Forum Settings
Forums
[Oshi No Ko]
Available on Manga Store
New
Pages (2) « 1 [2]
Jul 1, 2023 11:31 PM
Offline
May 2023
26
WHAaaaAT THE HECK
Jul 1, 2023 11:31 PM
Offline
May 2023
26
Cloud2x said:
ideally they wouldn't go into that territory. since they know it's so controversial and they have a peak manga and anime on their hands I don't think they would throw it all away like that. Plus I don't think a show like this would tip toe around the ethics of something like that anyway. they would likely and hopefully take It into a direction of them finding a new bond and working together for vengeance and whatnot

Yeah that would be horrible for the ahow
Jul 2, 2023 1:07 AM
Offline
Feb 2022
25
Birb_addict said:
i highly doubt aquaxruby will ever happen but it is a possibility. of it does happen, ill probably drop the show

I really hope it happens
Jul 2, 2023 1:10 AM

Offline
Aug 2021
394
_Doofenshmirtz_ said:
Physically it's incest, Mentally it's Pedophilia.
Perfect combination
Define the word 'Pedophilia'
Jul 2, 2023 3:48 AM
Offline
Apr 2023
2
Kritika2410_ said:
Okay so since the fast few days I have been coming around a lot of Hoshino siblings incest memes which made me curious 
 
I genuinely want to know, how do you guys feel about it? From my perspective I see Sarina as a girl with innocent crush and immense trust on him viewing him as her savior when no one was there for her whereas Goro as a compassionate and kind doctor who cared about her...

Though their motives and personalities changed a little their feelings didn't change in the least they still viewed each other the same as they did in their previous life... so I don't really life these kind of memes, I find them pretty disgusting but what about you guys? how do you view their relationship? and most importantly what do you think about these memes on a serious note


i agree, i dont these memes either
Jul 2, 2023 3:49 AM
Offline
Apr 2023
2
Kritika2410_ said:
Okay so since the fast few days I have been coming around a lot of Hoshino siblings incest memes which made me curious 
 
I genuinely want to know, how do you guys feel about it? From my perspective I see Sarina as a girl with innocent crush and immense trust on him viewing him as her savior when no one was there for her whereas Goro as a compassionate and kind doctor who cared about her...

Though their motives and personalities changed a little their feelings didn't change in the least they still viewed each other the same as they did in their previous life... so I don't really life these kind of memes, I find them pretty disgusting but what about you guys? how do you view their relationship? and most importantly what do you think about these memes on a serious note


i agree, i don't like these memes either
Jul 2, 2023 3:51 AM

Offline
Dec 2021
21
how is this topic still going on ?!? 
Jul 2, 2023 4:19 AM

Offline
Jul 2012
2721
_Doofenshmirtz_ said:
Physically it's incest, Mentally it's Pedophilia.
Perfect combination
For the latter, it basically composes most ships coming from the story, the only good ship truly is Aqua x Therapy lol
Jul 2, 2023 4:21 AM

Offline
Jul 2012
2721
Skullzastro said:
how is this topic still going on ?!? 
Because the leaks for the next chapter are something to be seen to be believed LOL

Jul 2, 2023 5:19 AM
Offline
Jul 2018
561871
I mean, it is anime/manga. If Usagi Drop could drop all pretenses of the parental relationship between the two leads to have them fuck, I'd be mighty cautious of this happening in Oshi No Ko too. 

I mean, I probably would not mind as much given that it is sibling on sibling incest versus parental figure on their ward, but it is still so weird and offputting. That being said, I do not mind Ruby actually falling in love with Aqua in light of these revelations. I just do not think Aqua should return her affections given his own development, at least romantically.
removed-userJul 2, 2023 5:29 AM
Jul 2, 2023 11:09 AM

Offline
Oct 2021
1075
That's Japanese anime for you. That's normal in Japanese anime. They're been normalizing it since the inception of ecchi, harem, reverse harem, etc. anime since the early 1980s. 😳

Demon Slayer is being watched by 5-year old to 10-year old Japanese kids. In the West, teenagers or the young adult audience watch Demon Slayer (battle-oriented Shōnen manga).

