Do you guys have examples of anime directors that fell off in your opinion? Mamoru Oishii gotta be the prime example of this with the "show" he created back in 2021 which nobody talks about.
| Sorry in advance for the "rant" Imagine criticizing modern anime and its creators for the “lack of focus” studios have, telling some directors they are “geniuses at copying others” or “devoid of any substance.” Then, decades later, they make an abysmal attempt at comedy that not only copies others (failing to even do that right) but also lacks any semblance of substance. Even worse, they act as if they are above tropes, making fun of them while still using them anyway. I know he said this show can serve as “strong medicine” and “piss off an old man,” but it fails on both fronts since old men aren’t watching this, and the people who usually watch this type of show will find the referential humor boring, tacked on, and nonsensical. It’s like if a Letterboxd user created a show just to brag about how cultured he is. The show itself is not funny at all, the animation is mediocre at best, it can look good in some moment but it feel rushed and cheap most of the time, the character design is either uninspired or straight up ugly and not in the good “experimental way” speaking of that, they also have live-action sequences but they are just not funny either like you would see in Panty and Stocking, not even a fraction of Trigger’s worst shows. The most interesting part about this is the presumption that this project was merely a money laundering scheme from a company called ICHIGO INC., which is a sustainable energy company. They only opened a subsidiary called Ichigo Animation, but this company hasn’t done anything since 2021, and their contact section is no longer working. The show was also a collaboration with Studio DRIVE and Production I.G. They bragged about how they got him behind it and that this was his ORIGINAL creation, which is the most disappointing aspect of all of this because it feels so empty. It has nothing to say, it’s not funny, and it’s not even so bad that it’s good; it’s just plain boring. This wasn’t a deep, subtle critique of modern anime since it embraces the worst aspects of it. I assume he just wanted to make more money and stay relevant, which he failed to do since nobody talks about him that much nowadays outside of anime news networks. I hear zero hype surrounding his new projects (if they even past pre-production at this point), and that show faded into irrelevance before it was completed, especially since they split the show into two parts. Also, nobody discusses the live-action movies he made recently. It’s so sad to see someone who was involved in on of the most influential films of all time ending up doing an insult to not only art but it’s legacy, If you want to create this kind of wacky over the top show and maybe make fun of others, at least do it right you know. Some say there might've been problems in the production and stuff which i doubt since they had time to make this, 3 studios behind, professional that should've known better, and according to same, it was based on a visual novel made by Oshii that has pretty much the exact same plot execpt the creepy anemic grey haired loser is male there so i doubt there was any struggle to figure out the nothing burger plot.  |
| oshii never fell because he was already down, he is an embarassment. He may be a good animator and artist but a failure as a director. |
    |
| Mamoru Oishii was never good, all the works attributed to him had many different artists' visions working on them not only his own. Also, none of the Ghost in the Shell animated media are faithful to the original manga but i'd hope Science saru can fix that in 2026. |
| My man Oshii is no longer a nazbol. He's now an expert libertarian who wants to commit tax fraud by money laundering. |
| MEA·MENTVLA·INGENS·EST |
| He fell off way earlier with Mezame no Hakobune. After Jin-Rou the man lost his mind in my opinion. |
| Everyone who already had their career peak. |
*kappa* |
| "criticizing modern anime and its creators for the “lack of focus”" The things OP are talking about come a bit like equivalence fallacy to me. Yes, most of the big anime artists have a stinker of too in their careers, but there are some guys in the industry who are consistently bad to mediocre. Also I wouldn't call Vlad Love a bad show. Its main problem is being too much idiosyncratic...which tends to happen with vanity projects. |
Reply to tchitchouan
Mamoru Oishii was never good, all the works attributed to him had many different artists' visions working on them not only his own.
Also, none of the Ghost in the Shell animated media are faithful to the original manga but i'd hope Science saru can fix that in 2026.
Also, none of the Ghost in the Shell animated media are faithful to the original manga but i'd hope Science saru can fix that in 2026.
| @tchitchouan Being faithful to the source material is not a sign of quality. The original GitS manga is arguably the worst piece of GitS media, suffering from terrible tonal clash between the serious plot, and the incessant humor (like FMA Brotherhood). And any 100% loyal adaptation would end up with the hentai tag... |
Prophetess of the Golden Era  |
Reply to Deathko
@tchitchouan Being faithful to the source material is not a sign of quality. The original GitS manga is arguably the worst piece of GitS media, suffering from terrible tonal clash between the serious plot, and the incessant humor (like FMA Brotherhood).
And any 100% loyal adaptation would end up with the hentai tag...
