Forum Settings
Forums
New
May 4, 2019 5:09 AM
#1

Offline
Jan 2019
2094
After watching Violet Evergarden and scrolling through forums about it on multiple websites, I noticed that a large portion of its audience think that Gilbert is a paedophile. I fully understand that Gilbert's love for Violet is born out of kindness and I am willing to argue with anyone who thinks otherwise but many people seem to think of it as a romantic kind of love. Sure, perception is a thing but, taking things the wrong way is also a thing.

Have you seen any anime or anime character you think is misunderstood by a fair number of people?


Sing for the reluctant heroes
Oh give me your strength
Your lives are too short
Sing for the reluctant heroes
I wanna be brave like you



Pages (2) [1] 2 »
May 4, 2019 5:15 AM
#2

Offline
Jul 2017
1759
griffith, boi just wanted to smack dat gut's ass while dis boi went on some psychological metaphysical trip, well they both went on some psychological metaphysical trip so in the end alls well dat ends well
May 4, 2019 5:51 AM
#3

Offline
Apr 2019
1163
After the Rain

I bet you that many people skipped that anime just because of the cover art and sypnosis, when it's actually truly one of the most light-hearted anime's I watched.







May 4, 2019 6:02 AM
#4

Offline
May 2013
1739
Pretty sure there's plenty of such instances.

The most common ones I see are Shinji from Evangelion, Subaru from Re-zero, Okabe and Mayuri from Steins;Gate, just to name a few.
May 4, 2019 6:18 AM
#5

Offline
Oct 2008
8644
First of all I am one of the people who think that Gilbert's love was romantic (sexual) towards Violet and find it perfectly exeptable.

Kiriyama Rei
Handa-kun

If you want more tell me.
May 4, 2019 6:30 AM
#6
Offline
Jul 2018
561864
Luffy, not really a misunderstanding but not many people know this. Oda said in an SBS(basically a Q&A) that Luffy doesn't kill his enemies because he would rather see them suffer for their actions rather than getting a peaceful death, pretty dark
May 4, 2019 6:34 AM
#7

Offline
Apr 2017
680
KreatorX said:
Pretty sure there's plenty of such instances.

The most common ones I see are Shinji from Evangelion, Subaru from Re-zero, Okabe and Mayuri from Steins;Gate, just to name a few.
how is Subaru misunderstood, sorry I try not to read on the forums too much, I'd get too pissed off

『 The truth has power because it’s the truth.
And because it is the truth, that makes it just.
It’s persuasive, isn’t it? Don’t you want truth like that? 』

May 4, 2019 6:38 AM
#8

Offline
Apr 2017
680
BananiSandwich said:
After watching Violet Evergarden and scrolling through forums about it on multiple websites, I noticed that a large portion of its audience think that Gilbert is a paedophile. I fully understand that Gilbert's love for Violet is born out of kindness and I am willing to argue with anyone who thinks otherwise but many people seem to think of it as a romantic kind of love. Sure, perception is a thing but, taking things the wrong way is also a thing.

Have you seen any anime or anime character you think is misunderstood by a fair number of people?
Dear God, there are people who think that ?! Good I try to stay away from these forums as much as possible.

Hmm, Light, for example, didn't inherently want to save the world through his actions, it was all about getting rid of his boredom.

And also Gilgamesh, most people just pass him off as an "arrogant asshole".

『 The truth has power because it’s the truth.
And because it is the truth, that makes it just.
It’s persuasive, isn’t it? Don’t you want truth like that? 』

May 4, 2019 6:45 AM
#9

Offline
Sep 2018
31
Gintama.
Everyone assumes it's all a gag & comedy fest (a fair portion is), when in actual fact the comedy is merely a subset to the serious plot devices it entails. They misunderstand the series from its exaggerative comedy & sometimes crude humour for the true story Gintama is telling; they are merely building up their characters and making you indulge in their personalities & relationships, for the serious moments that'll make you cry your eyes out.
Same thing goes for the characters, although you'd think that'd be quite easy to understand.

I think just a lot of people confuse themselves too easily, or are too used to anime that lacks development.
May 4, 2019 6:49 AM

Offline
Oct 2012
2104
Shinji of course. I get it, Eva is not everyone's kind of show, but man the shit people say about Shinji specifically sometimes smh. Like yes please tell me all about how badass you would have been if you were forced to fight in a violent war as a traumatized, alienated 14 year old.
May 4, 2019 6:56 AM
Offline
Apr 2016
203
JoJo's Bizarre Adventure, despite being known as the "meme" and "over the top" battle shounen anime, does have thematic depth later on, especially prominent in Part 5 onwards. The series is about fate and legacy, and also as Will A. Zeppeli says, "Courage is a marvel of humanity!" - JoJo is also about the beauty of humanity. Fate cannot be changed, instead of letting fate dictate our actions, we should courageously follow our beliefs and goals, and we can inspire others to pass on this will and courage and change the world for the better. That is the thesis of JoJo.
May 4, 2019 7:06 AM
Offline
Feb 2019
17
Ecchi Anime.
People expect so much on this shows, even though it was just fanservice but still some show good potential that made it popular but boi
May 4, 2019 7:19 AM

Offline
Aug 2018
2241
Kuraya said:
KreatorX said:
Pretty sure there's plenty of such instances.

The most common ones I see are Shinji from Evangelion, Subaru from Re-zero, Okabe and Mayuri from Steins;Gate, just to name a few.
how is Subaru misunderstood, sorry I try not to read on the forums too much, I'd get too pissed off
The most common are "he is useless", "he is an asshole" and "he is a pussy".

Useless because he is a normal kid with no money nor connections, so "failing" is dumb... bot imo, that is normal.

Asshole, because they way he acted during a couple of episodes when he broke... imo, all the things that happened to him are actually things that can break a normal kid.

Pussy, be cause he is afraid of dying... this one is the most retarded reason I've heard, and one of the mos common one... appearently, if you "could" revive (Subaru can't control that) you shouldn't care about death... but when most people hit their pinky toe they cry like bitches...
May 4, 2019 7:31 AM

Offline
May 2013
1739
Kuraya said:
KreatorX said:
Pretty sure there's plenty of such instances.

