Would the season been better if it was a movie instead?

Jun 24, 10:24 AM

Offline

May 2024

Don’t get me wrong I still appreciate this arc for what it brings to the other Hashiras that we never had time for, but after watching the second to last episode after waiting week after week for this slowburn build up to the finale… would it have been better if this season had gotten the same treatment like the Mugen train arc? Cut down some of the “filler” moments and make the story more coherent on what it’s trying to say? All in all i just hate waiting another year for the continuation even when the manga has been over for years now.

Jun 24, 11:11 AM

ktg

Offline

May 2016

1769

Nope. The story looks pretty episodic with the different training sessions while Mugen Train was one overarching story, so this was the better option.

Jun 24, 11:15 AM

Phantom_373

Offline

Aug 2022

1429

It could have been but they handled this season perfectly

Jun 24, 11:15 AM

KupoChino

Offline

Jul 2023

I don’t think a movie would be necessary, but this season should have been WAY shorter. This arc was like, 1 volume in the manga. 8 episodes was too much.

Jun 24, 11:17 AM

deg

Offline

Jan 2009

97133

ye it could work as a movie and without the boring slow pacing and fillers too since its only 9 chapters in the manga anyway

Jun 24, 11:29 AM

FZREMAKE

Online

Jan 2021

5353

No it wouldn't have worked as a movie. For a whole movie you need actual content that isn't just training and stuff. Mugen train was perfect for a movie. Introduced a new character, dealt with a demon in the middle, surprising twist at the end and beautiful fight sequence. This arc is literally just training. Promotional movie for the first episode is more than enough.
Besides, I love what they did in this episodic format. The additional content was new for manga readers as well and we will see one of the best cliffhanger next.
A trilogy movie format is perfect for the infinity castle arc. Jumping from a TV anime to movie theatres is much better.

If you enjoyed the time you wasted, then its not a waste of time.

Jun 24, 11:52 AM

kuga86

Offline

Dec 2021

Nah it’s good as it is

Jun 24, 12:24 PM

OtakuKun1

Offline

Oct 2022

497

I do not believe they could have been integrated everything in just one movie or two. I understand that this season is very short, it is the same in the manga (I’ve read all of it and I remember it was only 5 or 6 chapters of the entire Hashira Training Arc). I appreciate the fact that they decided to make a whole season for this training, even if it’s short. The animation and the way characters are presented are insanely worth watching, Aniplex and creators are still the best.

It was a great choice they made up their mind to make 3 movies for Infinity Castle Arc, though.

Jun 24, 1:09 PM

SenshadouOtaku

Offline

May 2023

439

This has the same running time as any regular 12 episode season. That’s four hours long. Hell no this wouldn’t have been better as a movie

Jun 24, 2:12 PM

#10

Moragi

Offline

Feb 2020

I don't think so. A movie script is pretty much made of four sections, which are introduction, conflict, climax and conclusion. Now, if you've been watching the hashira's training arc carefully, you'll see that the story doesn't exactly follows that pattern. I think that if they made a movie out of the episodes, it wouldn't appeal much as a movie as the mugen train arc for example, where the four sections I mentioned early are very clear and distinguishable.

Jun 24, 3:06 PM

#11

Blue_Maroon

Offline

Jun 2019

1273

Yes, a movie would have been a much better product with less filler and better pacing. However, I believe they didn't do this because the content they are adapting is not good enough.

If it's true that Ufotable is doing 3 movies to finish the series, prefacing that with a middling training arc movie that people paid to watch would undermine the significance of the "Grand Finale".

Jun 24, 5:36 PM

#12

BurntToastCrumb

Offline

Feb 2024

Yeah I feel like a lot of what’s been shown in this season has been a bit of a waste of time. If the absurd amounts of fat had been trimmed from this for it to be a movie I feel like I would be coming away from this arc a lot happier.

