| Ghibli. Cool. That's all I can say. |
| (That's for someone who deleted the post: Minimal number of 10, did not watch those, can't really say anything.) ^ Jaapsneep: Gintama, One Piece, Rurouni Kenshin: Tsuiokuhen - I believe truly good, hear only good things about them. The other one is unfamiliar to me. 20th Century Boys, GTO - Great! Eyesheild is believed to be great, I believe it too. Good luck with my 10's. |
LiarKDec 13, 2009 7:06 AM
| LiarK Bleach - I'm a big fan myself but a 10...I don't think so. Cowboy Bebop - Expected. Deathnote - Deserves it. H&C - It was OK. Far from a 10 IMO though. Howl's moving castle - Yes! Now you're talking. Kuroshitsuji - As much as I enjoyed this one and wanted to rate it a 10, I couldn't. The ending totally put me off. Waiting for season 2. Mushishi - May deserve it. It's brilliant but I haven't competed it yet. OHSHC - It was all good. But not good enough for a 10. Samurai Champloo - Oh yes! I love your ratings. Skip beat - I fell in love with it but the cliif hanger ending killed me. I see why we have a high compatibility. I also should mention I love the background (Byakuya being my No.1 Favourite). And you need to add Baccano! to your list right this minute. |
 |
| k0k0 Baccano! - 1930s immortal gangsters + fucking awesome plot = one of the best creations in existence. |
 |
| Xana-The-Divine Bit too many I think... but it's interesting how your KnK choices coincide with mine... I also consider 2,5 and 7 the best (although not worthy of a 10). Clannad is fine, but NGE is a no-no. But I'm not surprised. Higashi no Eden doesn't deserve a 10 in my book... it was kinda stupid. |
 |
corbenic said: Xana-The-Divine Bit too many I think... but it's interesting how your KnK choices coincide with mine... I also consider 2,5 and 7 the best (although not worthy of a 10). Clannad is fine, but NGE is a no-no. But I'm not surprised. Higashi no Eden doesn't deserve a 10 in my book... it was kinda stupid. My giving of a ten is based on three things: Direction, quality, and execution of the plot. How emotionally gripping said execution is. Grasp of interest and entertainment level. All of my 10s in accordance with my personal preference were worthy of that score. Anywho~ corbenic I've only seen Clannad ~After Story~ and as you can see from my list, it is in my top five anime. Several arcs in ~AS~ left me in tears much like the first season, but episodes 18 and onward had me crying the remainder of the show. Six episodes and roughly three hours of straight crying, with the end being a cherry on top of multi-layered cake. Clannad ~After Story~ is certainly worthy of a ten, more-so even. |
|
| Evangelion: 1.0 You Are (Not) Alone is a complete masterpiece. I loved the special Ramiel effects and the pacing was just epic. You have superb tastes. :) |
 |
| I can see the 10 for Evanegelion and EoE (even if i didn't like the ending, even the EoE ending missed something for me) since they are great animes. However the 10 of yu gi oh GX is a little awkward to me. Cant say I cant agree since I never watched the series, but still... |
 |
| Veethorn -never seen One Piece myself, but i see tons of 10s for it -I can't rightly recall if I've seen Char's Counterattack, I probably saw part of it on TV or something a long time ago -Princess Mononoke.....not a big Miyazaki fan here -does everyone rate Samurai X: Trust and Betrayl 10? I might just end up seeing it someday |
| The only ones I've seen among your faves are CHS and TTGL , and I simply loathe CHS. Don't really want to remember any of it as well. ^^ TTGL is, I think, overrated, not really mediocre, but not a good series >_> |
   |
| kikoushi NICE KnK, that almost made mine. Overall, I can tell you're a sophisticated anime-watcher, and you usually don't go for most of the crap Japan comes up with. |
 |
| MoeNekoDrill Higashi no Eden - Agree 100% TokiKake - My favorite movie of all time. 5 Centimeters per Second - Again, another of my favorites as well. Kara no Kyoukai 5: Mujun Rasen - Yup Kara no Kyoukai 2: Satsujin Kousatsu (Part 1) - Yup FMA - Okay, I didn't think it was worthy of a 10 Haruhi - Same as FMA CANAAN - The sugoi and unanswered questions left this as a 9 for me Neon Genesis Evangelion: Death & Rebirth - Holy shit, are you on acid? Give me whatever the fuck you have to rate this a 10. |
|
| sebg .. you don't have a 10 with the anime we share so I'll go with 9: Bakemonogatari .. I agree with you .. it's a very interesting anime .. Clannad .. it was very boring anime and a slow one .. I can't give higher than a 7 .. Clannad AS .. way much better but there's still parts that I disliked .. K-ON! .. nice and funny anime .. but to me there's something missing in it .. The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya .. I can never understand what's so good about it .. I got bored easily while watching it .. :) |
| LoveSong Of your 10s, I've only seen Fumoffu. I thought it was decent, but honestly prefered TSR and the first season. It was hilarious though, don't get me wrong. |
