New
Jul 29, 2012 7:46 AM
#51
Awkward moment when I actually like a lot of JC Staff's anime (Nodame Cantabile, Honey and Clover, and Bakuman in particular). Well, I'm not a VN player so I don't have much expectations right now. I am also a bit skeptical of Horie Yui voicing a male character though... |
Jul 29, 2012 8:02 AM
#52
All aboard the crazy train, lets just see how bad J.C. can ruin it. |
Jul 29, 2012 8:02 AM
#53
Radzeer said: noyoureinsane said: Still, it's not fair to just assume that the entire anime will be terrible because of it. I'm not familiar with any of the source material of their adaptions, but I do know that they have been criticized a lot for these. It's okay to be nervous about the adaption, but to just deem it off as "it's going to be shit" like some people have/are before even airing is pretty unfair to the anime itself. I'll admit, I'm a bit worried myself about how this'll turn out considering my own bad experiences with them (Ano Natsu, Zero no Tsukaima, etc.) but all the intense hate on the adaption already is just, well stupid in my opinion. I know the souce material. The filler arcs/routes are badly written and they will take up 80% time of the whole show IF they are going to be adapted - and according to the last trailer they will be adapted. And they'll have to rush the best and longest part of the story. They could have easily discarded some routes, like they did in Clannad. But there will be no season 2, so Refrain will have to fit in this + all routes. It's going to be fucking rushed. Well, nice to know you've went into the future and witnessed first-hand how much this show is going to suck. You mind telling us exactly what is going to happen, since you have obviously seen it already? Would be a good incentive for the other cynics to steer as far away from this show as possible. |
Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
Jul 29, 2012 8:03 AM
#54
Oh, I already knew about this a while ago~ |
Jul 29, 2012 8:04 AM
#55
It would be a bigger problem if they DIDN'T do the character routes. Now THAT is what I would call rushed, and would majorly piss off fans of those specific characters. |
Jul 29, 2012 8:08 AM
#56
i'm really curious as to know how many episodes there are going to be. |
Jul 29, 2012 8:19 AM
#58
Jul 29, 2012 8:21 AM
#59
Tyrel said: Also who's the girl at..1:03-1:06 that looks pretty much dead. Only like 6 hrs into the VN, so idk if it says or not. It's Kud. |
Do you know Oyashiro-sama? |
Jul 29, 2012 8:23 AM
#60
dtshyk said: nextday said: Tomoe Tamiyasu already posted about a month ago on her blog that it was airing in October. Not really news. That's not an official announcement. See http://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=91179 |
Jul 29, 2012 8:24 AM
#61
Jul 29, 2012 8:27 AM
#62
AO968 said: Well, nice to know you've went into the future and witnessed first-hand how much this show is going to suck. You mind telling us exactly what is going to happen, since you have obviously seen it already? Would be a good incentive for the other cynics to steer as far away from this show as possible. I refuse to argue with someone who has Shakugan no Shana and K-on! in his top5 anime. |
Jul 29, 2012 8:27 AM
#63
Jul 29, 2012 8:29 AM
#64
Radzeer said: noyoureinsane said: Still, it's not fair to just assume that the entire anime will be terrible because of it. I'm not familiar with any of the source material of their adaptions, but I do know that they have been criticized a lot for these. It's okay to be nervous about the adaption, but to just deem it off as "it's going to be shit" like some people have/are before even airing is pretty unfair to the anime itself. I'll admit, I'm a bit worried myself about how this'll turn out considering my own bad experiences with them (Ano Natsu, Zero no Tsukaima, etc.) but all the intense hate on the adaption already is just, well stupid in my opinion. I know the souce material. The filler arcs/routes are badly written and they will take up 80% time of the whole show IF they are going to be adapted - and according to the last trailer they will be adapted. And they'll have to rush the best and longest part of the story. They could have easily discarded some routes, like they did in Clannad S1. But there will be no season 2, so Refrain will have to fit in this + all routes. It's going to be fucking rushed. So, how again do you know that it will be badly written if not even one episode has been released..? Where does it say there'll be no season two? This is what I mean - you're talking as if you know exactly how this anime will turn out. Also @your above post, disregarding someone's own viewpoints because of their tastes in anime is completely ignorant. Them having K-On! on their favorites list doesn't make their opinion have any less value then if they had LoGH on it. In fact, what they said was completely true. |
