are about sharing my lists with people IRL, not people I encounter only online. I'm not familiar with rating trolls and what they are/do (I'm still relatively new here). Rating trolls are accounts made just to influence the scores. So pretend I don't like Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood which is at the top, I make another account(which is also against the rules) and I rate Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood and every other anime I don't like a 1, and then I add all the anime I like and rate them a 10. Those are rating trolls, some people will make tens of accounts to try and lower and higher certain anime's scores. The way people usually recognize them is how they rate usually just 10s and 1s, they don't have much info on their page, etc. If they are allowed to hide anime on their list, people wouldn't be able to see if they were ratings trolls. That's why I'm making that connection. If hentai are able to be hidden, why not everything else since it depends on the person which genre might embarrass them and there are things that can embarrass people in every genre. And if all anime are included, what's to stop rating trolls. |
Short of the day: Monotonous Purgatory(MAL) ✰Public Domain Club | One Piece Club✰ |
windy said: BE PROUD OF YOUR PORN!!!!!!!! List it with pride! Don't really think this is all that necessary. As illdoya said, just don't list it if you're uncomfortable with it. This^ Why be embarrassed about hentai? If someone is looking at your list, they are interested in anime. If they are interested in anime, they have saw hentai before. |
 |
IntroverTurtle said: Exaccus said: Yes I did notice that, but my point still stands that there are many other genres and things that you wouldn't want other people to see.I did mention in a previous post that my concerns are about sharing my lists with people IRL, not people I encounter only online. I'm not familiar with rating trolls and what they are/do (I'm still relatively new here). Rating trolls are accounts made just to influence the scores. So pretend I don't like Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood which is at the top, I make another account(which is also against the rules) and I rate Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood and every other anime I don't like a 1, and then I add all the anime I like and rate them a 10. Those are rating trolls, some people will make tens of accounts to try and lower and higher certain anime's scores. The way people usually recognize them is how they rate usually just 10s and 1s, they don't have much info on their page, etc. If they are allowed to hide anime on their list, people wouldn't be able to see if they were ratings trolls. That's why I'm making that connection. If hentai are able to be hidden, why not everything else since it depends on the person which genre might embarrass them and there are things that can embarrass people in every genre. And if all anime are included, what's to stop rating trolls. Does that mean if someone has a private list, their scores do not count? A troll could just make their list private, otherwise, couldn't they? |
| Aliis si licet, tibi non licet. |
sherlock5545 said: No their score still counts. But even if someone sets their list to private it's possible to see it using the API or something like that and the anime you share still shows up when you visit their profile.Does that mean if someone has a private list, their scores do not count? A troll could just make their list private, otherwise, couldn't they? |
Short of the day: Monotonous Purgatory(MAL) ✰Public Domain Club | One Piece Club✰ |
IntroverTurtle said: sherlock5545 said: No their score still counts. But even if someone sets their list to private it's possible to see it using the API or something like that and the anime you share still shows up when you visit their profile.Does that mean if someone has a private list, their scores do not count? A troll could just make their list private, otherwise, couldn't they? It's not actually, you will get this message. At least one list you're trying to view has been made private. |
 |
tsudecimo said: Yes you can if you use the API. Also like I said the anime you share will still show up on the profile(underneath the compatability) so you can at least see which anime you share. And since their scores still count, if you go to an anime's stats you can still see what they rated it. Also watching history is still there.IntroverTurtle said: sherlock5545 said: No their score still counts. But even if someone sets their list to private it's possible to see it using the API or something like that and the anime you share still shows up when you visit their profile.Does that mean if someone has a private list, their scores do not count? A troll could just make their list private, otherwise, couldn't they? It's not actually, you will get this message. At least one list you're trying to view has been made private. For demonstration, Anime_Name was a popular user that I remembered had a private list. Here's the link to his list, it's private. http://myanimelist.net/animelist/Anime_Name And here's the link to the API or whatever of his list. http://myanimelist.net/malappinfo.php?u=anime_name&status=all&type=anime I can see what he rated all of his anime and see all of them. |
Short of the day: Monotonous Purgatory(MAL) ✰Public Domain Club | One Piece Club✰ |
