Goblin Slayer (light novel)
Available on Manga Store
New
Dec 8, 2018 1:01 PM
#1
So with only a couple of weeks left til this anime ends, what do you all think? Will it get a second season or Not? Personally I think it will |
Dec 8, 2018 1:29 PM
#2
Dec 8, 2018 1:29 PM
#3
the novel is not so advanced so I do not think that soon. But I think it will have. |
Dec 8, 2018 2:13 PM
#4
So essentially you want more of the same. In not sure at this point if the series has anything more to offer that the bland MC killing Goblins. I won't be too upset if we don't get Hack & Slash season 2 |
Dec 8, 2018 2:30 PM
#5
I haven't really read too much of Goblin Slayer and how it's perceived in Japan, cuz I don't care about it but it depends on their reaction and if it pumps out that sweet yen from merch sales. I hope it doesn't though, that's extremely unnecessary considering there's nothing new to even learn about this world or the characters, and there's only so much you can do with Goblin slaying. |
Dec 8, 2018 3:36 PM
#6
BackstageMage said: I haven't really read too much of Goblin Slayer and how it's perceived in Japan, cuz I don't care about it but it depends on their reaction and if it pumps out that sweet yen from merch sales. I hope it doesn't though, that's extremely unnecessary considering there's nothing new to even learn about this world or the characters, and there's only so much you can do with Goblin slaying. - that's where you wrong kiddo. -with respects, an LN reader. |
"I know anything goes here... but this... this is clearly not fucking okay...!" -Fuyuhiko Kuzuryuu |
Dec 8, 2018 3:46 PM
#7
idontknowsarcasm said: BackstageMage said: I haven't really read too much of Goblin Slayer and how it's perceived in Japan, cuz I don't care about it but it depends on their reaction and if it pumps out that sweet yen from merch sales. I hope it doesn't though, that's extremely unnecessary considering there's nothing new to even learn about this world or the characters, and there's only so much you can do with Goblin slaying. - that's where you wrong kiddo. -with respects, an LN reader. So what happens then? I'm not saying they can't make another season of GS, but nothing in season 1 so far needs any more expansion, maybe the LN's better than the anime at this but I don't feel the need for more Goblin Slayer. |
Dec 8, 2018 4:01 PM
#8
I highly doubt it's getting a second season. We can only hope so. |
Dec 8, 2018 4:07 PM
#9
There's not enough source material for another season at this point. |
Dec 8, 2018 4:08 PM
#10
seeker_moc said: There's not enough source material for another season at this point. Yes there are, there's at least 6 volumes. The anime's adapting the first 2 volumes. |
Dec 8, 2018 4:23 PM
#11
BackstageMage said: idontknowsarcasm said: BackstageMage said: I haven't really read too much of Goblin Slayer and how it's perceived in Japan, cuz I don't care about it but it depends on their reaction and if it pumps out that sweet yen from merch sales. I hope it doesn't though, that's extremely unnecessary considering there's nothing new to even learn about this world or the characters, and there's only so much you can do with Goblin slaying. - that's where you wrong kiddo. -with respects, an LN reader. So what happens then? I'm not saying they can't make another season of GS, but nothing in season 1 so far needs any more expansion, maybe the LN's better than the anime at this but I don't feel the need for more Goblin Slayer. - so you want spoilers? |
"I know anything goes here... but this... this is clearly not fucking okay...!" -Fuyuhiko Kuzuryuu |
Dec 8, 2018 4:34 PM
#12
idontknowsarcasm said: BackstageMage said: idontknowsarcasm said: BackstageMage said: I haven't really read too much of Goblin Slayer and how it's perceived in Japan, cuz I don't care about it but it depends on their reaction and if it pumps out that sweet yen from merch sales. I hope it doesn't though, that's extremely unnecessary considering there's nothing new to even learn about this world or the characters, and there's only so much you can do with Goblin slaying. - that's where you wrong kiddo. -with respects, an LN reader. So what happens then? I'm not saying they can't make another season of GS, but nothing in season 1 so far needs any more expansion, maybe the LN's better than the anime at this but I don't feel the need for more Goblin Slayer. - so you want spoilers? Yep, spoil away /charalimit |
Dec 8, 2018 5:12 PM
#13
I actually hope that it gets another. However, it ultimately depends upon its popularity from Japan. Although, if it doesn’t occur; then at least we will eventually have the manga finished. |
Dec 8, 2018 6:40 PM
#14
