Who am I? I'm just a guy who likes anime. Why, you ask? For its creativity and imagination. Japans got some amazing ideas, but some others.. not so much...
My rating scale:
10: The best. Masterpieces. Flawless! 10s I will only give to anime that are almost totally perfect and/or extremely enjoyable (to me at least).
9: Very enjoyable, well done, does everything right and brings something new to the table.
8: Really good, but not quite amazing.
7: Good. A 7 is enjoyable to watch, but something or somethings were big enough to hold it back from a higher score. I'm happy I watched it, but It wasn't anything spectacular.
6-1: I will almost never rate something this low. Why? Because I don't usually watch something that deserve's a a low rating. I usually look into what I watch, and make sure its something I would enjoy (unless I'm caught up in something currently airing) In the time's I do give a rating this low, it's because something started out really good, but fell flat and disappointed.
Note, the enjoyment factor.
Now sometimes how much I enjoy a show can bump it up a point or two. Maybe it was a soundtrack I really enjoyed, maybe it was one of my favorite genre's or themes, maybe it was romance done perfectly, or maybe it just hit a sweet spot that makes me look past it's flaws or love it even more. In any case, I found it awesome even if a lot of other people don't. For instance, Guilty Crown. Sure it's plot disappoints in the end, but the style of action just hit a sweet spot for me and the sound track was AMAZING. I couldn't help but bumping it from 6 or lower to a 7, even though it might not totally deserve it.
Seriously, why have you all even been to my profile?