GiinZo said: I don't see most of these on your list. If you haven't even watched them, you are in no position to talk about them, honestly.overrated-naruto, bleach, one piece, code geass, legend of the galactic heroes, full metal alchemist, Ouran High School Host Club,ghost in the shell, last but not least Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann |
| Overrated: Toki wo Kakeru Shoujo (OVERRATED) Gurren Lagann (GREATLY OVERRATED, Good anime but lots of inmature Fanboy Fanservice and definetely not better then alot animes in the top 60* maybe even more) Code Geass (a bit overated) Believe me i liked them but i find them overrated. Underrated: NANA (so much better then alot animes above it, pure reality and perfect storytelling) Kimi Ga Nozomu Eien (this is how it goes in real life, could relate it to my own relationship i had, beautifull anime)/(too mature and depressing for some inmature people here. DAMN UNDERRATED here on MAL while its nr3 on animenfo and on ANN it gets a high rating too) Death Note (what a disgrace that its lower then Code Geass and Guren Lagann on the list *Pukes*) Full Metal Panic The Second Raid (wtf Fumoffu higher? it was funny but not better then the Second Raid with story and such, it should be alot higher in the list) Kanon 2006 (is better then some animes in the top 30 maybe not with story but the anime itself is pure wonderfull) |
GdesuOct 21, 2009 12:22 PM
Baman said: So? GiinZo said: I don't see most of these on your list. overrated-naruto, bleach, one piece, code geass, legend of the galactic heroes, full metal alchemist, Ouran High School Host Club,ghost in the shell, last but not least Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann Maybe he just forget to update his list or maybe he doesn't really care about updating his list. Who knows? |
HooHiraiBunnyOct 21, 2009 12:56 PM
psgels said: Garuda said: Kimi Ga Nozomu Eien (this is how it goes in real life, could relate it to my own relationship i had, beautifull anime)/(too mature and depressing for some inmature people here. DAMN UNDERRATED here on MAL while its nr3 on animenfo and on ANN it gets a high rating too) For anyone with more than a passing knowledge of fundamental neurology and psychology it is nothing like reality. I thought it was sort of like one long, giant soap opera episode in style, execution, plot and maturity really. Though I was positively surprised that they actually kept to their theme by the end. |
How is the world ruled and how do wars start? Diplomats tell lies to journalists and then believe what they read. | Report rules abuse | Your Panel | Clubs | Messages | Forum | Recent <img src="http://img593.imageshack.us/img593/4672/stuhlbarg.png" /> |
Baman said: GiinZo said: I don't see most of these on your list. If you haven't even watched them, you are in no position to talk about them, honestly.overrated-naruto, bleach, one piece, code geass, legend of the galactic heroes, full metal alchemist, Ouran High School Host Club,ghost in the shell, last but not least Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann haha. i only put the anime i like on my list. rebekah said: GiinZo said: overrated- code geass, legend of the galactic heroes, Ouran High School Host Club, last but not least Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann WRONG! If you mentioned these to people at school they would have NO idea what your talking about. actually nobody talks about anime... HooHiraiBunny said: Baman said: So? GiinZo said: I don't see most of these on your list. overrated-naruto, bleach, one piece, code geass, legend of the galactic heroes, full metal alchemist, Ouran High School Host Club,ghost in the shell, last but not least Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann Maybe he just forget to update his list or maybe he doesn't really care about updating his list. Who knows? correct. i never really update my list since im not a huge otaku Mod edit: Please don't triple post. You can edit a previous post to add something further. |
AsakoOct 21, 2009 4:48 PM
 |
GiinZo said: I see.haha. i only put the anime i like on my list. Then what made you dislike LoGH? Since you seem to have found it overrated, I assume you must have at least watched it halfway through or something? |
Baman said: GiinZo said: I see.haha. i only put the anime i like on my list. Then what made you dislike LoGH? Since you seem to have found it overrated, I assume you must have at least watched it halfway through or something? 16 episodes got bored and dropped it. i really didnt like the story, wasnt interesting |
| |
