Is there an anime you can't seem to find flaws in it's enjoyment? Probable spoilers for multiple series.
Ratohnhaketon said: tsudecimo said: SetsukoHara said: Objectively speaking, Mushishi is boring as fuck. Is the reason I don't plan to watch it ever. Yeah it doesn't have titties, stock characters, asspulls, explosions, cute girls or a dense main character. Must be shit. Really, you are going to use that meme sort of argument. It's going to be shit for the lack of interesting concept, episodic nature or any sort of appeal. Same as Aria, and other slow paced type of shows, that scream boring to me. |
 |
tsudecimo said: Ratohnhaketon said: tsudecimo said: SetsukoHara said: Objectively speaking, Mushishi is boring as fuck. Is the reason I don't plan to watch it ever. Yeah it doesn't have titties, stock characters, asspulls, explosions, cute girls or a dense main character. Must be shit. Really, you are going to use that meme sort of argument. It's going to be shit for the lack of interesting concept, episodic nature or any sort of appeal. Same as Aria, and other slow paced type of shows, that scream boring to me. Watch an episode of Mushishi right before bed and see if it makes a difference. |
 |
| Full Metal Alchemist: Brotherhood, Baccano!, and Mahou Shoujo Madoka Magica are all objective masterpieces that I love to fucking death. Maybe Baccano! a little less so considering how short it was and how long it's been since I watched it but whatever. SolBlade said: I honestly thought that the final villain was fine, considering that he was Brotherhood does have some flaws, such as (in my opinion) a lackluster final villain and some convenient moments. Nothing too major except the first point, though, so I can see what you guys mean. This is coming from a guy who gave it a 10, by the way. And even I'm wrong here, who cares about the final villain when you have people like King Bradley anyway? |
☕ Truth be told, I'm quite proud of my house blend. To attain my flavor and fragrance, I use five different types of coffee beans. ☕ |
Korrvo said: Full Metal Alchemist: Brotherhood, Baccano!, and Mahou Shoujo Madoka Magica are all objective masterpieces that I love to fucking death. Maybe Baccano! a little less so considering how short it was and how long it's been since I watched it but whatever. SolBlade said: I honestly thought that the final villain was fine, considering that he was Brotherhood does have some flaws, such as (in my opinion) a lackluster final villain and some convenient moments. Nothing too major except the first point, though, so I can see what you guys mean. This is coming from a guy who gave it a 10, by the way. And even I'm wrong here, who cares about the final villain when you have people like King Bradley anyway? Exactly. If it had been just Father then I would have been disappointed but the other Homunculi (especially Bradley) made up for it. |
|
tsudecimo said: Ratohnhaketon said: tsudecimo said: SetsukoHara said: Objectively speaking, Mushishi is boring as fuck. Is the reason I don't plan to watch it ever. Yeah it doesn't have titties, stock characters, asspulls, explosions, cute girls or a dense main character. Must be shit. Really, you are going to use that meme sort of argument. It's going to be shit for the lack of interesting concept, episodic nature or any sort of appeal. Same as Aria, and other slow paced type of shows, that scream boring to me. -snobby nerd snorting- Really, you are going to spout nonsense about a series you've never seen. It's nothing like Aria, not even in the way it handles its episodic nature. It might not be for you, but objectively speaking anyone who calls it Mushitshit jacks off to otaku pandering quasi-pedo moe girls. |
 |
| my top 5 are flawless so whenever i rewatch them i always enjoy them like i'm watching the shows for the 1st time |
SolBlade said: Watch an episode of Mushishi right before bed and see if it makes a difference. Nah, I have too many things I want to watch and finish in anime/manga/TV shows, like Baccano and Game of Thrones. I have no time to try a series, that doesn't interest me in the slightest. Reading that it's episodic alone make me lose interest. Why before bed though? any special reason? Ratohnhaketon said: -snobby nerd snorting- Really, you are going to spout nonsense about a series you've never seen. It's nothing like Aria, not even in the way it handles its episodic nature. It might not be for you, but objectively speaking anyone who calls it Mushitshit jacks off to otaku pandering quasi-pedo moe girls. I'm not spouting anything, I'm merely stating my expectation of the series, and why it doesn't interest me, and why I feel like it would be boring. That's cool and probably true, I mean similar as in slow pace, seemingly boring and having episodic nature. Same goes for Kino no Tabi. And you used to be one of the few reasonable and level headed people here, huh. |
