| Can we please just stop? What I mean stop is something like this: **New series came out** "Ah it's an isekai" "Ah, it's a harem" "Ah it's a strong MC" "IT MUST BE TRASHHH" You see, this is very annoying since a prejudice for isekai is too strong these days. Fucking shield hero and mushoku tensei can be regarded as generic as well if you just see the basic plotline and background but in the end are they really "generic"? Try to watch at least half of the show toll you judge and made fair score, for god's sake. |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| This thing sells, people in Japan want it, so they are making more. |
 |
| I had literally seen some youtuber a famous one i think many of you know him as he just read the synopsis and as soon as he read it's an isekai he was just like oh man this is gonna be another trash coming out to bore us.. |
 |
| agree. i thought that this show would be bad and generic but it’s been great so far. |
 |
Arthagrawal said: I had literally seen some youtuber a famous one i think many of you know him as he just read the synopsis and as soon as he read it's an isekai he was just like oh man this is gonna be another trash coming out to bore us.. Joey the anime man? |
| Everyday I find myself asking this: "What's the general consensus if people just say it's trash and don't like the show for what it is?" It's people's perceptions, not yours, so don't be a sandwich idiot to keep reiterating that they should follow your tastes. Everyone is built differently, and that is diversity. |
 |
whiters99 said: Can we please just stop? What I mean stop is something like this: **New series came out** "Ah it's an isekai" "Ah, it's a harem" "Ah it's a strong MC" "IT MUST BE TRASHHH" You see, this is very annoying since a prejudice for isekai is too strong these days. Fucking shield hero and mushoku tensei can be regarded as generic as well if you just see the basic plotline and background but in the end are they really "generic"? Try to watch at least half of the show toll you judge and made fair score, for god's sake. Oh, I thought this thread was meant to trashtalk the isekai genre... While I do agree on your statements of wanting to stop the judgementality but I do feel like you're adding more fuel into their desires. Ex of a story of an Isekai I am currently love named Death March, it has below 7 score here in MAL but I still love how the story revolves around each characters and it is still ongoing. Instead of complaining to other people how to view the story, its more good to educate them instead of complaining I think. I really don't meant any offense to any of you here reading this message. tee-hee P.S. Death March has a very similar world or atmosphere of Seirei Gensouki, that's why I came to like it at the start. |
| It's not that I dislike this genre but... to add unnecessary fan services to/in/for heroines and ultimately destroys her character and personality; their purity tarnished because of it, is the only thing I hope to not happen to them. For that sole purity is my fan service. |
astralkill00 said: P.S. Death March has a very similar world or atmosphere of Seirei Gensouki, that's why I came to like it at the start. Boy sure they have think i am two episode behind to finish Death March anime and being upto date with Seirei Gensouki anime and when i opened episode 1 disunion here first thing i saw these being compared |
| People wouldn't think so badly of Isekai anime if they didn't pump out a lot shitty/ripoff every season(this is apply to the new ones, not like Rezero, Konosuba Shield Hero etc). They all are like recycle products, like same plot, same character, same nonsensical anime logic (OP MC, dumb girls falling with him/her) and we got the same old crap over and over So what I'm saying is as long as Isekai anime keep making thrash people are gonna keep hating it |
RedChromeJul 20, 2021 2:09 AM
| I mean, I think this is trash because it feels like a ripoff of Shield Hero. Not because it’s an isekai, but because it borrows too many major attributes from it like discrimination. Although it does have some unique aspects like the better magic system. |
under”Mebius” is my salvation  |
whiters99 said: Can we please just stop? What I mean stop is something like this: **New series came out** "Ah it's an isekai" "Ah, it's a harem" "Ah it's a strong MC" "IT MUST BE TRASHHH" You see, this is very annoying since a prejudice for isekai is too strong these days. Fucking shield hero and mushoku tensei can be regarded as generic as well if you just see the basic plotline and background but in the end are they really "generic"? Try to watch at least half of the show toll you judge and made fair score, for god's sake. First episode was good actually but then it turned into a typical harem trash isekai with overpowered MC. |
| Aahh, Isekai fatigue |
 |
| oh yeah, let's hate, let's hate, let's hate. Over and over again. Seriously guys, if you really don't like it, just ignore it, add it in your drop list instead of making a fuss. You guys can complain all you want---just create your own story. Let's us see if it can even be adapted to anime or be recognized to have an anime. (Is my thought process right now). Yes, read my message, if you understood it, it clearly states. "It was gladly recognize and loved by many people and that's why it was animated" |
