Oda Nobuna no Yabou Episode 12 Discussion

Rexky said:
7/10



I agree, besides the characters are generic and cliche as hell. Saru is just the typical dumb "ordinary highschool protagonist" that lacks the most basic forms of common sense and does constantly dumb stuff but despite all his stupid decisions everything ends up working for him. I seriously facepalmed when hit nobunas brother, as someone from future he should have known that htting him would have gotten him killed but despite of that he still hits him since all these cliche male characters can never control their emotions and always do stupid stuff beacause of that. And whats even worse is that he still tries to hit Imai Asai a few episodes after despite of what happened with nobunas little borther. Every single cliche male character is either perverted or stupidly innocent, this is no exception as saru has the typical slightly perverted attitude. This might be nothing important but it seriously pissed me off how he constantly repeated the "oh give me the prettiest girl in Japan" line, it pissed me so much it made me want puch him trough the monitor each time he said that. And well in general he always used tons of cliche lines throughout the series.

Well, when a show has a horrible male protagonist I always overlook that flaw if the show has a good female lead, unfortunatly this is not the case. Oda, despite being a better character than saru, she was still pretty bad. Just like Saru she is constantly doing really stupid decisions that made me facepalm Even after defeating Yoshitatsu who rebelled against her she still lets him go? ROFL what the hell is this? Dumbest shit I have ever seen in my life. I realize this is a kids show therefore killing him might be too much be they could have atlest thrown him into prison or something, what she did here just shows how she lacks any sort of common sense. I also hate how much she whined when she was forced to leave one her retainers behind to defend the rear, seriously what sort of leader would want to surrender beacause of something like that, has she not realized that people die in war and that sacrifices are often necesary in war? well of course not, since this is a kids show where its completly impossible for important characters to die. I have no problems with tsunderes if they are like Tohsaka Rin, Makise Kurisu or Aoi Kunieda but when tsunderes use physical violence on their lover like Oda Nobuna are very often trash. Seriously even after finding out Saru is still alive shit still hits him, sigh.

I have no problems with shows for kids, but the setting of Oda Nobuna no Yabou are not appropiate for a kids show and the fact they decided to make a kids show out of this what made it in my opinion bad.

The art style was pretty good tough

Raziel1991 said:

Poparteeb said:


Hey man, you're missing the point.

Enjoy Oda Nobuna for what it is, not for what you're comparing it to. It's much more of a light-hearted/romance/don't give too many fucks about the serious nature' type of show.

Hell, if I was to criticize it for realism, I'd have dropped this shoe after ep 1. However, if you just take it in stride and watch it for what it is:

- a pleasantly done sengoku gender bender with some romance that isn't very serious or realistic, then you're good. I personally found it entertaining as hell. Even when they inject some kind of drama, I still was like, welp, its gonna turn out well, lets see what happens.

You're comparing this show to Fate and Steins;Gate, which is not exactly apt. Those shows start getting really serious and mature, Oda Nobuna, as it turns out, for this adaptation, is not ever touching the sense of maturity those 2 shows reached, especially Steins;Gate.