Forum SettingsEpisode Information
Forums
New
What did you think of this episode?
DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
Pages (10) « First ... « 4 5 [6] 7 8 » ... Last »
Mar 3, 2018 1:00 PM
Offline
May 2015
5
Ok yeah the ending kinda made me wanna drop this, it grossed me out a wee bit but... i mean its over now so i might aswell just finish it and see whats gonna happen. Did not expect this anime to be so "dark" when i started it and im hoping for it to redeem itself and be worth the watch or ill just drop it later i guess. BUT god bless the theo and siluca confession, gotta love it when people dont tiptoe around their feelings
Mar 3, 2018 1:05 PM
Offline
Dec 2017
46
I fucking hated it, I loved the show until the end of this episode.

Fuck you author you broke my mood.
Mar 3, 2018 1:07 PM

Offline
Jul 2015
51
adamfreddy said:
dropped. cant handle this rape shit anymore


Agree 100%, definitely not watching the rest. Is why i also dropped Kings Game after 2 episodes... can't stand it and it seems to creep in on so many anime these days :(
Mar 3, 2018 1:09 PM
Offline
Dec 2017
46
adamfreddy said:
dropped. cant handle this rape shit anymore
you are right, I dropped it too, I fucking hate that autor, I hate all the authors and anime's that include this shitty rape. How could people handle this bullshit, selling out true love and being so stupid, how the hell did the author even think of this ShiitShiiitShiiit idea, I hope that raper die in the worst way, but again I dropped it .
Mar 3, 2018 1:14 PM
Offline
Dec 2017
46
Sorrowsenpai said:
Going to keep watching this for one reason only, to watch the rapey guy killed, because now there is no way in hell this will end with that filth alive. I think the comparison of Alexis and her being romeo and juliet are right, even if they do end up together they will likely be dead shortly after.

This episode was repugnant, it was the point to be so, to claim some deeper meaning over the hard choices rulers make or some bullshit, but its lost over the fact that it does not even show why they are fighting or what the difference between the two factions even are, its all just a lame excuse.

But yeah last week people said they were looking forward to the rageposts so kudos to you guys, me I am looking forward to watching the rapey guy get killed, I just hope its slow.
Please message me when and which episode he die at I am going to watch only that episode. Fuck you author, this is the third time i say it in three comments in a single chat room, I feel sick of you.
Mar 3, 2018 1:43 PM

Offline
May 2009
9192
I don't get why are you so offended? I don't believe that pussy Alexis was your selfinsert.
Mar 3, 2018 1:58 PM
Offline
Mar 2018
4
1032patrick said:
Enternal said:
Everyone, just forget about that scene and remember the true scene in this episode, the Theo x Siluca moment. That moment was rose gold.
Totally agree.. Theo x Siluca are now together..faster than expected.
i wouldve rated it 11/10 if the last scene was not there.
And now im droping it.
Yep not gonna see through it.
Mar 3, 2018 1:59 PM

Offline
Feb 2014
2102
It was heartbreaking to see Marine choose the dishonest path even though we knew what those born in royalty breed. This just raised a disheartening death flag.

I can see Milza ending up dead at the end only to realize he had already been taken over.
Villar is gonna use this alliance as a foothold to end his cursed Keirsche bloodline to reign supreme!
When someone asks me why I like anime, I'd say Just Because.

Mar 3, 2018 2:40 PM

Offline
Oct 2014
673
Whoa, this show took a decidedly mature turn rapidly. The seemingly dense protagonist Theo finally got his shit together and confessed to Siluca, and she expectedly reciprocated. But then intense chemical warfare with graphic deaths... who needs actual fighting when you can just use poison I guess. Marrine really should not have done that, it was an upsetting moment that she clearly didn't want despite consenting to. But it just goes to show how far she's willing to go to succeed.

I guess the best word to sum up this would irreversible. I doubt the tone will return to light-hearted any time soon.
Mar 3, 2018 2:49 PM

Offline
Mar 2010
2842
AbattoirRat said:
GreenEmu said:
Jesus those last few minutes. They made that scene pretty explicit. To be honest I felt disgusted watching it.


