DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
btw. was there any information about 2nd season of Given? I'm looking forward it. And I'm here just to say (totally-not-like-only-100-people-did-it-before-me-in-thousands-ways): I FUCKIN LOVE THIS PERFORMANCE AND THIS EP, bye |
 |
| Oh man what a banging episode. They really nailed it on all fronts. I thought maybe that kiss would start some drama, but nah it's all good. Great song as well. Imma believe that he had those lyrics ready to go beforehand and just was afraid to say anything to his mates cause there's no way you just bang out a full song live like that. |
LienAlexandretta said: don't think there's enough mangabtw. was there any information about 2nd season of Given? I'm looking forward it. |
 |
| That song was INCREDIBLE! The part when Mafuyu straight up screamed was so perfect I can't even describe it, there was some raspy feel to it, too. Totally worth the wait ♥ |
| ☆ |
SouthRzVa said: I still don't get the context of the fight with Mafuyu and the "would you die for me?" phrase but I only can guess that Yuki was already suicidal or at least, was going through some kind of depression that the viewer had to notice. Don't quote me on this, but I'm pretty sure the flashbacks show that Mafuyu and Yuki were described to have been going through rough patches in their relationship and out of anger Mafuyu shouted "would you die for me". Those words must have held a lot of weight and most likely he asked this question as a way of testing Yuki's love for him sort of a like "do you love me enough to die for me?" sort of question. Mafuyu said those words out of anger because of their fight and in no way wanted him to actually die. I think we would have to assume that Yuki was depressed and suicidal already and we are left to assume those words probably had an effect on Yuki during the battle he was going through. I think the significance of that flashback to those words he says are his last moments with Yuki (the argument) and how Mafuyu might even blame himself and feel this heavy weight of guilt for words he said during the fight they had. It was just a fight, he probably wasn't thinking when he was angry maybe he felt hurt or betrayed (we don't really know for sure). I think these are all natural response: to feel guilty, to feel betrayed (for Yuki to leave him), and to feel all these things so during his song he went through a lot of those emotions and part of what he expresses is his thankfulness for Yuki, how he cannot forgive himself and cannot forgive Yuki either but he wants to and he is learning to keep living on. And that he knows he isn't alone. a more direct answer to your question though: |
EarlCielSep 6, 2019 7:45 PM
| I still can't get over this episode... I know a ton of people have already said something like this, but the song that Mafuyu sang was outstanding, especially with that monologue he gave throughout the song. The whole time, I felt the raw emotion he emitted when he sang, all those emotions he had for Yuki. I felt especially emotional when he screamed after the "Would you die for me?" bit and when he thought "I miss you," because I think those were we he felt really emotional. I've already rewatched this episode a bunch of times (especially the performance), but this always seems to blow me away. Given has already taken the spot for my favourite BL and music (as in music with lyrics) anime. I'm also kinda sad that this would end in 2 weeks, and I'm kinda hoping there'll be a second season. Once this anime ends, I'm definitely gonna read the manga. Also, I'm quite surprised that Mafuyu's voice actor, Shougo Yano, isn't in that many anime series? Especially music anime? I thought he would have been more popular because I think his voice was amazing. |
 |
| I really am SO glad that I decided to watch this anime! This was my favourite episode so far, it was amazing. I LOVED that song! when the flashback hit I was on tears. Yuki was such a nice and fun guy, it breaks my heart that he had such a tragic end. Just two more episodes to go, what a shame. I'm gonna miss this. |
 |
| THE BEST EPISODE EVER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Ritsuka-chan BEST ANGELIC SMILE!  |
tangerine_sushiSep 6, 2019 10:52 PM
| I've got one word: FEELS. |
 |