Jul 29, 2012 8:31 AM
#65
Radzeer said: AO968 said: Well, nice to know you've went into the future and witnessed first-hand how much this show is going to suck. You mind telling us exactly what is going to happen, since you have obviously seen it already? Would be a good incentive for the other cynics to steer as far away from this show as possible. I refuse to argue with someone who has Shakugan no Shana and K-on! in his top5 anime. Everyone has a different opinion. |
Jul 29, 2012 8:32 AM
#66
Radzeer said: Lol that's pretty childish. A person's top 5 has nothing to do with this argument yet you wont argue with someone because of it?AO968 said: Well, nice to know you've went into the future and witnessed first-hand how much this show is going to suck. You mind telling us exactly what is going to happen, since you have obviously seen it already? Would be a good incentive for the other cynics to steer as far away from this show as possible. I refuse to argue with someone who has Shakugan no Shana and K-on! in his top5 anime. Grow up dude. Your entire argument has been nullified just from this childish statement alone. If you can't argue/debate properly, don't do it at all. |
Jul 29, 2012 8:33 AM
#67
noyoureinsane said: I'll admit, I'm a bit worried myself about how this'll turn out considering my own bad experiences with them (Ano Natsu, Zero no Tsukaima, etc.) but all the intense hate on the adaption already is just, well stupid in my opinion. Agreed. I'm used to be skeptical about JC Staff anime (Arcana Famiglia is s*it, as I guessed it would be), but I think hate is just valid when you actually see things already done. Honestly, I prefer being hyped for LB and get disappointed than keep hating before the anime is started. JC Staff can do good adaptations. |
Jul 29, 2012 8:35 AM
#68
Radzeer said: AO968 said: Well, nice to know you've went into the future and witnessed first-hand how much this show is going to suck. You mind telling us exactly what is going to happen, since you have obviously seen it already? Would be a good incentive for the other cynics to steer as far away from this show as possible. I refuse to argue with someone who has Shakugan no Shana and K-on! in his top5 anime. So you should quit forums. Judging people's by its favorite entertainment is f*cking stupid, man. |
Jul 29, 2012 8:36 AM
#69
Alright knew this but cool. |
Jul 29, 2012 8:36 AM
#70
Mary_Vanucchi said: Key was working close with them IIRC, so they can't possibly mess it up.noyoureinsane said: I'll admit, I'm a bit worried myself about how this'll turn out considering my own bad experiences with them (Ano Natsu, Zero no Tsukaima, etc.) but all the intense hate on the adaption already is just, well stupid in my opinion. Agreed. I'm used to be skeptical about JC Staff anime (Arcana Famiglia is s*it, as I guessed it would be), but I think hate is just valid when you actually see things already done. Honestly, I prefer being hyped for LB and get disappointed than keep hating before the anime is started. JC Staff can do good adaptations. |
Jul 29, 2012 8:37 AM
#71
Welp, I guess I gotta get reading the VN sooner than expected. |
Ok™ |
Jul 29, 2012 8:40 AM
#72
Yvese said: Key was working close with them IIRC, so they can't possibly mess it up. THIS. ALso, if "i'm not wrong LB is has Warner involved in the production, together with the new Jojo anime. This can add some confidence. |
MiyamorisJul 29, 2012 1:49 PM
Jul 29, 2012 8:41 AM
#73