When it comes to Oshi no Ko, Japanese teens and young adults voraciously consume this kind of media because the series is eye-catching, it's an eye-candy series (anime and manga), the music is a banger, the animation transitions beautifully on the screen, and merchandise such as anime/manga figurines are also helping making the series more commercially successful.

In the West, Westerners don't propagate anime. Westerners don't promote incest, grooming, violence in kids' cartoons broadcasted on television. Westerners don't consume anime as much as the East (20% audience versus 80% audience). Incest, grooming, suicide, self-harm, death, idol-recruiting, kidnapping, etc. are themes you rarely see in Western adult cartoons but often see in Eastern shows (anime) targeting a young demographic.

Also, in the East, violence themes have been incorporated in cartoons (anime) targeting the teens, young adults, and kids since the early 1980s, 1990s, 2000s (Dragon Ball, One Piece, Naruto, Tokyo Ghoul, etc.).
marquinti2Jul 2, 2023 11:14 AM


-------------------------
Marianne

~Effort, Fortitude, and Tenacity
Jul 2, 2023 12:26 PM
Offline
Mar 2020
3
After seeing the new chapter "got damn"
ImperialLumaJul 18, 2023 12:18 PM
Jul 2, 2023 3:26 PM

Offline
Nov 2022
42
This thread is so entertaining to read through. Aqua x Ruby is a gift that keeps on giving.
"Shinji, crank that Soulja Boy."


Jul 2, 2023 5:12 PM
Offline
May 2023
10
if this happen I'm instantly dropping the show and the manga
Jul 2, 2023 11:37 PM
Offline
Jul 2023
3
In the 2.5D play arc something important was stated by the two mangaka's which I believe are somewhat of an expression of Akasaka's own feelings as a mangaka : that the thing they hated most when third parties interpreted their work was when they would make the characters do something which the characters the mangaka created ,their "babies", would never do. 

In other words I believe Akasaka has a strong attachment to the integrity of his characters. 

With that said, it would be completely out of character for Aqua to even humor the idea of incest. 

Akasaka wouldn't be portraying the characters he created if this ever went down the incest route.
Jul 2, 2023 11:50 PM

Offline
Apr 2012
24582
It seems to me that this is a classic case of people making more drama in advance than the plot itself, which has just marked the beginning of any development of this topic. Reminds me of people who have already turned Ruby into a horny bisexual just because she was impressed with the pink haired girl's big breasts.
Jul 3, 2023 6:51 AM
Offline
Mar 2023
12
In the first place, the anime is about a really serious topic even though there are indeed many comedic elements...and its a good combination. But I HIGHLY DOUBT by which I mean there isn't ANY POSSIBILITY of something like that happening. Frankly speaking, I don't think the Aka even had that idea anywhere in his mind andddd Aqua isn't out there for bitvhes, he's out there for revenge!!!
Jul 3, 2023 7:08 AM
Offline
Mar 2023
12
Sakkoa said:
Vanitas_ceara said:
In the first place, the anime is about a really serious topic 

This is the manga forum though.

This is the ANIME forum. And even so...it doesn't matter...
Jul 3, 2023 1:51 PM
Offline
Jun 2020
1033
Chapter 123 spoilers came out.
Jul 3, 2023 5:25 PM

Offline
Apr 2020
3937
This Thead or a variation of it probably already exists a hundred times over, on MaL. Keep it coming, boys. Feed on this fetish.
Jul 3, 2023 7:50 PM

Offline
Jul 2016
420
I haven't posted in a very long time so I came back just to say this:

If they go the incest route, it would 100%, no, 1000% ruin this series for me. It would be a shame. S1 was amazing. I'm looking forward to S2. If I know that the end goal is incest, I'll drop it. I haven't read the manga so I won't read much around here. Those "incest" memes have become so rampant that it caught my attention. 

Jul 3, 2023 9:39 PM

Offline
Sep 2011
16394
Funny that this topic is being discussed since the ships of Kana and Akane are sunk down.