Jun 25, 1:58 AM

#13

Dan_ALves

Offline

May 2022

846

I don't know. But it could have been better if they're did S3 and S4 in one season.

Jun 25, 2:35 AM

#14

joyrrhea

Offline

Sep 2020

seasons>movies ALWAYS IDC

Jun 25, 5:12 AM

#15

DarthHater

Offline

Apr 2020

Nah, a training arc is fine as a season but would’ve been boring as a movie

Jun 25, 6:04 AM

#16

Karnox001

Offline

Jan 2019

787

No, to make a movie you need more than just the right ammount of content, you need a narrative structure that works in a movie, or in other words you need set ups and pay offs, a three act structure with its rising action and all that stuff, character arcs, a narrative climax (not just a fight), etc.

This arc has a couple of those things and others can be created through adaptation, but there's just no plot to do a movie, because it's mostly training. It most definitely wouldn't work as a movie.

Jun 25, 6:50 AM

#17

Naveen6662246

Offline

Mar 2021

245

yo this is more than the movie....🧐

Anime Rules the world

Jun 25, 9:53 AM

#18

Otaku_guru

Offline

Jul 2023

166

gyoobr said:
Don’t get me wrong I still appreciate this arc for what it brings to the other Hashiras that we never had time for, but after watching the second to last episode after waiting week after week for this slowburn build up to the finale… would it have been better if this season had gotten the same treatment like the Mugen train arc? Cut down some of the “filler” moments and make the story more coherent on what it’s trying to say? All in all i just hate waiting another year for the continuation even when the manga has been over for years now.

Nope, you are utterly wrong here. Don't you see how they build up character of every hashira in this arc. A movie would not have been capable of doing this much character building of every hashira in 90Min. Although movie for each hashira fight in infinite castle arc would be much better duo to quality of fights we will have in it

Jun 28, 2:57 PM

#19

futarisaison

Offline

Apr 2017

Not really I think they did well with this format. :)

Jun 28, 8:45 PM

#20

ankitsharma679

Offline

Nov 2020

This would've never worked as a movie. The Slowburn and time spent with these characters were needed for the build up we get for Infinity Castle Arc

Jul 1, 12:49 PM

#21

Gator

Offline

Apr 2013

36781

At least to me it wouldn't, I'll always prefer a TV series to a movie.

See All Discussions

Poll: » Kimetsu no Yaiba: Hashira Geiko-hen Episode 8 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page ) anime-prime - Jun 30	539	by ProGoddess »» Sep 26, 10:40 PM
Poll: » Kimetsu no Yaiba: Hashira Geiko-hen Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page ) IzanaSolos - Feb 20	262	by ProGoddess »» Sep 26, 7:17 AM
Poll: » Kimetsu no Yaiba: Hashira Geiko-hen Episode 4 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 ) Kashimo_Official - Jun 2	182	by Matheus050 »» Sep 24, 9:36 AM
Poll: » Kimetsu no Yaiba: Hashira Geiko-hen Episode 2 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 ) Softhenic03 - May 19	155	by Sean_T_kendo »» Sep 23, 6:42 AM
Poll: » Kimetsu no Yaiba: Hashira Geiko-hen Episode 6 Discussion ( 1 2 3 ) Softhenic03 - Jun 16	126	by k-angel »» Sep 19, 12:08 AM

Would the season been better if it was a movie instead?

More topics from this board

Poll: » Kimetsu no Yaiba: Hashira Geiko-hen Episode 8 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

Poll: » Kimetsu no Yaiba: Hashira Geiko-hen Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

Poll: » Kimetsu no Yaiba: Hashira Geiko-hen Episode 4 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )

Poll: » Kimetsu no Yaiba: Hashira Geiko-hen Episode 2 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )

Poll: » Kimetsu no Yaiba: Hashira Geiko-hen Episode 6 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )

MoreTop Anime

MoreTop Airing Anime

MoreMost Popular Characters