It felt like fan service at the cost of character development. I'm confused what the ending scene meant to convey. I could see her throwing her virginity away, tarnishing herself in a "point of no return" kind of way to sever her feelings, to focus on her goals, but in this way? It just felt like sloppy writing. There was room for debauchery and character development, but on a whim? It wasn't even a condition for their alliance. He just asked and she said okay.
And I know this goes beyond anime logic, but yes, please, lets strip defenseless in front of the assassin who currently works for my enemy.

TL; DR - The sex was pointless and hurt the show.


Conquest is an euphemism for sex in this kind of context. Everybody both knew what he meant when he stated that which is Marrine's attendants where freaked out.

And more amused that a lot of people her are more outraged about the consensual than the fact she just used chemical warfare and violated the equivalent of Geneva Convention in their world. Who knows what kind of atrocities she is willing to commit now that she has crossed that line?

Enternal said:
Tokoya said:
I swear to god, every time I think that this forum cannot possibly get even more hilariously stupid, I end up being horribly wrong

Like Jesus Christ what is this thread even lol, do any of you vanilla posters even know what rape is? How in the flying fuck was this anything close to rape xD This woman gave consent and that alone warrants this as not being rape

And don't get me started on this NTR shit too lol, her and Alexis aren't even together....Like have any of you ever watched any type of medieval program before? Rulers of kingdoms like this always do this kind of stuff whether or not its marrying off into another family to unite them or cases like this

I can't believe that this thread is full of all this bitching lol....Regardless, this episode was GREAT, the only ship that matters fully took off, the action scenes were awesome, the example of guerilla warfare with the miasma attack was spot on (It's supposed to be petty like that) and that ending was just wow lol....Did not expect that to happen at all but hey, stuff like this happens


It's considered coercion rape (legal phrasing is sexual coercion) where one party pressured the other into sex through promising something. In this situation, he basically gave her a "choice" between having sex with him to win or don't have sex with him and lose. A bit similar to having your family held hostage and the perpetrator give you a choice to save your family by having sex with him. You don't have to save your family. In addition, her expression and tears during the whole thing was clearly saying "no." Even the maids were crying. That's clearly a "no." That's what made the whole scene disgusting. Added to the insult, apparently neither were actually enjoying it. It was simply a test of conviction.

Either way, like you said, what matters is the true ship that took off and that was GLORIOUS.


I don't think that applies in this case. First she came to him and he gave her demands and she accepted. It was not something she was forced to do as the option of turning it down and walking away was there. She could have still won the war without his help, it would just been much harder.
Iron_MawMar 3, 2018 5:22 PM
Mar 3, 2018 2:55 PM
Offline
Oct 2014
17
RebelPanda said:
Whoa, this show took a decidedly mature turn rapidly. The seemingly dense protagonist Theo finally got his shit together and confessed to Siluca, and she expectedly reciprocated. But then intense chemical warfare with graphic deaths... who needs actual fighting when you can just use poison I guess. Marrine really should not have done that, it was an upsetting moment that she clearly didn't want despite consenting to. But it just goes to show how far she's willing to go to succeed.

I guess the best word to sum up this would irreversible. I doubt the tone will return to light-hearted any time soon.


I totally agree even if Marrine is in a total love for Alexis, she choose the wrong path and like you say it's irreversible. And can't be calm when I see Marrine having the most disgusting moment in her life, how could she face her Alexis now ?
Mar 3, 2018 3:39 PM

Offline
Sep 2014
80
Jagd84 said:

Conquest is an euphemism for sex in this kind of context. Everybody both knew what he meant when he stated that which is Marrine's attendants where freaked out.

And more amused that a lot of people her are more outraged about the consensual than the fact she just used chemical warfare and violated the equivalent of Geneva Convention in their world. Who knows what kind of atrocities she is willing to commit now that she has crossed that line?


Lots of insecure kids who can't handle more mature plot devices.

And like you said the fact that she commited warcime atrocities which are even outlawed in this medival setting: No one bats an fucking eye. but having consenting sex for politcal reason that's where they draw the line. These guys are the worst.
Mar 3, 2018 4:23 PM

Offline
Jul 2009
587
I'm more annoyed by the fact on how those knights which are considered the elite and can destroy a castle wall with crossbows could be easily overwhelmed by a single opponent with no armor and not only in long range combat but also at close combat. Damn this guy has more plot armor than Kira Yamato from Gundam Seed.