| I'm still not over how perfect this episode was. I've cried several times reading this part of the manga, but this hit me so hard in yet another way. My favorite part of the whole song is when Mafuyu screams, cause you can hear and understand even if just a little how hurt he is and how even words can't exactly descibe his feelings. I think is a pity they didn't include Uenoyama's pov since it'd let you understand his emotions at that moment and how it made sense for him to go and kiss Mafuyu. |
| why did it take me until just now to realize that the symbolism in the broken guitar strings is that Uenoyama is slowly helping Sato piece back his broken heart because of Yuki. like the guitar strings literally broke the moment Yuki died. i- |
| 〰坂本竜馬はホモなんですよ〰 |
AnimeSnapShotz said: Idk, if I were a producer I'd deem it too risky. Even if you're optimisitic and say s1 will end at chapter 15, that's 13 chapters left, it's barely enough. Don't forget usually adaptations do something like two chapters an episode, so a cour needs 24 chapters, what happened in s1 is very unusual and I doubt it'll happen again. Especially if there's something like an arc ongoing in the manga. Animators like to have room of manoeuvre.There are currently 28 chapters of the manga. With episode 9 we have completed up to chapter 11 plus some content from chapters 12 and 13. So there could be enough for a second season, but the question is does Given have enough popularity for the production companies to put the $$ out for a second season? |
|
SouthRzVa said: Man, despite his looks, Yuki really was a sweet guy. I still don't get the context of the fight with Mafuyu and the "would you die for me?" phrase but I only can guess that Yuki was already suicidal or at least, was going through some kind of depression that the viewer had to notice. Anyways, it was a great episode overall and although the first part was a bit cliche for my taste, the presentation really made up for it. It was indeed a fantastic performance and Mafuyu's voice actually left me feeling quite moved. Yuki's suicide is reaaaaaally spoiler territory. If you're interested, I suggest you read the manga but to give a simple answer, their relationship wasn't really that perfect and they still fight like ordinary couples. It doesn't help that they were really young back then and had family issues. |
 |
EratiK said: AnimeSnapShotz said: Idk, if I were a producer I'd deem it too risky. Even if you're optimisitic and say s1 will end at chapter 15, that's 13 chapters left, it's barely enough. Don't forget usually adaptations do something like two chapters an episode, so a cour needs 24 chapters, what happened in s1 is very unusual and I doubt it'll happen again. Especially if there's something like an arc ongoing in the manga. Animators like to have room of manoeuvre.There are currently 28 chapters of the manga. With episode 9 we have completed up to chapter 11 plus some content from chapters 12 and 13. So there could be enough for a second season, but the question is does Given have enough popularity for the production companies to put the $$ out for a second season? The second season propably would focus on Haruki- Akihiko relation and Akihiko- Ugetsu, but later in manga there isn't any meaning actions about band development or anything else than them (or maybe I don't remember well) so I'm also not convinced if others chapters would be enough at this moment. But I think there is high possibility that sequel will be aired (in undetermined future) |
|
| NOW THIS IS THE EPISODE I've been waiting for. All those emotions of healing Mafuyu's heart after his friend Yuki's aftermath of a suicide, just like the guitar string symbolism in the OP, and even post-credits last episode. Even as someone like me who is not into BL, this strikes me the same way Bloom Into You did last year, just multiply that 100 times better in simple, basic but flawless execution and skill. Uenoyama realising ALL THIS TIME that Mafuyu has always been doing things on his own and trying to get good...being someone who is more technical than cautious. Irregardless, all feelings and emotions are prepared into the play. Mafuyu's song...is NOT JUST powerful, but soulful AND most importantly very, very raw, all of his life's experiences with Yuki from cradle to death. Life's unfair, but that kiss MADE ALL THE DIFFERENCE. Telling Mafuyu that Uenoyama is in love with him, and he's not lonely in his pursuit of music, and in Mafuyu's post-wording to Hiiragi, tells him of a new-found interest and love, which incites confidence and reliance in his band circle. Post-credits reveal more about Yuuki and Mafuyu, their time together like a side story (Chapter 11.5) in the same timeline, before his untimely death. Even sex before death...yea, yes not. What an exciting, yet phenomenal and exhilarating episode. Hanging in my breath from start to finish. It's easily a 100/10 in my book. |