The most common ones I see are Shinji from Evangelion, Subaru from Re-zero, Okabe and Mayuri from Steins;Gate, just to name a few.
how is Subaru misunderstood, sorry I try not to read on the forums too much, I'd get too pissed off

Yeah, plenty of it starts from him being "obsessed" with Emilia, him being whiny, him acting like a absolute idiot, him "not doing anything about his situation", "that fucker rejected Rem", the list goes on..

Many don't even get the base idea that the character is designed to be someone who is borderline fixated on escapism, suffers from low interpersonal skills due to being a NEET, treats everything around him as a videogame/anime/manga since that's how he thinks people around him behave. The also skimp on the idea that such people fear social rejection, especially more from someone they like.

It's funny, because many of the above people watched and enjoyed the mindset of the main character in Welcome to NHK, when Subaru in Re-zero is just a different version of Satou in a nutshell. Re-zero then takes a different trajectory with such a main character in an isekai with a videogame checkpoint like plot device.

DaCraziGuy said:

Pussy, be cause he is afraid of dying... this one is the most retarded reason I've heard, and one of the mos common one... appearently, if you "could" revive (Subaru can't control that) you shouldn't care about death... but when most people hit their pinky toe they cry like bitches...

LOL
KreatorXMay 4, 2019 7:51 AM
May 4, 2019 7:58 AM

Offline
Apr 2017
680
DaCraziGuy said:
Kuraya said:
how is Subaru misunderstood, sorry I try not to read on the forums too much, I'd get too pissed off
The most common are "he is useless", "he is an asshole" and "he is a pussy".

Useless because he is a normal kid with no money nor connections, so "failing" is dumb... bot imo, that is normal.

Asshole, because they way he acted during a couple of episodes when he broke... imo, all the things that happened to him are actually things that can break a normal kid.

Pussy, be cause he is afraid of dying... this one is the most retarded reason I've heard, and one of the mos common one... appearently, if you "could" revive (Subaru can't control that) you shouldn't care about death... but when most people hit their pinky toe they cry like bitches...
Dear God, I'm shocked by stupidity even though I know what peaks it can reach.

First off Subaru is not the most normal or common of people. At least after he was transported he was extremely social and optimistic. Why would anyone even bring up money if he was transported to another world tf

It's not a matter of opinion anyway, and you are underestimating his experience.
It's basically impossible for the human mind to withstand all the physical and psychological damage he went through. Subaru is extremely OP in this remark.

And that's retarded AF, what the actual shit. It's not about just reviving after. I can't pose facts here but for humans death is a one time experience. It's not just about the physical pain that causes the death, the simple sensing of death approaching you from all directions one time could make a person go crazy, Subaru has experienced that time and time again.

He's character is just incredible, I love him.

『 The truth has power because it’s the truth.
And because it is the truth, that makes it just.
It’s persuasive, isn’t it? Don’t you want truth like that? 』

May 4, 2019 8:03 AM
Offline
Jul 2018
561864
I often thought Hachiman is one of those. It's somehow eerie to me how some people, who identify with him, see him as some type of idol for themselves.
I see him as a lonely young man, who wrote the essay at the beginning out of bitterness and because he was judgemental towards people, since he didn't have much experiences with human relationships and imagined things about them to feel better about himself. He is one of those, who didn't know what it's like to have someone close to them and how it feels like, but he subconsciously wishes to (he said himself he wants something genuine), so he tries to protect himself by his made-up logic. He is, to me, one of the textbook person for overcompensating with arrogance and repression.
I mean, he starts to think about others too and what's wrong with himself.
But some people I saw, view him as their perfect role model, who can't do no wrong and this is pretty much a "wtf, have we watched the same anime" to me, although I understand which kind of person thinks like that.


And in general: Some people would call everything "whiny" that gives any hint of a human flaw and normal reactions to events (I mean, the not so cool flaws and normal reactions).
removed-userMay 4, 2019 8:16 AM
May 4, 2019 8:09 AM

Offline
Feb 2010
34616
Lmao, Violet is too old so even if he had a boner for her it would not be pedophilia. People really like to demonstrate their complete failure to understand basic concepts and what they mean.

That being said yeah, it was also pretty obviously not anything romantic per se, if anything her feelings towards him might have been of that nature but then again she was so confused and inept when it comes to feelings that she probably wouldn't be able to tell the difference between amicable and romantic love. This feels more like something that belongs in this thread:

https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1780533

Less of a difference in opinion and more of a complete misinterpretation of the whole show.
I probably regret this post by now.
May 4, 2019 8:17 AM

Offline
Feb 2010
34616
Maneki-Mew said:
I often thought Hachiman is one of those. It's somehow eerie to me how some people, who identify with him, see him as some type of idol for themselves.
I see him as a lonely young man, who wrote the essay at the beginning out of bitterness and because he was judgemental towards people, since he didn't have much experiences with human relationships and imagined things about them to feel better about himself. He is one of those, who didn't know what it's like to have someone close to them and how it feels like, but he subconsciously wishes to (he said himself he wants something genuine), so he tries to protect himself by his made-up logic. He is, to me, one of the textbook person for overcompensating with arrogance and repression.
I mean, he starts to think about others too and what's wrong with himself.
But some people I saw, view him as their perfect role model.


I also have seen very few people whose opinion on Hachiman aligns with mine, that goes both for the people who idealize him and for the people who hate him. I relate to him a lot, but probably not in the way that most of his fans do. More in the way that his personality, his insecurity and his worldviews are inherently setting him up so he'll always sabotage his own happiness and he kinda knows it but there's nothing he can really do about it because changing those things would just turn him into a different person and he doesn't want that either. He both hates and likes who he is, because while it'll probably keep him miserable for most of his life, being any other way would just be even worse for him.

