Final Fantasy: The Spirits Within

Despite what people say, this film was not awful. Okay, it didn't quite match up to the magical, epical, astounding, spellbinding, memorable, groundbreaking quality of the game series, but think of it as a normal SciFi movie and you'll be fine. That's right, SciFi. It's not really what I would classify as fantasy.

The story was quite simple, but decent enough. It had some good qualities, but nothing new. There were a couple of unexpected moments, some romance, action, and some interesting ideas. However, it wasn't nearly as good as what people hoped it to be. I preferred it to Advent Children since it was a ... story in its own right, but it doesn't compare to the game series.

The animation was astounding; the characters looked almost as real as they possibly could have done. For its time, it's groundbreaking. Better than the animation in FFVIII, which was being made at the same time.

The character voices were well cast and the music was serene. It added to the atmosphere, and all those sound effects we take for granted well sleak and done to perfection.

Characters were nice, and better than the plot. Each was unique and, while I didn't learn a lot about them during the film, I felt they were created well.

Considering its length, the time, and the fact it's a part of a series which is loved by millions, I would certainly say this movie is under-rated. It's not got much of a re-watch value, but I'd certainly say go and watch it once. Watch it with an open mind, and forget it's called "Final Fantasy". Think of it as nothing more than "The Spirits Within", and enjoy it for what it is, not what many people hoped it would be.

The Spirits Within is not like Anime at all. It sits at the midpoint between a Square style RPG and a Hollywood blockbuster. Reviewing this on an Anime website as a frequent movie goer and a fan of the Final Fantasy series, my perspective is, as you might expect, a little bit scattered. As an FF fan, this movie is a bit of a disappointment because it lacks a strong fantasy element and limit breaks (lets face it, we all want to see limit breaks). As a Hollywood Sci-fi movie sitting next to something like The Matrix, it is racked with cliches, but an engrossing ... watch nonetheless. Looking at it as an Anime, it puts the visual/audio of most films to shame, and its western blockbuster style is actually novel. My opinion of this film drastically changes depending on what I evaluate it against. After trying my best to put all my biases aside to look at this as entertainment pure and simple, I`ve come to realize that despite its flaws here and there, it`s not half bad.

Animation:
7 or so years after the fact, The Spirits Within still boasts visuals competitive with a newer Final Fantasy: Advent Children, . The character animations don`t seem quite as smooth and effortless, but the gritty, post-apocalyptic setting and the striking realism in the skin tones and hair of The Spirits Within remains matchless. The characters don`t look like digitized images of real people; they retain a little bit of a cartoony feel, only with eons more detail than nearly every piece of animation in existence. The clunky character animations and the lack of long, and truly gratifying action scenes leave me with a slight, very very slight, feeling of disappointment in the visuals; I feel like it was but 2 steps from blowing my socks off. As it is though, it is still brilliant, and a beauty to behold each and every second.

Music:
The sound track is always perfectly matched, never committing the cardinal sin of overpowering the inherent mood of a scene. It also just sounds good. The full on orchestral score compliments the epic grandeur that the story goes for. The soundtrack is not better than that of Star Wars or Lord of the Rings, but it is certainly comparable.

Story:
Even though a couple of characters feel like they belong right at home in any Final Fantasy game, the story bears no similarities to that of the games aside from a couple of nominal references and Sakaguchi`s strange obsession with anthropomorphing planets, . It is however, effective and interesting as a supernatural sci-fi story, at least up until the end. At the start of the movie, the planet has already been plagued by ethereal alien invaders for quite some time. These creatures, dubbed phantoms, can pass through matter and kill anything alive with a simple touch. The ravishing doctor Aki and her superiors are working on a special weapon that will destroy all of the aliens without harming anything else. Her opposition is a general who is insistent on using a large space cannon to wipe out the invaders by brute force. The government grants Aki some time to collect the "spirits" necessary to complete their project, and she enlists the help of a lower ranking military officer, Gray, who happens to be her old flame.