noyoureinsane said: So, how again do you know that it will be badly written if not even one episode has been released..? Where does it say there'll be no season two? This is what I mean - you're talking as if you know exactly how this anime will turn out. Also @your above post, disregarding someone's own viewpoints because of their tastes in anime is completely ignorant. Them having K-On! on their favorites list doesn't make their opinion have any less value then if they had LoGH on it. In fact, what they said was completely true. Since you asked nicely, I will answer. I wasn't talking about the anime, when I said the routes are badly written. It's the VN, the source material that is badly written. If the source material is badly written, how can the adaptation turn out good? That can't be improved. The only good part of the VN is Refrain. The dating sim routes are mediocre if not terrible (like in the case of Haruka). I'm assuming there will be no second season from the fact that the trailer shows 2 scenes from Refrain, which is the last part of the game. Refrain is the same to LB! as Afterstory is to Clannad. |
Jul 29, 2012 8:42 AM
#74
Yvese said: Mary_Vanucchi said: Key was working close with them IIRC, so they can't possibly mess it up.noyoureinsane said: I'll admit, I'm a bit worried myself about how this'll turn out considering my own bad experiences with them (Ano Natsu, Zero no Tsukaima, etc.) but all the intense hate on the adaption already is just, well stupid in my opinion. Agreed. I'm used to be skeptical about JC Staff anime (Arcana Famiglia is s*it, as I guessed it would be), but I think hate is just valid when you actually see things already done. Honestly, I prefer being hyped for LB and get disappointed than keep hating before the anime is started. JC Staff can do good adaptations. Considering the way not just the MAL forums, but the internet (and probably Japan in general, too) blew up after learning J.C. were producing it I'm really not surprised. |
Jul 29, 2012 8:45 AM
#75
On the official twitter account of Key, one of the staff explained the production policy of the Little Busters anime. Although the order of the events might be different from the original game, there won't be alterations in the story nor anime original characters. He said the length of the TV series is significantly long, but still it was necessary to shorten the original story to adapt it to the limited number of episodes. He added that the relationships among Rin, Komari, and other new members of the Little Busters team might be described more in detail than in the game. this was on the post from "Anxiety over J.C Staff btw. I expect atleast 20 Episodes, Unless we get trolled hard. |
Jul 29, 2012 8:46 AM
#76
Yvese said: Mary_Vanucchi said: Key was working close with them IIRC, so they can't possibly mess it up.noyoureinsane said: I'll admit, I'm a bit worried myself about how this'll turn out considering my own bad experiences with them (Ano Natsu, Zero no Tsukaima, etc.) but all the intense hate on the adaption already is just, well stupid in my opinion. Agreed. I'm used to be skeptical about JC Staff anime (Arcana Famiglia is s*it, as I guessed it would be), but I think hate is just valid when you actually see things already done. Honestly, I prefer being hyped for LB and get disappointed than keep hating before the anime is started. JC Staff can do good adaptations. This is the very studio that crippled Tsukihime. I can't honestly believe that statement. The trailer does not look promising too. Just look at the hair flow, detail and the roof spinning scene. I can say with confidence KyoAni does those a lot better. Just... so much better. |
Jul 29, 2012 8:47 AM
#77
Radzeer said: noyoureinsane said: So, how again do you know that it will be badly written if not even one episode has been released..? Where does it say there'll be no season two? This is what I mean - you're talking as if you know exactly how this anime will turn out. Also @your above post, disregarding someone's own viewpoints because of their tastes in anime is completely ignorant. Them having K-On! on their favorites list doesn't make their opinion have any less value then if they had LoGH on it. In fact, what they said was completely true. Since you asked nicely, I will answer. I wasn't talking about the anime, when I said the routes are badly written. It's the VN, the source material that is badly written. If the source material is badly written, how can the adaptation turn out good? That can't be improved. The only good part of the VN is Refrain. The dating sim routes are mediocre if not terrible (like in the case of Haruka). I'm assuming there will be no second season from the fact that the trailer shows 2 scenes from Refrain, which is the last part of the game. Refrain is the same to LB! as Afterstory is to Clannad. Simple - they execute it better and improve the writing. You don't have to change the entire plot to improve a source material's writing. Also, you're the first person I've heard to complain about this as well. Well, despite what the trailer shows, it's best not to assume things until there's an official announcement or until the anime is complete. I know that the gameplay is long and 26 episodes may be rushing it, but you never know just how it'll turn out. As long as they don't pull an Angel Beats! with it that is. |