tsudecimoApr 23, 2014 5:47 PM
|
| I watched 4 episdes of Mushishi, it had a chill atmosphere, was rather poetic... And that's about it, this is nice, but not enough to make me stay for 26 episodes. |
| for me that's Space Brothers x) |
| There are probably legitimate (though small) flaws in Baccano But I have so much fun watching it I can't even see 'em #RoseTint |
tsudecimo said: Ratohnhaketon said: -snobby nerd snorting- Really, you are going to spout nonsense about a series you've never seen. It's nothing like Aria, not even in the way it handles its episodic nature. It might not be for you, but objectively speaking anyone who calls it Mushitshit jacks off to otaku pandering quasi-pedo moe girls. I'm not spouting anything, I'm merely stating my expectation of the series, and why it doesn't interest me, and why I feel like it would be boring. That's cool and probably true, I mean similar as in slow pace, seemingly boring and having episodic nature. Same goes for Kino no Tabi. And you used to be one of the few reasonable and level headed people here, huh. "It's going to be shit" and agreeing with "it's boring as fuck" are hardly speculation, more like forced expectations without experience. I can give you a dozen reasons why I will never watch Boku no Pico, but I will never assume anything I can't say without watching it. Also based on your posts it just seems like you look for ways to shoot down anything in MAL's top 50 so I just have to wonder sometimes. Nice condescending tone, I'm shaking at my loss of reputation. |
|
| -too lazy to quote- I think Mushishi is really good if it's your taste, but it was not particularly my cup of tea. Like, it's a nice show but it didn't have much of an impact on me other than being a "poetic show". SSY definitely has flaws and I feel kind of bad for giving it a perfect score but the plot/world-building/foreshadowing/writing was just so good that I really didn't care if the characters were of less impact. Honestly, there are shows that do characters well and shows that just have a better plot. Take Madoka or Samurai Flamenco which were plot twist-type of shows. Neither had great characters but its really the story that made up for it. And then character shows like Nagi no Asukara and Uchuu Kyoudai which shone even with a not-as-captivating plot as other shows. Sun-Hae said: for me that's Space Brothers x) Same. It's really hard to find flaws in it, except the slow pacing in the latter episodes but otherwise, it's just masterful at everything. |
MayukaApr 23, 2014 6:12 PM
SetsukoHara said: I watched 4 episdes of Mushishi, it had a chill atmosphere, was rather poetic... And that's about it, this is nice, but not enough to make me stay for 26 episodes. Around the middle it did start to feel to me like it didn't need to be 26 episodes, but I still enjoyed it overall. I will say there are a few too many episodes of Ginko giving someone treatment and saying he'll return in a few months then the last 3-5 minutes show the outcome. Though I did appreciate them mixing up stories that ended on both happy and sad notes. |
  |
NarTaco said: FMA: Brotherhood. |
Ratohnhaketon said: tsudecimo said: Ratohnhaketon said: -snobby nerd snorting- Really, you are going to spout nonsense about a series you've never seen. It's nothing like Aria, not even in the way it handles its episodic nature. It might not be for you, but objectively speaking anyone who calls it Mushitshit jacks off to otaku pandering quasi-pedo moe girls. I'm not spouting anything, I'm merely stating my expectation of the series, and why it doesn't interest me, and why I feel like it would be boring. That's cool and probably true, I mean similar as in slow pace, seemingly boring and having episodic nature. Same goes for Kino no Tabi. And you used to be one of the few reasonable and level headed people here, huh. "It's going to be shit" and agreeing with "it's boring as fuck" are hardly speculation, more like forced expectations without experience. I can give you a dozen reasons why I will never watch Boku no Pico, but I will never assume anything I can't say without watching it. Also based on your posts it just seems like you look for ways to shoot down anything in MAL's top 50 so I just have to wonder sometimes. Nice condescending tone, I'm shaking at my loss of reputation. I