❌ Invalid Entries

^^^^

So that's how that entri works then, I saw that one and PMed riho for clarification.

Personally, I will go by the AniDB and Anime-Planet links provided, and even another source as long as they're able to provide a link to validated entry.

@riho88riho are we able to have members who are participating in the challenge to provide the episodic tag source link for entries that aren't the ones listed above? Since members could just easily add in anything they consider 'episodic', which will make it difficult for inspectors to determine if the turn-in is valid or not.

I PMed riho for clarification in that challenge enrti (and similar ones) and she said
"it means any genre as long as they didn't use it for one of the other requirements. So Yuri, Yaoi, Hentai is acceptable especially because it wasn't listed as an option above".

@AYOSHINA

Great! Thanks for the clarification!

[*] Watch a racing or combat OVA: Apo Apo World: Giant Baba 90-bun 1-hon Shoubu (Combat) is registered as a Movie

@IMKZ @riho88riho

Updated up to post #1355

It used to be on OVA when I watched it and I didn't checked it now, lol.

Switched for Midori no Makibao Compilation OVA (Racing).

None of those series appear in your recent history.


@IMKZ @riho88riho

Hidamari Sketch x 365 Specials does not begin with a letter between M - Z.

Resolved


I just want to point out that you were suppose to watch 2 movies on 15th to make up for missing the 14th.

Resolved


A lot of your entries didn't correspond with the date you provided.
Boku dake ga Inai Machi is not complete on your anime list.

Re-Turned In


Yakyuukyou no Uta is a baseball anime.

Resolved


Takamiya Nasuno desu! links to a manga.

Resolved



Sports:
Major S4 has over 25k members.

AWC 2016:
Can you just link the user you used for "Watch a highly rated and completed anime from another challenger who posted on the same page you signed up on" and also link the post where "an anime recommended to you by another Anime Watching Challenge participant" instead of the username.

Resolved

@IMKZ @riho88riho

My bad, mixed entries Hidamari Sketch x 365 Specials and Yuru Yuri♪♪ in each others requirement. It's fixed now.

I just want to point out that you were suppose to watch 2 movies on 15th to make up for missing the 14th.

[/quote]
I watched Kara no Kyoukai 4 and Howls moving castle

screwed up that quote

@Kreyul

I watched Kara no Kyoukai 4 and Howls moving castle

screwed up that quote

@Kreyul[/quote]
Oh okay, I see it now. Misread the dates @_@

Edited the requirement to "Watch a TV baseball anime" as it was supposed to be.

@kreyul

Lol, my bad. Fixed

@Kreyul I am actually such a spanner. I looked at scored by instead of members but it should all be fixed now

@IMKZ @riho88riho

Watch an "other" special Kuroko no Basket NG-shuu

"Other" - swimming, ping pong, football, golf, ice skating, gymnastics, dance, fishing, anything not listed as "main"

I'm asuming that special is about basketball, which belongs to "Main".

@IMKZ @riho88riho

updated up to #1387

I'm sorry about that, it was when I watched it (darn database editing). I replaced it with Wakaba*Girl: Onsen Tsukaritai. I watched this on September 19. So it still falls between my start date (May 26) & my end date (October 1).

Supernatural The Animation has over 10k members.

Re-Turned In

@IMKZ @riho88riho

No worries, it's all good now. Thank you!

-- [✓] Watch an OVA: Boku wa Tomodachi ga Sukunai Episode 0 is 11 minutes long, must be longer than 15.

Re-Turned In

@IMKZ @riho88riho

Fixed it. Replaced it with this:
-- [✓] Watch a series that begins with a letter between M - Z: Tonari no Yamada-kun

Mobile Suit Gundam-san is listed under both spring+summer. It aired in summer.

Resolved


Amnesia isn't scored 6 or under.

Resolved

@IMKZ @riho88riho

Thank you for noticing this, i just fixed it which was suppose to be Mangaka-san to Assistant-san to The Animation but not sure how i didn't catch that lol.

It has to be 6.00 or under?

That's what I thought, since 6.39 > 6.

Alright, i replaced it with Vampire Holmes (score 3.62).

#02 ✓ Watch a Shoujo Ai where all the characters have natural hair color ― Blue Drop: Tenshi-tachi no Gikyoku

Does this requirement referst to ALL characters listed or only the Main cast? because there is a character with blue hair and two with white hair in the supportig cast.

Honestly, Candy Boy Episode: EX01 fits that requirement much better, and you could remplace "Watch a Shoujo Ai with only 1 episode" with one of the yuri anime you watched, like Star☆Jewel, so you technically did complete the challege, hence I'm not tagging the admins.

Mmm, I never really thought about that since I just assumed it meant main cast, but I edited it with the suggestions that you made just in case.

Odd entries updated up to post #1443

@IMKZ @riho88riho

Ok i changed the ova to high school dxd ova and the 2nd one was meant to be the sequel which i have now edited

Thank you!

