| simple question, both studios are pretty much on top of their game atm and been up there for quite some time. but which studio would you like to animate your ideas? sunrise:been in the genre for over 3 decades now, renowned for their gundam series, brave series(with takara studios) and the original combiners. known for their scientifically plausible scenarios. gainax:younger company, brought us quality shows like TTGL, NGE and diebuster/gundbuster. the catalogue is not as deep as sunrise but they sure make logic/physics defying anime. if you have another studio in mind. lets hear it! |
| i'll pick sunrise ^_^ |
     |
| gundam are the best mecha ever i don't care what ppl say about them and if some said gundams suck he/she a baka :P |
|
| Am I the only one who remembers why Yoshiyuki Tomino was so reluctant to make another Gundam series/movie/ova? If it was my idea, I'd go with Gainax cause sunrise would try to tell me how to write it. "We want the main mecha to show up in the first episode", "Needs more mecha" all these statments just so they can sell more toys/model kits. It's B.S. I love them for what they have released and what they currently are releasing but I'd be more inclinded to produce it as a Manga myself first so that my property could be true to it's original story. |
 |
| Gainax. Cause Gurren Lagann. Nuff' said. Also, Someone's gotta take sides with Gainax. |
| If I was forced to choose between the two I would take Sunrise, but if not I would go with Satelight because Macross Frontier raised the bar. |
  |
| i would've included satellite and toei but they barely make mecha nowadays. |
| Sunrise. Evangelions? DO NOT WANT IN REAL LIFE. |
Orange-kun said: you mean gigantic cyborgs? i would love to see paul bunyan fight off aliens.Sunrise. Evangelions? DO NOT WANT IN REAL LIFE. |
| The studio doesn't matter, I'd just want Yasuhiro Imagawa to direct it. |
| real/semi-real = sunrise super = gainex |
| Gainax for their kick reason to the curb attitude. |
| You wa SHOCK!!! |
| If I were to pick a studio to animate my ideas, it would be Gainax. As with what most people say, they make law defying animes, which would be a nicer medium to be showing off works. Of course, Sunrise is nice as well. If this question were to be :" Which of these two studios is your favourite?", I probably won't be able to answer that. |
     |
| Sunrise may have made Code Geass(yay ^_^) But, I'll go with Gainax, I don't like being restricted with my ideas |
 |
| I always liked Sunrise, so I don't see the point not to pick Sunrise. |
 |
| Gainax.... 4 words TENGEN TOPPA GURREN LAGGAN |
| funny because out of every single anime-mech show ever created, Gundams are hands down the best mechs ever, can beat every other mech......Sunrise.... |
| If I wanted sexy visuals and bonkers concepts, Gainax. If I wanted an at least half-decent plot, Sunrise... |
| 'only the dead have seen the end of war' Plato listen to the whispers of your ghost  |
| @ laborpilot86, Are you serious? A publisher isn't going to define your anime as serious or goofy. They may inquire how to improve your series/ova/movie and they may not want your anime based on your concept but they wouldn't turn a drama into a comedy or vice versa. |
| |
| Erm, I would go with Sunrise, only if it was the 80's and 90's Sunrise. I liked the older Sunrise shows better. Post 2000 I'd go with Gainax... |
| Gainax all the way... Evangelion is one hell of a drug. |
| I would pick up Sunrise. I been watching more animes from Sunrise than Gainax, but I never would leave Gainax, maybeh Gainax can make other my ideas to anime :D |
<img src="http://i102.photobucket.com/albums/m101/ZnakeBiteX/Omat%20teokset/Signatures/0d2b55e5.jpg" border="0" /> |
| Sunrise, as long as Fukuda isn't directing. :P |
| Sunrise i have never watch any anime show from Gainax |
  |
| Gainax. Sunrise tend to twist their plots to sell models and figures, I mean what the hell? Gundam SEED was a prime example. Also, Sunrise barely focus on the mecha, and just have overpowered specs to win it all (Strike Freedom, again SEED), Gainax don't really do that. |
 |
| Sunrise(even with the purple flames and exposionsXD ) Gainax's shows more like super-robo show than real-robo...and even if i liked them, in mecha sense the sunrise shows are better... |
willyverebNov 24, 2008 9:39 AM
 |
WiikendWarrior84 said: Am I the only one who remembers why Yoshiyuki Tomino was so reluctant to make another Gundam series/movie/ova? If it was my idea, I'd go with Gainax cause sunrise would try to tell me how to write it. "We want the main mecha to show up in the first episode", "Needs more mecha" all these statments just so they can sell more toys/model kits. It's B.S. I love them for what they have released and what they currently are releasing but I'd be more inclinded to produce it as a Manga myself first so that my property could be true to it's original story. acholy that hole thing abowt mor mecha and toys thats bandeis doing thar the ones makeing the oys not sunrise and as for wh tamino didint whant to make another gundam tha are a few resuns 1 he never whanted to be famus for gundam he whanted to be know for his novils witch are great and 2 after comin to erms with the fact e will forever be known for makeing gundam he stated and this is a quot my time makeing gundam is over its now time for the new genaration to pick up whar I have left off and as for thw topic im with sunrise |
