Imouto wa Kanojo ni Dekinai noni

Edit

What would you like to edit?

SynopsisBackgroundAlternative TitlesPictureChapters/VolumesPublishing DatesRelationsTypeExternal Links  

6.3/10


The sweet glory and fulfillment an incest little sister manga provides is like no other, however, they are usually done horribly and awkwardly, which is what this manga has done. To be blunt, there’s just not much of engagement in each chapter due to the lack of character introduction and personality, realism, and a unique plot.

To be brief, the plot is the same old formula of flirtatious interactions between the mc and fmc while there is also some insignificant significant characters that are “introduced” to drive the forbidden romance or provide some cruddy humor.

The character introduction is abysmal; in the first panel, my reaction ... was “Oh, it’s gonna be THAT type of manga.” In other words, the author self-inserts characters here and there without further elaboration, and said characters are shallow, hollow, and awkward, even the main cast.

There’s some wholesome moments here and there, but the manga doesn’t do anything innovative nor is it well-written, which creates a lack on tension, immersion, and engagement, causing it to be pretty average as far as mangas go. Oh, the art is also garbage, so I guess that doesn’t help.


Reading Rankings (Portnoy inspired + A Huang-Teizan Original)
10 - God’s penmanship
9 - Must-read. Drop everything else.
8 - Instant bookmark
7 - Entertaining
6 - Good to pass time
5 - Why are you reading this?
4 - Bad.
3 - Typical garbage.
2 - My head hurts.
1 - Retirement is a thought.
0 - “Did they even give you a story?!”

I love trash romcoms. I love incest in manga. This ain't it.

The pacing is all over the place, the characters are ?????, the writing is a trainwreck, in some chapters I had to doublecheck to see if I missed any chapters.
This manga was so bad it took my review-virginity just so that I can shit on it. And let me tell you, I've LOVED some objectively bad mangas, like, just look at my manga list. This doesn't even qualify for guilty-pleasure.

Spoilers (this is practically the entire story so far):



MC and his sister are very close. They love eachother a lot. They even kiss.
Their parents tell ... them that they're divorcing, and that they're actually step-siblings.
(now known)Step-sister moves away to countryside.
MC gets together with a classmate that was a friend of both his and his step-sister's (with the the step-sister knowing about this relationship and agreeing to it as long as it's what the MC wants) to cheer the MC up
MC has sex with his girlfriend, while still worrying about his step-sister.
He drives a scooter for 7 hours straight to the countryside to bring his step-sister home. They kiss a lot.
MC's dad sees the MC's girlfriend and we find out that it's actually the MC's blood-related half-sister, born from an affair of his dad.
Girlfriend actually knew about this but hid it from the MC cuz she's in love with him.
Now comes the thing that made me drop it: The MC's colleague from his part-time job offers him to have sex with her to cheer him up. He refuses. And then in the very same chapter, a friend of the step-sister who the MC had been tutoring asks him to have sex with her and gets on top of him. What??

Yeah. this is a contender for being one of the craziest, incomplete, lust filled dummies I have seen by far. The top for me is still OREIMO but this is creeping in very close to it.

I spent an entire hour sharply reading up to chapter 18 and I refuse to bookmark!

The story is becoming twisted beyond belief and turning into a naughty fantasy world with no care for serious things. You got these other girls being curious about sex but jesus christ, the flow of events is skipping too many steps?

Too many plot holes and the fact he MC was willingly being overly intimate with ... the sister despite not knowing she was un-related yet is wild. But the "GF" getting into off screen intercourse with the MC knowing they are blood related is just crazy and struck as SWEET HOME ALABAMA. It's clear to me the characters here all have distorted ideas of common sense and it's not a good influence to any audience.

I literally just watched a MC drive all night for his sister fueled by his naive love.

Why can't japanese people understand intercourse between blood related people cannot happen or the children will suffer from severe genetic deformities?