Kaiserpingvin said: psgels said: Garuda said: Kimi Ga Nozomu Eien (this is how it goes in real life, could relate it to my own relationship i had, beautifull anime)/(too mature and depressing for some inmature people here. DAMN UNDERRATED here on MAL while its nr3 on animenfo and on ANN it gets a high rating too) For anyone with more than a passing knowledge of fundamental neurology and psychology it is nothing like reality. I thought it was sort of like one long, giant soap opera episode in style, execution, plot and maturity really. Though I was positively surprised that they actually kept to their theme by the end. why cant someone be hit by a car out of nowhere and get into a coma? And in fact its very realistic and MATURE romance, maybe you are too young too understand or you never had a lovelife yourself yet with depressing problems, i had a relationship for 3 years wich was going terrible at the end and we didnt talk alot while we lived with eachother, sometimes me or she ran away from home out of anger, argued over simple things everyday just like the mains in Kimi Ga Nozomu Eien. i truly felt each character almost like if they where real, i could relate it exactly to real life common relationship problems. and ive seen many people do this around me, even middle aged couples, or parents of people. kimi ga nozomu eien deals with common and realistic problems in relationships in a dramatic and depressing way wich is how it goes in real life too. yes Animes like Clannad and Kanon and such are wonderfull, but no not very realistic in terms of romance, its TOO wonderfull. in real life almost nothing is like how wonderfull it looks in animes, while in Kimi Ga Nozomu Eien the events that happen there are exactly like thow that would go in real life with the majority of people. some people are just too inmature or undevelopt in love to understand these feelings. it doesnt surprise me either that people who i recommend it to and like it are mostly people who are above 18 or above 20, and people who dont like it are mostly under that age or people didnt have a long term relationship yet |
| Hatenkou Yuugi. Seriously underrated! Ok I know that the first episode is one big wtf as there seems to be no plot or reason to anything that is done and characters just strangely appear as if they have always been a part of the story. However, once you get past that initial mecca fail of an intro the story progresses and it actually turns out to be quite good as far as adventure goes. I wont lie, there are still parts that are hard to follow and the characters always seem to know something you don't but it's all part of the craziness that is at the root of this anime series. |
AlexisSolitaire said: psgels said: AlexisSolitaire said: kaname-yuki-san said: Naruto and Code Geass Esp Naruto. The most emo stuff ever. Just be glad that you haven't watched Vampire Knight. ;) Unfortunately, I have (Season 1). but i watched it already -__- |
 |
| Hayate_Sama Then why is it that you have some 'dropped' anime on your list, if you only add anime you like on it? christ. i joined mal like 2 months ago. i was really into it but then i just got bored and stopped updating it. the anime i have on my plan to watch list i already completed some of them. and for the love of god, i stated my opinion and im staying by it. |
| |
VeryFastKid said: Overrated: NARUTO! Amen brother. Especially here at MAL. |
| I'm back. |
| Overrated (imo) - Code Geass: R2 Season 1 was great, but season 2 just lost me. Plot is all over the place. Lulu's characterization is all over the place. Although the ending was tragic and perfect, it doesn't make up for the abundance of fanservice and off the wall/circular logic used in the battles to me. Underrated - Ghost Hunt! One of my all time favorite anime that almost no one I know cares about or even likes. The only way to find people who like it is to make them watch my dvds with me! Also, so sad at everyone including Ouran High School Host Club on their overrated lists. By far one of my favorite anime ever. It's the reason I gave shojo anime a chance! hehe |
Sick_Bastard said: VeryFastKid said: Overrated: NARUTO! Amen brother. Especially here at MAL. |
 |
| Overrated: Code Geass, Clannad Underrated: Hikaru no Go |
 |
Kaiserpingvin said: For anyone with more than a passing knowledge of fundamental neurology and psychology it is nothing like reality. Would you say there are better shows in that regard? Can you point them out? |
 |
Usami-Haru said: Underrated: Bakumatsu Kikansetsu Irohanihoheto. Maybe it was the name that's too long, but most people don't know about this anime. I loved all of it, the plot was engaging, the characters interesting and original, the only flaw was the ending. But the character development and the epilogue made up for it. I second this so much! I should've included it. I have no taste for historical anime, but this one absolutely kept me riveting. I kept joking that I was giddy to see how it ended even though I could easily find out. =) Akizuki is such a great protagonist. I agree that the ending had a couple "eh??" moments for me, but overall I loved the idea of it.. Akizuki finding out what his true power was, etc. I just hated how they completed him and kakunojo. Ah well. I loved it. Akuzuki is my desktop! |
| overrated-ouran highschool host club, code geass underrated-maison ikkoku |
corbenic said: RahXephon almost certainly works.Kaiserpingvin said: For anyone with more than a passing knowledge of fundamental neurology and psychology it is nothing like reality. Would you say there are better shows in that regard? Can you point them out? Also, Figure 17 is heavily underrated. |
