What will happen to the anime industry if illegal streaming sites/DL sites get closed by the federals/etc?
?
The industry is doomed
51.9%
95
The industry actually benefits from this
14.2%
26
The industry remains indifferent
33.9%
62
183 votes
| Will it survive for the western audience? Discuss the future of the anime industry. Mod Edit: Changed title to be less obvious to DL sites/Streaming sites that are illegal |
TyrelAug 30, 2014 12:28 PM
| To think is the living of the believer. To believe, is to think. pw: qwertyuiop |
| What if there was a website that streamed all your favorite animu legally for free? |
fst said: Is it as high-quality as the one provided by pirate websites in mkv and with the possiblity of 60fps and other general quality enhancements?What if there was a website that streamed all your favorite animu legally for free? Or is it some poorly encoded shit like crunchyroll? |
| To think is the living of the believer. To believe, is to think. pw: qwertyuiop |
| That 60 fps shit is overrated. |
| just go on IRC and torrent the old fashion way you plebs |
| Anime is dead now. fst said: That 60 fps shit is overrated. Only way to watch Sidonia though. |
| Piracy will finds a way, like always did. |
 |
mclovinballz said: Anime is dead now. fst said: That 60 fps shit is overrated. Only way to watch Sidonia though. I'll never understand Japan's obsession with low-framerate CGI. It takes 0 extra effort on the animators' part to just render it at full 24 FPS, yet they still choose to make it look like shit anyway. |
kingcity20 said: Oh for the love of -_- nvm gotta love MAL |
| Your average western casual would probably stop watching it because they don't know how to DL. |
Kokororin said: fst said: Is it as high-quality as the one provided by pirate websites in mkv and with the possiblity of 60fps and other general quality enhancements?What if there was a website that streamed all your favorite animu legally for free? Or is it some poorly encoded shit like crunchyroll? 60fps what in the blue fuck? this isn't video games you bumpkin |
  |
| Piracy will always find a way. But, for the sake of argument, if piracy in anime was 100% stopped, then I have a year's worth of anime I have saved up to watch before actually having to sign up for hulu or crunchyroll. |
| japan would lose a lot of potential dvd sales in the west |
hybreezy said: Kokororin said: Is it as high-quality as the one provided by pirate websites in mkv and with the possiblity of 60fps and other general quality enhancements? Or is it some poorly encoded shit like crunchyroll? 60fps what in the blue fuck? this isn't video games you bumpkin It actually just makes it look and feel like a daytime soap opera, not a video game. Which is why it's overrated. |
hybreezy said: 60fps what in the blue fuck? this isn't video games you bumpkin It only makes more sense to want better smoothness in a viideo you WATCH compared to a video you PLAY. I don't care about 60fps in video games because graphics don't matter to me in video games. But an anime obviously graphic smoothness matters more than in video games, so I don't see your logic. JD2411 said: Probably.japan would lose a lot of potential dvd sales in the west SupaNiper said: I prefer my fpses to be high. Because higher = better, right?? must be true /Sarcasm/ http://30vs60.com/ SVP does interpolation:  |
| To think is the living of the believer. To believe, is to think. pw: qwertyuiop |
Kokororin said: hybreezy said: 60fps what in the blue fuck? this isn't video games you bumpkin It only makes more sense to want better smoothness in a viideo you WATCH compared to a video you PLAY. I don't care about 60fps in video games because graphics don't matter to me in video games. But an anime obviously graphic smoothness matters more than in video games, so I don't see your logic. this is a bad joke going over my head right? |
|
hybreezy said: Instead of dancing around, can you give your explanation for why it makes sense to care about graphics in video games but not in shows (like anime for instance)?Kokororin said: It only makes more sense to want better smoothness in a viideo you WATCH compared to a video you PLAY. I don't care about 60fps in video games because graphics don't matter to me in video games. But an anime obviously graphic smoothness matters more than in video games, so I don't see your logic. this is a bad joke going over my head right? |
| To think is the living of the believer. To believe, is to think. pw: qwertyuiop |
| For gameplay reasons, particularly in shooter games, framerate is much more important in games than in anime. Although it obviously doesn't matter if the only games you play are 2048 and KanColle. It's also highly ironic to say framerate in games don't matter, and then show a comparison of 30 fps vs 60 fps that's from a video game. Even that aside, it's a bad way to illustrate your point. That's a rendering thing; the 60 fps example isn't made by frame interpolation. A framerate increase from frame interpolation looks different from a framerate increase by rendering 3D graphics at a higher rate, you can see this easily if you pause and examine the interpolated frames. The interpolated frames look nothing like what that infographic displayes. Here's an interpolated frame from the Barakamon OP |