This queen was a complete hypocritical bitch since her wedding, I'm not surprised at all with everything she did in this episode.
Mar 3, 2018 4:40 PM

Offline
Feb 2013
6196
Count me surprised. I thought Theo x Siluca was never actually going to happen. Nice to see it has.



LOL'd so much at that "sex" scene at the end though. Dude's like, "sure I'll join ya, but you are the price."
Mar 3, 2018 4:54 PM

Offline
Aug 2017
104
Oh boi that escalated quickly! It went from a good episode with Theo confessing his love to an awesome one with that ending
Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines.
Mar 3, 2018 4:56 PM

Offline
Aug 2017
104
Peoples dropping the anime for that ending and being shocked by it when it was one of the best moment in this anime...
Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines.
Mar 3, 2018 5:15 PM

Offline
Jul 2014
634
Aleskar said:
Jagd84 said:

Conquest is an euphemism for sex in this kind of context. Everybody both knew what he meant when he stated that which is Marrine's attendants where freaked out.

And more amused that a lot of people her are more outraged about the consensual than the fact she just used chemical warfare and violated the equivalent of Geneva Convention in their world. Who knows what kind of atrocities she is willing to commit now that she has crossed that line?


Lots of insecure kids who can't handle more mature plot devices.

And like you said the fact that she commited warcime atrocities which are even outlawed in this medival setting: No one bats an fucking eye. but having consenting sex for politcal reason that's where they draw the line. These guys are the worst.


So, Marrine started tearing up when the prince made his move, so to speak. Personally speaking, that annoyed me a little. She made this choice so she doesn't get to feel sad about it. Especially not after releasing all that miasma. I really hope that comes back to haunt her.

Aside from that, I still have mixed feelings about this show. I do like this new, bloodier direction. However, it's still moving way too fast. Maybe I'd care more about Marrine if the show would slow down and develop its characters. Episode 8 wasn't enough for me to care about Marrine's 180 degree personality turn.
SithSteelMar 3, 2018 5:29 PM
Mar 3, 2018 5:19 PM
Offline
Apr 2016
95
I have to say after watching the last few minutes of this episode in fucking annoyed as shit. Maybe its because im a male and can sympathies with alexis but what happened made no sense. And she was with her two guards or maids or whatever and she was armed, she should have killed him.

Nope, i hate those two character now and forever, neither can be redeemed and i hope they all die painful deaths.

On a slightly more positive note, im glad theo and siluca's relationship is progressing, i just hope to the love of god that she doesn't get raped because after this i am now quite worried.
Mar 3, 2018 5:30 PM

Offline
Jul 2014
634
Otaku_Joe said:
I have to say after watching the last few minutes of this episode in fucking annoyed as shit. Maybe its because im a male and can sympathies with alexis but what happened made no sense. And she was with her two guards or maids or whatever and she was armed, she should have killed him.

Nope, i hate those two character now and forever, neither can be redeemed and i hope they all die painful deaths.

On a slightly more positive note, im glad theo and siluca's relationship is progressing, i just hope to the love of god that she doesn't get raped because after this i am now quite worried.

You really think Milza wasn't also armed? He could probably kill her with just his bare hands. Attendants or no attendants.
Mar 3, 2018 5:41 PM
Offline
Apr 2016
95
SithSteel said:
Otaku_Joe said:
I have to say after watching the last few minutes of this episode in fucking annoyed as shit. Maybe its because im a male and can sympathies with alexis but what happened made no sense. And she was with her two guards or maids or whatever and she was armed, she should have killed him.

Nope, i hate those two character now and forever, neither can be redeemed and i hope they all die painful deaths.

On a slightly more positive note, im glad theo and siluca's relationship is progressing, i just hope to the love of god that she doesn't get raped because after this i am now quite worried.

You really think Milza wasn't also armed? He could probably kill her with just his bare hands. Attendants or no attendants.


I'd rather fight and die than be force to agree.
Mar 3, 2018 5:44 PM

Offline
Jul 2014
634
Otaku_Joe said:
SithSteel said:

You really think Milza wasn't also armed? He could probably kill her with just his bare hands. Attendants or no attendants.


