Oongbuh said:Thigh_Tide said:Aggressively incoherent and mediocre. Dull art, animation and music, empty worldbuilding, repulsive designs, and above all just boring as hell. And ever-so-lazy characterisation, it's expies left and right. Not worth my valuable time, that's for sure.
Good old unnecessarily critically people. Gotta love those.
A - Why would being critical be unnecessary?
B - How can you identify this even is being "critical," rather than "fair?"
RegulusX said:Thigh_Tide said:Aggressively incoherent and mediocre. Dull art, animation and music, empty worldbuilding, repulsive designs, and above all just boring as hell. And ever-so-lazy characterisation, it's expies left and right. Not worth my valuable time, that's for sure. Kindly elaborate please.
I'm not really sure on what, I feel I got straight to the point, but alright.
Well to begin with, the checkpoint was evidently used as a framing device for introducing Bisco, but it was also interspersed with sequences in the city taking place at a different time, that I'm still not certain are meant to be prior or earlier. The obvious reveal was pulled out too long, even into the next episode, it seems, which only further causes the sequence to be less of an opportunity for narration and more an interruption to the story. I haven't read the source material, but I would assume this is a holdover from the book, where such an idea would likely make a lot more sense, only the adaptation failed to consider how it breaks up the visual flow, a problem which the original obviously didn't face.
Which segues to the art and animation, where both are just uninspired. No unique techniques or designs, which on the one hand I do note there wasn't much opportunity to do in this first episode, but that in itself is rather an issue. I'll tangent off on the pacing for a sec; the whole episode felt more like the first half of one. I'll admit, I did initially consider leaving it for one week longer, if it had done an hour-long premiere perhaps it could have done something.
Worldbuilding, while a lot of people have given it a lot of praise, there was really not much shown. We know that there is a Rust disease and Mushrooms are a thing, and that this guy and his sister live in a shithole. That's about it. We didn't really get a good glimpse at society there, or the local history, or even any sort of power structure. We got hints of that last point, but it quickly devolved to a generic gang doing gang stuff. As with the art and animation, the issue here is primarily a lack of creativity.
And then the few characters we've been shown are just basic anime tropes. There's no evident depth to any of them. I really can't think fo what else to say on that point, just again, no evident creativity.
Judging from what positive claims about this show are saying It rather seems like most of what this show has going for it is being weird, throwing all sorts of poorly-explained nonsense at the viewer fast enough for them not to notice. The phrase "if you can't dazzle them with brilliance, baffle them with bullshit" springs to mind.
LifeGiver said:Thigh_Tide said:Aggressively incoherent and mediocre. Dull art, animation and music, empty worldbuilding, repulsive designs, and above all just boring as hell. And ever-so-lazy characterisation, it's expies left and right. Not worth my valuable time, that's for sure. nice opinion, sadly you gave a 10 to a hatsune miku advert and gave a 9 to high school DxD so it doesn't matter
You would first need to demonstrate either of those are incorrect views. As of yet you're just trying to say "You are wrong about X because you are wrong about Y," with neither actually shown to be true. That's a fallacy.
Koshi_Inaba said:Thigh_Tide said:Aggressively incoherent and mediocre. Dull art, animation and music, empty worldbuilding, repulsive designs, and above all just boring as hell. And ever-so-lazy characterisation, it's expies left and right. Not worth my valuable time, that's for sure.
And nothing of great value was lost lol
Demonstrate that to be the case. Come on, actually stand behind your insults. |