seeker_moc said: There's not enough source material for another season at this point. There's about 9 Volumes of the LN out in Japan I believe. I think there's plenty enough material for another season. |
Dec 8, 2018 6:41 PM
#15
Damn the level of edgyness of the series's bashers in all the threads is higher than hero's party power's, and the hero's party is really OP. Makes me cringe. |
Dec 8, 2018 6:55 PM
#16
MasterAdventZero said: seeker_moc said: There's not enough source material for another season at this point. There's about 9 Volumes of the LN out in Japan I believe. I think there's plenty enough material for another season. Hopefully they add filler it'll easily make the show better.... |
I've surpassed your limit! |
Dec 8, 2018 6:59 PM
#17
Minerbit said: the novel is not so advanced so I do not think that soon. But I think it will have. Please... it has 8 volumes. |
Dec 17, 2018 10:01 AM
#18
Dec 17, 2018 10:08 AM
#19
Depends if it does well in Japan or not. If it does, WhiteFox will probably pull an Overlord and produce a second season but with a smaller budget. |
Dec 17, 2018 12:49 PM
#20
Quite possible, but hopefully they'll improve the art quality. |
Dec 17, 2018 6:42 PM
#21
Catalano said: But more importantly, will we have a scene like that in episode 1? so that every crybaby will lose their mind? I'm talking about goblin + bent over girl. That alone should justify a second season. |
Dec 18, 2018 3:48 PM
#22
If they do have another season I hope this one transfers more from goblin slaying to a bit more character development. I think that's the direction the series is headed in personally. |
Dec 18, 2018 6:57 PM
#23
Dec 18, 2018 10:20 PM
#24
I want season 2 so much JUST FOR 2 REASONS. 1) To see more awful rape scenes. 2) To make the haters bashing about the series and cry, oh don't forget the salt also kek. |
Dec 18, 2018 11:42 PM
#25
Low chances. It's not that there is no material it's just that the ending of the first novel seems almost like the ending of the entire season. The other seasons would be just missions, sure they are cool missions but the narrative stops until the ninth novel...i am not sure if an anime can handle that. |
Dec 18, 2018 11:44 PM
#26
Frazs said: Damn the level of edgyness of the series's bashers in all the threads is higher than hero's party power's, and the hero's party is really OP. Makes me cringe. Calm your titties, fanboy. |
Dec 19, 2018 11:29 PM
#27
I am not an LN leader but i am a Manga reader. I don't feel any particular hype about the anime, neither the Manga. Sure LN seems implied big things but if the pacing goes to slow and there's literally nothing happened than tin-can shenanigans killing goblin, people would lose interest overtime. I don't think the anime is popular in Japan. Something like badly bashed by western because the nonsense such as SSS Gridman or Toaru Majutsu no Index seems far more popular and even got vote for most wanted continuation. Likewise you can't expect studio care when it comes to western critiques. I also barely see any GS stuff in weekly LN/Manga. By far , Slime Isekai is more likely to have 2nd season than Goblin Slayer. So I'll give GS to have a very low chance getting an adaptation. Look now, the hype is technically died. |
Dec 20, 2018 2:55 PM
#28
Yo why should i be anything but calm? My comment was a consequence of pity feelings and twisting muscles after trying to read a thread on this forum without it being full of useless random rants by some tards passionately followinig series they dislike, so much they don't even want to watch them, lmao. How can i be aggressive about some weebs wasting their lifes in a cheap way? Its not like calling me fanboi changes it,add a proper diss at least. |
Dec 20, 2018 4:04 PM
#29
Frazs said: My comment was a consequence of pity feelings and twisting muscles after trying to read a thread on this forum without it being full of useless random rants by some tards passionately followinig series they dislike, so much they don't even want to watch them, lmao. From what I read, it's just people expressing their opinion. It's mixed with both positive and negatives, you're just being salty with seeing people bashing your favorite anime lmao. Just because they have different opinion than yours doesn't mean they're OBJECTIVELY wrong or they're edgy. saids the guy who calls other ppl edgy for not liking the same anime as he/she does. Why should I give you a proper diss when you did the exact same thing with ppl criticizing GS and not looking 4ward to the 2nd season? lol |
Dec 21, 2018 9:26 AM
#30
Goblin slayer is not good as fanboys said and also not bad as hater said, its just grey. Nothing special about this show, So for me there is unnecessary to make another season of it, if white fox want to make another season, they better make season 2 for Re:zero than this GS |