IntroverTurtle said: Exaccus said: I did mention in a previous post that my concerns are about sharing my lists with people IRL, not people I encounter only online. I'm not familiar with rating trolls and what they are/do (I'm still relatively new here). Yes I did notice that, but my point still stands that there are many other genres and things that you wouldn't want other people to see. Rating trolls are accounts made just to influence the scores. So pretend I don't like Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood which is at the top, I make another account(which is also against the rules) and I rate Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood and every other anime I don't like a 1, and then I add all the anime I like and rate them a 10. Those are rating trolls, some people will make tens of accounts to try and lower and higher certain anime's scores. The way people usually recognize them is how they rate usually just 10s and 1s, they don't have much info on their page, etc. If they are allowed to hide anime on their list, people wouldn't be able to see if they were ratings trolls. That's why I'm making that connection. If hentai are able to be hidden, why not everything else since it depends on the person which genre might embarrass them and there are things that can embarrass people in every genre. And if all anime are included, what's to stop rating trolls. I don't see anybody wanting to hide shounen or romance titles on their lists. Only hentai, because it's by far the demographic most likely to bring ridicule and belittlement upon those who watch it, mainly IRL. This isn't a slippery slope as you imply. What's to stop trolls on the internet in general? They're everywhere. And I don't see how the current set up is supposedly better at weeding out rating trolls. Maybe some people genuinely do think all their favorite animes/mangas are all 10/10. That doesn't mean they are necessarily trolls. Thankfully, most people are smart enough not to waste their time making dupe accounts in an attempt to change the average scores of anime or manga on some website. |
| Salmon is delicious. |
Exaccus said: Just because you don't see any, doesn't meant they are not there. Only hentai and ecchi like you've said? Ecchi is not hentai. But then, whats to stop people from wanting to hide other anime that might be considered embarrassing? I don't want my friends to know I watched and enjoyed Naruto, a sappy shoujo romance, a borderline hentai ecchi, this kids anime, hentai, this shoujo or shounen ai anime(yuri/yaoi), etc. I don't see anybody wanting to hide shounen or romance titles on their lists. Only hentai, because it's by far the demographic most likely to bring ridicule and belittlement upon those who watch it, mainly IRL. This isn't a slippery slope as you imply. What's to stop trolls on the internet in general? They're everywhere. And I don't see how the current set up is supposedly better at weeding out rating trolls. Maybe some people genuinely do think all their favorite animes/mangas are all 10/10. That doesn't mean they are necessarily trolls. Thankfully, most people are smart enough not to waste their time making dupe accounts in an attempt to change the average scores of anime or manga on some website. It's all the same, they're all anime. You add what you want and you don't add what you don't want others to see. Well then you don't understand anything. If someone can completely hide whatever anime they want, then you can't find ratings trolls. How users find trolls now is they go through an anime's stats and check the profiles and lists of users who have rated it 10 or 1 or whatever. And then if they think it's a troll account through the ratings and the profile then they report it here. Yes some people will genuinely think all their favorite manga/anime are 10s, that's not a problem. But if an account has no profile picture, hasn't been active in a while, no friends or any other sign that they've been active on this site, all their anime or manga are rated 10 or 1, the anime that they added are only the top anime on this site, there are multiple accounts with a similar name, etc then they are probably a rating troll, users use the clues to figure out who's real and whos not. They then put it in the thread, a mod will go through and if they believe the're right then they will either wipe their list or delete the account. Yes most people don't make duplicate accounts, but the people who do, make dozens. |
Short of the day: Monotonous Purgatory(MAL) ✰Public Domain Club | One Piece Club✰ |
| i got to say some echi's are worse then hentai some shows are rated hentai cause there is 1 time sex in it while for the rest of the show there is no nudity at all. but i understand some people are ashamed so i support the idea of hiding it for those who want to hide it for people like real life friends but i hope if it is accepted this will not bring more lag on MAL. i just got to say people who talk bad about others who watch hentai are 1. looking for drama 2. hiding there own thing and got some things they feel ashamed of them self. and the multi account thing will indeed give trolls better change to down rate shows. i guess i only have 1 hentai on my list and i know i have seen 1 more but don't remember its name but i got some very echi once. then again i don't care what people say/think about what i am seeing i have seen a big variety of shows some are not even meant for guys but what does it matter i just love almost anything. i can easy see to love ru or anything while i am with a girl or boy in the same room even if they my friends to be honest i even did that once there was a a few girls in my house and some boys all my friends and i was watching KissXSis all the boys acting cool and trying to make me feel ashamed cause there where girls but why would i care sure some will say some annoying things or harsh things but then i think to my self grow up we are adults now what is wrong with nudity. or i think i know you are just saying this things because you don't have the guts to come out for it and hide behind a big mouth and i am thinking to my self your even watching my screen many times other wise you could not argument some things you just said to me so your talking about your self to haha. then again i am maybe crazy haha. but is it even legal for me to react on such a old thread?? |
| "When a flat-chested loli hugs you, she holds you closer to her heart" "--I am a single bullet. It has no heart. Therefore, it does not think. It just flies straight towards its target." |
| HAVE NO SHAME IN YOUR GAME |
NO. |
| Fuck that shit, I'm having all my hentai in my list like it doesn't matter. ^^ |
More topics from this board
» Rework the database algorithm.Lucifrost - May 30 |
13 |
by Darkerplayer
»»
6 minutes ago |
|
Poll: » Add list setting to make notes private (on public lists)Shark93 - Nov 12, 2022 |
29 |
by wormwormy
»»
6 hours ago |
|
» The "related entries" redesign is atrociousFurMetarArkemist - Yesterday |
3 |
by Zarutaku
»»
7 hours ago |
|
» Prevent obscure Donghua from polluting the top rankingsZarutaku - Jun 3 |
14 |
by Zarutaku
»»
7 hours ago |
|
» Who thought this was a good idea?Shenhe - May 26 |
7 |
by Zarutaku
»»
Yesterday, 6:51 AM |