And any 100% loyal adaptation would end up with the hentai tag...
| @Deathko Yes exactly as Masamune Shirow has always intended with all the gratuitous nudity and boobage he could draw, i yearn for a gits anime that is as faithful and as pornographic as https://myanimelist.net/anime/20261/W-Tails_Cat__A_Strange_Presence, but so far we've only gotten only the philosophical transhumanist side of gits and none of the sexy side, but i hope science saru could rectify that in their new adaptation which seems to be more faithful. https://myanimelist.net/anime/58929/Koukaku_Kidoutai_TV |
| True, Oshii's career went downhill after a mere 21 episodes of Urusei Yatsura. Hiroyuki Yamaga is another example. His biggest hit was Honneamise in 1987. His attempt to replicate this success never went anywhere, unlike Anno's milking of Evangelion. Osamu Tezuka hasn't directed anything since 1989. Thank goodness his son is doing a better job than Miyazaki's son. |
LucifrostOct 31, 2024 7:06 AM
| その目だれの目？ |
tchitchouan said: none of the Ghost in the Shell animated media are faithful to the original manga but i'd hope Science saru can fix that in 2026. The original manga was no good. If it wasn't for the 1995 movie "Ghost in the Shell" wouldn't have brand recognition. Deathko said: The original GitS manga is arguably the worst piece of GitS media, suffering from terrible tonal clash between the serious plot, and the incessant humor (like FMA Brotherhood). Pretty much this. Except the Netflix SAC_2045 embarrassment exists now, which is much, much, much worse than the original manga. Arise was already a major step down, too. And I guess Hollywood also made a terrible live-action version. Then there's the awful remake/remaster of the 1995 movie with lots of CGI added in for no reason at all. There's big competition for "worst piece of GitS media" and I don't think the original manga got what it takes anymore. Heck, there's so much shit that it is honestly astounding that the reputation of the 1995 movie can carry the franchise to this day. Stand Alone Complex is also excellent, but I feel that one has been forgotten, unfortunately. |
Reply to TransferUser
tchitchouan said:
none of the Ghost in the Shell animated media are faithful to the original manga but i'd hope Science saru can fix that in 2026.
none of the Ghost in the Shell animated media are faithful to the original manga but i'd hope Science saru can fix that in 2026.
The original manga was no good. If it wasn't for the 1995 movie "Ghost in the Shell" wouldn't have brand recognition.
Deathko said:
The original GitS manga is arguably the worst piece of GitS media, suffering from terrible tonal clash between the serious plot, and the incessant humor (like FMA Brotherhood).
The original GitS manga is arguably the worst piece of GitS media, suffering from terrible tonal clash between the serious plot, and the incessant humor (like FMA Brotherhood).
Pretty much this. Except the Netflix SAC_2045 embarrassment exists now, which is much, much, much worse than the original manga. Arise was already a major step down, too. And I guess Hollywood also made a terrible live-action version. Then there's the awful remake/remaster of the 1995 movie with lots of CGI added in for no reason at all.
There's big competition for "worst piece of GitS media" and I don't think the original manga got what it takes anymore.
Heck, there's so much shit that it is honestly astounding that the reputation of the 1995 movie can carry the franchise to this day. Stand Alone Complex is also excellent, but I feel that one has been forgotten, unfortunately.
TransferUser said: Yes that indeed very true. but i prefer masamune shirow's "no good" manga, i never liked most of the animated adaptations of his work.The original manga was no good. If it wasn't for the 1995 movie "Ghost in the Shell" wouldn't have brand recognition. |
tchitchouan said: but i prefer masamune shirow's "no good" manga It would have been a lot better if it had more Ecchi than the first two pages. The way the 1989 manga is it's kinda like an inferior Dominion (1985). |
Reply to TransferUser
tchitchouan said:
but i prefer masamune shirow's "no good" manga
but i prefer masamune shirow's "no good" manga
It would have been a lot better if it had more Ecchi than the first two pages. The way the 1989 manga is it's kinda like an inferior Dominion (1985).
| @TransferUser Yes, that is an accurate assessment and i agree with your statement. |
| Did you create an alt account for this? Oshihi didnt direct Jin-roh btw. The Lupin epsiode he directed was pretty awesome so he still does great work from time to time. |
| @TransferUser I had forgot all about that garbage Hollywood movie 😭 Also, Netflix SAC??? I've been out of the loop for too long... |
Prophetess of the Golden Era |
More topics from this board
» Worst anime openingsRetroCagliostro - Oct 5 |
28 |
by NS2D
»»
53 seconds ago |
|
» Upcoming Dubbed Anime ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Kenny_Stryker - Dec 17, 2017 |
3981 |
by Paladin23
»»
2 minutes ago |
|
» ⌛ Best Girls of the Past ErasShizuna - 3 hours ago |
46 |
by Duado
»»
4 minutes ago |
|
Sticky: » AWC 2025 Anime Watching Challenge - Sign-Up (Open Until December 10th) ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )AWC_mod - Jan 1 |
901 |
by LMKirkland
»»
52 minutes ago |
|
» Are you smart enough to explain your favorite anime to angry people who ask questions?Catalano - Yesterday |
24 |
by Absurdo_N
»»
54 minutes ago |