I could probably write a few more paragraphs on him, but I don't have the time and energy right now. I just wanted to mention that I think he's a great example since most of the praise and criticism people throw at him sounds to me like they're talking about a different person compared to how I perceive him.
I probably regret this post by now.
May 4, 2019 8:34 AM
Offline
Jul 2018
561864
Pullman said:
Maneki-Mew said:
I often thought Hachiman is one of those. It's somehow eerie to me how some people, who identify with him, see him as some type of idol for themselves.
I see him as a lonely young man, who wrote the essay at the beginning out of bitterness and because he was judgemental towards people, since he didn't have much experiences with human relationships and imagined things about them to feel better about himself. He is one of those, who didn't know what it's like to have someone close to them and how it feels like, but he subconsciously wishes to (he said himself he wants something genuine), so he tries to protect himself by his made-up logic. He is, to me, one of the textbook person for overcompensating with arrogance and repression.
I mean, he starts to think about others too and what's wrong with himself.
But some people I saw, view him as their perfect role model.


I also have seen very few people whose opinion on Hachiman aligns with mine, that goes both for the people who idealize him and for the people who hate him. I relate to him a lot, but probably not in the way that most of his fans do. More in the way that his personality, his insecurity and his worldviews are inherently setting him up so he'll always sabotage his own happiness and he kinda knows it but there's nothing he can really do about it because changing those things would just turn him into a different person and he doesn't want that either. He both hates and likes who he is, because while it'll probably keep him miserable for most of his life, being any other way would just be even worse for him.

I could probably write a few more paragraphs on him, but I don't have the time and energy right now. I just wanted to mention that I think he's a great example since most of the praise and criticism people throw at him sounds to me like they're talking about a different person compared to how I perceive him.

Well, it wasn't exactly criticism. That's how I perceived him and I really came to like him too. At first as character, and as soon as he gave hints that he could be better than that, as a person as well.

This makes sense too. He kinda doesn't know how to be a different person, because it's scary to "lose" parts of yourself and he has been like that for a long time. So, it became a habit to be like that.
I understand to relate to him in these ways. Also I think many people have mastered sabotaging themselves in different ways.

Just thought that the "this is the perfect guy"-perceptions aren't what his development and the show wanted to show.
May 4, 2019 9:03 AM
Offline
Jul 2018
561864
Ginti (Death Parade) did nothing wrong.



What good is that for reincarnation? Why should someone who wasted their life and stood by that waste until the very end get reincarnation?
May 4, 2019 9:22 AM

Offline
Aug 2018
2241
Kuraya said:
DaCraziGuy said:
The most common are "he is useless", "he is an asshole" and "he is a pussy".

Useless because he is a normal kid with no money nor connections, so "failing" is dumb... bot imo, that is normal.

Asshole, because they way he acted during a couple of episodes when he broke... imo, all the things that happened to him are actually things that can break a normal kid.

Pussy, be cause he is afraid of dying... this one is the most retarded reason I've heard, and one of the mos common one... appearently, if you "could" revive (Subaru can't control that) you shouldn't care about death... but when most people hit their pinky toe they cry like bitches...
Dear God, I'm shocked by stupidity even though I know what peaks it can reach.

First off Subaru is not the most normal or common of people. At least after he was transported he was extremely social and optimistic. Why would anyone even bring up money if he was transported to another world tf

It's not a matter of opinion anyway, and you are underestimating his experience.
It's basically impossible for the human mind to withstand all the physical and psychological damage he went through. Subaru is extremely OP in this remark.

And that's retarded AF, what the actual shit. It's not about just reviving after. I can't pose facts here but for humans death is a one time experience. It's not just about the physical pain that causes the death, the simple sensing of death approaching you from all directions one time could make a person go crazy, Subaru has experienced that time and time again.

He's character is just incredible, I love him.
I like him too, sadly most kids (not all of them) and some delusional adults can't enjoy realistic characters. The sense of failing or struggling seems dumb in their minds, or that living can actually change you personality or line of thoughs. But well, all I can say is: "fuck them, we got second season" hahahah
May 4, 2019 9:29 AM

Offline
Aug 2018
2241
Pullman said:
Lmao, Violet is too old so even if he had a boner for her it would not be pedophilia. People really like to demonstrate their complete failure to understand basic concepts and what they mean.
wasn't she around 13-14 yo? That is pretty pedo imo. 16 is a more understandable age... even 15 in some cases, but less than that seems pretty crazy to be considered "safe".

If you were being sarcastic tho, ignore my comment.
May 4, 2019 9:30 AM

Offline
Apr 2017
680
DaCraziGuy said:
Kuraya said:
Dear God, I'm shocked by stupidity even though I know what peaks it can reach.

First off Subaru is not the most normal or common of people. At least after he was transported he was extremely social and optimistic. Why would anyone even bring up money if he was transported to another world tf

It's not a matter of opinion anyway, and you are underestimating his experience.
It's basically impossible for the human mind to withstand all the physical and psychological damage he went through. Subaru is extremely OP in this remark.

And that's retarded AF, what the actual shit. It's not about just reviving after. I can't pose facts here but for humans death is a one time experience. It's not just about the physical pain that causes the death, the simple sensing of death approaching you from all directions one time could make a person go crazy, Subaru has experienced that time and time again.

He's character is just incredible, I love him.
I like him too, sadly most kids (not all of them) and some delusional adults can't enjoy realistic characters. The sense of failing or struggling seems dumb in their minds, or that living can actually change you personality or line of thoughs. But well, all I can say is: "fuck them, we got second season" hahahah
I'm a kid too so I appreciate the parentheses.

lol, that's true, hah, still haven't completely grasped the notion of "Re:Zero 2nd season".
Even so, if the second season does what I expect it will be fucking amazing

『 The truth has power because it’s the truth.
And because it is the truth, that makes it just.
It’s persuasive, isn’t it? Don’t you want truth like that? 』

May 4, 2019 9:47 AM

Offline
Feb 2010
34616
DaCraziGuy said:
Pullman said:
Lmao, Violet is too old so even if he had a boner for her it would not be pedophilia. People really like to demonstrate their complete failure to understand basic concepts and what they mean.
wasn't she around 13-14 yo? That is pretty pedo imo. 16 is a more understandable age... even 15 in some cases, but less than that seems pretty crazy to be considered "safe".