Jul 29, 2012 8:49 AM
#78
Obstinate said: Please don't mess this up J.C Staff. My thought exactly. Cant wait for October. |
Jul 29, 2012 8:49 AM
#79
Zmffkskem said: Yvese said: Mary_Vanucchi said: Key was working close with them IIRC, so they can't possibly mess it up.noyoureinsane said: I'll admit, I'm a bit worried myself about how this'll turn out considering my own bad experiences with them (Ano Natsu, Zero no Tsukaima, etc.) but all the intense hate on the adaption already is just, well stupid in my opinion. Agreed. I'm used to be skeptical about JC Staff anime (Arcana Famiglia is s*it, as I guessed it would be), but I think hate is just valid when you actually see things already done. Honestly, I prefer being hyped for LB and get disappointed than keep hating before the anime is started. JC Staff can do good adaptations. This is the very studio that crippled Tsukihime. I can't honestly believe that statement. The trailer does not look promising too. Just look at the hair flow, detail and the roof spinning scene. I can say with confidence KyoAni does those a lot better. Just... so much better. You're looking into it way too much. KyoAni does better then pretty much any studio when it comes to animation, it's not really fair to compare the two. |
Jul 29, 2012 8:56 AM
#80
noyoureinsane said: Simple - they execute it better and improve the writing. You don't have to change the entire plot to improve a source material's writing. Also, you're the first person I've heard to complain about this as well. Well, despite what the trailer shows, it's best not to assume things until there's an official announcement or until the anime is complete. I know that the gameplay is long and 26 episodes may be rushing it, but you never know just how it'll turn out. As long as they don't pull an Angel Beats! with it that is. Then it wouldn't be staying true to source material, like what many anime do to manga. Anyway, I found the other heroines rather enjoyable, although I'm still pre-Refrain in VN. I also enjoyed Angel Beats!, which was an anime original, like Madoka. noyoureinsane said: You're looking into it way too much. KyoAni does better then pretty much any studio when it comes to animation, it's not really fair to compare the two. I can only hope so. I am hoping for Nodame animation and Toradora execution really. Honey & Clover doesn't really apply although it's what J.C. has not terribly wrecked as well. In short, I sincerely hope this does not fail. |
Jul 29, 2012 8:59 AM
#81
Jul 29, 2012 9:03 AM
#83
Zmffkskem said: noyoureinsane said: Simple - they execute it better and improve the writing. You don't have to change the entire plot to improve a source material's writing. Also, you're the first person I've heard to complain about this as well. Well, despite what the trailer shows, it's best not to assume things until there's an official announcement or until the anime is complete. I know that the gameplay is long and 26 episodes may be rushing it, but you never know just how it'll turn out. As long as they don't pull an Angel Beats! with it that is. Then it wouldn't be staying true to source material, like what many anime do to manga. Anyway, I found the other heroines rather enjoyable, although I'm still pre-Refrain in VN. I also enjoyed Angel Beats!, which was an anime original, like Madoka. Changes on the original material would be nice if they turn to be improvements. There are some anime adaptations that I prefer more than the original source. Now you say Angel Beats, don't know if I should say this but I have a feeling that if LB is beign produced with less episodes than necessary, it might turn into "2012 Angel Beats": somewhat rushed but dividing a lot os opinions. |
Jul 29, 2012 9:05 AM
#84
