The most annoying thing about Demon Slayer

CickNipolla said:
This problem is highlighted most of all in S2 of Demon Slayer. Tanjiro's inability to understand that his sister is a demon, and can not die from other demons, really makes me want to just smash my head into a wall. Like why is he always just keeping her in a fucking box instead of bringing her out when fights are going on. People have 100% died on screen because he was like " oh no i must protect immortal sister".

Not to mention how STUPID it is to fight an upper rank demon with her in a box on your back

official_brown said:

This was talked about in S1, Tanjiro was willing to let Nezuko stay with Ms. Doctor Demon and Mr. Simp. But he realized that he needed Nezuko as much as she needs him, plus she did not want to be away from her brother. They want to find the cure together. And whether or not she can’t die from other demons, he still doesn’t want her to get hurt. There is no real feasible solution other than what he did and put down the box during Daki’s fight. Plus leaving Nezuko alone with others might cause more harm by her maybe eating a human and or Micheal Jackson taking her and putting his blood in her (his curse/control)

And like others have mentioned she sleeps in the box instead of eating humans. Her sleeping is what negates her hunger, which is why when she is in the box she is basically sleeping the entire time. It helps so she doesn’t go berserk.

Dixoncider8142 said:
Not much of a deal but like it makes sense why he’s holding back his sister. It’s common sense he doesn’t want her to hurt ppl. You kinda complain over the minor things yet I think u gave the first season a 9/10. I don’t recall what u scored it but it was more than a 5 that’s for sure.

AwokenStroken said:
I know right? Absolutely flawless...

CickNipolla said:
This problem is highlighted most of all in S2 of Demon Slayer. Tanjiro's inability to understand that his sister is a demon, and can not die from other demons, really makes me want to just smash my head into a wall. Like why is he always just keeping her in a fucking box instead of bringing her out when fights are going on. People have 100% died on screen because he was like " oh no i must protect immortal sister".

Not to mention how STUPID it is to fight an upper rank demon with her in a box on your back

Shinuki_n_Reborn said:


And since when something needs to be flawless in order to be a masterpiece? None of the shows with a 10 in your list are flawless, none of the shows with a over 9.0 score in this site is flawless.

ScuzzyBear said:
people fail to recall that before this mid series was adapted the manga had an avg score of 7.6, that is until ufotable boosted it (literally) and carried this horribly average show with god tier animation and music. nowadays eyecandy is all that's needed for people to worship a series and call it "peak". so to have any "wtf this makes no sense" is just stupid. it should be expected from the start given how mid the series was to begin with. so honestly just shut up and enjoy the show, autopilot it if you need to. in the end its just the same cliche shit you've seen done countless times before so why give a shit?

CickNipolla said:
This problem is highlighted most of all in S2 of Demon Slayer. Tanjiro's inability to understand that his sister is a demon, and can not die from other demons, really makes me want to just smash my head into a wall. Like why is he always just keeping her in a fucking box instead of bringing her out when fights are going on. People have 100% died on screen because he was like " oh no i must protect immortal sister".

Not to mention how STUPID it is to fight an upper rank demon with her in a box on your back

official_brown said:

Doesn’t most anime have what you mentioned? I honestly don’t see the problem of loving a show and praising the aspects for which it does well. While I admit fanbases like, AoT, Demon Slayer, One Piece, DBZ, Naruto, MHA, are all annoying, they should be allowed and have a valid reason to love a show. I mean most of the fans of the show are Japanese people with Tanjiro being voted #1 as a model for young teens/children. And not only that, but still being the highest grossing anime film of all time during the apex of Covid. Whether you like the show or hate it, the show is loved for more than it’s animation.

CickNipolla said:


if thats what he wanted then he would leave her with someone he trusts. at least, logical and good story writing would dictate that. most people wouldnt carry around someone they are trying to protect in a box

ScuzzyBear said:
people fail to recall that before this mid series was adapted the manga had an avg score of 7.6, that is until ufotable boosted it (literally) and carried this horribly average show with god tier animation and music. nowadays eyecandy is all that's needed for people to worship a series and call it "peak". so to have any "wtf this makes no sense" is just stupid. it should be expected from the start given how mid the series was to begin with. so honestly just shut up and enjoy the show, autopilot it if you need to. in the end its just the same cliche shit you've seen done countless times before so why give a shit?

CickNipolla said:
This problem is highlighted most of all in S2 of Demon Slayer. Tanjiro's inability to understand that his sister is a demon, and can not die from other demons, really makes me want to just smash my head into a wall. Like why is he always just keeping her in a fucking box instead of bringing her out when fights are going on. People have 100% died on screen because he was like " oh no i must protect immortal sister".

