| Gantz! |
OTOhime said: They missed out all the good bits in the manga so it automatically sucks. Plus the animation was YUCK.Definitely Negima =_="" |
 |
| I agree. Negima is the perfect example. |
     |
T0sh1k1 said: Black cat QFT The Tsubasa anime was also disappointing... |
 |
| I guess Ken Akamatsu and Tanemura Arina's works just dont translate well into anime :P |
| Tsubasa Chronicles, Death Note and most definitely Naruto. Too much phail in that one. |
 |
| i never read mangas so there should be an anime version of every manga :/ |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| Negima!? |
     |
| Rosario+Vampire |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| Tsubasa.. |
| ONE WORD, Death Note. ..Gawd damn, kill me now. -_- |
katsup said: I guess Ken Akamatsu and Tanemura Arina's works just dont translate well into anime :P Well, I've read the Full Moon manga and watched the anime, and I think that that series is actually an exception. The anime is good, and the animation isn't screwed up 8lik in KKJ) Esxcept from that I would agree with you. KK Jeanne Should have stayed a manga. The anime is so horrible, both the animation and the story is bad. |
 |
| One Piece |
E_chan said: katsup said: I guess Ken Akamatsu and Tanemura Arina's works just dont translate well into anime :P Well, I've read the Full Moon manga and watched the anime, and I think that that series is actually an exception. The anime is good, and the animation isn't screwed up 8lik in KKJ) Esxcept from that I would agree with you. KK Jeanne Should have stayed a manga. The anime is so horrible, both the animation and the story is bad. fullmoon anime isnt bad but it has a completely different "atmosphere/feeling" to it than the manga. Its much more childlike in the anime than the manga. but yeah, its a good adaptation of arina's work, (especially when you compare it to KKJ ;.; poor poor kkj ) |
| I agree with a few titles here. Naruto Shipuden is defiantly better as a manga, infact its the first series that i have dropped as an anime to pick up as a manga. (not a big manga guy). I would not say claymore was a bad anime adaption, it was my favorite anime by far. They just completely ruined the last 6 or so episodes to make some closure of the story. How can anyone say that FMA was a bad anime, everyone loved it.. rated really high. Back when i was watching FMA anime, everyone said the FMA was a really bad manga.. |
 |
| Paradise Kiss...also Clover. I mean, two-thirds of what makes the manga so good is in the way it's drawn, with the disconnected panels and use of negative space. |
 |
Frenz said: How can anyone say that FMA was a bad anime, everyone loved it.. rated really high. Back when i was watching FMA anime, everyone said the FMA was a really bad manga.. Well since the anime and manga branch off in story, there are some great exclusive characters in each adaptation. Perhaps they didn't like the change. |
malefactress said: Paradise Kiss...also Clover. I mean, two-thirds of what makes the manga so good is in the way it's drawn, with the disconnected panels and use of negative space. why did you say paradise kiss? i'm curious :3 I haven't had a chance to read the manga yet, but from what i hear it follows the manga extremely close. On top of that, the animation in it is actually quite good. of course its not as good as the manga drawings, and the usage of negative space and such really is something that can only be pulled off in manga. I don't know, i really liked the paradise kiss anime a lot. They did a really good job with the narration, which is sort of what the disconnected panels in ai yazawa's works are for. ohman, i'm ranting now.... D= |
| Oh, the disconnected panels and negative space bit were about Clover. XD But no, I love ParaKiss...I guess I just don't see the point of animating it, when it stuck so closely to the manga, and when the manga is drawn so beautifully. I'm really more adamant about Clover, though. ^^; |
|