| surly i'll pick Sunrise ! |
 |
| Gainax! I have never heard of the other one. |
Demon said: Gainax! I have never heard of the other one. w what!!!!!!!!!!!! you nevr herd of the studeo that made gundam |
| Sunrise was the one who made Gundam, Code Geass and GaoGaiGar so I would of course I would pick that company. |
| he was being sarcastic not acting like an ignorant. geez you guys are too protective..... |
Frito said: Orange-kun said: you mean gigantic cyborgs? i would love to see paul bunyan fight off aliens.Sunrise. Evangelions? DO NOT WANT IN REAL LIFE. Not really Cyborgs they are more biomechas but I would have to say Gainax. I have five reasons Reasons: 5. Evangelion is the most popular anime in japan 4. Gundam went into a loop after Wing. 3. Although Code Geass is great Gurren Lagann was here first. 2. Gainax made Higurashi, the most brutal anime EVER! 1. 1 word Gurren |
MahoDisgaeaNegi said: god your lame.Frito said: Orange-kun said: you mean gigantic cyborgs? i would love to see paul bunyan fight off aliens.Sunrise. Evangelions? DO NOT WANT IN REAL LIFE. Not really Cyborgs they are more biomechas but I would have to say Gainax. I have five reasons Reasons: 5. Evangelion is the most popular anime in japan 4. Gundam went into a loop after Wing. 3. Although Code Geass is great Gurren Lagann was here first. 2. Gainax made Higurashi, the most brutal anime EVER! 1. 1 word Gurren |
MahoDisgaeaNegi said: but I would have to say Gainax. I have five reasons Reasons: 5. Evangelion is the most popular anime in japan 4. Gundam went into a loop after Wing. 3. Although Code Geass is great Gurren Lagann was here first. 2. Gainax made Higurashi, the most brutal anime EVER! 1. 1 word Gurren I laughed. This was a joke post, right? |
| Id go with Gainax hands down, Sunrise's best series was Gasaraki. Gundam is supposed to be real robo? some of the stuff in Gundam absolutely destroys that assumption. |
BorjoyzeeJan 12, 2009 9:50 PM
| Gainax for sure. Sunrise was great in the 70-90s, but they have failed epically. The debacle that was Code Geass R2 - with dead people coming back to life at random The joke that was SEED Destiny - Super Yamato much? oh yeah stop reusing the same gd scene 50 billion times At least 00 is good. Terminator Exia. :) I'd also to nominate Bones for this. Xam'd Lost Memories is not pure mecha, but its more of biomech, but still original designs ftw. Also Eureka seven was pretty good from what I hear. |
snoopycamel said: Gainax for sure. Sunrise was great in the 70-90s, but they have failed epically. The debacle that was Code Geass R2 - with dead people coming back to life at random The joke that was SEED Destiny - Super Yamato much? oh yeah stop reusing the same gd scene 50 billion times At least 00 is good. Terminator Exia. :) I'd also to nominate Bones for this. Xam'd Lost Memories is not pure mecha, but its more of biomech, but still original designs ftw. Also Eureka seven was pretty good from what I hear. its true that when seed was made it wasint sunrises best but since then thy have made great show after grear show and anther thing you forget is a good as a studio gainax is not known for thar mecha serres i fact thy whore the same serres evangelion for all its werth in the 11 years evas been out thar have been 11 box sets whar as sunrise relesis difrent big names in the bast 11 years |
| Everybody keeps saying Gainax only does over the top stuff, but that wasn't the case with the original Gunbuster. The first Gunbuster series was rooted very sternly in real science, even to the point of aging less while moving at the speed of light. The second series got more crazy, more true to Gainax style; still it was built on the premise of the original, only fast-forwarded a few centuries... or was it millennia? Then there was Eva, which took basic scientific concepts and assumed certain theories were true. Despite the awesome power of the Evas, they were generally limited in what they could do, except when their pilots "lost" or "freed" their minds. Then all bets were off. Finally, you've got TTGL, one of the most outrageous(ly wonderful) mecha shows ever created. In truth, this one is a super robot series moreso than a mecha. Even so, only an idiot would say the series wasn't epic. On the other hand, you have Sunrise, who has constantly put out the (at least on the basic level) scientifically sound Gundam