DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
| This film has really risen up the ranks for me. Everytime that I see it I love it more and more. I can't put my finger on it; the first 26 minutes or so before the meat of the plot gets introduced are absolutely captivating to me. I really think the central metaphor represented by the tower is nice, if simplistic. I have a tough time swallowing the fact that someone would potentially risk the entire world for a girl who, last he knew, was only a friend. The "science" behind the film is more psuedo-science too, but the movie is still packed with enough power and heartache that I love it. I also enjoy the ending. It's simultaneously happy and sad at the same time. Dreams are fleeting, and when we finally reach them, they're over all too soon. Something about that, and the rest of this film really resonates with me. And the scene where they "touch" even when apart worlds... so good. :D |
| I enjoyed watching the movie, but mostly because of the truly amazing background's....Breathtaking and mind blowing ....just like 5cm, beautiful .... The story it's not bad, it has a good premise, but in the end I got this feeling that something was missing... From Makoto Shinkai I've only watched 5cm and this one and I'm really enjoying his amazing artwork, I love the way he makes all those light effects, I don´t really know how to explain it, but I just love it! |
 |
| Fucking SLOW AS HELL--WAYYYY TOO DRAGGY. C'mon, who the hell wasn't waiting for the flying scenes already? |
| I like it. But 5 cm per sec is far better than Place Promised. It didn't make me cry [5 cm did.] but I will gave 10/10 because of amazing animation and backgrounds and due to that some other anime has 9/10 in my score and it would be a sin to compere these with Place ^^ |
| It's a good movie. I did not expect a happy ending, I was hoping for the air plane to explode and crash their dreams, but that didn't happen :\ 6/10 worth watching. |
ClosedCXJul 5, 2010 10:56 PM
 |
| Very slow movie that made little sense of the universe that the characters are in. I suppose I could watch it again and get a better understanding of what was reality and what the dreams/alternate-realities, but that just seems like a waste of time given how deplorably slow this movie was. There really is no indication of why she would love the narrator character over the friend, she was alone in her dreams and it was her memories of both of them that gave her her small grip on reality. Oh, . . . I suppose they were connected through dreams that led to this love. And then to say that it was no coincidence that these unusual circumstances are because she is the grandaughter of the tower's creator and then not explore that plot point to any further extent is a slap to the face to the viewers. Instead I'm left to speculate about a universe from a movie that really doesn't intend to keep its viewers pondering. Music and animation were superb, but this movie could have been a lot better. 7/10. |
| Good watch, great romance and sci-fi setting. However it felt slow at parts and didn't manage to get me on an emotional level. I felt like I've watched this before (5cm per second) but if I had to choose the better movie I would say this one, since now, 5cm per Second looks like a recycled version of this, without the war setting. |
 |
| I kinda liked it. I probably won't watch it again. I felt like something was missing...like the story wasn't complete. |
 |
| Coming off of this, I really have to wonder whether or not Shinkai has a grasp on how to tell a story. I'll give him points for nailing human emotion and crafting an interesting world that didn't hijack the story but I hope whatever he does next, he tries to tell it in a more traditional or linear fasion. I don't mean to sound but so negative; I did like the film but I wanted and tried so desperately to love it. Like "Voices of a Distant Star", the human emotion emanating from it drew me in to care about the characters while dragging my feet through a dull plot told in a somewhat incoherent fasion only to end right when I finally invest myself into their struggle. I was ultimately pleased to finally see the main characters get their happy ending, but I didn't get an emotional payoff from it. Overall, better than I feared but worse than I hoped. Gave it a 3/5 here and a 7/10 after marking its completion in my list. |
 |
| It's not a movie I'll watch again but I did quite like it. Did bore me out at times. The beginning was good but the sci-fi in it all really did kill it. Could of been a better movie definitely. It has something missing as said, but I don't know what exactly for me =/ |
| This movie fell in the category of something that could have been made even better. One thing though I wish all three of them was in that plane. |
| i really don't see why some one wouldn't like this. i thought it was a good looking anime that did its job. i did fell that there was something missing but it was still good and if you cant sit threw a 90 minute or more movie stop watching movies |
Makota508Aug 30, 2010 12:40 PM
 |
| oh wow..did the guy who did 5cm reall do this piece of work?It was um..god awful.Somewhere in the half it started to go downhill to the point where by the end I said to my self "This sucks". I read from one of the reviews this was his first work? glad to see he improved in 5cm though i enjoyed that one ;) Sent with Mal Updater |
 |
