[CLOSED] 👻 Trick-or-Treat 2024 Challenge

@Jaikeis

Thanks, I rearranged a lot of things and end up having to remove 2 anime to matches the rules and watched 2 new one also. Please note that my last watched anime finished on Dec 16 on my timezone (UTC+7). Hope this works, thanks.

👻 Username: vemz21
👻 Link to your completed anime list: https://myanimelist.net/animelist/vemz21?status=2

🔮 Link to your Sign-Up post: MSG_LINK

🍭 Baskets Completed: 10

💬 Comments: great event, happy to watch more.

👻 Username: Jeon
👻 Link to your completed anime list: https://myanimelist.net/animelist/Jeon?status=2

🔮 Link to your Sign-Up post: Link

🍭 Baskets Completed: 10

💬 Comments:

👻 Username: penguin9541
👻 Link to your completed anime list: https://myanimelist.net/animelist/penguin9541?status=2

🔮 Link to your Sign-Up post: Link

🍭 Baskets Completed: 10

💬 Comments: (optional)

👻 Username: HDAsylum
👻 Link to your completed anime list: https://myanimelist.net/animelist/HDAsylum?status=2

🔮 Link to your Sign-Up post: Link

🍭 Baskets Completed: 3

💬 Comments: (optional)

@Sokratis Only one invalid item:

❌ Shirotan: Shirotan ga Ippai! is rated G, not PG.

Let me know again when you've made your fixes, thanks!

@Jaikeis

Have fixed it, I end up have to reduce 1 basket since I don't have any anime with that rating watched during the challenge period. Watching another anime will end up invalidate the last basket by having 2 items of the same category. Thanks, though

@Sokratis Resolved, though you should update your end date to December 14 to match your last anime now.

@penguin9541

Please mark all eleven anime you started before the challenge period.

Let me know when you've made your fixes, thanks!

@KatjieKat

❌ The Adventure tag was removed from Jigoku Sensei Nube (Movie) on 2024-10-05, which is before you watched it.
❌ No character is stated for Marshmallow #05.
❌ No character is stated for Sour Candy #05.

Let me know when you've made your fixes, thanks!

@Canaan Looks good, but please change your challenge start date to October 1 as it is the same for everyone regardless of when your first anime was started.

👻 Username: juvialockser /// floral_sacrifice
👻 Link to your completed anime list: https://myanimelist.net/animelist/floral_sacrifice?status=2

🔮 Link to your Sign-Up post: Link

🍭 Baskets Completed: 9

💬 Comments: had a lot of fun with this challenge, hope we get more that are like it!

@HDAsylum

Please mark all three anime you started before the challenge period.

Let me know when you've made your fixes, thanks!

👻 Username: Marzipan-Goose
👻 Link to your completed anime list: https://myanimelist.net/animelist/Marzipan-Goose?status=2

🔮 Link to your Sign-Up post: Link

🍭 Baskets Completed: 9

💬 Comments: Fun but stressed cause of all the other challenges. But still fun! Disappointed I couldn't get the 10th :/

@vemz21

❌ Mnemosyne: Mnemosyne no Musume-tachi is rated R+, not R.

Let me know when you've made your fixes, thanks!

@Jaikeis opps sry wrong input,
btw DONE fixing, thx admin ^_^

@Marzipan-Goose
- Tsurezure Children does not have an end date marked. Provide episode history for this one.
- Sengoku Kitan Youtouden Movie, Wakaokami wa Shougakusei! Movie, Cardcaptor Sakura Movie 2: Fuuin Sareta Card, Amrita no Kyouen, and X/1999 are not on your list as watched at all. Luckily for you, I went to your list and saw that progress was marked as 1/1 for all of them (they are all movies). The dates of last edited match what you wrote in the challenge too. So just add in the dates to match.
- Hakumei to Mikochi: Neji to Bed to Irori to Bakuchi is not tagged anthropomorphic.

Reply back with the episode history and when the other changes have been made.

@HimeCrycho

Everything should be done now. Hakumei to Mikochi: Neji to Bed to Irori to Bakuchi replaced with special candy #2 and watched The Chocolate Panic Picture Show

Thank you!

👻 Username: ImagineBrkr
👻 Link to your completed anime list: https://myanimelist.net/animelist/ImagineBrkr?status=2

🔮 Link to your Sign-Up post: Link

🍭 Baskets Completed: 10

💬 Comments: (optional)

@floral_sacrifice
Fairy Tail OVA, Fairy Tail OVA (2016), and Shikanoko Nokonoko Koshitantan are all previously started anime. Please mark them as such and reply back letting me know!

@Marzipan-Goose
Sorry, but as I stated in the dm I sent as a reply to yours, nothing could be watched after the event ended on the 15th. So watching Chocolate Panic Picture show today doesn't work. You'll have to swap candies around to find one that works for something you did watch during the challenge period. If you can't, we'll need you to remove that item and just go with 9 baskets. I'd love for you to be able to get full credit though so look carefully to see if anything can be moved around!