Not to mention how STUPID it is to fight an upper rank demon with her in a box on your back

aktiwkunn said:
My man is trying to find logic in a story written by a woman

234Mannan said:
What a sexist statement...From my personal experience, female writers are>=male writers(for me they are better)
Pandora hearts, Relife, Blue period, Tsubasa, a silent voice, Fmab,86 etc...In short most of the consistent complete storylines that i have seen are from female writers....
Being Slow is not even a bad thing(taking your other comment into account) it just means, the writers are taking their time to develop the characters and such...so yeah pretty sexist..

aktiwkunn said:

I was talking about the majority not every single one of them.
And you're talking as if "A Silent Voice" was any better. That crap was mid as hell, don't know why people overrate it so much

234Mannan said:
Majority... Like it actually makes your case any better...judging by that most of the media crap we have nowadays is thanks to male writers....(In almost every medium).. Writing ability isnt determined by gender..and thats a very narrow minded prespective no offence
As far as A Silent voice is concerned, its a story about acceptance and coming in terms with your flaws. It explores some really sensitive themes with not being too over the top and executes everything pretty simply...
Its connects deeply with the majority and that might answer your question to why its soo overrated..... Its a pretty different story which is not there just for the sake of entertainment and has much more to offer then a typical girl changing an Mc s life...Its about struggle, values, regret, guilt and forgiveness.. combined with that ending which reconnects to all the interactions and decisions shouya took at that point...
Inshort analysing its themes might clear your query

aktiwkunn said:

You won't bother paying attention to the "themes" of a story unless the story itself is good/intriguing enough.
1- He bullies her for no reason then starts getting bullied himself to come to realise that he was in the wrong.
2- She wants to be friends with the guy who bullies her and falls for him when he started treating her well due to guilt.
3- The girl tries to confess then Boom they never talk about that matter ever again.
The characters in the movie keep contradicting themselves. The author even said that the two of them never got together as it would not make sense or something. Then why did she even make her fall for him?

CickNipolla said:
This problem is highlighted most of all in S2 of Demon Slayer. Tanjiro's inability to understand that his sister is a demon, and can not die from other demons, really makes me want to just smash my head into a wall. Like why is he always just keeping her in a fucking box instead of bringing her out when fights are going on. People have 100% died on screen because he was like " oh no i must protect immortal sister".

Not to mention how STUPID it is to fight an upper rank demon with her in a box on your back

Link10103 said:
ultimately I think the problem is you're putting too much thought into a shonen lol. enjoy the eye candy incarnate that is ufotable with maybe 5% of your brain active and call it a day.

very few shonen hold up to extensive critical thought.

Percy91 said:
one word: zenitsu

ScuzzyBear said:


I mean it is? you can't possibly say it's the story that makes it good without a smile on your face

aktiwkunn said:
She wants to be friends with the guy who bullies her and falls for him when he started treating her well due to guilt.

RioFS said:

I'm curious, how would you feel if Shouya assaulted Shouko while she was napping?

CommunistCowGod said:
the ass pulls


"I stopped my heart from beating to stop the poison."

"I re aranged my organs."

SirMonday said:


The anime community never fails to impress with its smooth-brained takes.

You're looking at a show with immortal telekinetic/pyrokinetic/magical vampires, colour-changing swords that only change colour if the sword detects that the wielder has some minimum skill, and "flesh and blood humans" jumping onto/over two- and three-story buildings... but throw in the ability to rearrange organs or consciously stop your heartbeat (and considering there are meditation techniques for lowering heart rate, the latter isn't even all that far-fetched) and suddenly the "this show isn't realistic enough" crowd starts making noise.

SirMonday said:


The anime community never fails to impress with its smooth-brained takes.

You're looking at a show with immortal telekinetic/pyrokinetic/magical vampires, colour-changing swords that only change colour if the sword detects that the wielder has some minimum skill, and "flesh and blood humans" jumping onto/over two- and three-story buildings... but throw in the ability to rearrange organs or consciously stop your heartbeat (and considering there are meditation techniques for lowering heart rate, the latter isn't even all that far-fetched) and suddenly the "this show isn't realistic enough" crowd starts making noise.

CommunistCowGod said:


I would understand these decisions IF THEY ACTUALLY MADE SENSE IN TERMS OF THE MAGIC SYSTEM AND CHARACTERS. Also, Tegan literally stopped his heart from breathing, he didn't lower it. In fact, I think the sword styles are somewhat realistic, its just that demon slayer has a low fantasy magic system, compared to a hard.

kushakashi said:

someone doesn't understand the difference between low and hard fantasy . . .