The post-apocalyptic America setting is beautifully fleshed out, and genuinely disconcerting; the alien invaders are at once sci-fi alien monsters and creepy, supernatural beings; plenty ominous, the obligatory romance is not half bad, and the general creates some political elements that complicate things nicely. In other words, the build up in the story is effective for a sci-fi film. The problem is the climax. The world turns on itself, and becomes inconsistent with its own logic. Conventional weapons can kill the phantoms (we see it happen), as can the space cannon, but it paradoxically also makes them stronger? That`s a head scratcher. There is also a gigantic contrivance in how Aki obtains the last spirit needed to utilize her special weapon, forcing an unspectacular ending that`s basically ripped right out of FF7. Yet another contrivance is an unnecessary death that occurs towards the end, but at least this one brings about a somewhat touching and emotional scene. The lackluster ending really brings down an otherwise well crafted story, but if asked the simple question of "like or dislike?" my fondness of the first 3/4 trumps my disdain of the last 1/4.

Characters:
Putting aside the solid characters in the villain and Aki, and a mediocre one in her lover, the rest of the cast feels like they`re still warm off a Matrix photocopier. Gray`s little platoon is a gallery of token characters. A fast talking little snark provides the much unneeded comic relief, which clunks up otherwise functional scenes with been there, heard that jokes. Somewhere in there is a noble and stoic black man, and an equally stoic, quiet woman. Dr. Cid is less of a cliche, but also lacks any personality beyond anything that is absolutely necessary for a generic scientist.

The villain, one of the two effective characters, would fit right into the cast of a Final Fantasy. He seems modeled after the FF7 villain, Sephiroth, only a little less crazy. The general looks terribly menacing from the get go, but his intentions, initially, are good. Eventually, ambition gets the best of him, and his actions become more and more unsavory. The movie highlights his just motives, humanizes him with conscience and regret, and yet manages to give him, throughout the whole film, an intimidating and menacing presence perfect for a good, love-to-hate villain.

Luckily, the other strong character is the main character, Aki. Might I first mention that she is beautiful, not only because of her fetching appearance, but also because of a certain quiet dignity she possesses. Despite her usual bland tone (voiced by Ming Na), she`s not stoic. A better description would be "mellow". She manages to express herself in her own muted and understated way, which is especially effective in her relationship with Gray. The few outright dramatic scenes she has are all the more explosive for their contrast to her usual, calm demeanor.

Aki`s romance with Gray seems to have much more baggage than a typical boy meets girl setup. They are past lovers after all. None of that baggage is explicitly revealed, nor does it need to be since the nuances that resulted from it are present in their interactions. The intimacy between these two characters is quietly warm, familiar but awkward. The romantic element generates the intended fuzziness overall, but the placement of the most affectionate scene is questionable. It`s right next to a tragic turn in the plot, and as lovely as that scene might have been anywhere else, it completely goes against the mood at that point in the story.

Closing Comments:
I first saw this film when it opened in theaters years ago. I kept waiting for the melee combat, the summoning of deities and of course, the limit breaks. I expected all of that, and received none, so despite the awe it left me in from its visuals, I left the theater disappointed. Upon watching it again, now 7 years after my first viewing, I saw it not as a movie version of the FF games, but simply as a computer animated sci-fi movie, and from this perspective, The Spirits Within is a decent watch. A couple of hiccups at the end murk up an otherwise memorable film. It`s a shame that this movie lost money for Square. A second effort that smooths out the story and keeps everything that was charming about the first would be truly spectacular.

Final Fantasy: The Spirits Within is an intriguing film. Released back in 2001, it was a bit of an unmitigated disaster for Square, costing them a lot of money. To this day, many people consider the later animated film by Square, Advent Children, to be vastly superior (although they are very different). However, whereas Advent Children was a lamefest of no plot and character development, The Spirits Within maintains some level of story and characterization.

Easily the first thing you will notice about The Spirits Within is that, even today, it looks amazing. You can see the pores and freckles on skin, hair moves independently, the ... facial expressions and nuances of each character all look fluid and real. After ten years, it still remains as a testament to the capability of CGI as it continues to improve.

