| For example, i gave FMA brotherhood a 10 but I felt the beginning was to rushed compared to the original series. Your opinions? |
| Yes. Things that are flawless: Aria the Origination Tom Brady My waifu Me SB49 |
 |
| I wouldnt because everything has things that could be worked on and can never be "perfect" due to biases |
  |
| No but I'm biased enough to overlook its flaws. |
 |
| Of course because no show is perfect. -Mastergold |
 |
| In truth, ther are no such things as 100% flawless, what we have tho, is animes which flaws are so small that it can be easily overlooked by the person (if the person even find these flaws in the first place)... Now you claim that the beggining of FMA:B was rushed compared to the 2003 one...Well, as for me who didn't watch the original one, there was no such thing as rushed or too slow in FMA:B at any instance, the pacing was perfect at all times...IMO. So not only flaws can be factual, but there are such things as subjective flaws as well, so is literally impossible for something to be flawless...NUFF SAID! |
| You are not your body, you are your brain, the "self" that emerges from within it. |
| Nothing is perfect but as close to perfect as a show can be. |
 |
| Well flaw is a lighter version of mistake. In my opinion my top animes have no mistakes. It can have "minor mistakes" (flaws) like: not showing one characters backstory / predictable fight outcomes / one really annoying side character etc. |
| I gave FMA:B a 10/10 rating even though I wanted to give it 9/10 for all the horrible and forced chibi humor. |
LeBestWeeb said: I don't think any of those is flawless, it's just that you overlook it's flaws/ don't consider them important while others might. No, they're all flawless. I would know! |
|
| We all know that no show is perfect but something on masterpiece level for me would be LOTGH. |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| For me they can, but they just have to be small enough to not effect my enjoyment of the anime itself. |
My Queens  |
| No anime is flawless but because majority of its qualities is good, its flaws can be overlooked. |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| it's honestly hard to truly call something objectively flawless, without consistent and absolute rules for what count as flaws. Anime judgment is far too subjective and even a flawless anime might be boring depending on ones definition of flawless. My reviews are nothing more than the strength of my personal recommendation. |
 Click the banner for anime lists, discussions, reviews, and let's plays! |
| Hmmm, maybe not flawless, but it must be that amazing to someone if they give something a rating of 10. I would give a 10 for an anime that I greatly enjoyed with only a few minor annoyances in it, but I rarely give 10's anyway. |
 |
| I score anything deserve better than 9 a 10. But hey I wanted to have as much 10s as 1s, I guess I need to watch more better animu |
 |
LeBestWeeb said: I don't think anything is flawless. I give a 10 to shows I greatly enjoyed, I will always remember and that had an impact on me and how I feel/see things. ^^ Totally agree. I don't think a 10 has to be perfect. My 10's usually go to shows that impact my view on the world-- shows with a broader influence that stays with me long after I've finished watching. On the other hand, I definitely think there are some phenomenal shows that don't have such a deep or far-reaching meaning. A show can also be a 10 for me if it really succeeds at what it was trying to produce (think: Ouran. Didn't leave me considering my place in the world or anything, but is a masterful shojo spoof that's super enjoyable.) Doesn't have to be absolutely flawless. |
 |
| No, flawless anime don't exist. My 10s do have flaws but I was able to overlook them because the anime was just that good.. |
| Nah, one of the biggest factors in my rating is enjoyment. Most of my 10's have plot holes in them. I don't care. I enjoyed it so so much I gave it a 10 :P |
| No I don't think so, nothing is perfect not even the Wire... |
| Sup... |
| No anime is completely flawless. Some just have smaller/less noticeable flaws. |
 |
| Nothing is flawless, absolutely nothing. |
 |
| Nope, it has its flaws as any other show, but they don't really matter that much and don't drag the show, just some minor things that can be passed, like having a slow start, mediocre animation, art or soundtrack. Though I just give a 10 if the show grows on me a lot. |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| I actually have a minor problem with the score of 10 being synonymous with "masterpiece". With 7 8 and 9 being good, very good and great respectively, it makes more sense if 10 were to be something like "amazing" or "fantastic". Both words are a step beyond "great", but unlike "masterpiece", they don't carry the connotation of perfection. At least, that's how I view the word "masterpiece". |
KrauserV said: Why did you give it a 10 if you didn't want to?I gave FMA:B a 10/10 rating even though I wanted to give it 9/10 for all the horrible and forced chibi humor. |
 |
| If I give it a 10 it's close to being flawless. |
|
| for my list, if it's a 10, it means I really liked it. |