| It takes talent to make the same story 3 times and still have me enjoy each of them. I wasn't a major fan of the scifi aspect to this film, I'm not sure i fully understand it now.Anyway it could have been written to make more sense therefore improving the film, but oh well. The beginning of the film i enjoyed, i did presume that Sayuri's dreams were going to be related to the tower and other worlds. The dream connection between Sayuri and Hiroki was beautiful, another great way of showing love over distance by Shinkai. The ending, hmmmm. I'm undecided on if i liked it or not. It's sad but also happy, you do get the feeling of a fresh start but it's also sad that the love has just kinda vanished. Overall I think i'll give this a high 8/10. If the "science" was better explained and there was more character development it would have got a 9/10 for sure. ----- 5 Centimetres Per Second > The Place Promised in Our Early Days > Voices Of A Distant Star. |
 |
| I usually love and worship Shinkai Makoto’s works, his style is unique, but sadly, The Place Promised in Our Early Days didn’t captivate me as much as his others films. The premise of the story was very interesting, I thought it had a big potential since the beginning, Sci-Fi setting and the theories of parallel universes attracted me. But it wasn’t completely developed, that was the main fault. A lot of things weren’t explained, just mentioned, and the storytelling kept jumping which made somewhat difficult to understand certain parts. The art was amazing, the backgrounds detailed and nostalgic, the landscapes simply beautiful and the character design pretty good, a clear improvement when you compare it with Voices of a distant star, for example. I couldn’t be more pleased with the art and animation section. The music was good, it wasn’t overwhelming or underwhelming. I wished the soundtrack and theme song had more impact, though, it could’ve been used in the climax of the movie and would’ve made it more memorable. The characters were nice, they can be understood and the way they think is something you might find really close to reality. Regardless all the good factors, as a whole, the movie bored me. A lot. The fact the pace was excruciatingly slow didn’t help. And what bothered me the most it’s that I didn’t felt anything, not a single want to shed tears, I couldn’t feel moved. It just didn’t make an emotional impact on me; I couldn’t really get into the story for much I tried to. So, I’m quite disappointed by this movie, I was looking forward to it since some time ago, but I didn’t enjoy it as much as I thought I would. It wasn’t anything special for me. |
I think, then procrastinate. Therefore, I am. |
GoodEnoughForMe said: This film has really risen up the ranks for me. Everytime that I see it I love it more and more. I can't put my finger on it; the first 26 minutes or so before the meat of the plot gets introduced are absolutely captivating to me. I really think the central metaphor represented by the tower is nice, if simplistic. I have a tough time swallowing the fact that someone would potentially risk the entire world for a girl who, last he knew, was only a friend. The "science" behind the film is more psuedo-science too, but the movie is still packed with enough power and heartache that I love it. I also enjoy the ending. It's simultaneously happy and sad at the same time. Dreams are fleeting, and when we finally reach them, they're over all too soon. Something about that, and the rest of this film really resonates with me. And the scene where they "touch" even when apart worlds... so good. :D Totally Agree!! xD very good movie 8/10 |
  |
| meh. okay movie. never really sucked me in. |
 |
| This was so beautiful. It's going to take me a while to absorb. 9/10 |
 |
| A 9/10 from me even though I thought it was lacking something. And the ending is not sad. It's not happy either. It's a mixed one. Even though she had woken up (the happy part) she has the feeling of losing something important (the sad part). |
 |
| I had someone watch this movie recently, and he said it was too mellow. I totally understand complaints about pacing with this film. It is plodding. This will not be for everyone. I am a little confused by the demands for more exposition, not only on this forum, but others I've seen. Do we really need the connection between granddaughter and grandfather explained in detail? Do we need exactly how the tower works explained? I don't see why we would. It's not the point of the film to dote upon weird sci-fi anymore than it already does. Hell, imagine if everyone demanded this of Star Wars after the first movie. "Dear Lucas, please explain how hyperdrive and reflector shields work in The Empire Strikes Back. Thanks." It's pointless. Not to mention, it would have made the film even sloooooooooower. They're plot devices. The tower is a metaphor, if it can even be considered that. It's about dreams; Sayuri's actual dreams, and the desires we all have. They want to see the tower in person. It's their one goal. And just like life, we always have these heartfelt desires, and before you know it, it's over. It's a very fleeting feeling. Yet there is that perfect moment when it finally happens, when the rest of the world seems to not matter. That stillness when the plane crashes through the clouds on it's way, as if the whole world has gone silent... so good. Maybe it's just the fan in me speaking, but the last thing I want for this film is Inception like exposition. That would most definitely make it too slow. |
| Once in a while, you come across an Anime that gives you a feeling of satisfaction due to a beautiful story. The Place Promised in Our Early Days is definitely one of those anime. Some parts felt slow and dragged on and the ending felt like it was missing something, but those are the only two points I can say I have against it. 9/10 from me, definitely a worthwhile viewing if you are looking for a movie or something short to watch. |