metaseries, and then followed it up with the very popular (and deservedly so, in my opinion) Code Geass. While some of their suits (see Strike Freedom and Infinite Justice) do manage to surpass the limits of the realistic fiction within the series, only 00-Raiser has thus far been able to surpass the absolute limits of realism and enter the impossible realm. So here's the thing: Gainax can do Gundam. I have no doubt in my mind that they could put out a show along similar lines, and that it would be well done and awesome. They can also do Gainax: the craziness of fighting on top of galaxies with mecha that can reach across the universe. Naturally, Sunrise can do Gundam, and despite what many may believe, they're damn good at it. In fact, when it comes to mecha, nobody has a record or repertoire like Sunrise. But they haven't proven to me that they can effectively work outside those Gundam lines and do Gainax. Code Geass, as far as I know, is the series that came closest, and it didn't even reach Bones' Eureka Seven. As a writer, my stories routinely cross the line between realism and impossibility. If I were to choose a group to do a story of mine, it would have to be Gainax, simply because they have displayed a flexibility that Sunrise has not. |
| i love my melodramatic gainax. and i love my quirky robots produced by sunrise. and dude gunbuster was epic. geez it was like starwars with boobs. and they fought random aliens and decided to give them six episodes to retreat or face a beating. |
Frito said: i love my melodramatic gainax. and i love my quirky robots produced by sunrise. and dude gunbuster was epic. geez it was like starwars with boobs. and they fought random aliens and decided to give them six episodes to retreat or face a beating. A Jupiter-sized beating. And back then (in the.. future...?) Pluto was/is still classified as a planet. |
Black_Kenshin said: Everybody keeps saying Gainax only does over the top stuff, but that wasn't the case with the original Gunbuster. The first Gunbuster series was rooted very sternly in real science, even to the point of aging less while moving at the speed of light. The second series got more crazy, more true to Gainax style; still it was built on the premise of the original, only fast-forwarded a few centuries... or was it millennia? Then there was Eva, which took basic scientific concepts and assumed certain theories were true. Despite the awesome power of the Evas, they were generally limited in what they could do, except when their pilots "lost" or "freed" their minds. Then all bets were off. Finally, you've got TTGL, one of the most outrageous(ly wonderful) mecha shows ever created. In truth, this one is a super robot series moreso than a mecha. Even so, only an idiot would say the series wasn't epic. On the other hand, you have Sunrise, who has constantly put out the (at least on the basic level) scientifically sound Gundam metaseries, and then followed it up with the very popular (and deservedly so, in my opinion) Code Geass. While some of their suits (see Strike Freedom and Infinite Justice) do manage to surpass the limits of the realistic fiction within the series, only 00-Raiser has thus far been able to surpass the absolute limits of realism and enter the impossible realm. So here's the thing: Gainax can do Gundam. I have no doubt in my mind that they could put out a show along similar lines, and that it would be well done and awesome. They can also do Gainax: the craziness of fighting on top of galaxies with mecha that can reach across the universe. Naturally, Sunrise can do Gundam, and despite what many may believe, they're damn good at it. In fact, when it comes to mecha, nobody has a record or repertoire like Sunrise. But they haven't proven to me that they can effectively work outside those Gundam lines and do Gainax. Code Geass, as far as I know, is the series that came closest, and it didn't even reach Bones' Eureka Seven. As a writer, my stories routinely cross the line between realism and impossibility. If I were to choose a group to do a story of mine, it would have to be Gainax, simply because they have displayed a flexibility that Sunrise has not. Sunrise made G Gundam, every entry in the Braves series (most famously GaoGaiGar), Ideon and (the more obscure) Overman King Gainer. So... not really. |
More topics from this board
» Favorite UnitRevillo_Phoenix - Dec 2, 2008 |
43 |
by Nerogranz
»»
Aug 17, 2023 1:35 PM |
|
» Mecha building contestwillyvereb - Dec 2, 2008 |
15 |
by DreamingGhost
»»
May 29, 2023 4:58 AM |
|
Poll: » Wich is the best Gundam (TV) Series? ( 1 2 3 )3rr0R - Aug 26, 2008 |
116 |
by DreamingGhost
»»
May 26, 2023 8:22 PM |
|
» Favorite Masami Obari mech design?removed-user - Oct 17, 2017 |
1 |
by Mango-man-dangO
»»
May 24, 2019 9:53 AM |
|
» [code]Favorite Masami Obari mech design?[/code]removed-user - Oct 17, 2017 |
0 |
by removed-user
»»
Oct 17, 2017 8:46 PM |