| It's not that I dislike this genre but... to add unnecessary fan services to/in/for heroines and ultimately destroys her character and personality; their purity tarnished because of it, is the only thing I hope to not happen to them. For that sole purity is my fan service. |
| Isekai hater is pretty a KAREN. Freaking annoying...but since they're karens, they ain't stop like their instinct tell him not to. >They still struggle to find a better genre to pick up. There's no cure for this. Maybe they just not happy with their life irl. Not sure why they would rather pick up isekai than yaoi/shounen ai. Just pick up something else and move up. |
| MALoween✟Mansion (2024) Candy Basket 🎃: |
| And it probably is trash and will prove everybody right. The End. My heart is only apathy. |
 |
whiters99 said: Can we please just stop? What I mean stop is something like this: **New series came out** "Ah it's an isekai" "Ah, it's a harem" "Ah it's a strong MC" "IT MUST BE TRASHHH" You see, this is very annoying since a prejudice for isekai is too strong these days. Fucking shield hero and mushoku tensei can be regarded as generic as well if you just see the basic plotline and background but in the end are they really "generic"? Try to watch at least half of the show toll you judge and made fair score, for god's sake. While this is true, this show certainly is 1/10 trash with zero to no redeeming or innovative quality. I'm at ep 5 and don't think I can stand another second. Slime and Tensei both did something well. Tensei followed a somewhat generic plotline (with decent twists) but did so perfectly and should be looked at as an example on how the generic plotline should be done. Slime did the generic harem power-MC but did something cool about it by following him on a journey to build a nation from scratch. This show does... nothing, and it does it poorly. Main character has the exact design of Kirito from SAO. After the most forced "escape" from the school he becomes shield-kun from Shield hero and adopts a slave-girl that looks exactly as Raf from that show. The fights are so dumb you have to laugh, they literally loop the same animation shamelessly over and over (see fight with taurus early on). When they have actual non-repeated animations it looks like still images stop-motioned across the screen with loud shouts to make it seem more animated. The characters are the most one dimensional I've ever seen. 5 years time skip in the first episode and everything is exactly the same but everyone is a little larger, when even before the time skip he had managed to become the best at everything in his class? dumb. The kidnapping in the first episode is so dumb I almost cried. It comes down to someone kidnapping and torturing someone because they didn't let him finish a sentence. And it happens again in ep. 5. "say this exact thing I made up or I'll keep hitting you with a stick!" "but I'm telling you this is what happene...." *stick* - repeat. So dumb. Nowhere in real life have I ever met anyone who so quickly resorts to a rage-induced violence for the dumbest of no reason as every single character, except the harem-girls, in this show. If there ever has been a dumpster fire of a show, this one is it. Complete trash. Don't watch it, your instincts are correct. Giving a show more than a few episodes isn't necessary to determine the quality of what you are watching. All this proves is that MAL scores means nothing and should be completely ignored. |
PoffpoffAug 17, 2021 4:56 PM
whiters99 said: Tbh, i dont hate these kind of anime, sometime i just watch because there nothing to watch, i hate that anime type because its just the same, op mc get harem, there is a lot, but sometime, i love this kind of anime, like my fav "Isekai Wa Smartphone" where i rewatch that anime multiple times, its a 50:50 situation really, idk,but that is my reviewCan we please just stop? What I mean stop is something like this: **New series came out** "Ah it's an isekai" "Ah, it's a harem" "Ah it's a strong MC" "IT MUST BE TRASHHH" You see, this is very annoying since a prejudice for isekai is too strong these days. Fucking shield hero and mushoku tensei can be regarded as generic as well if you just see the basic plotline and background but in the end are they really "generic"? Try to watch at least half of the show toll you judge and made fair score, for god's sake. |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Seirei Gensouki Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )Stark700 - Sep 20, 2021 |
159 |
by GooseHybrid
»»
Yesterday, 3:00 PM |
|
Poll: » Seirei Gensouki Episode 10 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - Sep 6, 2021 |
71 |
by GooseHybrid
»»
Nov 19, 10:31 AM |
|
Poll: » Seirei Gensouki Episode 9 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - Aug 30, 2021 |
87 |
by GooseHybrid
»»
Nov 18, 10:23 AM |
|
Poll: » Seirei Gensouki Episode 5 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - Aug 2, 2021 |
75 |
by Smokey_Lunge420
»»
Oct 15, 4:47 PM |
|
Poll: » Seirei Gensouki Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )Stark700 - Jul 5, 2021 |
138 |
by tamittam9
»»
Oct 12, 11:02 PM |