@HimeCrycho

Okay I was happily surprised that I was able to do 5 switches and things should now be fixed! I miss understood the Extra Candies functionality

I'm sorry if this is confusing but these are the switches I made:
2, 3 (Ginga Tetsudou no Yoru) going to 9, 5 (Hakumei to Mikochi: Neji to Bed to Irori to Bakuchi)
2, 4 (Stand By Me Doraemon) going to 2, 3
7, 2 (Cardcaptor Sakura Movie 2: Fuuin Sareta Card) going to 2, 4
8, 3 (X/1999) going to 7, 2
8, 3 filled with Hakumei to Mikochi: Neji to Bed to Irori to Bakuchi

@Marzipan-Goose
Baskets 8, 9, and 10 need to be reworked. As per the rules, each candy needs to be from a different category per basket. (Meaning you can't have two chocolate's together in the same basket as an example.)

@HimeCrycho

Ok I think I got it back to normal now only using 9 baskets 1-8, and 10. Let me know if I need to change the turn-in to 9 baskets

@Marzipan-Goose
Yes, please erase the unused items and mark basket ten as basket nine. Then we should be good to go!

👻 Username: acestrawbs
👻 Link to your completed anime list: https://myanimelist.net/animelist/acestrawbs?status=2

🔮 Link to your Sign-Up post: Link

🍭 Baskets Completed: 10

💬 Comments: Fun Challenge would have preferred slightly longer to complete it maybe 3 full months to complete it, as I felt like I had to rush and watch a bunch of shorter stuff.

Other than that denoting Previously started feels unneeded.

But overall a really enjoyable challenge and quite a tough one in the time frame, hopefully will be run again.

👻 Username: MegaManBK7
👻 Link to your completed anime list: https://myanimelist.net/animelist/MegaManBK7?status=2

🔮 Link to your Sign-Up post: Link

🍭 Baskets Completed: 10

💬 Comments: Thanks for hosting the events as always. Good job making it hard to complete afk, I had to try real hard to get two baskets done w/ backfilled shows before actually planning ahead.

@MegaManBK7
- Mizu no Kotoba is too short.
- Oneechan ga Kita, Gogo no Kouchou: Junai Mellow yori, and Hello Kitty no Yappari Mama ga Suki are all missing from your list completely.
- As per the rules.. Each basket holds five (5) candies, with the restriction that each one must be a different type of candy.
　— This means that for each empty block, you can only have five (5) items AND each one needs to be from a different category. (Meaning you can't have two chocolate's together in the same basket as an example. You def can't have all five together.)

Please reply back when all of this has been fixed! Keep in mind that the baskets must have been watched in order when you are re-arranging your candies.

@acestrawbs
- You have Undead Unluck marked as previously started when it was watched fully during the challenge period.
- The link for "Ani ni Tsukeru Kusuri wa Nai! 4" is broken.

Please reply back when these things have been fixed!

@MegaManBK7
- Mizu no Kotoba is too short.
- Oneechan ga Kita, Gogo no Kouchou: Junai Mellow yori, and Hello Kitty no Yappari Mama ga Suki are all missing from your list completely.
- As per the rules.. Each basket holds five (5) candies, with the restriction that each one must be a different type of candy.
　— This means that for each empty block, you can only have five (5) items AND each one needs to be from a different category. (Meaning you can't have two chocolate's together in the same basket as an example. You def can't have all five together.)

Please reply back when all of this has been fixed! Keep in mind that the baskets must have been watched in order when you are re-arranging your candies.

👻 Username: Dumasop
👻 Link to your completed anime list: https://myanimelist.net/animelist/Dumasop?status=2

🔮 Link to your Sign-Up post: Link

🍭 Baskets Completed: 10 4

💬 Comments: (optional)



Downgraded (info)

@Dumasop
Please provide episode watch history for:
Ai Shoujo Pollyanna Story
Aishite Knight
Ashita no Nadja
Tom Sawyer no Bouken
Shin Taketori Monogatari: 1000-nen Joou
Anime Sanjuushi
Otonari ni Ginga
Tokimeki Memorial: Only Love
The Big O
Golden Kamuy 4th Season
Otogi Juushi Akazukin

@HimeCrycho
I don't mark episodes while watching, just start/end dates for the whole title.

@Dumasop
That's fine. Can you go ahead and share the screenshots anyway since it will show when the shows were marked as completed?

@Dumasop yeah... that's not quite okay. I will only accept basket 7 to basket 10 and invalidate the rest. This decision cannot be contested.

The reason is that there does not appear to be any reasonable explanation as to why (despite being able to consistently mark series as completed) you would add multiple series as completed on a single day while dating them backwards. It would be one thing for them to be short series or one episode ones, but it is highly suspicious for them to be longer ones. This matter isn't related just to the series you were questioned about.

Furthermore, taking in consideration that you had been previously warned about the way you approach adding series to your list and the seemingly continued habits that do not align with the purpose of our club, this instance along with the previous one will be formalized as an Official Warning. More information will be provided on a private message.

👻 Username: Yterbium
👻 Link to your completed anime list: https://myanimelist.net/animelist/Yterbium?status=2

🔮 Link to your Sign-Up post: Link

🍭 Baskets Completed: 10

@Yterbium Everything is good, but please remove the unused candies/anime from your challenge post.

👻 Username: Papa_Dragon
👻 Link to your completed anime list: https://myanimelist.net/animelist/Papa_Dragon?status=2

🔮 Link to your Sign-Up post: Link

🍭 Baskets Completed: 6

💬 Comments: (optional)

👻 Username: RenxKentaro
👻 Link to your completed anime list: https://myanimelist.net/animelist/RenxKentaro?status=2

🔮 Link to your Sign-Up post: Link

🍭 Baskets Completed: 3

💬 Comments: (optional)