| this is more suited to be in a blog, but i felt maybe it can be true for the most part, and thus might help others who are new here? 1-scores are bullshit 2-popularity doesn't matter 3- reviews no matter you agree or disagree, are going to be always better than scores. including your overall opinion about the show. 4- there is no good taste or bad taste. 5- there is no such thing like elite in anime community. it is just a meme (i dont see it being used mostly here, but just wanted to say that. 6-again scores dont matter. reviews and other people opinions, especially people i disagree with, give some perspective on how this show is bad or good. 7- the helpful review vote is sometimes abused, because most people don't care about the review, they care about whether the reviewer is agreeing with them and how close the score is to them. so always check other reviews. 8-i am awesome. |
| i am shitposter. dont take me seriously. |
| Dude, there's one more ---> 9- am i even real? |
 "Please stop talking about math when I'm eating." |
Hussin said: And you are also using a duplicate account. Any reason?8-i am awesome. |
 |
| well, doooooooooooooooh. of course they are. who even takes them seriously? some of the best things i've seen in my life are rated awfully here (for mal standards). every new piece of dirt gets insta-8.5 even if it's not worth an average score even. anything old or peculiar automatically gets a low score because it's not muh animu. of course ratings are trash and they don't really matter. but we've been through this, anon. and about reviews, until the day they remove the scoring from reviews, they will never be as important as they should. most people only care about the score on the review anyway and they react only if it's something negative. point is, a five star scoring system might actually be more interesting (if they really need one) NOT TO MENTION how many inactive accounts have given shit scores earlier in the old days because the community was different back then. if said accounts would be removed, scores would be very different for some shows. there are lots of reasons why current scores on mal are irelevant. and don't even let me get into those fools who make fake accounts just to give great or horrible scores to something. again, many accounts should be deleted anyway. then, the scoring would be more accurate. and even so, it's still irevelevant. what matters is what YOU like. that's it. ps: your account seems to be fake too, so it should also be deleted |
"I came here to sniff Madoka panties and kick witch ass and I am all out 'doka panties" - Homora Akemi |
thatPinkSpider said: Dude, there's one more ---> 9- am i even real? dude...................thats deep |
| i am shitposter. dont take me seriously. |
i requested the mods to delete it. i was migrating from the old account. xd |
| i am shitposter. dont take me seriously. |
| at first i thought you were rating your thoughts on scores ironically lmao it was so much better that way |
イカロス --I K A R O S D E S U-- "Hai master" <3cruise   Becoming the bell of my heart dont click here, baka -->> https://soundcloud.com/franciscan-guitar |
Ikaros_42oh said: at first i thought you were rating your thoughts on scores ironically lmao it was so much better that way hahaha i like that! i will definitely do another one maybe after a year with this idea. thanks! |
| i am shitposter. dont take me seriously. |
| Sure, plenty of good shows have low ratings and vice versa, but this just seems to be a butthurt guy ranting. Also, an average review on MAL looks like this. |
DarthBob said: Sure, plenty of good shows have low ratings and vice versa, but this just seems to be a butthurt guy ranting. Also, an average review on MAL looks like this. that is an average review in mal?? really bad review. maybe the guy was trolling ? i mean i dont like the show but i think most if not all think the animation is great. |
| i am shitposter. dont take me seriously. |
Hussin said: DarthBob said: Sure, plenty of good shows have low ratings and vice versa, but this just seems to be a butthurt guy ranting. Also, an average review on MAL looks like this. that is an average review in mal?? really bad review. maybe the guy was trolling ? i mean i dont like the show but i think most if not all think the animation is great. That's what most reviews look like. You won't get much of an idea if you only look at the top ones. He wasn't even trolling. Take one look at his profile and you'll see. |
rvbrick said: Howl's Moving Castle is a masterpiece that transcends all conventional forms of storytelling, as such people mistake its greatest strengths as flaws etc etc. Redline well it's got cool art and uh well it's got cool art watch it! Diebuster transcends all conventional forms of story-okay you get the idea. Basically 1. Scores are BS 2. Reviews are BS Just watch what sounds interesting to you and if it sucks it sucks who cares it's not like you're going to die tomorrow and if you are then you should be doing something else besides watching anime. but that wasn't a review at all. a proper review should lay down the negatives and positives of the show in plot, character, animation, and sound with some overall opinion about the show. it helps a lot if the review is detailed. |
| i am shitposter. dont take me seriously. |
DarthBob said: Hussin said: that is an average review in mal?? really bad review. maybe the guy was trolling ? i mean i dont like the show but i think most if not all think the animation is great. That's what most reviews look like. You won't get much of an idea if you only look at the top ones. He wasn't even trolling. Take one look at his profile and you'll see. well then nothing matter anymore i guess. |