If you were being sarcastic tho, ignore my comment.


Well, IIRC the anime itself doesn't specific because she doesn't knowher own age so all we get in the anime is her 'guess'. But she sure doesn't seem/look like 14 to me, more like 16+.

But also the definition of pedophilia has nothing to do with being 'understandable' or not. It's by definition about prepubescent children only, meaning before the onset of puberty, so 12 at the oldest, usually younger. There are other medical terms for attraction to other age groups, but in any case neither of them are related to age of consent laws which can vary depending on the country (14yo is legal in my country for example, in many others it isn't) but instead invariable medical definitions. I don't know about you, but the common misconception I see (and was referring to) is people inflating pedophilia to mean any kind of relationship or attraction to anyone below the age of consent or under the age of 18, but that's not what the term means at all. It's much more specific than that. No matter how you think about people being attracted to 16yo girls, it's never gonna qualify as pedophilia.

On a sidenote if someone sees an adult in an anime caring for a 12 or 14yo war orphan and their first thought/interpretation is that he must have pedophilic intentions, I think it says more about how they view girls of that age than it says about the anime. The thought honestly never crossed my mind when I watched the show, and I'm a lolicon ffs -.-.
I probably regret this post by now.
May 4, 2019 10:07 AM

Offline
Oct 2017
441

KreatorX said:
Kuraya said:
how is Subaru misunderstood, sorry I try not to read on the forums too much, I'd get too pissed off

Yeah, plenty of it starts from him being "obsessed" with Emilia, him being whiny, him acting like a absolute idiot, him "not doing anything about his situation", "that fucker rejected Rem", the list goes on..

Many don't even get the base idea that the character is designed to be someone who is borderline fixated on escapism, suffers from low interpersonal skills due to being a NEET, treats everything around him as a videogame/anime/manga since that's how he thinks people around him behave. The also skimp on the idea that such people fear social rejection, especially more from someone they like.

It's funny, because many of the above people watched and enjoyed the mindset of the main character in Welcome to NHK, when Subaru in Re-zero is just a different version of Satou in a nutshell. Re-zero then takes a different trajectory with such a main character in an isekai with a videogame checkpoint like plot device.

I've always found the hate against him because of how he treated Rem to be weird. What she did to him before he got past the mansion reset would put anyone off being intimate with her for a while.
To me it looks like he sees Emelia as the main heroine that he needs to be with to "complete" the game and get a happy ending.
May 4, 2019 10:13 AM

Offline
Oct 2013
7960
low-key anyone who doesn't like a character within my fav section is misunderstanding them

Im slightly kidding tbh
May 4, 2019 10:27 AM

Offline
Nov 2013
21392
Since pedophilia was brought up, after Sherry Tyueli was saved by Kouji Sugawara by accepting her as his future bride in GATE, some labeled him as a pedophile. Which isn't true.
You're a louse, Roger Smith. - R. Dorothy Wayneright
This is my fight! No Senpai, this is our fight! - Kojou Akatsuki & Yukina Himeragi
May 4, 2019 10:52 AM

Offline
May 2013
1739
Platypus7 said:

I've always found the hate against him because of how he treated Rem to be weird. What she did to him before he got past the mansion reset would put anyone off being intimate with her for a while.
To me it looks like he sees Emelia as the main heroine that he needs to be with to "complete" the game and get a happy ending.

Exactly! He treated the world and people around him as if it were a videogame. The irony is funny when he himself quipped about Emilia becoming his "easy-to-get-heroine", and then you see him go through a series of outlandish trials just to start heading in that direction, lol.

Like for his "obsession" with her, you may already know this and it's also plain obvious to see why. Imagine if someone hauled you out of your room and dropped you in the middle of a foreign country (maybe in a rural place), you don't have your passport, no money, no phone, can't read the local language and get roughed up by the locals. You are shitting bricks at your predicament basically.

Then a person steps in to disperse the situation, provides lodging at their place, offers you a job and language lessons to help you get by in this new land. Folks at her place don't trust you but she places good faith in you despite that, because she wants to know more about you and help your situation before passing any verdict on you.

So of-course there will be a strong form of attachment towards such a person, because this is a type of helpful/trustful treatment being given in your favour, that too in a foreign land. Just putting two and two together here. Why a good chunk of people fail to see this, is simply beyond me.

Now that I think of it, even Emilia is in the same boat as Subaru. "Oh she did aBsOluTeLy nuFFin' for Subaru to even warrant his focus on her". ffs lmao
KreatorXMay 4, 2019 11:08 AM
May 4, 2019 11:11 AM

Offline
Aug 2018
2241
Pullman said:
DaCraziGuy said:
wasn't she around 13-14 yo? That is pretty pedo imo. 16 is a more understandable age... even 15 in some cases, but less than that seems pretty crazy to be considered "safe".

If you were being sarcastic tho, ignore my comment.


Well, IIRC the anime itself doesn't specific because she doesn't knowher own age so all we get in the anime is her 'guess'. But she sure doesn't seem/look like 14 to me, more like 16+.

But also the definition of pedophilia has nothing to do with being 'understandable' or not. It's by definition about prepubescent children only, meaning before the onset of puberty, so 12 at the oldest, usually younger. There are other medical terms for attraction to other age groups, but in any case neither of them are related to age of consent laws which can vary depending on the country (14yo is legal in my country for example, in many others it isn't) but instead invariable medical definitions. I don't know about you, but the common misconception I see (and was referring to) is people inflating pedophilia to mean any kind of relationship or attraction to anyone below the age of consent or under the age of 18, but that's not what the term means at all. It's much more specific than that. No matter how you think about people being attracted to 16yo girls, it's never gonna qualify as pedophilia.