My main worry is the animation quality. With J.C.Staff, I was hoping for at least some solid animation, but it seems really disappointing. Compare it to Hyouka, which KyoAni is currently doing. I feel like raging. >: |
Jul 29, 2012 9:09 AM
#85
noyoureinsane said: Simple - they execute it better and improve the writing. You don't have to change the entire plot to improve a source material's writing. Also, you're the first person I've heard to complain about this as well. The first thing that pops into my mind about writing and J.C. Staff is the last arc of Railgun. Which was anime original. They messed up that too. Pretty badly. |
Jul 29, 2012 9:11 AM
#87
That much was expected. In the meantime I'll just prepare myself for writing all the walls of text about what J.C. Staff is doing wrong. |
Jul 29, 2012 9:11 AM
#88
no saya? T_T sigh maybe i should just play the VN now and watch the anime and criticize it for how bad its gonna be |
Jul 29, 2012 9:12 AM
#89
Radzeer said: Since you asked nicely, I will answer. I wasn't talking about the anime, when I said the routes are badly written. It's the VN, the source material that is badly written. If the source material is badly written, how can the adaptation turn out good? That can't be improved. The only good part of the VN is Refrain. The dating sim routes are mediocre if not terrible (like in the case of Haruka). I'm assuming there will be no second season from the fact that the trailer shows 2 scenes from Refrain, which is the last part of the game. Refrain is the same to LB! as Afterstory is to Clannad. - Adaptation > Source Material CAN happen, though very rare. Ex: K-ON, although it's just a claim from some people since I didn't read K-ON manga. Again, quality is pretty relative. - Don't over-analyze a trailer, which isn't a seasonal review. Clannad S1 has ushio in it, but Ushio never showed up in S1, right? I guess it's a purely logical decision to include teaser about refrain, the main selling point of LB. - The official answer for your anxiety is it will be significantly long. I'm positive that it will be at least 26 eps (bye bye angel beats). My own prediction is 26+13, but we'll see later. This is not the time to over-analyzing the future, I'm running out of popcorn already after numerous baseless discussion about Little Busters! Let's just wait. p.s About Yui Horie, actually she is one of seiyuu that capable in long range of voice, so it's OK for me. Riki's voice in VN is already girly from the start. |
Jul 29, 2012 9:15 AM
#90
I'm not keeping my expectations really high or anything, but I must say I'm a little annoyed by all the negative comments about how the anime is gonna suck when it's not even out yet. Sure it's gonna be JC Staff and of course they will cut out some details from the VN. It IS an anime adaptation, and we see that kind of stuff so frequently with different studios. I quote Sakurano Kurimu from Seitokai no Ichizon ep1: "Understand the differences between media!" As Little Busters fans, can't we all simply be happy of the fact that the VN we love is finally going to be animated? |
Check out my list here. That's the Brigade Chief's orders! |
Jul 29, 2012 9:20 AM
#91
DanchouHaruhi said: I'm not keeping my expectations really high or anything, but I must say I'm a little annoyed by all the negative comments about how the anime is gonna suck when it's not even out yet. Sure it's gonna be JC Staff and of course they will cut out some details from the VN. It IS an anime adaptation, and we see that kind of stuff so frequently with different studios. I quote Sakurano Kurimu from Seitokai no Ichizon ep1: "Understand the differences between media!" As Little Busters fans, can't we all simply be happy of the fact that the VN we love is finally going to be animated? LB fans should at least be happy that the VN they love will be divulgated for more people. Even if the anime sucks, probably will fulfill its function on attracting some more people to the original material. I'm already attracted, even before the anime is aired! LOL |
Jul 29, 2012 9:25 AM
#92
J.C Staff.. You know what to do... Don't make all people in the world hate you.... |
Jul 29, 2012 9:29 AM
#93
