I couldn’t get myself to finish it (Actually watching up to this episode was a trial in and of itself in a way). It simply has too many flaws that can't be overlooked. Shakugan no Shana is one of those anime that has a really intriguing plot but can't follow up on it. The first episode was stunning and I was looking forward to a deep and somehow philosophic, mature anime but it turns out to be a bad-guy-appears-and-is-defeated-anime.
STORY
Don't be deceived by the intelligent beginning. I thought I was going to witness an excellent story and drama just from the opening. It quickly became
...
boring, lame, and confusing. It evolved into just another of the partly romance, partly action stories, with both aspects being underdeveloped, flat. If I had read a paragraph summary of the show then it would've been just that much more boring (ruining the only part of show) it was one of the few redeeming things the show has, that concept...
It has uninteresting dialogue, repetitive battle scenes, and slow execution. They bring in some sort of awkward romance story that isn't really fulfilling or moving. So this series basically becomes a horribly cliché and contrived romance with absolutely no progress in any meaningful direction. The actual story development with the baddies, romance and all that is REALLY cliché. Neither the story nor characters are worth it for watching this series. The action was actually boring to me, the ones I saw anyway...
It's best summed up as a sword girl + generic male lead fighting to save the day. They came up with some 'intricate' plots but really they aren't that impressive. The show tries to blur its simplicity with many terms and names. It's roughly about a boring and overly confusing and overly repeated plot about mistes, torches, flame hazes, guzes, balance of the world, etc... The whole thing is just confusing and I don't feel like it's my fault. There's not enough explanation yet there's so much confusing, boring dialogue
there was this ONE SCENE that I thought was the ULTIMATE EXAMPLE OF WHY it's so...manipulative and impudent at the same time. it also is one of the biggest/annoying problems in new anime that I canNOT STAND.
So they show Shana changing and they show her taking her panties off (lol)
But while she's doing that she's talking about all that mumbo-jumbo and that mumbo-jumbo made no sense.. AND AND because I have yet to thrown in the towel even though the signs are huge that the show is shit, I re-watch that scene. orz OTL I realize it really doesn't make ANY SENSE. it's like they're trying to cover it up with this weird loli fanservice which doesn't do much for me. Have her say shit that makes no sense which they are apparently deluded that the viewer will take in as really too complex and deep or whatevers to comprehend if she takes her undies off while she says it. Was this in the ep I dropped it? PRObably. this is a really bad tell-tale sign that this anime is a piece of popular overrated shit.
talk about trashy, and just plain insulting. i'm sure the loli otakus went crazy over that scene but i didnt...
CHARACTER
As episode after episode passed, I just felt horribly unsatisfied without any character development.They lack any sort of sort of dimensionality: unconvincing voice acting, dull dialogue, no development. Everyone else besides Shana is merely "devices" to make things a bit more intricate and to help push the "story" on. Characters are basically given whatever set of feelings and goals and repetitively do the same action. Nearly all of them are meaningless and replaceable. The male lead is not very appealing and can be easily forgotten. Shakugan no Shana is blessed with Shana, a cute character, but that's it. Shana is the only interesting character and even so she's not THAT interesting. Shana is clearly "loli" which doesn't make me like her any more BTW but hey if you're into that sure…
The enemies are just enemies, it's like they exist only because the anime needed them. They don't explain their background all that much, they don't have motives really, boring, possibly annoying, same old same old, in other words I couldn't care much... From the 1st ep I just thought the baddies just weren't that "cool" but then again I didn't get to see/meet the other baddies I saw in the opening so who knows. But I doubt it...
ANIMATION
I loved the artwork. It's what made me want to watch this in the first place. Though I did find the animation itself to be a little ordinary since I've seen other anime that look like this. It's normal production quality of recent anime. Basically as much as I like the artwork, I can't watch for that
Sound
One department Shana does quite well at is music. Its theme songs are very good and even fits in with the series with the lyrics. As far as voice acting, I couldn't help but feel that some characters weren't sounding too convincing. That could simply be due to the poor execution of the characters and storyline, consequently damaging the mood of the scenes.