didn't use ''it going to be shit'' as an actual speculation of the show. I merely replied with it's going to be shit, because you brought it up ''Must be shit''. My speculation and prejudgment was that it was going to be boring, nothing more and nothing less. Setsuko, said it was boring, I replied to express that I feel that show does indeed seem like something that would bore me, hence why I don't want to watch it. But you seem butthurt enough to take that as if I'm actually bashing the show or stating that it's shit and boring without watching it, and then to imply with that meme thing I would find it boring because of those things you listed. Cool, but I deny that assertion. I barely remember that Mushimushi is at the top 50 or top whatever. Sorry, I don't care for MAL's ranking, since they mean practically nothing. |
|
tsudecimo said: SolBlade said: Watch an episode of Mushishi right before bed and see if it makes a difference. Nah, I have too many things I want to watch and finish in anime/manga/TV shows, like Baccano and Game of Thrones. I have no time to try a series, that doesn't interest me in the slightest. Reading that it's episodic alone make me lose interest. Why before bed though? any special reason? Ratohnhaketon said: -snobby nerd snorting- Really, you are going to spout nonsense about a series you've never seen. It's nothing like Aria, not even in the way it handles its episodic nature. It might not be for you, but objectively speaking anyone who calls it Mushitshit jacks off to otaku pandering quasi-pedo moe girls. I'm not spouting anything, I'm merely stating my expectation of the series, and why it doesn't interest me, and why I feel like it would be boring. That's cool and probably true, I mean similar as in slow pace, seemingly boring and having episodic nature. Same goes for Kino no Tabi. And you used to be one of the few reasonable and level headed people here, huh. You have fucking Yojouhan Shinwa Taikei in your favorites. Taikei is episodic from what i've seen so far. I mean if you don't wanna watch it, it's fine but the "i'm not gonna watch it cause it's episodic" is kinda odd, considering The Tatami Galaxy is in your favorites. |
| "A samurai doesn't need a reason to take action. If something needs saving, all you have to do is grab your sword"-Sakata Gintoki |
mayukachan said: Sun-Hae said: for me that's Space Brothers x) Same. It's really hard to find flaws in it, except the slow pacing in the latter episodes but otherwise, it's just masterful at everything. MuttaxSerika: No progress at all! |
SetsukoHara said: i think you got it mixed up with episode 5 which ends with him saying bang, episode 6's ending was a really dumb deus ex machinaJizzyHitler said: Higashi_no_Kaze said: bebop episode 6Well, objectively speaking there are always LOGH and Cowboy Bebop to disprove the existence of flaws. The ending of that episode completely redeemed it. BANG! |
Immahnoob said: Jizzy, I know you have no idea how to argue for shit, tokiyashiro said: Jizzy as you would call yourself because youre a dick The most butthurt award goes to you And clearly you havent watched that many shows thats why you cant determine if a show is unique or not Or maybe you're just a child who likes common stuffs where hero saves the day and guys gets all the girls. Sad taste you have there kid you came up to me in the first place making you look more like a kid who got slapped without me even knowing it and start crying about it to me |
SetsukoHara said: mayukachan said: Sun-Hae said: for me that's Space Brothers x) Same. It's really hard to find flaws in it, except the slow pacing in the latter episodes but otherwise, it's just masterful at everything. MuttaxSerika: No progress at all! True. But, I don't care much about the romance. It's like an bonus in the show. |
za0ldyeck said: Eureka Seven. I don't know man I just love that show. woo another fan, it's possibly my all time favorite. People will be quick to attack Renton though, he seems to make a lot of people mad |
 |
SetsukoHara said: Not achieving his goal is a big one and always fixing the problems mostly by himself(he's like House). Also always saying the right thing at the right time, like randomly.mayukachan said: Sun-Hae said: for me that's Space Brothers x) Same. It's really hard to find flaws in it, except the slow pacing in the latter episodes but otherwise, it's just masterful at everything. MuttaxSerika: No progress at all! |
     Short of the day: Monotonous Purgatory(MAL) ✰Public Domain Club | One Piece Club✰ |
