DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
| Shaft's Fate/Extra > A-1's Fate/Apocrypha, /shitposting. I've played Fate/Extra and Fate/Extra CCC in my PSP and Fate/Extella through Steam. The Extra's universe is very different than others Fates, if Ufotable or any other studio animate Extra it will be very strange because they need to do a animation very different for got the Extra's atmosfere. For Extra we need a studio who makes the people watching say "wtf?" and try to use abstracts scenarios (like the scenarios used in all 3 games). |
Hardgore_LasagnaFeb 11, 2018 8:52 AM
 |
frenze12 said: So i guess the rule that says the last/most recent heroic spirits can only be from the last 150 years because in modern days it's to difficult to become a heroic spirit because humanity advanced to much with it's technology (and a simple phonecall can save the world and shit according to Nasu) doesn't apply anymore? I mean like seriously, Neil Armstrong? That better be a counter guardian like EMIYA... I think this show took Fate/Grand Order x Himuro's World to seriously lol. Nasu being Nasu again with his writing. Neil was a Servant in the original Extra.So long before himuro and FGO.Also that rule isnt absolute. |
frenze12 said: You realize that I just told you that Neil was in the Original Extra right.ssjokg said: Neil was a Servant in the original Extra.So long before himuro and FGO.Also that rule isnt absolute. You do realise that there a literal interview with the man himself saying it right? Also >Nasu making ironclad rules lol |
frenze12 said: ssjokg said: You realize that I just told you that Neil was in the Original Extra right. Also >Nasu making ironclad rules lol So what are you trying to tell? That Nasu changes his mind when he likes it? Like how this Rin > 3 berserker servants is canon now? Trying to undermine his credibility as a writer? No I am saying that no rule Nasu ever made cant be broken. In FSN he did that all the time. Also the rules that apply in Extraverse dont apply in FSN. Also we dont know what Rin did or if she even IS Rin. |
frenze12 said: ssjokg said: No I am saying that no rule Nasu ever made cant be broken. In FSN he did that all the time. Also the rules that apply in Extraverse dont apply in FSN. Also we dont know what Rin did or if she even IS Rin. About the whole "rules from show x don't apply to show y thing" "Heroic Spirits are also recorded and stored as data recorded from humanity's history within the Moon Cell, but they are identical to those within the Throne." Basically meaning according to this statement Mr. Armstrong also exist in F/SN as a possible servant (With the Throne existing outside time and shit) Except that I am not talking about the Throne/Moon Cell.I am talking about the abilities of characters.Spiritron Hackers are way more OP because they can interfere with the environment while magi in FSN etc are quite limited. The rule about modern Servants is that they cant become Heroic Spirits because anybody can replicate their skills. Except that back when Armstrong went to the moon this wasnt exactly something that anyone could do. Humans cant fight Servants. Servants cant survive without a Master/Grail. Shirou cant trace divine items. Were those rules broken?Yes.Was there a legit explanation?Yes. Really I dont understand how you never realized how flexible the rules Nasu created are when you seem to be a fan of the source material. |
| I don´t get why so many people are hating on SHAFT, personally I think they are doing a great job with the visuals, the main problem in my opinion is the story. |
 |
| I can't believe I was hyped for this show. Not quite ready to drop it, but I really feel Shaft are wasting their time on this. I feel nothing towards any of the characters, can't even bring myself to like Rin or hate Shinji as much as I would in any other Fate. The Rider character was a paper cutout, and an ugly one at that. The visual design in general reeks of mid-2000s. Can I have an Apocrypha-type comeback, please? |
 |
| That was really anticlimatic. This episode was so confusing, for the most part didn't understand what was happening, didn't play any of the games and i hope that it isn't the case, and it felt like it was rushed. The fight felt underwhelming ... I think Shaft's Rin looks so weird. |
 |
JudoJD said: Nah Shaft is obviously messing up . Only shaft fanboys from monogatari can't see how bad this is She wasn't just shitting on this show though. She said that every show they make is bad. |
 |
| I hate how Hakuno is such emotionless edge lord in this show, like in the game you are faced with sorrow and hesitations everytime you have to beat one of the masters and after the Alice stuff he was REALLY annoyed with this whole system and heck he even cries for his enemies later wtf with this theme Hakuno have no emotions except hate? you serious here? I know this is supposedly anime original but to alter it to the point where the MC is totally different character than how he is in the game is just ridiculous |
| Fight scene was pretty eh, but that's not the reason I watch Fate anyway. Didn't feel anything for Rider's death, though I don't think that was the point of the skirmish at all. That kiss was definitely something. Also, a Shinji that isn't a punchable dick is not Shinji. Having had no exposure to the original source material, I thought this episode was pretty great overall. |
| I need sleep. |
Here we go, better. Personally tho, even if its not that great, im still more interested in this than apocrypha and F/SN which is nice. |
STOP SLEEPING ON ODD TAXI |
DatRandomDude said: Here we go, better. Personally tho, even if its not that great, im still more interested in this than apocrypha and F/SN which is nice. I don't really think Zero needed that much of a comeback tbh. I was more referencing Apocrypha being absolutely unwatchable, awful and sleep-inducing in its first half, and its later improvement to the level of being basically okay. |
|
Specimen021 said: Oh ok, that way. I misunderstood, my bad. DatRandomDude said: Here we go, better. Personally tho, even if its not that great, im still more interested in this than apocrypha and F/SN which is nice. I don't really think Zero needed that much of a comeback tbh. I was more referencing Apocrypha being absolutely unwatchable, awful and sleep-inducing in its first half, and its later improvement to the level of being basically okay. I dunno, i dropped apo after a couple of episode lol |