Will you be able to do.... what must be done? |
| Nice story and beautiful art. The tower looked amazing from the view of the landscape, that airplane look cool too. Characters was fitted in and the many deep thing were included. |
     |
| Honestly, I didn't get this movie, but I liked the Romance in it. ^^ LoL |
"Wait for the signal, and I'll meet you after dark" |
| i didn't like it.. :S though the style was beautiful, i didn't like the rest.. or just that i didn't understand the story? well, now (and i suppose later too..) i will consider this one and a half hours watching this movie a complete was of time.. :-/ |
 |
| The artistry was pretty and the main romance was OK. The more I think about this the more the entire plot is nonsensical though. It's not that it's hard to understand. It just doesn't make sense. The Union is really going to create a tower that replaces the space around it with a parallel universe? That's not practical at all. Why would Grandpa link it to his granddaughter born years after the tower was constructed? Just to screw with her? Questions like that go on and on and the only answer seems to be to add drama. I can overlook a few things like that, but not the entire story. 5/10 |
| The art is really beautiful. It took me almost 2 hours to watch this because I kept pausing and replaying every landscape. The story was decent although I did not feel as emotionally attached as I should be compared to Makoto's other films. One thing I notice is that he likes to focus on the main characters' everyday life by animating transport, school, people on the streets etc to further portray the mundaneness and loneliness his characters feel. I feel this movie didn't do enough of that whereas I can clearly understand the emotions of the couple in Voices of a Distant Star although it was only like what, 30 mins? All in all, a pretty good film. Yay for happy endings. :) |
| Love this movie the only one thing i didn't get is in the end thet get togther but in the beginning he act like she died or somthing?!!?!?! LIEK WTH WHAT HAPPEN?! Overall it a great movie. |
 |
| One trick pony... Not watching anything else this guy makes... Even though it wasn't bad I just can't stand his movies anymore. |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| liked it 8/10 much better than 5 centimers//second , 5 cm is basically this minus the sci-fi with wtf ending. |
| it was amazing, beutiful story ^^ |
 |
| This film was great, I absolutely love the way Shinkai chose to portray the feeling of isolation. Looking at this thread though, I get the feeling that a lot of people missed some of the more subtle plot points. |
 |
| The only constant problem of mine with the works of Shinkai Makoto is that they are not long enough, and while they build up a great atmosphere, the rushing plot takes away some of its value. Here however, the pacing is right, but the plot seemed to promise more than what it actually delivered, a bit disappointing. I'm glad for the happy end though, that's my weakness. 7/10. Ps: Loved the visuals. |
| It was a really great movie. I do admit it started out slow but it was worth it for the other 40mins of the movie. I gave it a 10. Probably one of the most beautiful anime movies I've seen. |
 |
| nice this director is really starting to grow on me. i liked it very much, and i need to check out his other movies :) |
| I really loved 5 Centimeters per second (I gave it a 10/10), but I was really disapointed by that movie. Actually the plot is about nothing, not really making much sense, naive and ... boring. Really, big, big, dissapointment. The idea was good, but the realisation got completely wrong. What a shame. |
| After some thought here is what I believe the plot to be. In a earlier scene he came to relise something in a dream he had when sleeping at the station. He realized that he loved her but the relization slipped away as he awoke people who dreamed may have experienced this before. She relizes in her 'dream' that she loves him but like him it slips away, she left with the sad feeling knowing only that she has lost something important. At the beginning we are shown that he is alone so I take it that the two of them didnt work out. Years later he has come to realize somethings thoughts, feelings and meanings of words. Based on his other works it seems the the characters never get together and the life lesson is meant to be learnt that if you love someone tell them you love them before you lose them. *EDIT but his words at the end would seem to hint at a good ending |
KidNemoMar 17, 2012 12:09 PM
 |
| Interesting movie, I enjoyed it tbh |
 |
| So lovely One of the best anime movies out there with ease. 9/10 |
 |
| Okay, yet another romance anime with sci-fi elements. It was good, but I'm starting to feel fed up with the concept. |
 |
More topics from this board
» I can't believe this movie came out in 2004sometaters - Mar 9, 2023 |
10 |
by sometaters
»»
Mar 13, 2023 5:53 PM |
|
» Not a good thing (spoiler)Someone_OwO - Oct 3, 2022 |
3 |
by kyo_1
»»
Oct 4, 2022 12:43 AM |
|
» Love the Movie? Join the ClubDrinkMyCrumbs - Jul 21, 2009 |
1 |
by Harsh-
»»
Mar 23, 2022 11:12 AM |
|
» The place promised in our early days HELP [SPOILERS]tankker5 - Dec 29, 2014 |
5 |
by Lelewoski
»»
Jan 22, 2022 4:50 PM |
|
» I did some research, and..sniW - Dec 8, 2008 |
2 |
by SolarPioneer
»»
Mar 16, 2019 4:00 AM |