 |
| was that expecting that to be that good! This anime is so good at building things up, and finally when he SANG, my god !! I really hope they make a second season and continue this |
| This was already incredibly powerful and emotional in the manga but this was even better because of the song. To actually hear it, all the pain and loss being screamed out. Great episode! |
m0llerz said: was that expecting that to be that good! This anime is so good at building things up, and finally when he SANG, my god !! I really hope they make a second season and continue this Yes, that would be wonderful. Also, there is still enough material for a second season. I wish I would know when the next manga volume will be released. I binge-read all five volumes that have been available so far but I want more. |
| This was a beautiful episode, and I'm still crying. Like ah my heart.. It was done so well, the feels hit harder than they did when I read the manga. The string breaking, Uenoyama running, when they were on stage and you see Mafuyu looking at his three bandmates..the song and the scenes of Mafuyu and Yuki together... Mafuyu's voice was more powerful than I had expected...ahh...my tears were just pouring. And then when he was singing of moving forward and the lights got brighter and we got to see Uenoyama's beautiful smile and everyone feeling that song T^T Wasn't expecting the beach scene to be included at the end...that hurt... Looking forward to the next episodes, and what will happen with Mafuyu and Uenoyama. |
Tohsaka_Rukia said: SouthRzVa said: Man, despite his looks, Yuki really was a sweet guy. I still don't get the context of the fight with Mafuyu and the "would you die for me?" phrase but I only can guess that Yuki was already suicidal or at least, was going through some kind of depression that the viewer had to notice. Anyways, it was a great episode overall and although the first part was a bit cliche for my taste, the presentation really made up for it. It was indeed a fantastic performance and Mafuyu's voice actually left me feeling quite moved. Yuki's suicide is reaaaaaally spoiler territory. If you're interested, I suggest you read the manga but to give a simple answer, their relationship wasn't really that perfect and they still fight like ordinary couples. It doesn't help that they were really young back then and had family issues. Oh, I see. Then I guess there's still a lot to cover regarding their story and that this performance just worked as a way to give Mafuyu more development rather than giving his problems a closure as I initially thought. Thanks for the info, by the way. Perhaps I will give the manga a chance if the anime doesn't receive an announcement for a second season soon. |
| The lyrics of the Mafuyu's song was so heartbreaking that I found myself crying in the middle of the flashbacks even when I read the manga before, it was an a sofocating sadness who broke me into tears. Aboiding this fact the last images about Yuki and Mafuyu's past was sad too and I cryed again. Sad to notice that the end it's almost near. Just 2 episodes more and thats all. Btw I really love Haruki reactions to Akihiko provocations. |
-¡Give yourself to me! |
huntress1013 said: m0llerz said: was that expecting that to be that good! This anime is so good at building things up, and finally when he SANG, my god !! I really hope they make a second season and continue this Yes, that would be wonderful. Also, there is still enough material for a second season. I wish I would know when the next manga volume will be released. I binge-read all five volumes that have been available so far but I want more. I’ve been avoiding reading the Manga because I feel like since I can’t actually hear the music, it might be harder to follow? Would you say to read it if I want more background and depth though on each character? God my rating on this anime went from 7 to 9 just from this one episode due to the FEELS. |
| hmmm a powerful episode.... |
 |
