FMmatron said:@ColourWheel
Probably your sense of humor if you see Peach Girl as a comedy, but definitely fair enough if you say it like that (my brother who only watched anime on TV as a child also laughed at how overdramatic AoT is) It's been a while since I've seen it. Comedy-wise I don't remember much, regardless of it was unintentional or not. Only that I genuinely liked the drama. Anime being overdramatic or melodrama in general is what I like about it in the first place. And yes, occasionaly that's comedic as well. Which can be a good thing, too.
If you want me to shamelessly name-drop another title more conventional to being an actual comedy, there’s
"Magikano". It’s basically what you’d get if fanservice was raised by cartoon gremlins and handed a script with no rules. A raunchy middle school perverted comedy for the whole family. lol
"Magikano" is one of those shows that feels like it made a dramatic escape from a voluntary mental institution, even when one could’ve just freely walked out of the place with no problem, and landed in a school uniform.
It’s chaotic, unhinged, and lives off pure early-2000s anime energy aimed at a general Japanese male demo. Like someone mashed a trashy magical girl harem and a slapstick pervy ghost comedy together, then triple-dosed it with extra-refined sugar and said, “Yup, that’s the tone". lol
It shouldn’t work. By all logic, it should be a mess. But somehow, that mess is hilarious. It doesn’t just lean into the absurd, it swan-dives off the roof of the school, shamelessly flaunting its white panties, and yells “Plot? What plot?!” on the way down. Even at times, it pokes fun at actual anime fanservice, while ironically offering it at the same time, in a way that isn’t inherently meant to sexually gratify the viewer at all in the first place.
Nobody ever brings this show up, and that honestly blows my mind. It’s comedy gold! It’s got that “your weeb friend randomly recommended it and you were just expecting it to be complete trash, but now you’re 4 episodes deep and actually loving the chaos” energy.
You want underrated? This is it. If your taste runs a little off-kilter and you like your school comedies cracked out, unpredictable, and aggressively anti-serious... Then metaphorically,
"Magikano" is your dream girlfriend material tease that you had a huge crush on back in 1991. All dressed up in a trendy T-shirt they bought at the GAP, and wearing a very short and tight stone-washed jean miniskirt, white socks, and the silkiest white panties they probably own, all for your movie date. Knowing full well they’re expecting to get totally felt up that evening, sitting in the very back row of the almost-empty theater with you.
"Magikano" can come off just that unhinged. lol