Ranked #2335

Yumekui Merry

I'm just gonna get straight to the point...

Story 4/10: The concept is very unique, but also kind of weird, even freakish. These kids get some dream demon to become their "vessel" or something (for some reason) and if that dream demon dies, the kid becomes a dreamless husk who feels as though they won't amount to anything or some shit like that. It's comparable to Black Rock Shooter, where people's emotions are personified in an alternate universe and if that personification dies, the kid's emotions are wiped clean. Dream Eater Merry's plot is certainly intriguing, but how it was portrayed is the problem. There were a couple questions left unanswered. Especially that damn cliffhanger ending. They hinted at a second season but never got one. Anyways, another unanswered question is of the part where Merry was in that one swordsman chick's dream world and she started magically tearing it apart while holding some keys. That scene was incomprehensible to me because it never explained what that even was. I guess that gives her nickname meaning though: "Dream Eater." But it hardly touched on that whatsoever. It kinda just HAPPENED and that's it, and then was never mentioned again. Another question is why Merry was stuck in the real world? That's what made the ending a cliffhanger. They were talking about how they're going to find a way to get her back there, but then it ended and I was dumbfounded that it was over, just like that. O.o... Oh yeah, and I just wanna talk about the cheesy win against the antagonist. You know how they beat her? They "believed in themselves." Yeah, not kidding. And that emotionless chick with the gun did all the frickin' work! She's the only one who really did anything. Just... Why did I watch this?

Oh and, always a beach episode. Always. >.>

Art 9/10: Pretty fuckin' good artstyle. Merry has a nice loli-like body, and you know how I like them lolis. ;D Oh, you don't. Because you don't know me. But yeah, I like lolis. And flatties. Don't judge me. But yeah the artstyle was actually pretty nice.

Sound 8/10: The music's forgettable, but I loved the English cast for the show. Hilary Haag, Brittney Karbowski and Vic Mignogna are some of my favorites.

Character 7/10: Decent character development, I guess. Although a lot of side characters in the show only had one moment of screen time. But for the main characters, it was pretty good development. Oh, and the supposed "main antagonist" is one of those people that only had one moment of screen time, by the way.
But yeah, I honestly loved Merry, she's a great character. Her obsession for donuts, her somewhat tsundere appeal, her cuteness, etc. I liked the emotionless girl, Chizuru, too. She had to cast away her emotions and wasn't allowed to interact with others because of her dream demon (I forget the exact reason, I haven't seen the show in a while), and then suddenly she starts caring for a new friend and she basically destroys her own mind to save her friend's life. I think Merry's adorableness and Chizuru's impacting devotion are some of the only things I actually liked about this anime.

Enjoyment 5/10: It was average at best. Not all that fond of the show, but it was okay.

Overall 5/10: Meh. read more

They say that variety is the spice of life, but if that's true, then why is there such a lack of it in anime and manga? Part of the problem stems from the fact that there seems to be a certain number of themes that can be considered the "bread and butter" of the industry, but the subject of dreams is surprisingly not one of them. This is more than a little odd as Eastern folklore is littered with stories about dreams, and one has to wonder why such a rich and varied theme tends to be ignored.

So what is a dream?

There are those who believe they are nothing more than one's subconscious mind doing a bit of "housecleaning", whilst others claim that there is a supernatural element that can be defined and translated to provide a message to an individual. Many people believe that dreams are simply flights of fancy that occur while one is asleep, and almost everyone has used the term in reference to personal goals. The common misconception though, is that while they are often weird, and maybe a little unnerving (this includes some real life ambitions), they are also harmless. What people tend to forget is that a nightmare is also a dream.

But what happens when dreams and reality merge, and just how important are they to a person?

Based on the manga byYoshitaka Ushiki, Yumekui Merry (Dream Eater Merry), tells the story of Fujiwara Yumeji, a high school student who has the ability to see auras around people that allow him to predict what kind of dream they will have. Unfortunately his own dreams involve him being chased by armed cats, but all of that changes when he meets the mysterious Merry Nightmare.

The story features several interesting dream related elements that offer some food for thought, and while there are a few rather lacklustre attempts at comedy, the series manages to retain a reasonably serious atmosphere. That said, the cliche manner in which the two leads meet does a good job of negating the generally forthright approach to character introductions, and shattering the illusion of seriousness. Granted the two have to meet in some way, but did it really have to be that?