I'd rather fight and die than be force to agree.

He didn't force her, though.
Mar 3, 2018 5:58 PM
Offline
Apr 2016
95
SithSteel said:
Otaku_Joe said:


I'd rather fight and die than be force to agree.

He didn't force her, though.


He gave her an ultimatum, that's practically forcing.
Mar 3, 2018 6:12 PM
Offline
Jun 2012
11
Did anyone notice that they used the same music piece for when Marrine and Alexis promised each other as when Marrine agreed to Mirza's demands?

It seems like they used a lot of contrasts and comparisons in the episode to build an effect. Whether or not it was cleverly used or just an excuse for poor story telling is up to debate.
Mar 3, 2018 6:14 PM

Offline
Jul 2014
634
Otaku_Joe said:
SithSteel said:

He didn't force her, though.


He gave her an ultimatum, that's practically forcing.
Otaku_Joe said:
SithSteel said:

He didn't force her, though.


He gave her an ultimatum, that's practically forcing.

Not really. She could have easily walked away and found some other ally to defeat Villar or just continued onward without Milza.
Mar 3, 2018 6:44 PM

Offline
Oct 2014
1572
exsion said:
Did anyone notice that they used the same music piece for when Marrine and Alexis promised each other as when Marrine agreed to Mirza's demands?

It seems like they used a lot of contrasts and comparisons in the episode to build an effect. Whether or not it was cleverly used or just an excuse for poor story telling is up to debate.

No. They did mean that.

But that doesn't change that the scene, as well as the whole anime, is a failure. =D
Mar 3, 2018 7:07 PM
Offline
Mar 2017
67
Even though Marrine has Alexis.. I consider her and Siluca as my waifus..What she did was so devastating. She is a queen, pure and beautiful but now.. He could have just tested her resolve and stopped.. But no. He enjoyed doing that to Marrine..Damn Kill Milza! You're too cocky, power hungry, greedy, sly and a huge pervert. Don't worry you will be dealt with. Theo must enhance his sword skills and beat...I mean kill Milza.
Mar 3, 2018 7:19 PM
Offline
Mar 2017
67
One thing I'm happy about is Theo x Siluca. He was not dense after all.. Nice move Theo.. That caught Siluca off guard. Congrats
Mar 3, 2018 7:20 PM
Offline
Apr 2016
95
SithSteel said:
Otaku_Joe said:


He gave her an ultimatum, that's practically forcing.
Otaku_Joe said:


He gave her an ultimatum, that's practically forcing.

Not really. She could have easily walked away and found some other ally to defeat Villar or just continued onward without Milza.


Maybe she is just really stupid
Mar 3, 2018 7:23 PM

Offline
Jul 2014
634
Otaku_Joe said:
SithSteel said:

Not really. She could have easily walked away and found some other ally to defeat Villar or just continued onward without Milza.


Maybe she is just really stupid

Perhaps. This show could be a lot better if it just slowed down a little and explained things.
Mar 3, 2018 7:25 PM
Offline
Mar 2018
1
Sorrowsenpai said:
solomon585858 said:
This episode was disgusiting. I hope Marine dies horrible death. She never deserved such man as Alexis. Whore, woman with blood on her hands....


Curious, why do you despise and call her a whore instead of pitying her?

Why the hell would you pity her? Everything that's happened to her has been her fault. She could have still married Alexis even though her father died. What is her god damn reason to live? Unite the continent under and and iron fist and make everyone's life miserable? She didn't need to have sex with Arabic prince of Dartania. That makes no goddamn sense. If she wanted to unite the continent, the only thing she has to do is marry the guy she's in love with. It's the easiest simplest damn thing to do.
Mar 3, 2018 7:56 PM

Offline
Oct 2013
1290
This episode was bold and great, split in two parts that contrast each other. Between Siluca & Theo's confirming their love for each other(mby they did it too,mby not, who knows! but damn does heavy rain bring people together < 3).