|
| Xana-The-Divine Eh.. only seen Evangelion 1.0 You Are [Not] Alone, which I more or less agree on it since I gave mine a 9. xD Great remake of a great series, got high hopes for the rest of the Rebuild of Eva. |
| Sakhet It seems quite obvious that you enjoy Mecha anime, which is something I myself and not a huge fan of. ---Mobile Suit Gundam Seed ---Mobile Suit Gundam: The 08th MS Team I have not seen either of the Mobile Suit Gundam animes that you gave 10s to, but may look into them if you actually only gave the two them 10s out of all the others. ---Neon Genesis Evangelion NGE was an awesome anime, and I can understand why you gave it a 10. It was an interesting anime, even though it is a mech anime.. sort of. You should really watch Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann, seeing that you enjoy that genre of anime so much. |
Music & Anime > Everything Else  |
| doctorwolf gonna credit the ones i've watched and previewed: Samurai Champloo- It is a cool anime in my preview, yet there was something to lack off...maybe a 10 from your preference TTGL- Since its kinda overrated, credited to be deserved by majority's taste Mushishi and FMA- Both are classics, well deserved by your opinion for me... GTO- The realism and morality humor gives a quick hint to praise this Kaiba- hmmm...i checked this long time ago...not very attractive to my preference |
| sauteed_roaches Great name! I also love the dango daikazoku background on your list. Code Geass - It was interesting for a little while, but it eventually lost taste and any entertaining value. Clannad ~After Story~ - Best romance and one of the best overall anime I've seen to date. Characters and the story it tells are near unparalleled. Agree 110%. |
|
| Xana-The-Divine 5 Centimeters per Second.. it was a very beautiful movie .. but there was something missing in it .. i don't know what it is ..:) Clannad .. I can NEVER understand why a lot of people give it a 10 .. the 1st season was really really boring .. the arcs weren't that interesting esp the Fuko one .. the comedy didn't fit the show unlike the 2nd one .. plus it was a very slow in the beginning very fast in the middle (16-18) and the again very slow .. Clannad After story .. this one I can understand .. but I really hated the end it was very stupid .. and I actually preferred clannad the movie .. ^^. |
LoveSong said: Xana-The-Divine Clannad .. I can NEVER understand why a lot of people give it a 10 .. the 1st season was really really boring .. the arcs weren't that interesting esp the Fuko one .. the comedy didn't fit the show unlike the 2nd one .. plus it was a very slow in the beginning very fast in the middle (16-18) and the again very slow .. Clannad After story .. this one I can understand .. but I really hated the end it was very stupid .. and I actually preferred clannad the movie .. ^^. Something doesn't have to be fast paced to be enjoyable. Clannad took its time when explaining the situations of each character and milked the viewer of emotions. The Fuuko arc was actually one of my favorites of the first season and always makes me cry, the same with the Ushio arc in After Story. The comedy was insert to try and lift the depressing mood the series puts on a person, much how like Shakespeare used clowns in his plays directly succeeding a death or deaths. You can't say an ending was stupid without giving a valid reason why. The ending was necessary and spirit lifting. |
|
| Gankutusou and Baccano!, I love those. If I wasn't such a shounen fanboy those would've been my favorites. Clannad and NGE, meh. Too much moe and mindfuck. I loved the mecha in NGE but Shinji pisses me off. I can understand why you'd rate the NGE movie a 10 if you loved NGE so much, imo the movie was better (cool reanimation for the cube and EVA01!). Haven't seen the rest, sorry :) |
| Benatron Clannad ~After Story~: Much love there, agree completely. Eureka seveN: I'm pretty sure I rated this a 9 only because Bakemonogatari: Fantastic show is fantastic. A 9 for me so far because it's taking too fucking long to release the last episodes! |
|
| What can I say? I also have a 10 on Bacanno, so I have to agree with you. For the other, I have to watch it. |
| -Fixing- |