| i am shitposter. dont take me seriously. |
Houndthree said: I don't even rate anime, I just finish watching them. That's it. 1+ well for me, i rate anime for my own sake based on my twisted and bullshit rating system. so after long time i would know what show i would rewatch and why. but what you do is really logical, so take this imaginary upvote. |
| i am shitposter. dont take me seriously. |
| Though I don't argue with sock puppets, I'll just interject that scores are a perfectly reasonable way to quantify how much a show lives up to the rules set forth by its genres, and if it breaks those rules; whether it was done well or not. It can however become problematic when people conflate their scoring too much with provisions for music, animation, art and other non-critical production value components that should at the most nudge a score one way or the other after the main score is already found. |
 |
| 1. Why migrate to a new account? 2. Have you seen shit reviews? 3. Migrating to a new account is a sign of insecurity, ergo point 8 can never be true 4. Popularity and scores are great ways to introduce one to the medium, ergo points 1-2 are subjective as well 5. OP has shit opinions, which translate to shit tastes. 6. The need for emphasis is disturbing. |
Brb said: 1. 1. Why migrate to a new account? i dont like my old ratings, i dont like to adjust them because i forgot what happened in the anime i watched, with few exceptions. so i need to rewatch them. i needed to delete all or most my anime entry, but it is tiresome to delete them manually. so i created new account. also i like starting new. 2. Have you seen shit reviews? yea. 3. Migrating to a new account is a sign of insecurity, ergo point 8 can never be true i didnt understand this question 4. Popularity and scores are great ways to introduce one to the medium, ergo points 1-2 are subjective as well not always true. for most ? maybe. 5. OP has shit opinions, which translate to shit tastes. well i cant argue with that 6. The need for emphasis is disturbing haha how is that |
| i am shitposter. dont take me seriously. |
DarthBob said: Sure, plenty of good shows have low ratings and vice versa, but this just seems to be a butthurt guy ranting. Also, an average review on MAL looks like this. His reviews are really honest and badass tbh tho. |
 |
| Good job, you figured it out. But the casuals haven't. And until they do.. $$$$$$$$$$$$$$ I make money off people like you |
| I wouldnt mind about scores but first in my case - Check review, (I'll skip one that is long and nonsense, would've nice to it simple and organized) but again review is based user preference - Checking out the highlight and see if theres something could interest me. - Find out major reason why its low or high. and be done with it. |
| I would like to ask, is this bait? I can't really tell. |
 |
| Agree there is no good taste or bad taste. Casual pleb also don't exist. |
But it's important to remember that a movie review is subjective;it only gives you one person's opinion. http://www.classzone.com/books/lnetwork_gr08/page_build.cfm?content=analyz_media&ch=30 It doesn't matter if you like LoGH,Monster etc.If you are a jobless or college/school dropout living in your mom basement, you are still an unintelligent loser. Taste in anime does not make you a better person.If elitist don't exist, casual pleb and shit taste also don't exist. |
| Scores are bullshit only if they are not made by me. |
Hussin said: 1-scores are bullshit 2-popularity doesn't matter 3- reviews no matter you agree or disagree, are going to be always better than scores. including your overall opinion about the show. 4- there is no good taste or bad taste. 5- there is no such thing like elite in anime community. it is just a meme (i dont see it being used mostly here, but just wanted to say that. 6-again scores dont matter. reviews and other people opinions, especially people i disagree with, give some perspective on how this show is bad or good. 7- the helpful review vote is sometimes abused, because most people don't care about the review, they care about whether the reviewer is agreeing with them and how close the score is to them. so always check other reviews. Really?! No kidding! That's debatable. |
D-ohnutsMay 16, 2017 5:20 AM
 |
| all the points are pretty much spot one except for the last one atleast. all ratings and reviews are YOUR opinion.you shouldn't really give a single fuck about anyone's except for yours unless you want to waste other people's time by saying something opposite to what they are saying just to trigger them. (me 80% of the time, guess im a bad person) |
 |
| And this thread is bullshit like scores are. |
If scores are bullshit, reviews are bullshit, and taste is bullshit, would that mean this thread is bullshit as well? |
| Average-quality shitpost. Work harder at that shit. |
"I'd take rampant lesbianism over nuclear armageddon or a supervolcano any day." ~nikiforova |
Hussin said: yet i dont see you faving Genma Taisen anytime soon >___> this is more suited to be in a blog, but i felt maybe it can be true for the most part, and thus might help others who are new here? 1-scores are bullshit 2-popularity doesn't matter or anything outside the top 1000 if youre gonna preach bullshit like that at least get some obscurer and low rated favourites |
 |