KingKongShrest said: You have fucking Yojouhan Shinwa Taikei in your favorites. Taikei is episodic from what i've seen so far. I mean if you don't wanna watch it, it's fine but the "i'm not gonna watch it cause it's episodic" is kinda odd, considering The Tatami Galaxy is in your favorites. Was it though? the difference here is that Tatami Galaxy, actually has a reason for each episode to be episodic. It has a purpose on the narrative and not merely just a choice for storytelling. It adds more interest and subtlety, rather than taking it. And the final choice for Watashi has more impact due to his ''episodic'' experiences. While on the normal type of episodic, the episodic does harm, without presenting any merits and benefits from it, in my own personal experience. I'm not saying that any episodic anime is boring or will be boring. I just tend to lose interest in them. Especially if they are 20+ episodes like Samurai Champlo for example. It's just not my cup of tea. |
|
mayukachan said: True. But, I don't care much about the romance. It's like an bonus in the show. Really? Damn. Having romance would have gave more motivation to continue from episode one. So, the romance is not prevalent in the series or important? gombo said: za0ldyeck said: Eureka Seven. I don't know man I just love that show. woo another fan, it's possibly my all time favorite. People will be quick to attack Renton though, he seems to make a lot of people mad He is the best character in that show imo. The rest suck imo (except for Ray and Charles obviously). |
|
tsudecimo said: SolBlade said: Watch an episode of Mushishi right before bed and see if it makes a difference. Nah, I have too many things I want to watch and finish in anime/manga/TV shows, like Baccano and Game of Thrones. I have no time to try a series, that doesn't interest me in the slightest. Reading that it's episodic alone make me lose interest. Why before bed though? any special reason? From the little I've seen so far, it's the kind of anime that has a calming effect for restless days, so that was my reason for the suggestion. |
|
JizzyHitler said: SetsukoHara said: i think you got it mixed up with episode 5 which ends with him saying bang, episode 6's ending was a really dumb deus ex machinaJizzyHitler said: Higashi_no_Kaze said: bebop episode 6Well, objectively speaking there are always LOGH and Cowboy Bebop to disprove the existence of flaws. The ending of that episode completely redeemed it. BANG! Episode 6 was with that kid that couldn't age, right? That's the one which ended with Spike saying Bang at the end. IntroverTurtle said: SetsukoHara said: Not achieving his goal is a big one and always fixing the problems mostly by himself(he's like House). Also always saying the right thing at the right time, like randomly.mayukachan said: Sun-Hae said: for me that's Space Brothers x) Same. It's really hard to find flaws in it, except the slow pacing in the latter episodes but otherwise, it's just masterful at everything. MuttaxSerika: No progress at all! I'm speaking about their romance. |
| Out of what I've seen, Madoka Magica for sure. The quality of the writing in that show is just incredible. |
SetsukoHara said: And I'm throwing in some more flaws.IntroverTurtle said: SetsukoHara said: Not achieving his goal is a big one and always fixing the problems mostly by himself(he's like House). Also always saying the right thing at the right time, like randomly.mayukachan said: Sun-Hae said: for me that's Space Brothers x) Same. It's really hard to find flaws in it, except the slow pacing in the latter episodes but otherwise, it's just masterful at everything. MuttaxSerika: No progress at all! I'm speaking about their romance. |
Short of the day: Monotonous Purgatory(MAL) ✰Public Domain Club | One Piece Club✰ |
tsudecimo said: I didn't use ''it going to be shit'' as an actual speculation of the show. I merely replied with it's going to be shit, because you brought it up ''Must be shit''. My speculation and prejudgment was that it was going to be boring, nothing more and nothing less. Setsuko, said it was boring, I replied to express that I feel that show does indeed seem like something that would bore me, hence why I don't want to watch it. But you seem butthurt enough to take that as if I'm actually bashing the show or stating that it's shit and boring without watching it, and then to imply with that meme thing I would find it boring because of those things you listed. Cool, but I deny that assertion. I barely remember that Mushimushi is at the top 50 or top whatever. Sorry, I don't care for MAL's ranking, since they mean practically nothing. I'm going to call you butthurt but look at my essay. Well I'll apologize. It was clearly my fault for not interpreting the full meaning of a poorly articulated one liner. Please forgive me, I am not worthy. |
