Marxist said: Overrated: Chaos;Head No. It's rating is, imo, the most accurate rating on the site (except, maybe, Mars of Destruction). It's quite low due to the crappiness of the last half (or whatever point where they start better explaining the plot), but not incredibly so due to the excellence of the first few episodes. |
Confucius say man who stand on toilet is high on pot. |
Jarez0 said: Elilu said: Jarez0 said: Elilu said: Overrated: Neon Gensis Evangelion, The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya, Death Note, Ah! My Goddess Underrated: Paradise Kiss, Hellsing, Kuroshitsuji, Samurai Champloo lots lots lots lol You should read the Hellsing manga, so you'd see why many people (including me) dislike Hellsing anime.. I think the most overrated anime's are Clannad /as, TTGL, Haruhi suzumiya. None of them are bad, but i just dont see any reason why they r so damn popular. Actually I have read it. More than once in fact. And the OVA follows much more closely than the series - if that's what you are getting at. But I find it a show that is beautiful as a stand alone as well. I have long since given up on anime mirroring manga, the same as movies mirroring books. Most often you have to view them as two separate entities that happen to have the same characters. I dont really mind about it being totally different from the manga. I jut think its damn boring and ugly etc. Alucard and the musics are the only reason i gave it even so much as three points out of ten. lol To each his own. The music /is/ very lovely though. |
     Please don’t say “You are lazy,” because I’m actually crazy. |
| How about underrated characters? wow..I know this is off topic but, this guy is friggen epic and such an original creation: |
 |
Elilu said: Jarez0 said: Elilu said: Overrated: Neon Gensis Evangelion, The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya, Death Note, Ah! My Goddess Underrated: Paradise Kiss, Hellsing, Kuroshitsuji, Samurai Champloo lots lots lots lol You should read the Hellsing manga, so you'd see why many people (including me) dislike Hellsing anime.. I think the most overrated anime's are Clannad /as, TTGL, Haruhi suzumiya. None of them are bad, but i just dont see any reason why they r so damn popular. Actually I have read it. More than once in fact. And the OVA follows much more closely than the series - if that's what you are getting at. But I find it a show that is beautiful as a stand alone as well. I have long since given up on anime mirroring manga, the same as movies mirroring books. Most often you have to view them as two separate entities that happen to have the same characters. Agreed on the Clannad though. And TTGL is mecha which usually is enough to gain it a large fanbase. lol I disagree. I marked down shows when rating for cutting out important canon. |
| Right now I think Bakemonogatari is overrated. It's already in the top 10 on ANN. XD |
Mimi_Taylor said: lolwut? At least it's ranked more reasonably here (112).Right now I think Bakemonogatari is overrated. It's already in the top 10 on ANN. XD |
| Confucius say man who stand on toilet is high on pot. |
| Underrated: Katekyo Hitman Reborn |
| Underrated: Doruko-chan |
| Listen to my music ;) https://soundcloud.com/in-contrast |
Mimi_Taylor said: That's because hardly anyone votes on ANN. You should see the top manga - there's a manga ranked 25 or something with 5 votes. Lol.Right now I think Bakemonogatari is overrated. It's already in the top 10 on ANN. XD |
| Overrated: Lucky Star, Seto no Hanayome, Bleach, Naruto, Air, Aria. Underrated: Itazura Na Kiss, Ayakashi, Midori No Hibi. |
| Bakemonogatari went to 1st place in russian tops o.o Actualy I'm hightly surprised by it's popularity. Tsundere power? |
 Outside of a dog, a book is a man's best friend. Inside of a dog, it's too dark to read. |
| Since we are talking about ver and underrated animes Naruto with Disney edits is UNDERRATED |
 |
AlexisSolitaire said: Underrated: Katekyo Hitman Reborn |
|
| Overrated: Elfen Lied, NGE, FF:AC, Naruto, Bleach, One Piece, School Days, Shakugan no Shana, Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya, Lucky Star [...] Underrated: Mouryou no Hako, Gintama, Shigurui |