In addition to this the plot contains several typically shounen themes that act as a foundation for development of the story, which is a bit of a shame as while there are some explanations on offer about certain events, there are also a few glaring omissions that can leave viewers wondering how everything fits together. Yumekui Merry also suffers from the fact that all of the action takes place in a particular area, and generally involves people in a particular age range, which immediately raises several questions that are never answered.

The design poses an interesting dichotomy as on the one hand the series adopts a very typical formula with regards to characters and environs, yet on the other there is a degree of imagination and innovation on display, in particular where supernatural characters and otherworldly realms are concerned. While this is obviously a purposeful move to highlight the difference between reality and dreams, J.C. Staff haven't really made the effort to break new ground (and seem overly addicted to Merry's navel), and because of this Yumekui Merry retains a humdrum quality that makes it difficult to take seriously.

As for the animation itself, the series does achieve a very high standard, especially during a few action set pieces, but there's no real consistency to the quality so these high points are more the exception than the norm. There are many scenes where things could have been timed better and movements could have been sharper, so it's somewhat annoying to find that the effort hasn't been made to raise the bar in any way.

The opening sequence features the typical character introduction montage blended with some action that never appears in the anime proper, all against the J-rock/pop stylings of Daydream Syndrome by Fujiwara Marina. That said, the ending theme attempts to keep things simple with a boppy little J-pop track (Dreams And Hopes And The Me Of Tomorrow by Sakura Ayane), set against an image of Merry that is gradually being revealed from underneath flower petals.

Unfortunately one of the biggest problem areas is the background music as there are a number of tracks that don't seem to mesh well with the on screen action or appear to be completely unnecessary. In addition to this there are also issues with the levels, and all too often whatever track is playing will lay the foundations of a veritable cacophony when large audio effects kick in or characters begin speaking loudly. Unfortunately these issues could have been easily rectified during the recording process, so one has to wonder if there has been a poorly executed attempt to enhance the atmosphere of particular scenes, or simply a continuous oversight during production.

That said, there is some decent performances from Okamoto Nobuhito (Fujiwara Yumji), and Sakura Ayane (Merry Nightmare), but this is only in comparison to the rest of the cast. A large portion of the acting is nothing more than lines by rote which can be attributed to a script that's more than a tad juvenile, and this truly is a shame as the cast are a talented bunch for the most part.

Yumekui Merry features a variety of personalities that one might find in any number of highschool anime, yet while there is a certain amount of depth applied to several prominent characters, this never really feels like true development. It seems as though the producers have decided to follow a method that attempts to define the characters rather than make them grow, which is unfortunate as this approach can only really yield good results when there is a decent amount of characterisation from the start.

Sadly, there isn't.

Aside from the generic looks and routine personas, it's only Yumeji who appears to have any sort of detail at the start of the story, and part of that stems from the manner of his introduction into the tale. While one might argue that Merry's introduction also constitutes definition of sorts, nothing substantial is done with her until the latter half of the series. Most of the characters are apportioned a certain amount of screen time to tell a highly abbreviated version of their personal history or future goals, but there's very little emotion involved in this and the story can sometimes feel like more of a writing exercise than anything else.

Even with the flaws there's still something to this anime that manages to raise it from mediocrity, and that's the interesting ideas it can spark about dreams and how important they are to a person. While the explanations of cause and effect are a bit on the simplistic side, they can also be somewhat original and unusual, and this helps to retain the viewer's interest in the story. In addition to this the main thrust of the narrative is well conceived, even if the execution is lacking, and the generally serious tone of the story helps to offset the fact that Yumekui Merry can be a chore from time to time.

One thing that should be pointed out is that the series has a very clear "kids versus adults" mentality that seems more a convenience for its own sake than an outright declaration that everyone over a certain age is "evil", which makes it pretty obvious who the target audience is for this show (as if the highschool wasn't already a dead giveaway). The ending also lacks a degree of substance due to its slightly hurried nature, and many of the concepts in Yumekui Merry aren't fully realised, but given that the manga is ongoing it will be interesting to see where things go from here. While the series barely manages to hold it's own against the likes of Yume Tsukai (which isn't really all that impressive to be honest), there's an earnestness that appears from time to time that really should have been more prominent as it would have offset the lethargic productions values. read more