fst said: For gameplay reasons, particularly in shooter games, framerate is much more important in games than in anime. Although it obviously doesn't matter if the only games you play are 2048 and KanColle. In video games you do two things: watch and play. In anime you do only one thing: watch The video smoothness is tied to the "watch" part, so even if the "watch" part is bad, there's stil lthe play part to compensate. In anime there's only the "watch" part that you can do. You can't control the anime. It should be more important to have better visuals in anime than in games. That's my preference, I'm arguing because someone just called out on me for caring about quality on anime when supposedly you should only care if it's games. fst said: It's also highly ironic to say framerate in games don't matter, and then show a comparison of 30 fps vs 60 fps that's from a video game. You don't play the game in that site I gave, you just watch it. Same for anime, you just watch. The comparision works for showing video where you just watch. When I'm playing I pay more attention to the game surroundings/strategy/reflexes than the video quality. fst said: Indeed, but that's irrelevant, someone said "higher fps doesn't make any difference" in:Even that aside, it's a bad way to illustrate your point. That's a rendering thing; the 60 fps example isn't made by frame interpolation. A framerate increase from frame interpolation looks different from a framerate increase by rendering 3D graphics at a higher rate, you can see this easily if you pause and examine the interpolated frames. I prefer my fpses to be high. Because higher = better, right?? must be true And I proved it does by providing game footage in different fps./Sarcasm/ The quote here doesn't say "anime" but FPS in general. Smooth Video Project proves you can - via interpolation - create 60fps in general pre-rendered video too. |
| To think is the living of the believer. To believe, is to think. pw: qwertyuiop |
| Nobody cares what fps you watch a video game at; you could watch a game at 24 fps just fine. Playing it at 24 fps vs playing at 60 fps is a very different matter. |
fst said: And why is it different for anime?Nobody cares what fps you watch a video game at; you could watch a game at 24 fps just fine. Playing it at 24 fps vs playing at 60 fps is a very different matter. Unless you're watching an anime made in powerpoint, there will have movement present in the anime and the smoothness in which frames switch and the interpolation between positions is visible will be present. Same applies for video games. I don't care about games to be honest and that's part of the reason I disregard quality for it. --- Here, this isn't from a video game:  Better now? Regardless, I would rather have this topic not be derailed any further. What was I supposed to do? Have people egg on me for caring about quality and just sit and watch without defending myself? If you don't care about quality, cool, that's fine, go watch your crunchyroll. But why be disrespectful to people who care about quality? If you think "quality only matters in video games" that's cool too, but the same as above applies ^ |
KokororinAug 30, 2014 1:41 PM
| To think is the living of the believer. To believe, is to think. pw: qwertyuiop |
| The problem (as far as I'm concerned, anyway) is not that higher framerates isn't better, it's that it doesn't really look better when you get higher framerates by frame interpolation. That and your fallacious arguments about video game framerates and your poor examples. |
Kokororin said: In video games you do two things: watch and play. In anime you do only one thing: watch The video smoothness is tied to the "watch" part, so even if the "watch" part is bad, there's stil lthe play part to compensate. In anime there's only the "watch" part that you can do. this is acceptable... |
 |
fst said: The problem (as far as I'm concerned, anyway) is not that higher framerates isn't better, it's that it doesn't really look better when you get higher framerates by frame interpolation. It obviously does, have you ever tried yourself? The gif I showed is frame interpolation if you don't know. Honestly, I just love to get my quaility little mkv from <pirate website>, plug my notebook on my television, enable 60fps frame interpolation, use a good video renderer, good video filters, lay on my bed and chill all day. I tried watching crunchyroll on my TV and it just feels horrible since I'm used to quality. The lack of decent codecs, video rendering, lack of options to apply your fragment shaders of preference in case you dislike the original video choice, lack of subtitles filtering customization and all the blablabla shit that adds to quality is just a cut-off. fst said: Point one.That and your fallacious arguments about video game framerates and your poor examples. My examples posted are perfectly good too. If 60fps didn't really made any difference then wouldn't be so many developers working on it for the sake of bringing a smoother video experience to users. Edit: Anyway I'm off to bed, please try watching anime with quality for yourself once, friendly suggestion. |