|
| The funny thing here is that I most likely will enjoy Mushishi. I mean I didn't think I would like Space Dandy at all since it's about Space, is episodic and seems unappealing from the first look. There is just certain anime, that I don't feel like trying them out, even if I might like them (ex: Gibli movies, Rurouni Kenshin, Hotarubi no Mori, Cowboy Bebop, Ghost in the Shell) Baccano! was one of the those, and what do you know, I actually enjoyed it, despite it being seemingly boring, when I first saw it's page. SolBlade said: From the little I've seen so far, it's the kind of anime that has a calming effect for restless days, so that was my reason for the suggestion. I see. Well, calming anime, have no particular effect on me, so I doubt I will appreciate that aspect of it. |
tsudecimoApr 23, 2014 6:39 PM
|
tsudecimo said: mayukachan said: True. But, I don't care much about the romance. It's like an bonus in the show. Really? Damn. Having romance would have gave more motivation to continue from episode one. So, the romance is not prevalent in the series or important? It's mainly him crushing on her. I'm still on episode 88 and nothing big has happened so far. She's in love with her food-kun though. Honestly, the best part of the show is the slice of life, realism factor and how everyone is striving for their dreams. IntroverTurtle said: Not achieving his goal is a big one and always fixing the problems mostly by himself(he's like House). Also always saying the right thing at the right time, like randomly. Well, they haven't reached their goals yet cus the anime ended LOL. I really don't mind if it drags out a bit longer, but not Detective Conan length obviously. Yeah, I guess he fixes his own issues most of the time, but it's an anime =p But yeah, those are legitimate flaws, although not very important to me. |
IntroverTurtle said: SetsukoHara said: And I'm throwing in some more flaws.IntroverTurtle said: SetsukoHara said: Not achieving his goal is a big one and always fixing the problems mostly by himself(he's like House). Also always saying the right thing at the right time, like randomly.mayukachan said: Sun-Hae said: for me that's Space Brothers x) Same. It's really hard to find flaws in it, except the slow pacing in the latter episodes but otherwise, it's just masterful at everything. MuttaxSerika: No progress at all! I'm speaking about their romance. Ah OK. I didn't understand, my bad. Yeah, I kinda agree, |
SetsukoHara said: it was the one with the kid but he never said bang, the episode ends with the kid just openly taking a shot that kills him, episode 5 is when spike flies out the church and says bang before blowing it upJizzyHitler said: SetsukoHara said: i think you got it mixed up with episode 5 which ends with him saying bang, episode 6's ending was a really dumb deus ex machinaJizzyHitler said: Higashi_no_Kaze said: bebop episode 6Well, objectively speaking there are always LOGH and Cowboy Bebop to disprove the existence of flaws. The ending of that episode completely redeemed it. BANG! Episode 6 was with that kid that couldn't age, right? That's the one which ended with Spike saying Bang at the end. |
Immahnoob said: Jizzy, I know you have no idea how to argue for shit, tokiyashiro said: Jizzy as you would call yourself because youre a dick The most butthurt award goes to you And clearly you havent watched that many shows thats why you cant determine if a show is unique or not Or maybe you're just a child who likes common stuffs where hero saves the day and guys gets all the girls. Sad taste you have there kid you came up to me in the first place making you look more like a kid who got slapped without me even knowing it and start crying about it to me |
mayukachan said: Same thing with the romance. IntroverTurtle said: Not achieving his goal is a big one and always fixing the problems mostly by himself(he's like House). Also always saying the right thing at the right time, like randomly. Well, they haven't reached their goals yet cus the anime ended LOL. I really don't mind if it drags out a bit longer, but not Detective Conan length obviously. Yeah, I guess he fixes his own issues most of the time, but it's an anime =p But yeah, those are legitimate flaws, although not very important to me. I don't think it will ever get that long if and when it comes back. Maybe 200 max. |
Short of the day: Monotonous Purgatory(MAL) ✰Public Domain Club | One Piece Club✰ |
