A-Girl

The main thought I had while watching "A-Girl" is that I bet this is someone's favorite show. It's sort of a Minimum Viable Favorite Anime, which got me thinking about what that means. There is not a whole lot to this. Not to imply that there's not much to silent film, but this is a silent film, so it conveys its narrative through pictures and title cards and the music selection. The relationships it depicts are archetypical enough that you could probably understand even without the cards. The character designs look somewhat similar to each other, enough so that it can take a second to differentiate secondary characters.

But there's so much emotional imagery compressed within this OVA. And I don't mean that in the "you're supposed to cry here" sort of way; you couldn't even call this story sad. I mean it walks us through an impressive number of different emotions and caters each scene to expressing that feeling and making us share in it. That was impressive and a wonderful approach to animating this story. It felt fresh and unique enough in a way that could make me absolutely understand someone finding this and going "This is my favorite thing ever."

Helpful

read more

Story 7/10 : I absolutely didn't get a damn thing about the story but I had an overall impression of cuteness and sadness about this love story.

Art 8/10 : Nothing to say considering the age of the anime. Reminded me of Aishite Night mostly because of the chara I guess.

Sound 10/10: The music is a real tear-bringer, seriously.

Character 8/10 : We didn't have much time to get to know the characters but fair enough for a single 25-minute episode. The characters were way to similar but it's a common problem for almost every romance anime from the 90s

But damn, I need an explanation of this anime or I won't sleep T_T

Helpful

read more

I don't know what's up with the very low review score for this OVA on MyAnimeList, but rest assured, A-Girl is one of those hidden gems that makes sifting through all the garbage of late-eighties-early-nineties anime OVAs worth it. It's genuinely something special.

I didn't expect this to be a weird experimental silent film, and I also didn't expect this to be legitimately pretty moving and sweet. The animation is so good, too, which baffles me for how obscure it is. I love it when we get really nice coming-of-age stories for women out of nowhere. Plus, thanks to being a silent film, there's a ton of great music!

Helpful

read more

This anime isn't for everyone and was probably not intended for the masses. It is a piece of high art.

Story: The story is fine and relatable if you are familiar with anime tropes of the time and can follow the storyline. This anime is dense and doesn't tell you anything. It wants you to perceive the storyline rather than give it to you.

Art: I'm watching a VHS rip on a 40" 4K monitor. Of course it doesn't compare to anything modern. It is on par with many things of the same time period and better than most. They took their time to draw a great animation.

Sound: There is very little spoken dialogue. Most of the anime is visuals and music. The music is well chosen and always fits perfectly with the animation. It is a S tier soundtrack.

Character: They aren't well fleshed out, but they do a lot with the minimal time given.

Enjoyment: 10/10 for me. Otherwise, I wouldn't be here writing a review.

Overall: 9/10 It's just good. If you like old anime just watch it.

Helpful

read more