I am a Ruby fan and I do ship Aqua x Ruby but I never really thought of this manga will go towards incest. Heck, in my point of view, I don't see Aqua x Ruby as incestual relationship because of their previous lives but that might be considered as pedophilia although everything here is beside the point.

Back to topic, as long as Aqua has common sense, the incest route is not going to happen. Sure Ruby, according to chapter 123, she will do her best to get Aqua's attention as she has undying love for him but to Aqua/Gorou, he never thought of Sarina/Ruby as love interest and that is something everyone should have known and until now(This recent chapter 123), his feelings for Sarina/Ruby are still the same.

Unless the author will do something about it and will try to touch the incest subject but I am not sure how that will fit to the series. All I can see is that Ruby will only have one-sided love and Aqua prefers to be alone and not having any romantic interest towards anyone.

Or, everything will lead to here:
TennoujiJul 3, 2023 10:45 PM


Jul 4, 2023 4:02 AM
Offline
Nov 2018
198
Kritika2410_ said:
Okay so since the fast few days I have been coming around a lot of Hoshino siblings incest memes which made me curious 
 
I genuinely want to know, how do you guys feel about it? From my perspective I see Sarina as a girl with innocent crush and immense trust on him viewing him as her savior when no one was there for her whereas Goro as a compassionate and kind doctor who cared about her...

Though their motives and personalities changed a little their feelings didn't change in the least they still viewed each other the same as they did in their previous life... so I don't really life these kind of memes, I find them pretty disgusting but what about you guys? how do you view their relationship? and most importantly what do you think about these memes on a serious note


its to be expected , they just dont want things happening other than their way.


incest is bad , this situation is messed up.


what can happen next?

they kill their father and resolve all relationship drama

one of them gets killed , and surviving one kills father and paired with either of their "Tools"

both are killed , others get sucked up in the revenge and somehow survive , idolizing twins while moving on with life

see outcomes are messed up too, Genes are of that murderer so kids are of similar mentality , outcome could be outrageous somewhere along taboo and romeo juliet
themes with either of girls

Every manga, literature has some level of cringe or reality based ending. Forrest gump to AOT.

accept it for its cringe or keep on coping 🗿
Jul 4, 2023 10:02 AM
Offline
Mar 2023
22
it was half funny for like the first 5 posts after that it just became disgusting and I don't want this to be cannon
Jul 5, 2023 1:08 AM
Offline
Aug 2022
30
Azriel-chan said:
Like there is hentai of them you dont have to imagen

Oh man, how disgusting has the world become! 😢

I can never forgive the person who drew that, so for that, I NEED the sauce so I can report it and remove it from the face of the internet forever.

Please help me in this journey of washing it off of the face of the Earth, and for that, I need your help 🙏
Jul 5, 2023 4:06 AM

Offline
Mar 2021
1501
We gonna go full yosuga no sora route baby
Lets fuckin gooooooo
Jul 6, 2023 11:07 AM
Offline
Jul 2022
70
Polvo_Aranha said:
Chapter 123 spoilers came out.
The despair, I felt I tell you, was immeasurable... My Jaw dropped so hard that it actually hurt for a while
Jul 6, 2023 11:11 AM
Offline
Jul 2022
70
Za_Panda said:
We gonna go full yosuga no sora route baby
Lets fuckin gooooooo
PLEASE I honestly didn't wanna see this image... way to ruin someone's night man
Jul 8, 2023 3:36 AM
Offline
Aug 2021
513
zanemazza said:
It is incest.

It’s also pedophilia. He’s lived for over 30 years, plus another 17 meaning he’s lived for at least 47 years. She is 17 years old. She is a child.


Yes, it is incest.