There are better anime of this genre out there fo sho. Shana never really passes more than an average/below average show. I would recommend that you watch the openings, because they look awesome and all that & maybe the firsrt couple eps if you just wanna know what it's about but I can't fathom watching all 24 eps... Overall, a show with huge potential that fails to live up to its hype.
do yourself a favor and watch SLAYERS NEXT!! (watching slayers next twice is more enjoyable than watching shana once lol) instead of this anime. it has a girl with red hair too lolz... no but seriously it's actually funny and the serious parts are really good too (this anime is cool... in short while shana just gets lamer and lamer). seriously the characters actually have souls and the story is actually cool (I have this thing against fantasy anything but I love this fantasy anime) and the background music kicks ass and so does the op/ed and the seiyuu. It's better in every single way except maybe animation but I personally prefer slayers next animation to shana animation personally. it's on HULU!
www.hulu.com/the-slayers-next
Alternative Titles
Synonyms: Burning-Eyed Shana
Japanese: 灼眼のシャナ
More titlesInformation
Type:
TV
Episodes:
24
Status:
Finished Airing
Aired:
Oct 6, 2005 to Mar 23, 2006
Premiered:
Fall 2005
Broadcast:
Thursdays at 00:45 (JST)
Studios:
J.C.Staff
Source:
Light novel
Duration:
24 min. per ep.
Rating:
PG-13 - Teens 13 or older
Statistics
Ranked:
#21692
2
based on the top anime page. Please note that 'Not yet aired' and 'R18+' titles are excluded.
Popularity:
#426
Members:
545,542
Favorites:
4,955
Available AtResourcesStreaming Platforms | Reviews
Filtered Results: 17 / 91
Sort
Your Feelings Categories Mar 29, 2008
I couldn’t get myself to finish it (Actually watching up to this episode was a trial in and of itself in a way). It simply has too many flaws that can't be overlooked. Shakugan no Shana is one of those anime that has a really intriguing plot but can't follow up on it. The first episode was stunning and I was looking forward to a deep and somehow philosophic, mature anime but it turns out to be a bad-guy-appears-and-is-defeated-anime.
STORY Don't be deceived by the intelligent beginning. I thought I was going to witness an excellent story and drama just from the opening. It quickly became ... May 26, 2008
Shakugan no shana... An anime with alot of potential that overall felt like alot of regurgitated shounen/romance anime was a bit of a let down. The predictable uninspired story line, repetitiveness, cheesy humor, and mediocre character development left alot to be desired and is far from a masterpiece that is popularity would make you believe it is.
Story line: The initial introduction of the story really got my hopes up; basically about a normal boy who gets pulled into a bizarre battle only to find after words he no longer really exists, and that his entire being will slowly fade away and be forgotten by ... Dec 3, 2007
This anime.... is just another anime. Nothing spectacular or amazing.
STORY: it started off extremely slowly, and i think the first half of the series was basically explaining the main concept of how people disappear, who Shana was and what she does. I would have rather liked to see all these elements integrated into the story, because otherwise, it is a huge influx of information. The plotline was predictable. ART: best part of the series. I liked the scenes when there were a lot of red, there seemd to be many shades of red, and it reflected the intensity of battle. NOTE: battle intensity that should be ... Jun 17, 2007
Title: Shakugan no Shana (??????)
Genres: Drama, Fantasy, Novel, School Life Episodes: 24 Studio: J.C. Staff Plot (by sirhcle): Shakugan no Shana is set in our world in which everything is fueled by the power of existence. One day a boy names Sakai Yuji finds that he is moving in a time-frozen realm, whilst a monster (called Rinne) ingests blue flames (power of existence) for their masters (called Tomogara). It is here that Sakai Yuji meets a girl who he later names Shana. Shana is a flame haze, responsible for annihilating Rinne and hunting down their masters. Who wish to use power of existence to become stronger, by harvesting the ... Dec 28, 2009
It's a decent series however there is a ton of emotional and time filler. First the good points however and then the filler issue.
The animation is really nice and the story is reasonably unique. The character design can be summed up as either really good or direly lacking depending on the character in question. The story doesn't move too slow, it's mainly a filler issue. The story has depth though it's not as structured as some others. There is no overwhelming sense of the ultimate structure of the fictional universe...it's more of a perspective of seeing the box from within the box then being able ... Nov 29, 2014
I saw a fire that ignited and blazed strong for an instant. It grabbed my attention and had me going towards it. The fire quickly died down however, weakened and became very dim. I watch the flame, waiting for it to die, but for some reason it stays: weak and flickering.
This is essentially what I thought about this anime. It starts off really strong in the first four episodes with really cool ideas and even some thought provoking themes that could potentially be explored. I was really interested to see where it was all going to go... and it ended ... Nov 24, 2009
man oh man, i should stomp whoever told me this was good in the face. Shana is just about as boring and generic as you could get and it is also the creator of that Tsunderie nonsense where every tsundere now has to be a midget who beats the shit out of the people.
there is hardly a redeeming factor about this anime. forced drama, dull characters and a generally childish plot. Ah well, at least I managed to finish it. Jul 23, 2014
Shakugan no Shana... when I first start watching this anime I though I was going for another version of Zero no Tsukaima but after a few episodes I realized that this anime is nothing like Zero no Tsukaima.