| My most favorite anime is LoGH but it does have a few minor flaws(like the annoying narrator). The most flawless series for me is Natsume Youjinchou(all 4 seasons). There is not one thing that I dislike about it. I don't really like slow paced shows that much but for some reason I really love Natsume. |
 |
Tarextherex said: "Find flaws in it's enjoyment" Wtf is that supposed to mean? You speak as if "enjoyment" is a trait that comes directly from the anime but it's not, it's just the wrong word used when you want to talk about your overall impressions of a show. Story, characters, art, sound, all of those common reviewing criteria add up into enjoyment, it's not a separate criteria by itself. ^this. People who say 'anime X is best because its enjoyable/sad/made me shed rivers' aren't making much of a concrete statement regarding its quality. |
Kagami_Hiiragi said: Idc if you think its weird, I have a life and friends and an income of money. |
gombo said: za0ldyeck said: Eureka Seven. I don't know man I just love that show. woo another fan, it's possibly my all time favorite. People will be quick to attack Renton though, he seems to make a lot of people mad Yeah , I hardly remember everything in that show but boy I remember how annoying Renton's ass was and how much I hated him couldn't stand him. Lol I'm hoping someones says SAO ......lol the sh!t that would ensue . The aftermath of saying it alone would be hilarious to see |
Wintovisky said: For me no, unfortunately. Lately all anime that I watch always manage to annoy me somehow (but in different degrees, of course). I love how this is so accurate. Whatever anime that DOESN'T fit this criteria is at least 9.5/10, 8's annoy me a bit |
| Chobits When I got into Anime (Actually knowing what it was) it was my first Anime and I fell in love with it! I even read the Manga ^.^ Hamtaro was my first Anime though when I was younger :3 And Chobits was recommended to me from someone on Neopets :3 And with that, My love for Ecchi was born :D |
 |
kirAth-shiAue said: My most favorite anime is LoGH but it does have a few minor flaws(like the annoying narrator). The most flawless series for me is Natsume Youjinchou(all 4 seasons). There is not one thing that I dislike about it. I don't really like slow paced shows that much but for some reason I really love Natsume. And wow, a lot of people shitting on other people's opinion and favorite anime. So lame. A perfect example of a flawless anime is ef a tale of memories. I almost gave it a 10 but its not my favorite so I gave it a 9. |
rodacApr 23, 2014 10:30 PM
| Legend of the Galactic Heroes? |
|
ladyhaman said: And wow, a lot of people shitting on other people's opinion and favorite anime. So natural. ^fixed. That's the law everyone abides in MAL |
Kagami_Hiiragi said: Idc if you think its weird, I have a life and friends and an income of money. |
| In terms of enjoyment, probably FMA:B. I do find Mushishi the closest thing to perfection but then again I can't marathon it without dozing off |
| Welcome to the NHK from a technical standpoint, but not it's entertainment value. I personally love it, though. |
 |
| Azumanga Daioh. As far as comedy goes, I've yet to see a comedy in anime that comes close to AzuDaioh's mastery of comedic timing, other than maybe Nichijou and Minami-ke (who imo are still a distant second although Minami-ke's 3rd season is pretty impressive). The only real flaw I think AzuDaioh has is that its format is repetitive (i.e. festivals and summer beachhouse every 3-5 episodes), but the humor and the characters themselves are excellent. Gintama is much better at parody (and is extremely funny in its own right) but AzuDaioh takes the cake as far as pure comedic timing goes. |
| closest I've got is Revolutionary Girl Utena, not saying that it doesn't have it's issues but it's one of the very few anime whose faults didn't really impede my enjoyment. Hell I sat through all the goddamn elevator scenes since I couldn't get enough of ZETTAI UNMEI MOKUSHIROKU |
gedataApr 27, 2014 9:22 AM
 |
More topics from this board
» World Masterpiece Theater are hidden gems.Zhenro - Yesterday |
25 |
by Lucifrost
»»
2 minutes ago |
|
» What exactly are the perks of having waifu?SgtBateMan - 5 hours ago |
18 |
by MasterTasuke
»»
2 minutes ago |
|
» How much anime is too muchST63LTH - 3 hours ago |
21 |
by Yonahim_Zz
»»
3 minutes ago |
|
» Does seinen anime focus on other things besides ultra manliness?fallout45 - Yesterday |
40 |
by JoeChip
»»
3 minutes ago |
|
» How would you describe modern mainstream anime?RobertBobert - 3 hours ago |
31 |
by RobertBobert
»»
5 minutes ago |