The story, however, is not as strong. It tends to occupy the realm of "be good to Earth" that many sci-fi films do. It's passable, but it doesn't really do anything to make this message new or original. This is compounded by the use of a villain right out of sci-fi stock. He is predictable and very typical, and it means the conflict isn't as compelling as it should be. You'll see his role and decisions from a mile away.

The rest of the cast is decent. Aki, the female scientist and protagonist, is a strong-willed, independent woman, who is, rather refreshingly, not sexualised at all. There are other typical character types here; the wizened old biologist, who is easily one of the standouts as a perfect mix of intelligence and compassion, the concerned love interest, and the comic relief. They're all mostly genre standbys.

I can forgive some of this, however, because, perhaps most surprisingly, the "acting" in this film is rather great, whether you watch it subbed or dubbed. Buoyed by the realistic animation, the voice acting feels incredibly natural and comfortable. I daresay, the "acting" in this film is substantially better than the acting of many modern day sci-fi movies.

While the story itself may not be a home run, director Sakaguchi and company keep up a relentless pace, never letting the film get too terribly wordy and preachy. The action scenes are generally well choreographed and intense, and the story moves along at a brisk pace. While you have to deal with some wishy-washy new age mysticism regarding "spirits," and a living Earth, it doesn't really detract from the film as a whole. Yes, the environmental message is pretty heavy-handed here, but it's incorporated well enough into the story and justified enough that it doesn't detract too much. Same with the spirits and mysticism aspect.

A quick word on the ending; I actually rather enjoyed it. It does a good job answering enough questions but leaving the future of humanity and the planet somewhat up in the air. We don't really know if anyone outside of Aki knows exactly how the Earth was "saved," which is a nice bypass of the standard, leave-some-people-alive-to-tell-the-story device.

Ultimately, I consider Spirits Away one of the most surprising animated films I have seen in awhile. While the story doesn't set the world on fire, and the nature of the conflict is a bit cliché, the strong acting, solid lead characters, and exciting pace keep the film very watchable and enjoyable. If you're looking for a true Final Fantasy film, go elsewhere, as this has pretty much nothing to do with the games. If you're looking for a generally exciting sci-fi movie, this should definitely pass the time.

8/10

Where in the world do I begin with this train wreck of a movie?

The plot is the essentially a clone of other Final Fantasy movies and has more or less the same story arc we've all seen a thousand times before in sci-fi and anime. What makes all those other countless identical films superior to this one is exposition. Flashbacks, memories, narrative storytelling, correlated events - all of these are what give a tale depth and interest. Sadly, none of that is seen here, just a series of events given in one block of time. The closest we ever come to any dimension added ... to the characters are the little tidbits they happen to drop in conversation with others. However, without compelling imagery, the words are just as flat as the script on which they were written.

The one saving grace is the CG artwork, which was crisp, defined, and of good enough quality. Again, though, the "phantoms" practically had generic written all over them. Less-than-material creatures that glow a lot and eat spirits - anyone else getting a little déjà-vu yet?

So, once again, the amazing video game franchise is slightly cheapened with another badly made movie. It would have been just another mediocre bit for the masses, but unfortunately, every other film-maker did it first, and every other film-maker did it better.

Fine, first I want to specify that I watched the anime quite a long ago, a year or two ago I guess. I haven't played the games, so I can say with no mental self-accusations that this was the better part of Final Fantasy movies. For me.

Story - it wasn't something veeery special, still, at least you understood what is going on and that stuff, which in Advent Children was possible only for who has already played the game. There is no game Final Fantasy on this particular story I think and that is one of the good sides, I guess, because you watch it ... like a separate film, with a different story, different characters and etc. So I must say to the non-fans of Advent Children/people who hasn't played the games - better watch this, I don't say it is a really good movie, but the story is comprehensible and you won't get tha-a-at bored as if you watch Advent Children ;)

Art - oh, it wasn't really good, it was Amazing... You watch the characters as if they are real human beings.. :) (better than Advent Children, I have the feeling xD)

Sound - I don't remember it very precisely, but the soundtrack wasn't bad and the other sounds were a fine piece of workmanship.