Hussin said: I don't think this is necessarily true. It mostly depends on the person behind the review or score. I'd pay a lot more attention to a score given by someone whose opinion I value than some shitty review written by a 10 year old. I mean, you don't ned to have any qualifications to write a review, any idiot can do it. Doesn't mean their opinion is more valid than someone who doesn't want to waste their time on something like that.3- reviews no matter you agree or disagree, are going to be always better than scores. including your overall opinion about the show. 6-again scores dont matter. reviews and other people opinions, especially people i disagree with, give some perspective on how this show is bad or good. Hussin said: Oh...you're lame...that kind of aside isn't even funny, it's just pitiful...8-i am awesome. |
CureEtudeMay 16, 2017 6:20 AM
Hussin said: 2-popularity doesn't matter I don't know what you're trying to get at here. Popularity is probably the most objective thing on this list as there is no real argument on how many people watched a thing. If you want to say popular does not equal good then say that. Hussin said: 5- there is no such thing like elites in the anime community. it is just a meme (i don't see it being used mostly here, but just wanted to say that. There are definitely people who look down on others, thinking they are superior. It is not just anime and can be applied to any fandom Hussin said: 8-i am awesome. Come on man, you don't to reassure yourself like that. If you want to attack something, you need to own up to your arguments and have confidence in that. |
Hussin said: this is more suited to be in a blog, but i felt maybe it can be true for the most part, and thus might help others who are new here? 1-scores are bullshit 2-popularity doesn't matter 3- reviews no matter you agree or disagree, are going to be always better than scores. including your overall opinion about the show. 4- there is no good taste or bad taste. 5- there is no such thing like elite in anime community. it is just a meme (i dont see it being used mostly here, but just wanted to say that. 6-again scores dont matter. reviews and other people opinions, especially people i disagree with, give some perspective on how this show is bad or good. 7- the helpful review vote is sometimes abused, because most people don't care about the review, they care about whether the reviewer is agreeing with them and how close the score is to them. so always check other reviews. 8-i am awesome. What about the -/10 score? Does that have a place? |
| your old avatar was much better tbh. |
| I probably regret this post by now. |
| so why do u rate ur anime and that is how we make a stupid thread the overall scores of an anime is the opinion of thousand of people at the same time the reviews are th r opinions of one person thet no one care about and having ouran hight school hist club in ur fav make the opposite of awesome |
 |
| I don't read reviews and would much rather look at the score... I mean, if it has hot girls and a really low score im probably gonna end up loving it |
   |
| I like scores for how they effect the affinity system. I think it's really neat. Also the first thing I do when I check out other peoples lists is sort it by score. I like to see what people rated 10 and what they rated 1. I just find it super interesting, don't know why. |
chrissy_poo_tooMay 16, 2017 9:10 AM
well for me, i rate anime for my own sake based on my twisted and bullshit rating system. so after long time i would know what show i would rewatch and why takenMalUsername said: Hussin said: 2-popularity doesn't matter I don't know what you're trying to get at here. Popularity is probably the most objective thing on this list as there is no real argument on how many people watched a thing. If you want to say popular does not equal good then say that. Hussin said: 5- there is no such thing like elites in the anime community. it is just a meme (i don't see it being used mostly here, but just wanted to say that. There are definitely people who look down on others, thinking they are superior. It is not just anime and can be applied to any fandom Hussin said: 8-i am awesome. Come on man, you don't to reassure yourself like that. If you want to attack something, you need to own up to your arguments and have confidence in that. 2- yea i was was trying to say popularity doesn't always mean good show for anyone. 5-that is true, but still i refuse to use the word "elite". it doesn't fit them nor it is true, so why are you keeping naming like that. it is like saying terrorists are religious fighters and not terrorists. call them who they are, and not meme them. 8- it was meant to be a joke. if it worked on few of few, then i am happy. abhutrash said: Hussin said: I don't think this is necessarily true. It mostly depends on the person behind the review or score. I'd pay a lot more attention to a score given by someone whose opinion I value than some shitty review written by a 10 year old. I mean, you don't ned to have any qualifications to write a review, any idiot can do it. Doesn't mean their opinion is more valid than someone who doesn't want to waste their time on something like that.3- reviews no matter you agree or disagree, are going to be always better than scores. including your overall opinion about the show. 6-again scores dont matter. reviews and other people opinions, especially people i disagree with, give some perspective on how this show is bad or good. Hussin said: Oh...you're lame...that kind of aside isn't even funny, it's just pitiful...8-i am awesome. that might be true for the most part. but i like to believe that there are people who score according to a rating system fairly. but that is the case here, not everyone use the same rating system. sometimes you can find two famous reviews have more or less same review but with different scores for some reason. romagia said: Hussin said: yet i dont see you faving Genma Taisen anytime soon >___> this is more suited to be in a