Confucius say man who stand on toilet is high on pot. |
| Underrated: Megazone 23 here on MAL |
 |
| Underrated: CANAAN |
| Overated: Code Geass *Sighs... I dropped it. I just couldn't stand how it goes... I'm not too fan of those mecha empire stuffs... Overated in mai world: Naruto, Bleach (Ima SJ hater kill me kill me kill me kill me) Amen. Underated: Kaiji I haven't seen this, but I know it's good. My father's favourite anime. I was the only one who actually knew this anime in my school. So yeah. |
AlexisSolitaire said: Underrated: CANAAN because it sucks |
 |
BigSimo said: The 10's are because it's so bad it's hilarious. I just wish that there were subs, as apparently it's even funnier when you know what everybody is saying (although some companies have been looking to license it, so we may yet see it in English).Jaapsneep said: wow. that's the first time i've seen that kind of thing - unless most of those 10s are for the lulz (like with Mars of Destruction).THIS underrated and overrated at the same time (scores vary from 1 - 10, but I haven't seen anyone rate it 2-9 :P) |
| Confucius say man who stand on toilet is high on pot. |
| overrated: toradora |
| So zetta slow! |
Mawootad said: BigSimo said: The 10's are because it's so bad it's hilarious. I just wish that there were subs, as apparently it's even funnier when you know what everybody is saying (although some companies have been looking to license it, so we may yet see it in English).Jaapsneep said: wow. that's the first time i've seen that kind of thing - unless most of those 10s are for the lulz (like with Mars of Destruction).THIS underrated and overrated at the same time (scores vary from 1 - 10, but I haven't seen anyone rate it 2-9 :P) Oh lord. Why do things like this get picked up and things like LOGH get left behind. :/ |
| I'm back. |
Sick_Bastard said: VeryFastKid said: Overrated: NARUTO! Amen brother. Especially here at MAL. Hallelujah!! |
Sick_Bastard said: Because LotGH is long and old, whereas GUN-dou Musashi is epically bad, recent, short, and therefore probably not very expensive (not to mention that the unedited dvds sold rather well in Japan).Mawootad said: BigSimo said: The 10's are because it's so bad it's hilarious. I just wish that there were subs, as apparently it's even funnier when you know what everybody is saying (although some companies have been looking to license it, so we may yet see it in English).Jaapsneep said: wow. that's the first time i've seen that kind of thing - unless most of those 10s are for the lulz (like with Mars of Destruction).THIS underrated and overrated at the same time (scores vary from 1 - 10, but I haven't seen anyone rate it 2-9 :P) Oh lord. Why do things like this get picked up and things like LOGH get left behind. :/ |
| Confucius say man who stand on toilet is high on pot. |
| True Tears is underrated D: |
| Glass Mask (2005) has to be the most underrated anime here. Only 404 completed and 1841 members. It isn't even an old anime. 2005-2006. All episodes are subbed and it has a high score yet hardly anyone watches it. |
       |
| underrated: Mouryou no Hako (still waiting for the someone to sub the last episode... :/) and Pani Poni Dash |
 |
ruusakraj said: Glass Mask (2005) has to be the most underrated anime here. Only 404 completed and 1841 members. It isn't even an old anime. 2005-2006. All episodes are subbed and it has a high score yet hardly anyone watches it. I agree, though I haven't finished it because, for the longest time, it didn't have the last half subbed. I may just pick that back up as it was an excellent series. |
| "Yes, I have been deprived of emotion. But not completely. Whoever did it, botched the job." - Geralt of Rivia |
papapapuffy said: underated: hentai overrated: yaoi/yuri That doesn't make sense. |
| I'm back. |
papapapuffy said: underated: hentai overrated: yaoi/yuri You should state the names of the anime. |
AlexisSolitaire said: papapapuffy said: underated: hentai overrated: yaoi/yuri You should state the names of the anime. HE WAS MAKING A FUNNY |
| I'm back. |
| Most underrated: from this autumn, it's sure Princess lover. Most overrated: Kyoto+Key TRASH |
| I have Princess Lover on my hard drive. Is it that good? |
| I'm back. |
| Princess Lover is the summer release, not autumn. Overrated: Nana, School Days Underrated: Sasameki Koto |
More topics from this board
» what do you think about people who say that older anime is better than newer anime. ( 1 2 )MRM2405 - Oct 24 |
84 |
by BilboBaggins365
»»
2 minutes ago |
|
» ANIME STRENGTH COMPARISON.LETS SETTLE THIS WITHOUT USE OF WEB OR AI ( 1 2 )A_THUND3R-1000 - Today |
55 |
by Phloup
»»
5 minutes ago |
|
» You realize the anime you're watching is actually bad, would you drop it?Rinrinka - Yesterday |
42 |
by kihel
»»
8 minutes ago |
|
» Would having more normal body types for female characters be nice? ( 1 2 )fallout45 - Oct 28 |
77 |
by RobertBobert
»»
18 minutes ago |
|
» Am I the only one who can't stand dub haters? ( 1 2 )Mattenan - Yesterday |
83 |
by Kruszer
»»
20 minutes ago |