Character - trite. You see, there wasn't anything interesting about them. I can't even remember them, just that woman, the main character, and her beloved.

Enjoyment - fair, I guess, because of the art, it really smashed me up(it was one of the first movies that I had watched with so realistic graphics then) and some of the action scenes weren't bad...

Overall, I recommend it as a killer of time and as a really good 3D art movie, which has nothing to do with Advent Children as story, but for people, who haven't played the game and won't be angry if they don't like the film, would be a gulp of fresh air. :)

People say the movie is good, some say the movie is bad, it all kind of depends on ones opinion, the movie had its good points as well as the bad points. As far as the story went, it was a decent storyline , it wasnt a great one, but it wasnt a horrible one either. The CGI is absolutely stunning, if you enjoyed the CGI in FF:AC , you will definiately enjoy the CGI in Spirits Within. To be perfectly honest, the characters to me were quite forgettable, i dont recall thier names. As far as enjoyment goes theres one factor you need to ... consider, if you are a scifi kind of person, then you will love this movie, if you seek action, you may be bored to tears, the movie does have some action, but the movie kind of drags for action fans, but if you are a scifi fan then the movie will seem intresting and keep you hooked. Overall, Final Fantasy Spirits Within is one of those love it or hate it movies, but it is worth checking out

The very "first" Final Fantasy movie. I thought the story was well done, and it sort of paid homage to the games if anything. The CGI work is incredible and was basically the main appeal in this movie. At the time and even still today it was cutting edge and so realistic that when I first saw the trailer I thought I was watching real actors. The music and sound effects are very well done, but the thing that stands out is the voice work. Square got some big name actors in this film like Alec Baldwin, Ving Rhames, Steve Buscemi, James Woods and Donald ... Sutherland so as you would expect, the voices are pretty much flawless. Overall, as long as you don't go into this movie expecting anything Final Fantasy-like then you will enjoy it. Personally, I don't think this should have the name Final Fantasy because it's nothing like what the fans of the series know. It should have just been called The Spirits Within but overall, it's exciting and very entertaining. Reminds me of Halo in a way.

I think that if I had seen this movie without noticing the 'Final Fantasy' attached to the beginning, I would have enjoyed it. But there was something about it, as I compared it in my mind to all the amazing and mindblowing games I had played, that could only fall short. I didn't find the characters very sympathetic or engaging. All in all, I would have been fine going my entire life without seeing this film.

Wow, this was a pretty good movie I have to say, better than I expected. At first, I didn't quite undersatnd where they were going with the story, but then it came all together and I absolutely loved it. It had a supernatural mystery about it and the power of the unconcious mind. It also made me laugh a couple time :P And a bit of romance. The animation was amazing too. Not quite like the movie 5 Centimeters Per Second, but still really great. This is a great movie and I really reccomend it.

First and foremost you must take Final Fantasy out of your head when you watch this. I saw this film when it was released in theaters. I remember walking out at the end and simply repeating "That was not Final Fantasy." The only thing that links this to the Final Fantasy series is the person responsible for it. Other than that, it is best to view it as a unique film. That being said, it wasn't bad at all.

Visually this was a masterpiece. It really should have changed the industry instead of bankrupting a studio. It was filled with the most beautiful computer animation that ... had been done at that time. The music score was perfect for the film as well. There was not one piece that was out of place. If you are talking art and sound, then it gets a 10 in both categories. Even the voice acting was superb, but that's because this wasn't dubbed into English. It was an American/Japanese collaboration. These were the highlights of the movie.