I'm not saying that I hated Shakugan no Shana but I have to admit that the character development was very slow and some of the episodes were also quite boring at some point because It was basically the same thing over and over again, and you won't see much development in their relationship either (in a romantic way). About the Story, well I don't have much to complain about ... Aug 4, 2015
This is a very opinionated review. I found this anime had great potential but by midway through i realised that no matter how kickass the main heroine is, it wont take away how frustratingly simple and annoying the male MC is.
This is what made me rate this so low. i coudnt stand how much potential this show had at the beginning to how much it lacked towards the end. Shana the main MC is amazing. her character development was well thought out and all her surrounding characters really complimented her. I especially liked her guardian Flame of Heaven and the other Flame blaze. they are both ... Nov 22, 2014
First review and I usually don't care to post reviews but I just had to for this one. I watched the Dub of this, and that is the only reason i actually finished this series.
Story: There was a decent story to this, nothing very original. It was interesting though. The pace in the anime was so slow that you really didn't care much though. It is slow, incredibly slow. Give it one point up for being dubbed there, you could get up and make a meal or go to the bathroom and still hear the plot. I skipped ... Jun 11, 2016
This anime gives me strange feeling. I can't say I I really enjoy the show. If there is one thing I have really enjoyed the most, it's Shana's voice actress. She sounds so cute and lovely that it was the only reason why it kept me watching the show. But story itself just lacked the kind of development and flow that makes one keep watching.
In fact, the story is rather dull. While I understand how it may be interesting to some, the fact that the story is based on one man's value due to what he holds inside just doesn't make it all that ... Dec 9, 2020
With the enigma of Haruhi Suzumiya's character, ※Noiji Itō's other lead heroine, by design, is a firecracker: she's strong-willed, intuitive, and a badass fighter. In the concept of parallel dimensions, Shana is the centripetal force, freeing the souls of slaves to the "Crimson Denizens"! That premise and her iconic personality alone, was enough to get me to give this series a watch-through!
※Ms. Itō sure knows how to attach herself to good projects! ⚠️ This review will have spoilers ⚠️ —Story/Characters I have always been drawn to stories where a lone warrior fights the treacherous, supernatural entities to release humans as their slaves! That's why I loved "Vampire ... Jul 24, 2013
The first thing that came to my mind when I saw the first episode.... Cliche girl saves boy/boy saves girl anime... Shakugan no shana can't be described any other way. The anime is overall ok with it's good soundtrack and art, but everything else makes it mediocre. The plot is cliche, the characters have no depth, especially the villains. One thing in my opinion that can destroy an anime's reputation is the protagonist. In this anime we have a wimpy protagonist, who occasionally learns to get better at controlling his powers ( again cliche). The characters are just not likable, except for shana because she
...
Dec 3, 2016
The world of Shakugan no Shana is a fascinating one. It is rich with lore and completely developed into something surreal yet believable. Unfortunately, there are many times in the first two seasons where we become lost in the "comedic" school lives of Yuji & co. or slice of life-esque drama, all of which are irrelevant to the plot. It distracts from the things that make the show interesting, to the point of being boring.
It doesn't help that there are entire arcs of the show that move at a snail's pace, with episodes of buildup leading to each confrontation. Rather than creating suspense, it loses ... Jul 31, 2021
(Impressions on Season 2 & 3 included - Spoiler-free)
Take my review as a friend suggestion: Don't start Shakugan no Shana if brought here by its fame. I'm not an hater, I actually loved many parts of the show (season 2 and 3 included), but it's not what I hoped it would be. Episode 1 is almost perfect, the prelude to a magnificent world building and interesting plot development, but sadly nothing happens for over 40 episodes. The first 2 seasons left me with the impressions of a simple love comedy, while the battles had little to no effect in developing the story. In fact at the moment you start ... May 27, 2021
I'm going to start by saying, I love shojo and shounen titles, it's fun just to watch people duke it out and turn your brain off, or watch a blossoming couple as they go about their relationship.
Now this anime has both, but in my personal opinion they don't do both particularly well, except for one fight in one of the earlier episodes and the romance doesn't make me root for any particular relationship cause non of them seem believable or fun to watch. We learn bout Shana's job as a "heat haze" which sounds like a '"soul reaper" type gig which they don't explain or show ... May 17, 2020
Shakugan no Shana manages to be one of the most unbalanced watches I've had in recent memory. It has strong character development, and basically nothing of anything else.
The characters really are great, especially early on in the show. Shana and Yuji are especially good, though some of the side characters also get decently developed. Sure, it's somewhat predictable, but considering that most anime doesn't include any character development, it's easy to praise the show for it. The villains are significantly less developed and mostly just feel like they're out of a B-movie. They're wacky enough to keep you entertained, but nothing to write home ... |