Mary_Vanucchi said: Zmffkskem said: noyoureinsane said: Simple - they execute it better and improve the writing. You don't have to change the entire plot to improve a source material's writing. Also, you're the first person I've heard to complain about this as well. Well, despite what the trailer shows, it's best not to assume things until there's an official announcement or until the anime is complete. I know that the gameplay is long and 26 episodes may be rushing it, but you never know just how it'll turn out. As long as they don't pull an Angel Beats! with it that is. Then it wouldn't be staying true to source material, like what many anime do to manga. Anyway, I found the other heroines rather enjoyable, although I'm still pre-Refrain in VN. I also enjoyed Angel Beats!, which was an anime original, like Madoka. Changes on the original material would be nice if they turn to be improvements. There are some anime adaptations that I prefer more than the original source. Now you say Angel Beats, don't know if I should say this but I have a feeling that if LB is beign produced with less episodes than necessary, it might turn into "2012 Angel Beats": somewhat rushed but dividing a lot os opinions. The source material doesn't have to change completely for the writing to improve. Like said above, it could add improvements. It's not fair to just assume the worst. KyoAni has done bad adaptions too, you know. I enjoyed Angel Beats! as well, but what I'm saying is that people should be grateful for at least 26 episodes and hope that it doesn't turn out rushed like in AB! I agree with Mary_Vanucchi, though I think the dividing opinions thing is already set-in to happen. It's already happening and the anime hasn't even aired yet. Someone also said something about overthinking a trailer, which I agree with as well. They aren't going to bring out the best animation and scenes in a 2 minute trailer, and just because it's in the trailer doesn't mean everything in it is limited to season one. I just think a lot of fans are scared and overreacting because of J.C. Staff's reputation and their love for the VN. I'm pretty sure everyone will end up hating them though if they screw this up, which is why I'm more optimistic towards this adaption. I mean if they fuck up, they're done. |
Jul 29, 2012 9:33 AM
#95
Looking from the positive side, previous trailer : recent trailer : You can't deny that they already made a leap of improvement. Also, we get (another) remix of Little Busters! (OP) Actually, I'm already pretty satisfied if they keep the animation in quality of that trailer. Comparing JC Staff product with Hyouka in term of animation is a suicide with expectation. Why you want to compare it with the best (pretty much almost not arguable) animation details and consistency in TV series in recent seasons? |
Jul 29, 2012 9:42 AM
#96
VioLink said: Wait, so it's not a baseball anime? It's a story of friends who decide to play baseball and other funny-silly things for lulz, behind a "twist". If Clannad is about family, the main theme of LB pretty much is about friendship. |
Jul 29, 2012 9:59 AM
#97
Jul 29, 2012 10:00 AM
#98
Never heard of game, but many people are hyped for this, so i guess i shall check it out. |
Jul 29, 2012 10:01 AM
#99
Jul 29, 2012 10:03 AM
#100
J.C. Staff. I will be waiting for the shitstorm... |
As a child, I was told that society is a melting pot of talents; knowledge and experience combined to form important alloys that will contribute to mankind. When I got to highschool, however, I thought that it's more like a river in which the water represents our peers while we ourselves are the stones in the river. Constant erosion by mindless majority sheeping has made us lose our unique edge. After I hit the age of 18, I realized that I've been wrong all along. Society is no melting pot. Society is no river. Society is a person, a very skilled rapist, and he has fucked us all. |
More topics from this board
» New 'Mahou Shoujo Lyrical Nanoha' TV Anime in ProductionVindstot - Yesterday |
15 |
by ItsXolo
»»
45 minutes ago |
|
» 'Bleach: Sennen Kessen-hen' Fourth Part Announced as Final SeasonVindstot - Yesterday |
7 |
by Rinrinka
»»
3 hours ago |
|
» Mamoru Hosoda's New Movie 'Hateshinaki Scarlet' Set for Winter 2025 ReleaseVindstot - Dec 23 |
17 |
by malvarez1
»»
4 hours ago |
|
» 'New Panty & Stocking with Garterbelt' Reveals Cast Members, Additional Staff, Teaser Promo for 2025Nioxys - Dec 24 |
14 |
by Playcool
»»
11 hours ago |
|
» Original TV Anime 'Maebashi Witches' Announced for Spring 2025Nioxys - Sep 5 |
24 |
by AmanoDaichi
»»
Yesterday, 12:28 PM |