Paprika is used twice

Now i think it's everything alright.

Siddhartha Gautama's eyes are more on the blue side than green.
The following don't have characters listed:
Ultraman USA , Kushimitama Samurai , Baton , Inochi no Chikyuu: Dioxin no Natsu , 8-gatsu no Symphony: Shibuya 2002-2003.

Re-Turned In


Yamada-kun to 7-nin no Majo (TV) does not end with the same last letter as your username.

Re-Turned In


Katanagatari : None of the main characters have a little brother/sister.

Resolved

@AYOSHINA (should I just mention you since you're the new HoF updater? o: )

That what I hate about color based challenges. Colors can be so subjective. I swear his eye look teal (greenish blue) to me. I thought charaters promently displayed on the cover & mentioned on in the synopsis would work. My bad.

I dug and found suitable replacements. I just need your approval before I replace them.

Blonde: Shizuo Heiwajima from Durarara!!x2 Shou: Watashi no Kokoro wa Nabe Moyou (Watched: Oct. 1)
Male w/ long hair: Andy Bogard from Fatal Fury: Legend of the Hungry Wolf (Watched: Sept. 29)
Shorts: Kedamono from Popee the Performer (Watched: Sept. 28)
Dress: Pai from 3x3 Eyes Seima Densetsu When she and Yakumo traveled, her traveling attire is a burgundy dress, a vest, a tied white button-down and hat. (Watched Oct. 5)
School uniform: Hime Yarizakura from Yozakura Quartet: Hoshi no Umi (Watched: Sept. 30)

Green eyes: Move C.C. to this spot and replace her green hair entry with: Minai Ruo from Shikabane Hime: Kuro Special (Watched: Oct. 1)

Sorry to intervene here, as I'm not in charge of inspection, but I would also consider synopsis or cover pretty valid. MAL lacking information doesn't mean you're not necessarily doing the challenge. I think if it's pretty obvious by cover and synopsis that a character is actually a main character, then it should be valid. Though that's just my opinion on something that I don't think it's clearly stated. All of this is especially true when we consider this challenge asks for 105 entries, which is obviously quite a lot in term of number of entries.

@riho88riho @Kreyul @AYOSHINA @Punkero

They all work however, C.C actually has yellow/golden eyes.



Honestly, the "People Challenge" already requires a lot of outside research. I personally spend a good half hour - 2 hour checking each entry submitted. Not having a character on MAL make it a lot more difficult to judge. I would understand if the synopsis includes the character's names and would consider them a "main character", but because there are no characters, that also means there will most likely be lack of information on the internet itself. So, finding a decent picture and actually knowing that it is indeed that character would be pretty difficult. Also, just because a character is on a cover, does not automatically put them as a "main".

I had personally messaged riho88riho before posting that entry as invalid.

I can perfectly understand that, but then I think it should be stated in the rules, because if not, we're bound to see a lot of such cases in the future.

Personally, few times I linked to AniDB character entry because MAL doen't have character entries for the anime and once I even had nothing to link, hoping the poster is enought to prove the character has red hair. I think that MAL having the character entry should not be required. However, what should be required is the character name, preferably also links. That way it would be faster to check the turn-ins. And in cases you really aren't sure, just have poeple provide some screenshot.


(Also, Siddhartha's eyes looks green to me.)

Ah you're right. he has an older sister. oops =P
Fixed now.

I have edited all entries. I forgot her eyes are gold. So, I used Goro Fumonji from VitaminX Addiction for the green eyed entry. This is why I always watch more than what is required in challenges. So incase something is wrong, I can just dig back and replace it something else. Guess I'll use Minai Ruo for my medium entry.

I forget about AniDB because I don't use it too often. I could have probably used Anime Characters Database too. I'll keep them in mind next time.

Oh, right, I misread that one. I fixed it by replacing it with Clannad: After Story.

If outside links are provided, I would not mind checking over them as long as they can prove character name and that they are indeed a main character. Besides MAL, I check outside sources such as anidb, animecharacterdatabase, google images, and occasionally pvs/actual episodes/movies.

In Siddhartha's case:

I'm just going to add all the unresolved invalid entries that were missed + ones that haven't been crossed out yet here:


Highschool of the Dead does not have "Romance" tag.

Resolved


Gintama: Shinyaku Benizakura-hen is less than 15 mins total.

Resolved


Gyo is an OVA.

Re-Turned In




Mirai Nikki (TV) did not air the same season you joined MAL. You joined during the Summer season (July/Aug/Sep).

Re-Turned In


Itazura na Kiss does not have school tag.
Denpa-teki na Kanojo did not air in Fall.


PM'd


Slice of Life :
Danchigai : Not all main cast has natural colored hair.

Historical :
Koihime†Musou's score is not over 7.

@AYOSHINA
Can you give me a heads up when you update. I can make a new post, so you don't have to keep checking this one plus it'll re-notify you. o__o;