Then between Mirza & Marine which, along with her taking that commander's crest by killing him & getting all bloodied, confirms her commitment towards the warpath she's decided to take. The scene making it very apparent how unpleasant & dirty she felt during the sex scene went to extra lengths to show her drive, as well as Mirza's drive of conquest(in many forms apparently).

Goes without saying that such expressive scenes will come at the cost of upsetting some people ~ WHAT A SHAME!
Mar 3, 2018 8:10 PM
Offline
Oct 2017
67
As one union is made in love, another is made in personal gain. Man that's a nice parallel.

I do feel both prince and princess have gone past the moral event horizon at this point but I do like all the nice touches of the princess coping with her decision, things like her looking at the blood on her hand, looking away from the prince amidst their 'meeting' that stuff's pretty nice.

I'm just looking forward to the reactions from the others and how they're going to resolve this. This anime's pacing is a recurring issue, but at the same time, I find myself enjoying it.
Mar 3, 2018 8:30 PM

Offline
Feb 2017
94
Dropped for the last scene. Glad theo and siluca got together but i'm not watching a series that feels the need to add that kind of plot into it. I'll just think of this series as ending about 15 minutes into episode 9
Mar 3, 2018 9:25 PM
Offline
Jun 2017
25
Theo confessing his love was like OHHHH DAMNNN! MY SHIP IS SAILINGGGG, BEST EP SO FAR!

Then suddenly the last part was shit, I've never closed any video this fast in my life.
They should've switched the 18+ scene for Theo and Siluca instead duhh..
Mar 3, 2018 10:26 PM

Offline
Mar 2010
123
I don't usually score an anime before I've finished it but this one is gonna get a permanent 6/10 simply because I know how it ends, if Marianne wasn't such a moron it could have easily scored higher smh.

It had the potential to be great like Arslan Senki but this poor turn of events that exists purely for shock value has left a sour taste in my mouth, unity through marriage was the correct path as unity though force isnt, the more the war continues then the more people will be killed and therefore less people to fight the true enemy.
Mar 3, 2018 10:34 PM

Offline
May 2017
1785
Pussies like Alexis deserves to get NTRd anyways

Milza is alpha af lol and my man Theo, I take back what I said about this series in the first episode being generic, okay TheoxSiluca is still generic af infact I called it. but the overall show itself ain't generic

Also to the people who calls the last scene "rape" wtf was the meaning of rape changed when I was asleep or something lol
Mar 3, 2018 10:38 PM

Offline
Dec 2010
568
ManlyTear said:
This episode was bold and great, split in two parts that contrast each other. Between Siluca & Theo's confirming their love for each other(mby they did it too,mby not, who knows! but damn does heavy rain bring people together < 3).

Then between Mirza & Marine which, along with her taking that commander's crest by killing him & getting all bloodied, confirms her commitment towards the warpath she's decided to take. The scene making it very apparent how unpleasant & dirty she felt during the sex scene went to extra lengths to show her drive, as well as Mirza's drive of conquest(in many forms apparently).

Goes without saying that such expressive scenes will come at the cost of upsetting some people ~ WHAT A SHAME!


Not at all, 70% of the people who reply here with the redundant dropped word are 1 post alts, they do not post with their main account because they will continue to watch it till the very end. Trust me, more people will watch from now on. :)
Also yea, if it wasn't for the last events the serie still be very mediocre and generic with the same 2 pages comments. A-1 producers get good response and praise from the fans in Japan for the whole adaption till now, so worry do not.
Fn76Mar 3, 2018 10:42 PM
Mar 3, 2018 10:38 PM

Offline
May 2017
1785
SithSteel said:
Otaku_Joe said:


Maybe she is just really stupid

Perhaps. This show could be a lot better if it just slowed down a little and explained things.


Marinne had a choice and that choice was already made before she even met with him unguarded. It's in no way rape.
Mar 3, 2018 10:40 PM

Offline
Jul 2014
634
TsundeReaper said:
SithSteel said:

Perhaps. This show could be a lot better if it just slowed down a little and explained things.


Marinne had a choice and that choice was already made before she even met with him unguarded. It's in no way rape.