On a sidenote if someone sees an adult in an anime caring for a 12 or 14yo war orphan and their first thought/interpretation is that he must have pedophilic intentions, I think it says more about how they view girls of that age than it says about the anime. The thought honestly never crossed my mind when I watched the show, and I'm a lolicon ffs -.-.
I agree that she doesn't look at all to be less than 16 years in any aspect. Also, it's true that thinking that he wanted to bang the kid is a pretty retarded interpretation. But I'm not sure about the meaning of the love that the "dude-that-I-can't- remember-his-name" expressed is at that moment.

Leaving that asides, technically you could say that only under 12 is the pedo barrier... or you could also use the legal barrier. There is no doubt that under 12 is bad in every aspect. The 13 - 18 is a very gray area imo because, every girl(and boy) and every year change everything. I do think tho, that most under 16 yo kids don't have a good judgement in a lot of aspects and some adults could take advantage of them (in more than one aspect).

And last, I know that it's not that uncommon to have 14 yo as legal age. In my country is 16, and I kinda agree on that but I'm not that sure anyway.
May 4, 2019 11:12 AM

Offline
Mar 2012
18960
I would say Imouto sae Ireba Ii is one. The title alone already filter user since most people allergic to imouto on the title in the same vein of how isekai do. Not only that but the series itself did more filtering on showcasing the sheer absurdity in it's first view minute which necessarily turn people off.

In actually it's a series about creator life and struggle they have to stay in creative industry. Having your won series destroyed after much anticipation, inferiority complex with your loved one, bullying, watching your unrequited love having unrequited love and such. Also dealing with the possibility of having your creation destroyed just to be having a chance to stand with your lover.

It's great series honestly with likable cast. 100% want a sequel or at least for someone to translate the LN.

Also the OP are great. I keep listening to this every other day.

Kickstarter for Rokujouma is fully funded. Good work everyone. Lets wait for the result of our hard work together.
May 4, 2019 11:29 AM

Offline
Oct 2017
441
KreatorX said:
Platypus7 said:

I've always found the hate against him because of how he treated Rem to be weird. What she did to him before he got past the mansion reset would put anyone off being intimate with her for a while.
To me it looks like he sees Emelia as the main heroine that he needs to be with to "complete" the game and get a happy ending.

Exactly! He treated the world and people around him as if it were a videogame. The irony is funny when he himself quipped about Emilia becoming his "easy-to-get-heroine", and then you see him go through a series of outlandish trials just to start heading in that direction, lol.

Like for his "obsession" with her, you may already know this and it's also plain obvious to see why. Imagine if someone hauled you out of your room and dropped you in the middle of a foreign country (maybe in a rural place), you don't have your passport, no money, no phone, can't read the local language and get roughed up by the locals. You are shitting bricks at your predicament basically.

Then a person steps in to disperse the situation, provides lodging at their place, offers you a job and language lessons to help you get by in this new land. Folks at her place don't trust you but she places good faith in you despite that, because she wants to know more about you and help your situation before passing any verdict on you.

So of-course there will be a strong form of attachment towards such a person, because this is a type of helpful/trustful treatment being given in your favour, that too in a foreign land. Just putting two and two together here. Why a good chunk of people fail to see this, is simply beyond me.

Now that I think of it, even Emilia is in the same boat as Subaru. "Oh she did aBsOluTeLy nuFFin' for Subaru to even warrant his focus on her". ffs lmao

Yeah, he basically imprints on Emelia. His relationship with Rem is more regular. I can see why a lot of people prefer Rem over Emelia because she does get more development but that doesn't make her a better girl from Subaru's perspective.
May 4, 2019 12:22 PM

Offline
Dec 2017
1116
Most recent example would be Mya-nee from wataten. People think that she is a horny pedophile because of the synopsis the anime has but its totally different in reality.


"All that is gold does not glitter,
Not all those who wander are lost;
The old that is strong does not wither,
Deep roots are not reached by the frost."

May 4, 2019 12:46 PM

Offline
Dec 2018
57
So many people act like Kyubey from Madoka Magica was a malicious, evil being who deliberately set out to cause harm. I really feel like that isn't the point of his character whatsoever.
I MUST SOMEHOW MAKE SENSE OF OUR CONVOLUTED SITUATION
May 4, 2019 1:44 PM
Offline
Jul 2018
561864
Kuraya said:
DaCraziGuy said:
I like him too, sadly most kids (not all of them) and some delusional adults can't enjoy realistic characters. The sense of failing or struggling seems dumb in their minds, or that living can actually change you personality or line of thoughs. But well, all I can say is: "fuck them, we got second season" hahahah
I'm a kid too so I appreciate the parentheses.

lol, that's true, hah, still haven't completely grasped the notion of "Re:Zero 2nd season".
Even so, if the second season does what I expect it will be fucking amazing

Yeah, people are just different, but I remember that I had less patience for some character drama and flaws too (mainly the "mean" ones or some characters with depression), when I was like 15. I think, some anime targeted to teenagers have stories and characters that are better understood by an older audience (in general, of course not an overwhelming majority). Do you know the feeling of coming back to something you have watched like 2 - 5 - 10 years ago and now, you see it with different eyes.

DaCraziGuy said:
Kuraya said:
Dear God, I'm shocked by stupidity even though I know what peaks it can reach.

First off Subaru is not the most normal or common of people. At least after he was transported he was extremely social and optimistic. Why would anyone even bring up money if he was transported to another world tf

It's not a matter of opinion anyway, and you are underestimating his experience.
It's basically impossible for the human mind to withstand all the physical and psychological damage he went through. Subaru is extremely OP in this remark.

And that's retarded AF, what the actual shit. It's not about just reviving after. I can't pose facts here but for humans death is a one time experience. It's not just about the physical pain that causes the death, the simple sensing of death approaching you from all directions one time could make a person go crazy, Subaru has experienced that time and time again.