| Infinite Ryvius is veeerry underrated. |
BigSimo said: I've been meaning to try that sometime. But the art reminds me of SEED, so I keep putting it off :/Infinite Ryvius is veeerry underrated. |
Baman said: From what I've seen of SEED (some short scenes from it here and there), its art is more bishounen-y if you know what I mean, whereas Ryvius is kind of a cross between the 90s look and a little bit of SEED design influence (both shows have the same character designer).BigSimo said: I've been meaning to try that sometime. But the art reminds me of SEED, so I keep putting it off :/Infinite Ryvius is veeerry underrated. But yeah, definitely give it a shot. It's really...different. Fairly unconventional from what I've seen. I'm in love with the soundtrack. |
simo000Oct 4, 2009 7:00 AM
| Almost every anime in the MAL top list is overrated for someone who doesn't like them. I just happen to like some of them so I don't consider those overrated. Hayate no Gotoku season 1 is underrated. Id expected it to be higher than season 2, but its not.. ;( |
Jaapsneep said: Yeah but that's mostly because it's a sequel, those who didn't like the first season will probably not watch the second season, so the sequel always end up with a stronger fanbase than the prequel.Hayate no Gotoku season 1 is underrated. Id expected it to be higher than season 2, but its not.. ;( |
HooHiraiBunny said: Yeah. Now we just need Baman to use this to explain why CGR2 has a higher ranking than the original CG.Jaapsneep said: Yeah but that's mostly because it's a sequel, those who didn't like the first season will probably not watch the second season, so the sequel always end up with a stronger fanbase than the prequel.Hayate no Gotoku season 1 is underrated. Id expected it to be higher than season 2, but its not.. ;( |
| Confucius say man who stand on toilet is high on pot. |
| Overrated: Naruto Shippuuden, ef- tale of memories, Shugo-Chara, K-ON! (I like the animation, but the plot bored me), Underrated: Ayakashi, Shangri-La, CANAAN, Mahou Sensei Negima, Shaman King, To-LOVE-ru, Tokyo Godfathers |
 |
| the 2 most overated are bleach and naruto and they have tooo many fillers |
 |
Mawootad said: I've already done it plenty of times. And there's no other feasible explanation, is there?Yeah. Now we just need Baman to use this to explain why CGR2 has a higher ranking than the original CG. |
Baman said: Yeah, leave poor Baman alone. I'm pretty sure he's sick of writing lengthy posts on why CG fails.Mawootad said: I've already done it plenty of times. And there's no other feasible explanation, is there?Yeah. Now we just need Baman to use this to explain why CGR2 has a higher ranking than the original CG. |
| I think Blassreiter is pretty underrated. |
| i fink naruto iz underrated. |
|
GeneralZaroff said: Dragonball is underrated. Everyone loves DBZ but not many DBZ fans particularly care for it. Dragonball is more fun because it's not just pure action and fighting. It starts out as an adventure with fights along the way. Saiyans don't dominate it like later DBZ. Humans are actually pretty strong until you get to when Piccolo starts running around. Even then Tien didn't do TOO bad against Piccolo Jr. if I recall correctly. I loved Dragon Ball. In fact, you make me want to go watch the movies that I plan to watch right now. |
| Dragonball had too many fillers to be properly enjoyed. If you took all the filler out, I'm sure people would love it just as much. I liked the manga portion of Dragonball better than I liked the manga portion of Dragonball Z. Dragonball was before all the "ARRGHH I AM POWERLEVEL 90232323239029349 desu!!!" and "EAT MY POWER ARGHH BLAST!!!" bullshit. Episodes of "i am more powerful than you" and huge faggot explosions didn't exist back in DB. |
| I'm back. |
| Except for Full Metal Panic TSR, which is underrated and > they're other stuff. Though I like Haruhi - that is, the original version, not the 2009 one (which I haven't seen yet). |
VEE said: KyoANi's prodcution normally overrated. apart from K-ON!, they are not overrated, they are just infinitely better than your average harem/moe show, think about it |