| "Say, Haruki. You can be a little more conceited, you know." Oof its happening. Their faces when Mafuyu started singing, epic. That's a great song. Powerful vocals too, this went beyond my expectations. The instrumental, lyrics, melody and vocals. Ah, so Mafuyu asked him if he could die for him and that's what led to Yuki's death? Hmm, still a bit. stupid on his former lover's part but I can see why Mafuyu takes as it he does. The smile Ritsuka and Mafuyu share on the stage is so precious. Even tho he partly must be jealous, he smiled so purely. That kiss. Perfect. That post-ED scene sure was powerful. Also hate bots can go bite their own hate, hah. |
| EEEEWWWWWW! revolting and gross that kiss was nice... |
 |
| This episode honestly will get this anime a +1 mark for me. It really doesnt even matter what happens the next few episodes. Man that was powerful. Such a great series. Did not expect that at all! |
 check out my twitch: https://twitch.tv/slowy |
| from 2 "hated it" to 41...people really were mad this episode was amazing |
 |
Tsukizono said: m0llerz said: I’ve been avoiding reading the Manga because I feel like since I can’t actually hear the music, it might be harder to follow? Would you say to read it if I want more background and depth though on each character? God my rating on this anime went from 7 to 9 just from this one episode due to the FEELS. The anime actually drags out the manga and adds a lot of anime original scenes, so the character depth thing definitely doesn't apply, except for this ep where Uenoyama had a very short monologue during the performance and during the kiss scene that was removed. The kiss scene was also portrayed differently in the manga - it was more passionate and intense while in the anime it's soft and gentle. However, the manga is still great because the art is very detailed and beautiful - it conveys atmosphere and emotion extremely well and tbh the performance scene in the manga is still amazing without the music. The manga is faster paced but I wouldn't say that it's hard to follow or anything. Totally agree. The extra scenes in the anime are wonderful and totally fit BUT the manga is also great because we get a lot of internal monologues that are missing in the anime. In the manga, for example, we have this internal monologue of Uenoyama who has finally accepted that he loves Mafuyu. I can definitely recommend the manga because it adds to the story but on a different level. |
beminim said: justasadguy said: yeah, it is probably just homophobes anyway. They hate to see a show having successfrom 2 "hated it" to 41...people really were mad this episode was amazing this episode went from 98 to 89 in a day...and it had 0 "hated it" marks yesterday |
|
justasadguy said: beminim said: yeah, it is probably just homophobes anyway. They hate to see a show having success this episode went from 98 to 89 in a day...and it had 0 "hated it" marks yesterday There will always be people butthurt over a BL/fujoshi anime gaining traction. Just look at that chinese anime fiasco. I really doubt those scores came from people who actually watched the episode. Probably feeling threatened Given was entering the 8.00 mark. |
|
| Praise be to the anime gods for blessing my eyes and ears with this episode. |
90s J-rock was our aesthetic peak. |
| Omo!! my eyes!!! （／_＼） I feel sad :( I ship Mafuyu x Yuki T-T I like Uenoyama but the "bond" of Yuki and Mafuyu is in another level.. I'm sad for the end of their relationship :( I don't hate BL.. but it's really a waste to see pretty guys like pretty guys too huuhu >gomen< I read the manga, I changed my mind about BL now lol |
erenmeiiSep 29, 2019 8:18 PM
| Proverbs 4:23 Above all else, guard your heart, for everything you do flows from it. |
| Came back to check the poll results and wow, 44 voted 1/5 hmmmm seems pretty susp |
 'On-Hold' is another way for a completionist to say 'Dropped' |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Given Episode 11 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )Gardevoir101 - Sep 19, 2019 |
138 |
by Stuntdrath
»»
Nov 18, 6:36 PM |
|
Poll: » Given Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )Tubby - Jul 11, 2019 |
171 |
by Kevinwzlx
»»
Sep 26, 9:19 AM |
|
» The OST of this anime!?!Choi_yuna - Apr 1, 2022 |
6 |
by Chaimello
»»
Jun 27, 8:39 PM |
|
Poll: » Given Episode 10 Discussion ( 1 2 )Gardevoir101 - Sep 12, 2019 |
79 |
by Mario64M
»»
Jun 22, 10:31 AM |
|
Poll: » Given Episode 2 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )Tubby - Jul 18, 2019 |
114 |
by Antoinn
»»
May 21, 12:52 PM |