| To think is the living of the believer. To believe, is to think. pw: qwertyuiop |
| I have tried it. The algorithm works fine for pans and zooms. It does not work fine for anything more complicated than that, as shown in the example I posted earlier inside the spoiler tags. I found it to be disappointing overall, though it is necessary to make Sidonia watchable. |
| First world problems are still problems. Which means they can probably be solved with duct tape, WD40 or some combination thereof. |
j0x said: MiniSiets said: I'll never understand Japan's obsession with low-framerate CGI. It takes 0 extra effort on the animators' part to just render it at full 24 FPS, yet they still choose to make it look like shit anyway. i agree its not that they are rendering this CGI animation on last decade computers They might be, actually. The last decade was only 4 years ago... |
laldonkaments said: Most shit's still down? Srsly, I cannot believe I have to resort to DDL...  bakabt is going just fine peasant ^_^ |
|
| I don't know how the studio works, I'm just saying it's plausible that they're rendering on computers from the last decade. |
| It'll never happen. Piracy always finds a way, cut off 1 head and 2 grow back. DDOS that's happening on nyaa won't last either |
| People will always find a way to pirate. Don't worry, torrents won't die ;) No matter what you do. |
| S H O U T _ O L D _ B U T _ G O L D |
| Simple, torrenting will just become a lot more popular for anime. |
| Previously: BlueXRam |
| Oh dang if this happen, NO MORE FREE KAMEN RIDER EACH WEEK. ILL BE SAD |
| MALoween✟Mansion (2024) Candy Basket 🎃: |
| 600 sites closed down, 9001 more goes up. |
 |
| Not a Big deal......Since I've already watched Inferno Cop and SSJMaster vs. Xinil - A story of epic battles! Season 2 my Life is complete.........a few thousand anime wo'nt make much of a difference |
 |
vongola-undecimo said: Not a Big deal......Since I've already watched Inferno Cop and SSJMaster vs. Xinil - A story of epic battles! Season 2 my Life is complete.........a few thousand anime wo'nt make much of a difference what the.. who the fuck changed mars of destructon title on mal lmao. im quite shocked when i go to my profile page lmao |
| i'd have to DL all my anime, but even that's a ballache! and i probably wouldn't watch as much then consequently |
ninjastarforcex said: vongola-undecimo said: Not a Big deal......Since I've already watched Inferno Cop and SSJMaster vs. Xinil - A story of epic battles! Season 2 my Life is complete.........a few thousand anime wo'nt make much of a difference what the.. who the fuck changed mars of destructon title on mal lmao. im quite shocked when i go to my profile page lmao If you're referring to SSJMaster vs. Xinil - A story of epic battles! Season 2,then that was the name all along......you were simply intoxicated by the epicness and never realised |
|
vongola-undecimo said: ninjastarforcex said: what the.. who the fuck changed mars of destructon title on mal lmao. im quite shocked when i go to my profile page lmao If you're referring to SSJMaster vs. Xinil - A story of epic battles! Season 2,then that was the name all along......you were simply intoxicated by the epicness and never realised w...what!?  |
ninjastarforcex said: saaaaamei dont understand fps thing but i still enjoy |
Mikeforall said: When the inofficial steamingsites would shut down, many Europeans and Americans wouldn't be able to watch anime. good for Japanese, no one will call them having shit tastes |
MrLief said: Your average western casual would probably stop watching it because they don't know how to DL. this |
| MAL: A community that thinks every anime is bad, but rates everything a 7/10. |
| Streaming sites < couldnt care less because i do not stream ANY of the episodes i watch. Torrent trackers will never die out,never! i got all the sub and rip groups that matter on my RSS feed subscribed via Feedly which notifies me if of new releases the moment they are out. I dl every single episode from nyaa,tokyotosho,bakabt trackers since ages. For the ppl who want to continue watching anime daily/weekly nothing will change. |
More topics from this board
» Why do people think “anime” is an art style?Old_School_Akira - 9 hours ago |
29 |
by thewiru
»»
4 minutes ago |
|
» are anime fans more likely to be bullied?talked - 11 hours ago |
12 |
by rohan121
»»
9 minutes ago |
|
» Which anime villain had a goal you secretly understood or agreed with?Zorastella - Yesterday |
23 |
by AcD4c
»»
10 minutes ago |
|
» Do VA watch all the anime they spoke a character in?ApfelMyName - Oct 13 |
13 |
by Yuu_Kanzaki
»»
11 minutes ago |
|
» Help me find the circa 2000 anime about school girls & small peopleBel - 13 minutes ago |
0 |
by Bel
»»
13 minutes ago |