Go read 'Mediterranean Hegemon of Ancient Greece' If you like webnovel with historical, military and kingdom building genre. |
Dec 21, 2018 2:26 PM
#31
I hope not. If second is going to be equally, if not more, tame and censored as current season, then it'd better to just stop on 12th episode. |
Dec 21, 2018 3:16 PM
#32
NyronGTR said: I hope not. If second is going to be equally, if not more, tame and censored as current season, then it'd better to just stop on 12th episode. I'm not saying you're wrong but I'm curious as to what made you see it as tame and censored especially after the uproar the first episode caused with the rest of the community |
Dec 22, 2018 5:19 AM
#33
hiimnewbenice said: NyronGTR said: I hope not. If second is going to be equally, if not more, tame and censored as current season, then it'd better to just stop on 12th episode. I'm not saying you're wrong but I'm curious as to what made you see it as tame and censored especially after the uproar the first episode caused with the rest of the community No episode came remotely close to what the first baited audience with. Occasional carnage, sure, but nothing remarkable. Then comes the obvious censorship and i'll let the samples speak for me How conveniently placed hair. Notice how only shorts happened to remain. |
Dec 22, 2018 8:46 AM
#34
Frazs said: Yo why should i be anything but calm? My comment was a consequence of pity feelings and twisting muscles after trying to read a thread on this forum without it being full of useless random rants by some tards passionately followinig series they dislike, so much they don't even want to watch them, lmao. How can i be aggressive about some weebs wasting their lifes in a cheap way? Its not like calling me fanboi changes it,add a proper diss at least. That wasn't a diss. Just an accurate observation tbh |
1.1.Six |
Dec 22, 2018 1:48 PM
#35
It would be weird if this great show didn't get a 2nd season in the future - when stuff like the slime anime already got 2-cour from the beginning. I can't imagine this wouldn't sell like crazy. Nice variety of waifus (elf girl, priest girl, ...) - for the fans that watch because of this. Violence and rape. (All stuff that attracts viewers.) And the chars and their interaction were nice so far. Likeable characters and a nice own fantasy world that felt classic from the style and not too fancy or with own/weird stuff like other anime try too often. (Especially the Isekai stuff gets annoying.) |
Dec 22, 2018 2:02 PM
#36
Luthandorius said: It would be weird if this great show didn't get a 2nd season in the future - when stuff like the slime anime already got 2-cour from the beginning. I can't imagine this wouldn't sell like crazy. Nice variety of waifus (elf girl, priest girl, ...) - for the fans that watch because of this. Violence and rape. (All stuff that attracts viewers.) And the chars and their interaction were nice so far. Likeable characters and a nice own fantasy world that felt classic from the style and not too fancy or with own/weird stuff like other anime try too often. (Especially the Isekai stuff gets annoying.) It's hard to tell in my opinion. Many anime with many of the clichè you mentioned were cut off without meaning. |
Dec 22, 2018 5:05 PM
#37
Xaelath said: I don't think the anime is popular in Japan. So I'll give GS to have a very low chance getting an adaptation. Honestly, there's no way to tell how popular the anime is in Japan until the DVD/BD sales figures start coming out, and since the 1st volume of the 3 volume set doesn't release until 02/20/2019...well, if you know of another way to tell, pls, do share. Well...there is one other way. Ultimately, anime based on manga or light novels have one purpose: to sell more of their source material. That being said, the Goblin Slayer light novel series was already in the top 25 in sales BEFORE the anime started, and the volume that came out following the release of the anime pushed it into the top 4. So, there is THAT. BUT. Even the hugely popular One Punch Man aired its 1st season from Oct-Dec 2015; Season 2 for One Punch Man will be coming in Apr 2019. So, if GS does get a 2nd season, it probably won't be for a bit. |
Dec 22, 2018 5:09 PM
#38