He's character is just incredible, I love him.
I like him too, sadly most kids (not all of them) and some delusional adults can't enjoy realistic characters. The sense of failing or struggling seems dumb in their minds, or that living can actually change you personality or line of thoughs. But well, all I can say is: "fuck them, we got second season" hahahah

I don't think that most of those people don't understand these concepts.
Some might struggle with empathy and so on, but most of them might use fiction as an escape (which is nothing bad per se, of course) and don't want to see parts of themselves or other people they dislike in a medium they use as an escape.
And some are really idealistic and have strict rules. They want to behave characters in a certain way inbetween their strict rules.

DaCraziGuy said:
Pullman said:
Lmao, Violet is too old so even if he had a boner for her it would not be pedophilia. People really like to demonstrate their complete failure to understand basic concepts and what they mean.
wasn't she around 13-14 yo? That is pretty pedo imo. 16 is a more understandable age... even 15 in some cases, but less than that seems pretty crazy to be considered "safe".

If you were being sarcastic tho, ignore my comment.

Never thought she could around 14? I thought she is around 17.
May 4, 2019 2:05 PM

Offline
Aug 2018
2241
Maneki-Mew said:
Kuraya said:
I'm a kid too so I appreciate the parentheses.

lol, that's true, hah, still haven't completely grasped the notion of "Re:Zero 2nd season".
Even so, if the second season does what I expect it will be fucking amazing

Yeah, people are just different, but I remember that I had less patience for some character drama and flaws too (mainly the "mean" ones or some characters with depression), when I was like 15. I think, some anime targeted to teenagers have stories and characters that are better understood by an older audience (in general, of course not an overwhelming majority). Do you know the feeling of coming back to something you have watched like 2 - 5 - 10 years ago and now, you see it with different eyes.

DaCraziGuy said:
I like him too, sadly most kids (not all of them) and some delusional adults can't enjoy realistic characters. The sense of failing or struggling seems dumb in their minds, or that living can actually change you personality or line of thoughs. But well, all I can say is: "fuck them, we got second season" hahahah

I don't think that most of those people don't understand these concepts.
Some might struggle with empathy and so on, but most of them might use fiction as an escape (which is nothing bad per se, of course) and don't want to see parts of themselves or other people they dislike in a medium they use as an escape.
And some are really idealistic and have strict rules. They want to behave characters in a certain way inbetween their strict rules.

DaCraziGuy said:
wasn't she around 13-14 yo? That is pretty pedo imo. 16 is a more understandable age... even 15 in some cases, but less than that seems pretty crazy to be considered "safe".

If you were being sarcastic tho, ignore my comment.

Never thought she could around 14? I thought she is around 17.
I totally get what you mean by watching something with different eyes, it happened to mee.

Not sure if most of the type of people I talked about understands what I was reffering too, the complains and the arguments behind are usually really "dumb". The easiest example I can say now is about Subaru with the: "ugh, Subaru is so dumb, if he can revive why doesn't he kill himself. He can solve everything like that. And he also is dumb for loosing his mind in mid season, I don't get how can be so asshole.". That line of thoughs is hard to take seriously, at least for me. I do agree that the story and character isn't for everyone.

And about Violet, I think like you. When they said her age I really was "WTF?" hahhaa
May 4, 2019 3:16 PM

Offline
Nov 2017
430
Michael Corleone, it's undebatable
DagviMay 5, 2019 12:40 PM


May 4, 2019 3:38 PM

Offline
Dec 2017
469
Anyone who says Shinji Ikari spends all of the series crying in a corner doing nothing. He literally does the most out of everyone in the cast when it comes to defeating angels and is told to get out of Nerv more times than he runs away (not to mention he defies the orders to run away literally every time). Most of the people criticizing him for this haven't even watched End of Evangelion too, which is the only time in the entire series that he lives up to his reputation of being completely ineffectual and crying in a corner (and not without good reason). Asuka spends more time acting like the typical portrayal of Shinji by memes and people who don't like Evangelion than Shinji himself does.



I'll keep wishing for a world where you can be happy.


May 4, 2019 4:00 PM
Offline
Jul 2018
561864
DaCraziGuy said:
Maneki-Mew said:

Yeah, people are just different, but I remember that I had less patience for some character drama and flaws too (mainly the "mean" ones or some characters with depression), when I was like 15. I think, some anime targeted to teenagers have stories and characters that are better understood by an older audience (in general, of course not an overwhelming majority). Do you know the feeling of coming back to something you have watched like 2 - 5 - 10 years ago and now, you see it with different eyes.


I don't think that most of those people don't understand these concepts.
Some might struggle with empathy and so on, but most of them might use fiction as an escape (which is nothing bad per se, of course) and don't want to see parts of themselves or other people they dislike in a medium they use as an escape.
And some are really idealistic and have strict rules. They want to behave characters in a certain way inbetween their strict rules.


Never thought she could around 14? I thought she is around 17.
I totally get what you mean by watching something with different eyes, it happened to mee.

Not sure if most of the type of people I talked about understands what I was reffering too, the complains and the arguments behind are usually really "dumb". The easiest example I can say now is about Subaru with the: "ugh, Subaru is so dumb, if he can revive why doesn't he kill himself. He can solve everything like that. And he also is dumb for loosing his mind in mid season, I don't get how can be so asshole.". That line of thoughs is hard to take seriously, at least for me. I do agree that the story and character isn't for everyone.

And about Violet, I think like you. When they said her age I really was "WTF?" hahhaa

Now I'm more curious.
I know it's a petty reason to avoid an anime, but the waifu wars about re:zero annoyed me. I fully understand, if people are enthusiastic about characters and shippings they like (I mean, I relate), but oh boi, it could become annoying. Especially, when nobody speaks about the actual plot and characters as individuals anymore or if it's everywhere and overdone.

Yes, she looks like that. That's so weird in some anime.

May 4, 2019 4:13 PM

Offline
Jan 2018
1896
Skana said:
Taiga Aisaka. Way too many people give her hell and exaggerate her violent streak. Are we even watching the same show?