| There is nothing flawless in this world. Same goes for anime |
 |
| Of course, and that's why I'll never rate anything a 10/10 because nothing in this world is flawless. Just my opinion through. |
X105-StrikeJun 26, 2016 10:29 PM
| Most of the time. Either I found it to be amazing in every way or I enjoyed all of it. Those are two different things mind you. |
Wiziliz said: KrauserV said: Why did you give it a 10 if you didn't want to?I gave FMA:B a 10/10 rating even though I wanted to give it 9/10 for all the horrible and forced chibi humor. Very good question, it's because it's really as close to 10 as it'll get, so even if I was really annoyed by the misplaced humor, I still think that giving it a 9/10 would not be justified considering other things I've given 9/10 to. I also gave 10/10 to Shinsekai Yori despite its obvious flaws, because it was extremely moving in a very unique way. |
KrauserV said: I do the same for some anime/manga as well. For example I feel it deserves lower or higher but my feelings of my experience is different.Wiziliz said: Why did you give it a 10 if you didn't want to? Very good question, it's because it's really as close to 10 as it'll get, so even if I was really annoyed by the misplaced humor, I still think that giving it a 9/10 would not be justified considering other things I've given 9/10 to. I also gave 10/10 to Shinsekai Yori despite its obvious flaws, because it was extremely moving in a very unique way. |
| If the standard for 10/10 was flawless, then there is no such thing as a 10/10. Near flawless would be more accurate. |
 |
| No because that would an impossible standard to meet. Nothing is without its flaws, but flaws are subjective so unless it's something catered towards you specifically (or a small enough niche which you fit into) then there's going to be some stuff that you won't enjoy so much, but that isn't exactly a bad thing. Some may say that SEL is flawed because it's hard to understand while others say it's great because it's interesting to figure out and has great rewatch value. These are both opinions and neither is incorrect. I do like to differentiate between my 9s and 10s for reasons so my 10s can't possibly be flawless simply because of the fact that I decided to rate any products of human effort scores of 10/10. |
  |
| I rate anime 10/10 if it entertains me greatly and keeps me interested from the first episode to the last. I'm not a critic, so yeah these anime have flaws but as long as they don't cause much of a hindrance in my enjoyment then I can give it a 10. |
| No, but good enough to overlook the flaws it has almost completely |
 |
| No, nothing is perfect which means everything has flaws. |
| I usually say that the anime that does the most things right gets the higher score. FMAB got a 10 from me because it done so many things right, however it is not flawless. The positives just outweighed the negatives. |
| No anime is flawless so obviously not. In that case you could never give anything a 10, which would effectively make the rating system just a 1-9 scale, which would be stupid |
  |
| No, it isn't flawless, it just means that I enjoyed them the most |
 |
| Pretty damn close. The opening to Mind Game for example was kinda eh but I was so amazed by the rest of it and how it was the most I'd enjoyed any movie in a long time I had to give it a 10. |
| "No, son, you may not have your body pillow at the dinner table!" |
| Nothing is flawless because humans are flawed. A (10) anime is so good that talking about its flaws feels redundant. Why mention the tiny things that don't work when you have an ocean of highlights to analyze? |
| WEAPONS - My blog, for reviews of music, anime, books, and other things |
| No a 10 is not flawless but it is so great that flaws don't matter. |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
zal said: No a 10 is not flawless but it is so great that flaws don't matter. This If 10 is a perfection, then the best any anime can gets is 7.5/10 |
 |
| Flawless? What the hell are you talking about? This is reality, and nothing is ever flawless here. |
| Much like everything else, it is all a matter of preference and opinion. So it's not always right claiming something as a flawless masterpiece, because someone is always gonna disagree and weigh the cons that are overlooked. Though I do say that, but I strongly think that the show closest to a flawless execution is Gurren Lagann. But that's my biased opinion. |
  "ππππ ππ πππ‘ ππππππ πππ ππππππ πππππ." β π°ππππ π»πππ β β π
π½π³π β β π±ππππππππππ’ β |
More topics from this board
» Is there hope for classic super robots?Timeline_man - Yesterday |
7 |
by IKKIsama
»»
5 minutes ago |
|
» Anime Misandry ( 1 2 3 )ColourWheel - Apr 21 |
137 |
by KittenCuddler
»»
7 minutes ago |
|
» Is anime just more honest about it's intent than western media?Spunkert - 2 hours ago |
3 |
by FanofAction
»»
18 minutes ago |
|
» Is there an anime character who looks like you in real life?Alpha_1_Zero - 2 hours ago |
4 |
by Rinrinka
»»
22 minutes ago |
|
» Is it weird to be attracted to anime characters under the age of 18?bluefin2004 - Yesterday |
47 |
by LostSpectre
»»
28 minutes ago |