blog, but i felt maybe it can be true for the most part, and thus might help others who are new here? 1-scores are bullshit 2-popularity doesn't matter or anything outside the top 1000 if youre gonna preach bullshit like that at least get some obscurer and low rated favourites i promise i am gonna put it in my plan to watch, thank you. Pullman said: your old avatar was much better tbh. i am person who changes his mind a lot. i will consider changing back to my old pic. InsaneLeader13 said: Average-quality shitpost. Work harder at that shit. the fact that you said average and not low makes me happy and thankful to your compliment. AltoRoark said: If scores are bullshit, reviews are bullshit, and taste is bullshit, would that mean this thread is bullshit as well? hmmm maybe _Ako_ said: And this thread is bullshit like scores are. it is that bad? jeez u guys are harsh. but i will try to take this as advice and try to make better post in future. Darek said: Yeah... Reviews may be "better" than ratings but they are still next to useless. yea sometime. you are right. i should have worded my post better |
| i am shitposter. dont take me seriously. |
Arxy-A- said: When I check out shows to watch, I honestly couldn't give less of a damn about statistics such as the mean rating or reviews from other users. I also don't pay much heed to the synopses, other than to get a very basic idea of what the show is probably about. There have been quite a few shows that I have truly enjoyed, despite only achieving a mean score in the 6's and 7's, coupled with what I perceive to be harsh and unreasonable reviews. On the other hand, there are shows such as Code Geass that have mean scores that approach a 9, and yet I did not resonate or care for the shows at all. If I had let scores and other statistics influence my decision on whether or not to watch a show, I would have missed out on many anime that are important to me. Besides, I don't think there is much of a point in putting heavy emphasis on scores given by others when the entire system lacks an even somewhat standardized scoring system. That is to say, I do not believe that one word definitions of scores such as "Good" or "Great" serve as sufficient standardization. It's all subjective, so don't stress about what other people rate a show! i agree with you. personally, sometimes though i trust some people's score to some point. because thier rating system made sense. mostly they are famous reviewers. not all of them but few. |
| i am shitposter. dont take me seriously. |
D-ohnuts said: Hussin said: 1-scores are bullshit 2-popularity doesn't matter 3- reviews no matter you agree or disagree, are going to be always better than scores. including your overall opinion about the show. 4- there is no good taste or bad taste. 5- there is no such thing like elite in anime community. it is just a meme (i dont see it being used mostly here, but just wanted to say that. 6-again scores dont matter. reviews and other people opinions, especially people i disagree with, give some perspective on how this show is bad or good. 7- the helpful review vote is sometimes abused, because most people don't care about the review, they care about whether the reviewer is agreeing with them and how close the score is to them. so always check other reviews. Really?! No kidding! That's debatable. well some people disagree and call these points, or some of them, are bullshit. so yea, no kidding. |
| i am shitposter. dont take me seriously. |
Sjo said: what matters is what YOU like. that's it. ps: your account seems to be fake too, so it should also be deleted i think i need to mention this in my fourm signiture to avoid replies like this. i made new account. |
| i am shitposter. dont take me seriously. |
| this is probbly the best thread in some time. Better than digibro opinion threads |
PoeticJustice said: this is probbly the best thread in some time. Better than digibro opinion threads digibro had thread here?! brb i am gonna check it out |
| i am shitposter. dont take me seriously. |
PoeticJustice said: this is probbly the best thread in some time. Better than digibro opinion threads Lol... Digibro threads on MAL are quite good if you ask me... It lasts for somewhat a day worth of reading, and at the end you'll ask yourself "Why the fuck did I even read it in the first place?!" |
_Ako_ said: PoeticJustice said: this is probbly the best thread in some time. Better than digibro opinion threads Lol... Digibro threads on MAL are quite good if you ask me... It lasts for somewhat a day worth of reading, and at the end you'll ask yourself "Why the fuck did I even read it in the first place?!" that is masochism. digibro's anti wank fest is dumb as shit but he is trash |
PoeticJustice said: _Ako_ said: Lol... Digibro threads on MAL are quite good if you ask me... It lasts for somewhat a day worth of reading, and at the end you'll ask yourself "Why the fuck did I even read it in the first place?!" that is masochism. digibro's anti wank fest is dumb as shit but he is trash That's not masochism but pleasure of allowing other's perspective be inside of you. |
More topics from this board
» 🍉 Summer 2025: Anime of the Season (AOTS) ( 1 2 3 4 )nirererin - Oct 9 |
195 |
by eksratu
»»
3 seconds ago |
|
» Anime musicnishant0 - 2 hours ago |
7 |
by Hikkusan
»»
6 minutes ago |
|
» Are we going through a Yuri Renaissance?Dragevard - 9 hours ago |
39 |
by ProudElitist
»»
7 minutes ago |
|
» 🍷 AD Summer 2025 Best Girl Contest ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Shizuna - Sep 28 |
350 |
by Dazonwraith
»»
16 minutes ago |
|
Poll: » Do OPs and EDs contribute to your rating of an anime?W3TFT - Oct 11 |
26 |
by logopolis
»»
26 minutes ago |