Well, that's what I said.
Mar 3, 2018 11:05 PM
Offline
Mar 2017
67
That scene of Marrine and Milza.. was like a beast devouring the princess. Sorry but Milza is ugly inside and out
Mar 3, 2018 11:26 PM

Offline
Jan 2013
223
wahahaha I guess a lot of people gonna drop it and will never reach the true ending XD my armor is thicc!
Mar 3, 2018 11:29 PM
Offline
Apr 2016
208
sba said:
That ending...:/ i guess they search a way to kill marrine and now they find it. She can happily die



wow author sure love this stuff
Mar 3, 2018 11:29 PM
Offline
Jul 2015
17
Sorrowsenpai said:
AbattoirRat said:


I'm curious why you think she deserves pity? Other than her fathers death of course.
She Chose to sleep with the arab, he didn't even say sex was a condition, only he wanted to "make her his conquest". He more than likely would have joined her with or without the sex with very little persuasion, they both want a military rule, where as her enemies want peaceful resolution. The decision to sleep with him only lost her credibility; she seemed weak, and ignorant, unable to stand up for herself, very much in contrast to the perceptive/clever being we've been shown until now. I cannot honestly say I understand her motivation anymore. She feels less like a character and more like a plot device at this point.


Because the author is incompetant, its a metaphor for domination, make her his conquest is sleeping with them, there is no other meaning to that sentence,

From these you can draw a simple conclusion really, the author is a MORON, that is why I pity the character as much as I do,


I understood the metaphor, but what stands is it was only a request. If she really wanted to devote herself to her cause, wouldn't self respect still be important? Otherwise eventually everyone will just stop following her, even blind loyalty fades. I'm not arguing anything here, just food for thought.

Pity because the author is a moron. Claps hands* I guess you were right.
Mar 3, 2018 11:39 PM

Offline
May 2014
26
AsT5 said:
sba said:
That ending...:/ i guess they search a way to kill marrine and now they find it. She can happily die



wow author sure love this stuff

Than somebody need to kill both :) alexsis give up his position for her but marrien give up her virginity :/ how twisted this plot :/
--------------------------------------------------------------------
Just watch what you may like.
Don't watch it and don't make bad comment about it.
Every anime wants to be praised.
--------------------------------------------------------------------
Mar 3, 2018 11:47 PM
Offline
Jul 2015
17
rounin_rogai said:
AbattoirRat said:


It felt like fan service at the cost of character development. I'm confused what the ending scene meant to convey. I could see her throwing her virginity away, tarnishing herself in a "point of no return" kind of way to sever her feelings, to focus on her goals, but in this way? It just felt like sloppy writing. There was room for debauchery and character development, but on a whim? It wasn't even a condition for their alliance. He just asked and she said okay.
And I know this goes beyond anime logic, but yes, please, lets strip defenseless in front of the assassin who currently works for my enemy.

TL; DR - The sex was pointless and hurt the show.


I think that before they did the Deed, Milza hinted that he is aware of Marrine's love for Alexis. I think he didn't do it for the sex, but to test Marrine's character (Victory > Love), or to put in her in a mental state where she's not fit to be with Alexis anymore. Mirza always sought to support a strong leader, and it would make sense for him to get a little insurance so that Marrine won't pull out at the last second because of her love for Alexis.

She will probably love-cope-out tho lol. Anyhoo, just an opinion.


He did point that out, and what you said actually makes good sense. I hadn't thought of it in that way. Although, he knows she still loves Alexis, and he knows this act will not stop her from loving him, and everyone knows Alexis would forgive this act, so really its a moot point still.
Also if he wanted a strong leader, wouldn't something like "No, we both have the same goals, work with me to obtain true victory" gone way further to show her strength, than easily submitting? This scene made her look incredibly weak IMO.
Even though your idea has good perspective, it needed to be made cannon, otherwise this scene can be taken any which way. This scene lacked clarity, irresponsible writing.
Mar 3, 2018 11:59 PM

Offline
Oct 2008
13718
So did they f*ck!? no, not Mirza x Marrine that's obviously already a given...i'm talking about Siluca x Theo after they kiss...lolz
That sex scene part i'm remembering some H-manga with a tag emotionless sex!
w0w so many comments for this specific episode! haha!
5/5.