Xana-The-Divine said: LoveSong said: Xana-The-Divine Clannad .. I can NEVER understand why a lot of people give it a 10 .. the 1st season was really really boring .. the arcs weren't that interesting esp the Fuko one .. the comedy didn't fit the show unlike the 2nd one .. plus it was a very slow in the beginning very fast in the middle (16-18) and the again very slow .. Clannad After story .. this one I can understand .. but I really hated the end it was very stupid .. and I actually preferred clannad the movie .. ^^. Something doesn't have to be fast paced to be enjoyable. Clannad took its time when explaining the situations of each character and milked the viewer of emotions. The Fuuko arc was actually one of my favorites of the first season and always makes me cry, the same with the Ushio arc in After Story. The comedy was insert to try and lift the depressing mood the series puts on a person, much how like Shakespeare used clowns in his plays directly succeeding a death or deaths. You can't say an ending was stupid without giving a valid reason why. The ending was necessary and spirit lifting. Yes, I agree with you. Ever read Dear Friends manga? Depressing ending left a lot to be desired. Hmm, Elfen Lied - It was so, so. Don't like recaps much and thought much of the series overdone. But I did like certain scenes, involving Kurama and Mariko, and Nana and that's pretty much it. At times, the series can be poignant, but at other times, this feels quite uninspired. Great opening theme though. It was sad, riveting and haunting but unfortunately proved to much for the series, raising expectations needlessly high. Seto no Hanayome - great comedy series overall (much better than what we usually get today I suppose). Episode 24 was probably my favorite of the lot. The ending sort of ruined my overall depiction of the series as it rushed important scenes and the more uninteresting events were dragged. Quite a few characters and their quirks got old fast, characters like Maki, Shark, Mawari, Akeno and Lunar and some felt too similar. The character design in general just wasn't my thing. But first 24 episodes were good. Figure 17 - plan to watch. Heard good things about this series, although the ratings for it is pretty low compared. |
 |
| Obsessive -haven't seen Aria, but I do like the director a lot -Code Geass, can't stand it -Cowboy Bebop is always a solid choice -I personally find Monster horribly overrated, a good show, but not mind-blowing -Hell yeah! TTGL all the way! -haven't seen the others. |
| classicalzawa Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann - Great show. I gave it a 9, I could see someone giving it 10. Needed more Kamina though. Interstella5555 - The 5tory of The 5ecret 5tar 5ystem and Metropolis - Honestly never heard of them, no comment. Princess Tutu - Never seen it, but it has Chris Patton and Luci Christian as main characters, so it must be good. Legend of the Galactic Heroes - I won't know what to think of this until I see it. Who knows? Perhaps I'll love it. I've never heard of your 10 rated Manga either. :/ |
FloreteDec 19, 2009 2:46 AM
| YES, we have the same tastes. I agree. |
 |
| Amy-nyan A twelve-year-old "weeaboo." Impressive. Nearly half of your completed series are 10s. I'm sure that as time passes you'll lower some of those scores as you see more and more series. Higurashi - You've seen both the first season and Kai, so that's awesome. I can agree with a scoring of 10 for both, however Kai appealed to me more with the explanation of the events from the first season. All in all, a fantastic series. Haruhi - Eh, it was good and enjoyable and I had it rated a 10 once, but it just isn't deserving. Still a great show, however. Nyoro~n - I didn't think it was possible to rate this so high .__. Clannad - I can agree with this for every piece except Kyou chapter. It felt far too rushed and it didn't give the viewer as much as an emotional response or tie as Tomoyo chapter or the first two seasons did. Umineko - Because of that shitty beginning, I'm keeping this at a 9. Whenever Umineko no naku koro ni Kai comes out, I'll certainly give that a 10. Hetalia - No. |
|
| A sucker for cheap emotional thrills. |
| LEGENDOFTHEGALACTICHEROESLEGENDOFTHEGALACTI LEGENDOFTHEGALACTICHEROESLEGENDOFTHEGALACTI LEGENDOFTHEGALACTICHEROESLEGENDOFTHEGALACTI |
| Golden Boy is an okay anime i guess, but i wouldnt give it a 10 because the comedy wasnt very funny to me |
 |
| well, what can i say death note and spirited away i myself rated these two with ten so nothing to complain about. and Dragon ball...i haven't seen it and neither planing to. |
| Haven't completed CANAAN yet but I don't think it deserves a 10. I will never understand TTGL hype. |
 |
| Cowabunga -only manga 10 is for Monster, which I found good, but vastly overrated -Cowboy Bebop is always a solid choice -I've seen the main series for LoGH, but haven't seen any of the spin-offs and movies yet (consider it part of my Spring Semester anime goal list, I will be watching them at some point). Looks like you're in the third season of the show, hoping you're enjoying yourself! |
| classicalzawa - Everybody loves TTGL , amirite? Good choice , bro -Interstella's music might be epic (FUCK YEAH!) but you can't judge it by music only so I don't see how you can give it a 10 -I've seen a lot of people give Legend of the Galactic Heroes a high score I might have to watch it sometime even tho the art style looks HORRIBLE! -Even though I've never watched Princess Tutu...That's a weird choice -No opinion on Metropolis |
