The following will be a list of users that finished the challenge (after Dec 19, 11:25 AM UTC-4) and had only their sign-up form revised. This only includes that the titles selected actually fit the with the specific item. Given that I didn't have enough time, I didn't check their anime list to confirm the details (dates and the anime actually being there). Hey @SheyCroix, thanks again for your hard work. I just have a few questions about what you wrote. My username is in the part 3 list - are we the ones you contacted for revisions? And what do you mean by "This only includes that the titles selected actually fit the with the specific item"? And when you say you didn't check our lists, do you mean you didn't re-check our revisions or you didn't check thoroughly? |
| ^_^ |
jet2r0cks said: Hey @SheyCroix, thanks again for your hard work. I just have a few questions about what you wrote. My username is in the part 3 list - are we the ones you contacted for revisions? And what do you mean by "This only includes that the titles selected actually fit the with the specific item"? And when you say you didn't check our lists, do you mean you didn't re-check our revisions or you didn't check thoroughly? Everyone that had something to fix was contacted for revisions. As stated, those added to " part 3 " had only their sign-up revised to check the anime used fits with what that specific item asks for. It also mean that given the time left I didn't check the anime list, meaning that I didn't compare the sign up form with the anime list to see if they actually watched or not the anime used, neither if they watched it during the challenge period. This was something done for everyone else part of part 1 and part 2. If someone had revisions, yes, I checked the forms to see the change reflected there. |
| Finished the easy challenge just before the New Year (when Hibike S2 ended) and i should say it was hard for me, well i did expect it, but it was even harder. I'm mostly following the new seasons so in the end was scraping all the watched stuff. Finally watched Barakamon that was on my waiting list for quite a long time and it was really good (great) as people say, and i think today a lot of comedy shows are just meh and Barakamon is fairly old. Tried to conitnue the manga, but the different character design was such a turn off for me, mb i should've started with the manga, but after i watched it i think that Miwa's character looks so differently good and beatiful. Props to the people who are completing medium and hard, i started my "anime career" kinda late so was on the catch up train and was watching quite a lot of stuff which most of them/half/quarter now would've just skipped. But now that i watched it i view it as an experience and my watched number is pretty high (at least i think so) which is a self-satisfaction i guess :D. And thanks to people who are doing these challenges, was pretty interesting and i'll probably participate again and mb even try to complete medium (the year seems pretty promising). And i think i will/might try manga challenge (for some reason i think that it might be easier for me as i follow quite a lot of stuff). And Happy New Year everyone! |
 |
Jounin_Katie said: Sorry, I don't know if this is the best place to ask this, I'm kinda new to the forums.. but is there gonna be another one of these this year? I didn't find out about this until it was too late and it seems really fun! ^^ Also happy new year! Yes, last years sing up threads were posted in January 5, so this year is probably gonna be the same, you can already start watching anime/reading manga tho. |
 |
SheyCroix said: jet2r0cks said: Hey @SheyCroix, thanks again for your hard work. I just have a few questions about what you wrote. My username is in the part 3 list - are we the ones you contacted for revisions? And what do you mean by "This only includes that the titles selected actually fit the with the specific item"? And when you say you didn't check our lists, do you mean you didn't re-check our revisions or you didn't check thoroughly? Everyone that had something to fix was contacted for revisions. As stated, those added to " part 3 " had only their sign-up revised to check the anime used fits with what that specific item asks for. It also mean that given the time left I didn't check the anime list, meaning that I didn't compare the sign up form with the anime list to see if they actually watched or not the anime used, neither if they watched it during the challenge period. This was something done for everyone else part of part 1 and part 2. If someone had revisions, yes, I checked the forms to see the change reflected there. So those in part 1 and 2 didn't need revisions at all? |
| ^_^ |
jet2r0cks said: of course they did, and some quite a lot. The difference lies in that for them I went to check every single anime used for the challenge in their anime list (titles completed and start/end date).So those in part 1 and 2 didn't need revisions at all? |
| After failing miserably at completing the 2016 challenge; do you guys think its fair to use stuff that I haven't even touched for this year version? |
 |
| Thanks for the great work SheyCroix! :) |
  |
SheyCroix said: by that you mean anime you wanted to use but didn't start watching? Yes, just had then listed for the challenge. But haven't started or seen any episode at all. |
|
Phil_Murray said: Thanks for the great work SheyCroix! :) (^_^)/ jhoson14 said: Yes, just had then listed for the challenge. But haven't started or seen any episode at all. There shouldn't be any complain if it's like that. I plan to do the same with some I listed for the manga challenge but didn't have the time to actually read them. |
SheyCroixJan 2, 2017 8:00 PM
| The last days went by so fast that I didn't have time to post the separate turn-in form for my participation so is there a possibility to do that anymore since the thread is now closed? |
| "Oh, I wasn't trying to be funny.. I would've put a 'Haha' at the end of it." |
xXAnimefanXxx said: The challenge for 2016 is over as the thread is locked. If you failed to complete it or forgot to turn in your form, you failed the challenge.The last days went by so fast that I didn't have time to post the separate turn-in form for my participation so is there a possibility to do that anymore since the thread is now closed? |
 » "You've fought a valiant duel, my friend..." « ⍏⍏⍏⍏⍏ inspector @ MAL's anime watching challenge |
| Is there going to be an Anime Watching Challenge 2017? Can't find any info about it. |
Lixaxy said: Is there going to be an Anime Watching Challenge 2017? Can't find any info about it. Yes, but its not been posted yet. The 2016 one wasn't posted until the 5th, so I wouldn't expect the 2017 one until then this year. It takes quite a lot to organise. |
  |
| Here's hoping that 2017's has some more unique challenges rather than just being 80% the previous year's challenges. |
Wallflower said: Would re-watching from the start make it possible to count?Queeg_500 said: I imagine the answer will be no If you started them in 2016 as that's how the rules worked for it in the past.For this year's challenge can you use anime where you've already seen 1-2 eps? I have a bunch of anime where I've just seen the first episode and decided to save them for later, and I wouldn't mind using a few. |
  |
RulenneClarissa said: I think yes, but the start date on your list entry should still be the current year????Wallflower said: Would re-watching from the start make it possible to count?I imagine the answer will be no If you started them in 2016 as that's how the rules worked for it in the past. |
 |
More topics from this board
» How do you deal with (subjectively) bad endings and developments of your favorite shows or their sources? ( 1 2 )RobertBobert - Nov 14 |
50 |
by JizzyHitler
»»
18 seconds ago |
|
» Japan is being forced to censor Anime and Manga... What do you think? ( 1 2 3 4 )Dije - Nov 11 |
157 |
by thewiru
»»
14 minutes ago |
|
» Fan DecensorsJackson1333 - Yesterday |
6 |
by DesuMaiden
»»
16 minutes ago |
|
» Most overrated waifus?Mattenan - Nov 19, 2023 |
49 |
by TheSuave
»»
25 minutes ago |
|
» 🎖️Opening of all time & discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )nirererin - Nov 8 |
432 |
by mo_lave
»»
25 minutes ago |