This. I normally can't stand tsunderes (ie. Asuka, Rin), but Taiga's such a sweetheart. I have a feeling that most people who bash her just either didn't watch the show past episode 1, or were simply incapable of understanding basic human emotions enough to see the cause of her behaviors. I'll admit, episode 1 of Toradora was a bit over-the-top and could've probably been toned down a bit, but her personality itself was pretty justifiable.
GreyleafMay 4, 2019 4:17 PM


"I am not sure that I exist, actually. I am all the writers that I have read, all the
people that I have met, all the women that I have loved; all the cities I have visited.
"
― Jorge Luis Borges
[url=]Goodreads[/url] | [url=]Letterboxd[/url]

May 4, 2019 4:35 PM
Offline
Jul 2018
561864
Greyleaf said:
Skana said:
Taiga Aisaka. Way too many people give her hell and exaggerate her violent streak. Are we even watching the same show?

This. I normally can't stand tsunderes (ie. Asuka, Rin), but Taiga's such a sweetheart. I have a feeling that most people who bash her just either didn't watch the show past episode 1, or were simply incapable of understanding basic human emotions enough to see the cause of her behaviors. I'll admit, episode 1 of Toradora was a bit over-the-top and could've probably been toned down a bit, but her personality itself was pretty justifiable.


She's like that because she is a rich girl who's wealth has made her lonely + distant from others and thus anti-social. Ryuuji breaks into this bubble that Taiga has formed for herself and so she reflexively reacts violently and antagonistically. As a defense mechanism so to speak.

After spending so much time with Ryuuji in this classic rom-com setup of a plot, she slowly realizes how much Ryuuji means to him and comes to an epiphany of how nice Ryuuji is for acting like a human angel with her. How much he has helped her with her insecurities in many ways.

Her tsun side fades away and she reveals her philanthropic endeavors of giving gifts to orphans during Christmas.

Then, they fall in love. It ends with a tsun gag moment.

I suspect you're fine with her but not with the others because she doesn't look like a teenager and so her abusive elements don't hit you as hard if she looked like a teenager. She looks like a kid throwing a tantrum and maybe you find that endearing? Or like a sweetheart?

Really though, in terms of abuse, Taiga is much worse than Rin and even Asuka. Asuka was verbally abusive but never hit Shinji. And Asuka never relied on Shinji as a defacto caretaker. However, Taiga insults and hits Ryuuji frequently, who does take care of her throughout the anime.

As for Rin, she's not abusive. Just snippy. A pretty mild tsundere. She doesn't really insult Shirou, doesn't hit him, and shows her dere side far more frequently. Like she's cold sometimes and blushes. That's the extent of it. I can see why you wouldn't like her if you don't like tsunderes(I'm not a fan of her either) though.
May 4, 2019 4:47 PM

Offline
Aug 2009
101
You can not love a woman differently than sexually.
May 4, 2019 5:27 PM
Offline
Jul 2018
561864
Some think Hokuto no Ken is sexist because it is 80s where this was more common, plus muscles, but I havent seen any character more respecting to and honest with women than Kenshiro. I'dd add even Raoh and others. Same for Souten no Ken. I'd say newer shonen are much more sexist in comparison
May 4, 2019 5:29 PM

Offline
Aug 2018
2241
Maneki-Mew said:
DaCraziGuy said:
I totally get what you mean by watching something with different eyes, it happened to mee.

Not sure if most of the type of people I talked about understands what I was reffering too, the complains and the arguments behind are usually really "dumb". The easiest example I can say now is about Subaru with the: "ugh, Subaru is so dumb, if he can revive why doesn't he kill himself. He can solve everything like that. And he also is dumb for loosing his mind in mid season, I don't get how can be so asshole.". That line of thoughs is hard to take seriously, at least for me. I do agree that the story and character isn't for everyone.

And about Violet, I think like you. When they said her age I really was "WTF?" hahhaa

Now I'm more curious.
I know it's a petty reason to avoid an anime, but the waifu wars about re:zero annoyed me. I fully understand, if people are enthusiastic about characters and shippings they like (I mean, I relate), but oh boi, it could become annoying. Especially, when nobody speaks about the actual plot and characters as individuals anymore or if it's everywhere and overdone.

Yes, she looks like that. That's so weird in some anime.

Well, I had a similar experience with Banana Fish... the comunity with the "not-gay-hidden-gem-masterpiece vs some-gay-shit" was SO FKING ANNOYING for me, especially because the show was in the middle ground for me. It really made my experience worse... I watched it till the end despite that and I enjoyed it, but I stopped reading anything related to that show because it was just a sandstorm from both sides.

Oh, I almost forgot that BNHA's fandom is also annoying af.

But well, in those cases you should ignore the community sadly and enjoy(or hate) it by yourself.
May 4, 2019 5:38 PM

Offline
Sep 2012
4153
shinji. the people that hate him are 100x more annoying than him.
how you could watch the show and not understand/empathize with him is beyond me. how the fuck would you expect any person to act in his situation?



Oh maybe, maybe it's the clothes we wear
The tasteless bracelets and the dye in our hair
Or maybe, maybe it's our nowhere towns or our nothing places
But we're trash, you and me
We're the litter on the breeze
We're the lovers on the streets
Just trash, me and you
It's in everything we do
It's in everything we do



May 4, 2019 5:46 PM
lagom
Offline
Jan 2009
107504
i say usually the villains with the end justify the means beliefs, one character i remember right now that is like that is this https://myanimelist.net/character/149087/Charioce_XVII

im usually about utilitarianism so i can understand that the end justify the means mentality especially if you will do evil things for the greater good (or greater number of people) but ye its immoral especially in modern times but in the past i see it as a necessary evil
May 4, 2019 6:03 PM
Offline
Jul 2018
561864
petran79 said:
Some think Hokuto no Ken is sexist because it is 80s where this was more common, plus muscles, but I havent seen any character more respecting to and honest with women than Kenshiro. I'dd add even Raoh and others. Same for Souten no Ken. I'd say newer shonen are much more sexist in comparison

It's pretty hilarious in its own ways. Don't mean to attack you or anything, but some scenes I have seen had such an over the top violence, so they felt like anime wanted the equivalent to an 80s hollywood action movie with those gar-protagonists that had their cool one liners and killed everything in their way in ... well, these ways.

