Report fluffycow17's Profile

Thanks

thank youuu \^o^/

Thank you!

Ahh, you meant in that way, I see..>:P>
I think you should do it if you want to proofread the content and make sure its user friendly and appropriate but at the same time, it would be hard for you to keep up, and as you say, might serve as a barrier so at first, just ask people if they can send you their reviews after making them, before they post them, and if you OK it, then they can post it.

Oh, I wasn't feeling pressured about it, just stating my point, lol..^^3
That's true. Personally, I like reading review for small and unpopular series but I'm probably part of the minority when it comes to doing this, lol..x'D> I feel like you've made a valid point, and I would be curious to see how things go from here on out.

Regarding your questions in the last paragraph, I believe that making a thread where people can post their reviews is a good idea, but you would still need to moderate some things (proper netiquette, stopping posts that might lead to a fight within the club, etc.) but the parts you moderate can be minor, if you feel like delegating some works to other admins and officers. As for my part, I leave club greetings to my officers for the manga club I run since that one is public, but I will do everything myself for my GIFt club since it's a private club and I mostly operate things on my own. I'll let the club comments alone as long as I don't see a fight in it, so there's not much to moderate (there was maybe one time in my manga club where I had to stop a fight and ban a member, but these things happen solemnly/very rarely). You can choose the model you see fit/working better for yourself though, no need to feel like you need to use one of the methods I talked about. It's your club and your choices to make, after all, but I hope it helps give you a direction as to what you need to do.

It depends on the number of manga readers in the club and the availability and interest in writing reviews among those people. I'll be fairly busy for a while so it would be hard for me to write reviews but I could come and check from time to time if you need the help getting set up and such.

From what I could see from the manga votes, a lot of users don't read the manga they vote so I don't know how successful it would be. Granted, I do read a lot of manga myself, but I'm only one person so I don't know how much that would go for.

Yo! I sent you a message in your PMs. Please respond when you can.

Hey, Happy New Year! Thanks for the recommendations, I have already finished one of them and am eager to start the next.

Fluffycow? You can have this since you like cows:

Thank you so much!!!! :)

Thank you!!

Hey so quick note regarding the Knuckleheads; The poll results history and Hall of Fame do not display the number of IDKs for Perfect Blue
https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=2040774
https://myanimelist.net/stacks/9708
It should say 1 IDK
https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=2115131

Nothing, just from the outside it looked like “non-shoujo anime with shoujo vibes”. Perhaps clarification of the description somehow alleviated the situation.

But if you define shoujo and josei as "anime for a female audience", then more than half of these shows are like that. For example, My Happy Marriage is based on a female-focused LN and has a shoujo manga adaptation. Free is an all-male show for girls (like Hibike, but that's another conversation), Nozaki-kun is essentially KonoSuba in the world of shoujo manga, Romantic Killer was even licensed in the west under the Shoujo Beat brand for a girls' manga. etc.