So what was wrong with it? Well after watching it again I realized that the story should have been good, but squeezing something so large into such a small time frame took sacrifice on the story's part. It should have had a lot more going on in the beginning or this should have been the beginning of a much greater story. Not a lot really happened, though it was a fascinating concept. it was just missing something, and it's difficult to say what that should have been. They could have done so many things with the world they created. The problem is that I felt like I was tapping my foot waiting for something bigger to happen, but nothing big ever really happened. It didn't need more action or anything like that, it simply needed to tell a bigger story. If anything took away from this movie, it was the package they put all of these amazing visuals into.

If you're looking to be wowed, then this movie won't do it (except visually). That doesn't mean it's not worth watching, because it still is a decent movie. I would say take Final Fantasy out of the title and more people would have enjoyed it more than they did. It isn't a must see, but not necessarily something you should skip either.

The project was unsound from the beginning - even today, making a fully CGI animated film like this costs too much to be profitable and is not particularly convincing as a realistic art style besides. Final Fantasy is an outlandish sci-fi and fantasy video game series - why not make a film like this using traditional animation? Not only would it have looked better, it would have served the narrative better, as this story centers around nature versus technology. Hell, they could have made this movie live-action with the same cast for 140 million dollars and it would probably have made more money and reached ... a wider audience. But then it would not be on MAL to review, I suppose.

Anyways, despite the fact that the film is based on a video game series, this plotline is entirely original, with some trace overarching elements from the franchise included. This is because the Final Fantasy games are all self-contained narratives that take place in their own universes. This plot in particular draws from Princess Mononoke and other traditional Japanese narratives regarding the conflict between Nature and Technology (namely the belief that all life is sacred and equal versus the belief that nature exists to be used by man), misdirected idealism, and religious tenets vaguely drawn from Shintoism. There are also many elements overtly lifted from James Cameron's filmography, namely The Abyss, Aliens, and Titanic. The director of this film is notably a fan of western cinema and desired to create a synthesis of western and Japanese narrative elements here. This makes sense as the Final Fantasy games have a big following in the west and often contain Arthurian constructs such as knights, castles, and western designs of things like dragons and swords. It's a fascinating blend of ingredients.

The chief obstacle is the animation. Even for the time, these models paled in comparison to something like Blue Submarine No. 6 which was airing on Toonami. It makes scenes like the zero gravity make-out scene between the two romantic leads sillier than they would have been otherwise. It's an uphill battle from the start to expect western filmgoers to emotionally connect to these PS2 mannequins. The film often feels in stasis - the character's faces aren't facing, the plot is not moving, and there's very little action. This is more of an epic character drama in the vein of again something from James Cameron. It's really not a kid's film despite being based off of a video game. I personally feel that a few colorful side characters would have helped tremendously, but every character here is dead serious and bland. Also, considering how expensive the project was already, I don't think there was much upside in hiring celebrities like Alec Baldwin, Steve Buscemi, and Ving Rhames for the English dub rather than your usual VAs who would work for dirt cheap around this time. Admittedly these celebrities were not A-listers but there is little reason to seek them when anyone could do this voice acting. They needed to save money where they could since they were bleeding cash on the animation. I suppose companies like Pixar and Dreamworks hire celebrities for their animated features, but they have the backing of financially strong western film studios while this project was on the outs from the beginning. After all, it's not like video game movies have ever been particularly profitable. There are a few exceptions such as Mortal Kombat and the first few Pokemon movies, but those never cost anywhere near 140 million.

Anyways, this film is not horrible per se, but this is a very weak 5 bordering on a 4. There are some good ideas strictly with regards to the story - nearly everything else is ill-conceived. The execution is fine but the ideas were not great. It's an interesting experiment and a noble failure, but not something anyone needs to see, even FF fans.

First off spirit within is CG but don't let that turn you away it's possibly the best CG you wil have seen in a film, shame it bankrupted Square Pictures but that beside the point.

Not only is the artwork fantastic but the story and acting is'nt half-bad either whether watched in japanese or english.Something i do have to point out is that it does slow down at some points and even borders on you know what's going to happen next

All in all this is one film to watch, if you liked this you may also want to watch Advent Children also a very well done ... film