GeneralZaroff said: rebekah said: i fink naruto iz underrated. Surely you jest. jest? |
|
| Overrated- Ouran High School Host Club, Lucky Star Underrated- Gintama, Seirei no Moribito, Seto no Hanayome |
Renegade765 said: Overrated- Ouran High School Host Club Underrated- Gintama |
| One that a lot of people don't really know about is Rune Solider. It's not the greatest in the world, but it's still a nice little gem. |
flyingkipper said: My other underrated nominations would go to Tenchi in Tokyo and Vampire Princess Miyu. Yeah, but more than being underrated, they are being forgotten. |
| Eo tempore, cum tibi occuri, Mihi vita laeta fuit, Cum autem te nusquam conspexi, Eo tempore mortem cognovi |
| there is alot underrated and overrated on this site, makes no damne sense at all, they should reset the rating system to 0 votes, all animes that where high since the beginning are too hard to compete with for newcoming great animes the top 100 makes no damn sense, some titles i agree with but some REAAAALY not, and fcking nice animes are damn underrated here. what also doesnt make sense = Code geass and TTGL higher then Death Note? dont make me laugh, and believe me i liked CG and TTGL too but they WERENT better |
Garuda said: I'll agree that the first third of Death Note was better than both of those. However, I'll also say that the middle third was worse than both of those shows and the last third was crap.there is alot underrated and overrated on this site, makes no damne sense at all, they should reset the rating system to 0 votes, all animes that where high since the beginning are too hard to compete with for newcoming great animes the top 100 makes no damn sense, some titles i agree with but some REAAAALY not, and fcking nice animes are damn underrated here. what also doesnt make sense = Code geass and TTGL higher then Death Note? dont make me laugh, and believe me i liked CG and TTGL too but they WERENT better |
| Confucius say man who stand on toilet is high on pot. |
narutobleach said: Underrated: Naruto and Bleach That's ironic, since both are OVERrated. |
Garuda said: there is alot underrated and overrated on this site, makes no damne sense at all, they should reset the rating system to 0 votes, all animes that where high since the beginning are too hard to compete with for newcoming great animes the top 100 makes no damn sense, some titles i agree with but some REAAAALY not, and fcking nice animes are damn underrated here. what also doesnt make sense = Code geass and TTGL higher then Death Note? dont make me laugh, and believe me i liked CG and TTGL too but they WERENT better Dude, I've got a better idea. They should just let you pick the top anime. Problem fucking solved! |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
Neverender said: Garuda said: there is alot underrated and overrated on this site, makes no damne sense at all, they should reset the rating system to 0 votes, all animes that where high since the beginning are too hard to compete with for newcoming great animes the top 100 makes no damn sense, some titles i agree with but some REAAAALY not, and fcking nice animes are damn underrated here. what also doesnt make sense = Code geass and TTGL higher then Death Note? dont make me laugh, and believe me i liked CG and TTGL too but they WERENT better Dude, I've got a better idea. They should just let you pick the top anime. Problem fucking solved! People have differing opinions regarding what anime is good and what's not, etc. So the problem still won't be solved. |
More topics from this board
Poll: » What tropes do you find the most annoying in a protagonist?ZeroMajor12 - 2 hours ago |
12 |
by Nirinbo
»»
1 minute ago |
|
» Who are your enemies in the anime industry/fanbase?Catalano - Yesterday |
31 |
by SgtBateMan
»»
2 minutes ago |
|
» Why male characters tend to have more interesting personalities than female characters?Alpha_1_Zero - 3 hours ago |
5 |
by Vaturna
»»
2 minutes ago |
|
» MULTIPLE UNRELATED anime that you think could be set in the same anime universeIpreferEcchi - 46 minutes ago |
4 |
by SgtBateMan
»»
4 minutes ago |
|
» what is battle shonen?deg - 2 hours ago |
11 |
by Catalano
»»
4 minutes ago |