In the UK and I believe Japan however Age of Consent in 16 no it's not pedophilia. You also can't add his previous age without adding her previous age which would make both adults and within age ranges of other famous people. Doesn't make it right and it shouldn't happen but it's not pedophilia.
Jul 8, 2023 6:24 AM

Offline
Aug 2013
306
The author is clearly rooting for Aqua X Kana at the end, the rest is just to tease the fans and I like how the mangaka is good at it
Jul 8, 2023 9:42 AM
Offline
Nov 2018
198
Kritika2410_ said:
Za_Panda said:
We gonna go full yosuga no sora route baby
Lets fuckin gooooooo
PLEASE I honestly didn't wanna see this image... way to ruin someone's night man

it would be funny , killing ships.

just like isayama lol

both shippers would be full of cringe if that happens, lets face it no ship is winning here

some one is getting killed and characters move on after that with either mc pairing with present options which would be dramatic imo

romanticizing this is just stupid , they both need therapy or possibly a year or two in rehab
Jul 8, 2023 9:59 AM

Offline
Jul 2022
357
The incest bait got me to read the manga again to see the dumpster fire. I was pleasantly surprised and ended up liking some of the recent 40 or so chapters that I caught up on.

I'll be honest, as much as they pushed for it in Chapter 123, Aqua x Ruby is going to be a one-sided relationship with Ruby wanting it to happen. Aqua isn't seeking a relationship, he is just a vengeful spirit.
Jul 9, 2023 3:06 AM
Offline
Jul 2022
70
Dulonkk said:
The incest bait got me to read the manga again to see the dumpster fire. I was pleasantly surprised and ended up liking some of the recent 40 or so chapters that I caught up on.

I'll be honest, as much as they pushed for it in Chapter 123, Aqua x Ruby is going to be a one-sided relationship with Ruby wanting it to happen. Aqua isn't seeking a relationship, he is just a vengeful spirit.
I think so too as Aqua never saw Sarina "that" way I cannot see a future where he would want her.. anyway let's see what the next chapter reveals
Jul 10, 2023 10:45 PM
Offline
Jul 2018
561871
PeripheralVision said:
I mean, it is anime/manga. If Usagi Drop could drop all pretenses of the parental relationship between the two leads to have them fuck, I'd be mighty cautious of this happening in Oshi No Ko too. 

I mean, I probably would not mind as much given that it is sibling on sibling incest versus parental figure on their ward, but it is still so weird and offputting. That being said, I do not mind Ruby actually falling in love with Aqua in light of these revelations. I just do not think Aqua should return her affections given his own development, at least romantically.

Yes same. I don't mind the "incest", since we know they are reincarnated from former lives, but Aqua already lived a full life as a doctor and is mentally much older than Ruby (besides the fact he mainly wants revenge). That's the thing that doesn't sit right with me.
Jul 12, 2023 10:56 AM
Offline
Jul 2023
4
zanemazza said:
It is incest. They have lived together and have been siblings for 17 years. I don’t think it matters how they interacted in their past life, in the present it’s messed up.
It’s also pedophilia. He’s lived for over 30 years, plus another 17 meaning he’s lived for at least 47 years. She is 17 years old. She is a child. There is no excuse for it, if they were to be a couple, it would be disgusting.
People shipping them should take a good hard look in the mirror and reconsider their morals.
Who cares. Incest or not. I don't understand this "taboo". If you not having kids with each other then who cares? And dont be hypocrite there is no pedophilia here, she died at what age? 10? 12? 17+10=27. She mentally is at least 27 years old. Physically they are both 17 year old teenagers, nearly adult. So much drama..Western people are too puritan for their own good.

SinderlokJul 12, 2023 11:13 AM
Jul 12, 2023 11:10 AM
Offline
Jul 2023
4
Also this heavily supports theory that this story will continue with incest route. It depends on whether it will have a happy ending or a sad one, with another reincarnation.  Tsukuyomi's and Amaterasu's story didnt end well in the end. Tsukuyomi's anger and violent actions were the reason of their sad end.
Jul 13, 2023 10:42 AM

Offline
Mar 2018
710
Anyone who's expecting incest to happen should double check their reading comprehension and maybe limit(entirely) their exposure to ************ content.


I literally can't describe how much this stupidity gets on my nerves because of the "fans" who don't understand what is going on in this story. This is the first time I came across such a good series that suffers so much because of it's wide appeal since Chainsaw Man, where people were/are shipping Denji with Makima (Bruh!!) and even then it wasn't as bad as this.

I feel like those who expect incest didn't pay enough attention while those who are wanting it are ignoring everything this series is trying to tell/explore....simply desiring to see an escapist fantasy...