malefactress said: Oh, the disconnected panels and negative space bit were about Clover. XD But no, I love ParaKiss...I guess I just don't see the point of animating it, when it stuck so closely to the manga, and when the manga is drawn so beautifully. I'm really more adamant about Clover, though. ^^; ohhh i see ^^;;; lol well clover's anime adaptation was like... not even a real adaptation. it was that bad =P |
| xxxholic |
 |
| As much as I love CLAMP I would have to say Tsubasa Chronicle should have just stayed a manga. |
| Tsuba Chronicles and probably Vampire Knight if they dont do anything about that animation -_- |
 |
hanabiii said: Tsuba Chronicles and probably Vampire Knight if they dont do anything about that animation -_- Agree (Vampire Knight). VK manga is better than VK anime -_-" |
| This is a hard one, i've actually got a few...probably Naruto. I should be more clear by saying it should never have gotten american VOs. :p But besides that I can't think of any right now. |
| Samurai Deeper Kyo, they made so many changes in the anime... |
desiprince said: although there are a bunch of anime which are worse to their manga counterparts i think its nice to have both lies... LIES! do you know how many people probably think lowly of Tsubasa Chronicles now!? bad anime do so much damage to good manga, unfortunately. |
  |
| Tokyo Mew Mew |
| Aishiteruze Baby is definitely my top one... ugh the animation was horrible, the voice acting was horrible... I about cried just watching the first episode. The manga was such a beautiful, cute story and that was the only thing that carried the anime. Next would be Special A. I didn't like the drawing style of the anime and the humor seemed to fall pretty flat. |
     |
| Fruits Basket |
 |
| Katekyo Hitman Reborn - oh they just ruined yamamoto Eyeshield 21 - i was wonderin if sena really looked like THAT Tsubasa Chronicles - horrible. plain horrible drawing. same w/ xxxholic. |
 |
| definitely naruto. so many fillers; it was horrible x_x |
     |
| Lunar Legend Tsukihime, even though the anime came first. The manga is much more accurate to the game than the anime is |
 |
| Tsubasa Chronicle, Rurouni Kenshin, Bleach... the list goes on |
 |
| Chrno Crusade, I HATE the anime with a passion. The ending was a total bummer... >_> |
| Bleach and Naruto |
| Samurai Deeper Kyo and Negima. |
accela said: Tsubasa Chronicles Dear lord. YES. >: |
| avatar made by akihito @ livejournal.com |
| Angel Sanctuary. The anime being just an OVA doesn't do it justice. |
| We are made of star stuff. We are a way for the cosmos to know itself. - Carl Sagan |
| Air Gear and Vampire Knight |
     |
| Tsubasa and Lucky Star. It was cuter without all those horrible 'otaku' gimmicks. |
 |
accela said: Tsubasa Chronicles Dear lord. Definitely agreed. The manga wasn't all that bad, and then the anime came. It's awful. |
| <img src="http://manga.tokyo/wp/wp-content/uploads/2016/02/318963e6e6d19177d77a3e23e528527e.jpg" border="0" /> |
| I totally agree with Tsubasa Chronicles!! The first season was good and I like it, but the second season wasn't worth it... then they cancelled the third season where the story begin to be really good and instead they just did 3 episodes for the OVA... :( I really like the manga, but the anime was so-so and they completely change the story at the end of the second season... |
| I say Angel Sanctuary Calvero said: Full Metal Alchemist. They changed it to much. Some of the Changes just didn't make any sense And the ending was terrible. Haven't completely finish to read the manga yet but I didn't find the anime that bad.. |
     |
lops-sama said: The manga should never been created either.Bleach and Naruto |
More topics from this board
» Do you collect physical copies of manga?DesuMaiden - Sep 6 |
43 |
by SkullKn1ght
»»
3 hours ago |
|
Sticky: » 2024 Manga Reading Challenge - Sign Up ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )MRC_mod - Jan 18 |
450 |
by NUGAzz
»»
Yesterday, 4:05 PM |
|
» Action manga with few panels per pageLineagon - Yesterday |
1 |
by ScaryOwl
»»
Yesterday, 1:51 PM |
|
» Do you miss pre-webtoon era manhwa/manhua?Eternal-Destiny - Sep 16 |
3 |
by MullerVon
»»
Yesterday, 12:19 AM |
|
Poll: » Anime Movies QuestionScaryOwl - Sep 15 |
8 |
by ghostsamurai
»»
Sep 17, 3:50 PM |