Mar 4, 2018 12:02 AM
Offline
Jul 2015
17
DGemu said:
AbattoirRat said:


It felt like fan service at the cost of character development. I'm confused what the ending scene meant to convey. I could see her throwing her virginity away, tarnishing herself in a "point of no return" kind of way to sever her feelings, to focus on her goals, but in this way? It just felt like sloppy writing. There was room for debauchery and character development, but on a whim? It wasn't even a condition for their alliance. He just asked and she said okay.
And I know this goes beyond anime logic, but yes, please, lets strip defenseless in front of the assassin who currently works for my enemy.

TL; DR - The sex was pointless and hurt the show.

It was basically a test from Milza. Its common knowledge that Marrine and Alexis were to marry, and he was seeing if she loves Alexis and won't go all the way through with her methods she just showed to unite the crests.

But the thing is, theres like no other person shown who has the volition to unite all the crests with the means to an end attitude that Milza wants, so I'm pretty sure Milza would've temporarily joined them anyways or at the very least introduce a new person with that attitude or the guy just decides to do it himself. Worst case scenario, he would attempt to kill her if she refused and take her crest (which would've been interesting to me to show if this princess actually has some power or physical might).

This scene just comes off as for the shock value and it was hilarious to me. Its seemingly worked judging by some comments lol


First, I loved this show, it was smart, I still like it but...
If it was a test, I say she failed. He wants someone strong to follow, but why follow someone so weak willed that they would give up self respect without repercussion? It's honestly an oxymoron, "I want to follow someone strong, submit to me."
Shock value still needs to work within boundaries. It would be shocking if aliens came and deus ex machina a pivotal battle, but that would be terrible writing. This scene was terrible writing, made worse without explanation.
Lastly, if your shock value causes a drop epidemic, you did it wrong.
Mar 4, 2018 12:07 AM
Offline
Jul 2015
17
Jagd84 said:
AbattoirRat said:


It felt like fan service at the cost of character development. I'm confused what the ending scene meant to convey. I could see her throwing her virginity away, tarnishing herself in a "point of no return" kind of way to sever her feelings, to focus on her goals, but in this way? It just felt like sloppy writing. There was room for debauchery and character development, but on a whim? It wasn't even a condition for their alliance. He just asked and she said okay.
And I know this goes beyond anime logic, but yes, please, lets strip defenseless in front of the assassin who currently works for my enemy.

TL; DR - The sex was pointless and hurt the show.


Conquest is an euphemism for sex in this kind of context. Everybody both knew what he meant when he stated that which is Marrine's attendants where freaked out.

And more amused that a lot of people her are more outraged about the consensual than the fact she just used chemical warfare and violated the equivalent of Geneva Convention in their world. Who knows what kind of atrocities she is willing to commit now that she has crossed that line?


I understood the metaphor, merely pointing out he did not say it was conditional to their pact.

People are not freaking out over the weight of that act, but that the act itself was plainly bad writing.
Mar 4, 2018 12:11 AM
Offline
Sep 2016
1
Bad anime for this winter
Mar 4, 2018 12:15 AM
Offline
Apr 2016
95
SithSteel said:
Otaku_Joe said:


Maybe she is just really stupid

Perhaps. This show could be a lot better if it just slowed down a little and explained things.

Yeah true, it is going quite quickly
Pages (10) « First ... « 4 5 [6] 7 8 » ... Last »

More topics from this board

Poll: » Grancrest Senki Episode 2 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )

Stark700 - Jan 12, 2018

102 by LazyFlames »»
Aug 12, 8:08 PM

Poll: » Grancrest Senki Episode 10 Discussion ( 1 2 )

Stark700 - Mar 9, 2018

76 by Airs »»
Jun 9, 10:21 PM

Poll: » Grancrest Senki Episode 3 Discussion ( 1 2 )

Stark700 - Jan 19, 2018

86 by IskandarThain »»
May 17, 12:51 AM

Poll: » Grancrest Senki Episode 6 Discussion ( 1 2 )

Stark700 - Feb 9, 2018

53 by RGreatDanton »»
Apr 30, 3:44 AM

Poll: » Grancrest Senki Episode 5 Discussion ( 1 2 )

Stark700 - Feb 2, 2018

62 by RGreatDanton »»
Apr 29, 10:42 PM
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login