Seriously...We're talking about RUBY AND AQUA....!! What character arc they have? What development to they had with each other and other characters? What are the implications on a thematic level?
I'm sorry BUT "that would be a bad move" and the thematic commentary is that lies can become the truth...so what are the lies regarding their character and their relationship? 


Aqua's entire character arc revolves around him getting over his desire for revenge that causes him stress/panic attacks/suffering and doesn't let him fully embrace his new identity as Aquamarine Hoshino, Amemiya Goro being just a shadow a this point that torments him with guilt...It was explicitly said "the bridge between me and Aqua Hoshino is disappearing" and during the time he thought his father is dead he actually made significant progress, so anything that would make him act as Amemiya Goro would not only negate his development but it would be a thematic contradiction because the fact that he is Aqua Hoshino, Ai's SON is the lie that needs to become the truth in order for his character arc to be completed....

"If this sixteen-year-old idol would come to date you, would you accept?" It almost feels like Ai's image in Ruby is giving him the opportunity to live the fantasy that he had as a fan of Ai when he was Goro but because he isn't the same person anymore(literally), he will instead showcase his development by rejecting anything remotely romantic from "Ai"...Not obvious at all that they will become BROTHERS and closer to each other after this situation gets resolved....It's almost as if the lie that they are brother and sister will become the truth as well by addressing the lie....SERIOUSLY!! Why isn't this obvious?

Also, Ruby's character arc implies her getting over her childhood crush on Amemiya Goro and moving on in the same way Aqua's character arc also implies him getting over his crush that he had on Ai as Goro, which is why she had the same reaction after she found out that he was murdered, wanting revenge, like Aqua when he discovered that Ai's murderer had an accomplice. It's an obvious parallel to make her going through something similar and make them get closer to each other as a result...

And don't even let me start to talk about Aqua "You violated a city ordinance for taking a minor to your place past 11:00 PM." Hoshino's relationships with other characters, especially Akane and Kana...but also Taishi and Myako...
During the entire series up until this point, any form of genuine romance took place within the love triangle, so the story to take a sudden turn in another direction without any build-up would result in food for backlash, creating one of the rare occasions where the shippers might be in the right in their eventual complaints...(I personally find shipping wars really annoying but not nearly as distaseful and awful...)
Let's go backward!!....I remember a conversation on a bridge that Aqua had with someone and that someone said something (just) apparently out of nowhere at the end of that chapter...And THAT was another moment where the story gave the audience an ultimatum, but ending in a conflict that got resolved in the literally next chapter.....almost like ch.123-124 potentially? 
(Akane is seriously the most misunderstood out of all the characters...). 



So no, the incest is not happening!! It would make no sense for the story at every level and it would result in too much backlash, making a lot of readers to potentially drop the series...
(Disclaimer: This is how things are right now. The story can go in another direction with the characters BUT ONLY WITH THE PROPER DEVELOPMENT...)

Btw...This being the case, the memes shouldn't be taken seriously!!
Jul 13, 2023 2:36 PM
Offline
Aug 2020
472
Za_Panda said:
We gonna go full yosuga no sora route baby
Lets fuckin gooooooo

PLEASE I honestly wanted see this image... way to make someone's night man
Pages (2) « 1 [2]

More topics from this board

Poll: » "Oshi no Ko" Chapter 131 Discussion

ARK-13 - Nov 6, 2023

36 by Dogstideta »»
Sep 30, 10:27 PM

Poll: » Favorite Arc in the manga

SkyAcrosssTheBri - Sep 20

5 by HoangNguyen2107 »»
Sep 21, 1:35 PM

Poll: » "Oshi no Ko" Chapter 166 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

ARK-13 - Nov 6, 2024

257 by Confused_100 »»
Sep 12, 8:46 AM

Poll: » "Oshi no Ko" Chapter 165 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )

ARK-13 - Oct 30, 2024

106 by zerokarasu »»
Sep 11, 3:25 PM

» Is the ending that bad? ( 1 2 3 )

HoangNguyen2107 - Nov 8, 2024

100 by zerokarasu »»
Sep 11, 8:29 AM
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login