Anyway, I don't think that I like characters, who are portrayed as "respectful to women". I mean, I do and I can't say anything against it, if it's their way of thinking, but not making any really big differences for most parts (besides obvious, biological reasons) is far more likeable to me, imo.

Ironically, I always thought that Shounen are in average far less sexist than your average Shoujo, since they don't care to make female self-insert protagonists.

DaCraziGuy said:
Maneki-Mew said:

Now I'm more curious.
I know it's a petty reason to avoid an anime, but the waifu wars about re:zero annoyed me. I fully understand, if people are enthusiastic about characters and shippings they like (I mean, I relate), but oh boi, it could become annoying. Especially, when nobody speaks about the actual plot and characters as individuals anymore or if it's everywhere and overdone.

Yes, she looks like that. That's so weird in some anime.

Well, I had a similar experience with Banana Fish... the comunity with the "not-gay-hidden-gem-masterpiece vs some-gay-shit" was SO FKING ANNOYING for me, especially because the show was in the middle ground for me. It really made my experience worse... I watched it till the end despite that and I enjoyed it, but I stopped reading anything related to that show because it was just a sandstorm from both sides.

Oh, I almost forgot that BNHA's fandom is also annoying af.

But well, in those cases you should ignore the community sadly and enjoy(or hate) it by yourself.

They could get very annoying. I avoid the AoT-forum and tags in social medias at the moment, because of "Why is this popular!!??" and others, where you could expect a fandom war in some ways haha.
It's the best to them in peace and maybe discuss them afterwards with people, who are really pleasant having a discussion with.

Yomiyuki said:
shinji. the people that hate him are 100x more annoying than him.
how you could watch the show and not understand/empathize with him is beyond me. how the fuck would you expect any person to act in his situation?

*sign this*
removed-userMay 4, 2019 6:16 PM
May 5, 2019 1:02 AM
Offline
Jul 2018
561864
Maneki-Mew said:

It's pretty hilarious in its own ways. Don't mean to attack you or anything, but some scenes I have seen had such an over the top violence, so they felt like anime wanted the equivalent to an 80s hollywood action movie with those gar-protagonists that had their cool one liners and killed everything in their way in ... well, these ways.

Anyway, I don't think that I like characters, who are portrayed as "respectful to women". I mean, I do and I can't say anything against it, if it's their way of thinking, but not making any really big differences for most parts (besides obvious, biological reasons) is far more likeable to me, imo.

Ironically, I always thought that Shounen are in average far less sexist than your average Shoujo, since they don't care to make female self-insert protagonists.


One reason I never take anime seriously or else I would not enjoy such scenes. As a kid I would literally replace my reality with cartoons though.

70s shojo especially when the mc cries for the tiniest reason, is abused without reacting and dreams of the saving knight, usually a rich boy. Series like Candy became popular worldwide and are filled with such scenes. Proved very traumatic for its target audience

But it makes those baroque sfx and gfx all the more impressive.

Souten no Ken goes extreme with the respect issue.

I could not believe what I was reading. Masterful writing. Every other shonen seemed like trash compared to this.

May 5, 2019 3:41 AM

Offline
Nov 2014
1307
KreatorX said:
Pretty sure there's plenty of such instances.

The most common ones I see are Shinji from Evangelion, Subaru from Re-zero, Okabe and Mayuri from Steins;Gate, just to name a few.


I think Okabe is pretty loved and appreciated, more than Shinji at least.

Yomiyuki said:
shinji. the people that hate him are 100x more annoying than him.

how you could watch the show and not understand/empathize with him is beyond me. how the fuck would you expect any person to act in his situation?


Tahmmeow said:
Anyone who says Shinji Ikari spends all of the series crying in a corner doing nothing. He literally does the most out of everyone in the cast when it comes to defeating angels and is told to get out of Nerv more times than he runs away (not to mention he defies the orders to run away literally every time). Most of the people criticizing him for this haven't even watched End of Evangelion too, which is the only time in the entire series that he lives up to his reputation of being completely ineffectual and crying in a corner (and not without good reason). Asuka spends more time acting like the typical portrayal of Shinji by memes and people who don't like Evangelion than Shinji himself does.


Case in point.

Zehennagel said:
griffith, boi just wanted to smack dat gut's ass while dis boi went on some psychological metaphysical trip, well they both went on some psychological metaphysical trip so in the end alls well dat ends well


Are you okay?
May 5, 2019 3:48 AM

Offline
Mar 2018
815
Koi Wa Ameagari No You Ni

Both MC. I am quite certain that many people skipped over this gem because of the premise but the story is actually about something entirely different. It is about two lost people becoming unlikely friends and finding their way out of the rain. Nothing icky at all.

Kaze Tachinu

So yes it is about the engineer who created the planes, Horikoshi Jiro, and yes those planes were used during the war by Kamikaze pilots but anyone who actually knew Miyazaki's stance regarding war should have known better than to condemn the movie before actually having watched it.
May 5, 2019 4:39 AM

Offline
Dec 2012
10012
Any anime with weak or flawed main character. People constantly complain how they hate them but usually the point of the show is that there's usually character development for them.
"The name's Gambit. Remember it."
-Gambit "X-Men '97"

Pages (2) [1] 2 »

More topics from this board

» Anime characters that used to be older than you, now you're older than them

ComeInReiAsuka - Yesterday

17 by XMGA030 »»
4 minutes ago

» anime characters that are literally you?

Ymir_The_Viking - Today

19 by XMGA030 »»
10 minutes ago

» Characters you want to become your siblings

m_alhafidz - Yesterday

18 by Morphun »»
14 minutes ago

» Has using MAL made you enjoy anime less?

Dragevard - Oct 8

36 by pk8list »»
17 minutes ago

Poll: » Has BL animanga been getting better?

Auron - Yesterday

14 by XMGA030 »»
21 minutes ago
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login