| STOP SLEEPING ON ODD TAXI |
| Shaft is doing great job honestly. To be able to fix an anoying character like Shinji and make him somewhat deep is no small feat at all. Also I love the music in this show. |
| Great episode! Great, we're now 3 episodes in and haters will stop dropping this which will make these threads a lot better. So Shinji is not a complete dog in this series? Well played Nasu, I actually think deep down he likes Shinji. Umu stole the show once again, she approved of the kiss! |
 |
kronos7 said: Shaft is doing great job honestly. To be able to fix an anoying character like Shinji and make him somewhat deep is no small feat at all. Also I love the music in this show. Every studio can do that if they want to and nasu wrote the script no shaft It`s amusing how the fate fags keep defending every type moon series |
kronos7 said: Shaft is doing great job honestly. To be able to fix an anoying character like Shinji and make him somewhat deep is no small feat at all. Also I love the music in this show. Nasu wrote this, not Shaft, and he already did that in Extra and CCC. Shaft did nothing but animate. |
 |
| All these long posts :/ I just wanna say they made Red Saber's breasts too big. |
  |
LightHunt said: Thanks Shaft for butchering Nasu script into a one cour, and the worst is they said to him to "go wild" and "to not care about the budget' but they don't even have the budget for a 2 cour anime. was it ever stated they're only going to do 1 cour? Wasn't there going to be a second broadcast called "Illustrious Geocentrism" to be aired? |
LightHunt said: Theorder14 said: was it ever stated they're only going to do 1 cour? Wasn't there going to be a second broadcast called "Illustrious Geocentrism" to be aired? It's juste stated to be a special broadcast and since the story is rushed as hell... eh, they're not adapting the game so i wouldn't say that the story is "rushed". Sure, we didn't get to know Drake but there's clearly some time-loop shenanigans going on here. It's possible the second "arc" will explore another loop. |
Theorder14Feb 11, 2018 2:33 PM
JudoJD said: Nayout said: -Nasu confirms that the story is original -People complain that they are not faithful to the game - ????????????? Well, in your original comment you complain mostly about the animation... After people try to take seriously the ratings of this page when have comments like these Animation is part of execution and I also have to agree Shaft's scenes (especially the fights) are poorly choreographed and animated Lol you just ended up agreeing with her for blaming the studio Unless now you wanna say Nasu animated the thing The only problem is the fight between Drake and Nero, but everything else is perfectly explained in this post https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1705980&show=50#msg54025344 Devil_Slayer said: wtf with this theme Hakuno have no emotions except hate? you serious here? I know this is supposedly anime original but to alter it to the point where the MC is totally different character than how he is in the game is just ridiculous Does it really surprise you? Lenka is nothing like Yuu in the God Eater anime Sorey in the second season of Zestiria changes a lot compared to the game and I can continue to give examples |
 |
Red Saber has large breasts. She's not a pettanko like blue Saber. |
| UmU/10 .would Umu again |
| EL PSY KONGROO!!! |
frenze12 said: DarknessSerpent said: I don´t get why so many people are hating on SHAFT, personally I think they are doing a great job with the visuals, the main problem in my opinion is the story. True, same thing went for Fate Apo, nagging about design and animation while the biggest flaw was it's character presentation and storytelling lol. At least Apocrypha was somewhat understandable. In the end perhaps no Gilgamesh, no likey from me. I needed my weekly dose of “mongrels”, maybe some other time, fingers crossed. |
 |
redlight21 said: kronos7 said: Shaft is doing great job honestly. To be able to fix an anoying character like Shinji and make him somewhat deep is no small feat at all. Also I love the music in this show. Every studio can do that if they want to and nasu wrote the script no shaft It`s amusing how the fate fags keep defending every type moon series Soo I am a fag, because I've written a positive opinion about the series I enjoy? I am obviously not talking just about writing, but overall directing of scenes with him / the choice of music / the way his character was presented etc. There's way more behind successful character then just writing behind him. |
in extella, her breasts weren't that big |
|
| That battle ended a lot less excitingly than I thought. There wasn't a real struggle of any sort--just Nero getting shot, getting back up, and one-shotting Drake. Shame since I thought it was going to be an amazing fight. |
Official data: Height: 150cm Weight: 42kg Three sizes: B83/W56/H82 Umu! |
| |
| Damn I was so hyped when Drake appeared, at least they could give her one more episode :[ |
| Perhaps I didn't pay well enough attention, but did all the other living masters who gave up die in that flood? Or were there none of them in the first place and the world was just the NPCs we've seen? |
| Jaywalker. |
 Now a Rin myster comes to place. |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Fate/Extra: Last Encore Episode 10 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )Stark700 - Mar 31, 2018 |
119 |
by bl3nk_anime
»»
Apr 23, 12:55 PM |
|
Poll: » Fate/Extra Last Encore Episode 2 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )Stark700 - Feb 3, 2018 |
221 |
by CrazyButNot4U
»»
Apr 14, 6:10 PM |
|
Poll: » Fate/Extra: Last Encore Episode 9 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - Mar 24, 2018 |
63 |
by SomeDudeOverHere
»»
Apr 12, 10:40 PM |
|
Poll: » Fate/Extra Last Encore Episode 5 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - Feb 24, 2018 |
72 |
by Selleri_UmU
»»
Dec 30, 2023 6:40 PM |
|
Poll: » Fate/Extra: Last Encore Episode 8 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - Mar 17, 2018 |
60 |
by Apreggi
»»
Dec 12, 2023 8:03 AM |