| 2-D GTO is indeed funny but it doesn't deserve a 10. TTGL is overrated. Haruhi's 1st season is amusing but it's not a masterpiece. I've only watched 60-something eps. of One Piece, so I can't say if a 10 is fair or not. |
|
| Cowboy Bebop definitely deserves a 10 but i've never seen LOtGh but i don't see why it is so popular on this site is it really that good? |
| BLeakXBuRSTX19 FLCL - Bored me. I don't know what everyone sees in it. Haven't seen the others, though I plan on watching the Kara no Kyoukai movies and Cowboy Bebop soon. |
| yeah, i like clannad though i definitely don't think it's masterpiece. the same about after story. i enjoyed it even less than the first one. |
| Hello, Redfoxoffire... Clannad- I like it, but I won't give it a 10 cuz well, it's not my cup of tea. Clannad AS - I understand why ppl give it a 10, though I won't give it more than 5 mainly cuz it's super boring, Though if it ended with ep 18, I would give it 8 or 9, mayb. Code Geass - Hangyaku no Lelouch R2 - it's a great show, I once gave it a 10. Death Note - I like the first arc so much, but the second arc puts me off frm giving it a 10, though I once gave it a 10. Elfen Lied - Agreed, very beautiful yet very sad and cruel story. One of my all time favs. The rest I've not watched. Oops. Someone beats me. @firy Canaan - It's one of my most fav action shows. Sry, I duno why I dun wanna give it a 10. Code Geass - Hangyaku no Lelouch R2, Death Note and Elfen Lied - as described above for Redfoxoffire. Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann - a really entertaining show, I won't give it a 10 cuz it seems like it lacks some seriousness compared with other mecha i've seen. Welcome to the NHK! - One of the very few SoL shows I've watched. Then blame my genre discrimination. It isn't so much to my taste. The rest I've not watched. |
ForsakenArcherDec 20, 2009 4:33 PM
We are the United. Even in defeat we stand united. |
| Freedom_Gunboy, I remember you. Anyway... FMA: Brotherhood - I haven't started it yet, but I loved the first series and I hear this is even better. Code Geass - Great show, I once had it at 10 but lowered it. I plan on re-watching it. Rurouni Kenshin: Tsuiokuhen - It was good, but I don't think it's a masterpiece. Perhaps it's because I finished the manga first so I know the rest of the story and how his past fits in with his present. Don't know the others. |
| -Xeley -I've read a bit Kimi ni Todoke, seems pretty good so far -I did not like Higashi no Eden at all -I found Haruhi to be completely average -Girl Who Leapt Through Time was pretty good, but the ending killed it for me, seemed too rushed -NHK started off pretty good, but I didn't like it as much as the show went on and ending it the same way they ended another episode was a huge crime to me -don't know any of your other ones |
| LotGH, couldn't agree any less TTGL, first arc was great, second arc sucked. (gave it a 9/10) Princess Tutu, another amazing anime worthy of a 10 haven't seen the others |
| Saiensu Of your tens I've only seen one, Clannad ~After Story~, and it is in my top five of all. There isn't much else I can say really except I love your Gankutsuou background. |
|
| Xana-The-Divine Girl who Leapt through Time - Agreed, a 10 from me as well. 5 Cm Per Second - Another one I don't get what people see in it. It didn't really bore me, it just didn't stand out in any way to me either. It felt kind of pointless. Clannad/Clannad ~After Story~ - Couldn't agree more, ~AS~ is my #1. (And hey, we both have Nagisa avatars) Higurashi no Naku Koro ni Kai - A great series for sure. I gave it 9, but I can understand giving it 10. Everything else - Dunno. btw, nice Plan To Watch list. |
| Redfoxoffire -didn't like the first season of Code Geass enough to bother with the second -Death Note's 2nd half shot down any chance for it to be a 10 if you ask me, although the first half was still very good. -I saw half of Elfen Lied before getting distracted by something shiny, but I did like what I saw, probably not to a degree of a 10 though -Girl Who Leapt Through Time's ending made the movie a big disappointment for me |
More topics from this board
» Vent something v.3 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Steph - May 7, 2023 |
5997 |
by I_shoot_kids_fr
»»
8 seconds ago |
|
» On a scale of 1-10 how strict is the user above ( 1 2 )Ice-Cube - Jun 18, 2022 |
90 |
by PPL_CaLL_Me_DUDE
»»
2 minutes ago |
|
» What are your thoughts after visiting the profile of the user above? v.3 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Kunii - Aug 9, 2023 |
3927 |
by Synkiiz
»»
2 minutes ago |
|
» Which one of the two users above you is scarier? v4 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Kunii - Apr 13, 2021 |
8631 |
by PPL_CaLL_Me_DUDE
»»
2 minutes ago |
|
» Do you ship the two users above you? v.12 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Kunii - Dec 3, 2023 |
1840 |
by PPL_CaLL_Me_DUDE
»»
4 minutes ago |