shukujo said: Xaelath said: I don't think the anime is popular in Japan. So I'll give GS to have a very low chance getting an adaptation. Honestly, there's no way to tell how popular the anime is in Japan until the DVD/BD sales figures start coming out, and since the 1st volume of the 3 volume set doesn't release until 02/20/2019...well, if you know of another way to tell, pls, do share. Well...there is one other way. Ultimately, anime based on manga or light novels have one purpose: to sell more of their source material. That being said, the Goblin Slayer light novel series was already in the top 25 in sales BEFORE the anime started, and the volume that came out following the release of the anime pushed it into the top 4. So, there is THAT. BUT. Even the hugely popular One Punch Man aired its 1st season from Oct-Dec 2015; Season 2 for One Punch Man will be coming in Apr 2019. So, if GS does get a 2nd season, it probably won't be for a bit. I hope that doesn't happen. I don't know if Goblin Slayer has enough hype to keep it relevant for that long like One Punch Man did. I would hate to see the series die because the second season took too long to come out |
Dec 22, 2018 6:39 PM
#39
seeker_moc said: There's not enough source material for another season at this point. >2/9 volumes adapted >not enough material Do the research before talking |
The opinions of people with shit taste, such as yourself, may differ of course. |
Dec 22, 2018 7:00 PM
#40
it needs to have a season 2 obviously, the anime is great, i had give up on anime for months and Goblin Slayer gave me back the will to watch anime again so it better have season 2 for my sake. |
Dec 26, 2018 11:45 AM
#41
bhaizett said: From what I read, it's just people expressing their opinion. It's mixed with both positive and negatives, you're just being salty with seeing people bashing your favorite anime lmao. Just because they have different opinion than yours doesn't mean they're OBJECTIVELY wrong or they're edgy. saids the guy who calls other ppl edgy for not liking the same anime as he/she does. Either you are blind,didn't understand my comments or you are just joking,because otherwise it would be just sad. I'm not attacking reasonable opinions,and the anime is far from my favorite,it has many flaws and many times i agreed to critcizsm of the show,i like the series so that's why even i took the time to respond to your sh*tty comment, the problem are the bs toxic comments which you can see too many of(talking about the whole forum), they don't add nothing to the discussions if not simple lazy hate. Its the mere volume the major problem, and its not like im the first addressing this. bhaizett said: Why should I give you a proper diss when you did the exact same thing with ppl criticizing GS and not looking 4ward to the 2nd season? lol lazly tought comments just for the sake of shtting on things are bad and discredit the community, thats what i was talkiing about, not "people not looking 4ward to the 2nd season". Don't defend this shit, you make a fool of yourself and make you part of the problem |
Dec 26, 2018 12:20 PM
#42
Frazs said: Either you are blind,didn't understand my comments or you are just joking,because otherwise it would be just sad. I'm not attacking reasonable opinions,and the anime is far from my favorite,it has many flaws and many times i agreed to critcizsm of the show,i like the series so that's why even i took the time to respond to your sh*tty comment, the problem are the bs toxic comments which you can see too many of(talking about the whole forum), they don't add nothing to the discussions if not simple lazy hate. Its the mere volume the major problem, and its not like im the first addressing this. O, rly? Goblin Slayer is far from your favorite you say? *Checks favorite manga and anime list* Oh what is that? Goblin Slayer I see? Clearly far from your favorite here. *Kek* The toxic comments are here and there, but most of them, despite it's toxicity, it can be considered a valid point. I even re-read the comments criticizing this shows to reply to your salty comments. Yes, this show is a cheap product, yes this show half-assed, yes, this show is lifeless compares to it's manga and LN counterpart. This product from white fox who made critically acclaimed adaptation like White fox, re:zero so why would anyone want a 2nd season if it's gonna be the same low effort product that's far inferior to it's source material? Also, most of the criticisms from the many replies are just an opinion of an individuals, you can't even accept that. It's not something like, "Rape in episode 1 makes the anime the worst of this season ever" or something like that. It's also far from being edgy compares to your reply. Frazs said: lazly tought comments just for the sake of shtting on things are bad and discredit the community, thats what i was talkiing about, not "people not looking 4ward to the 2nd season". Don't defend this shit, you make a fool of yourself and make you part of the problem Long one: Telling the ppl criticizing the shows "discrediting the community" is somewhat ironic coming from you who's actually discrediting the GS fans community by being a salty boi here. "You" are the problem, you say you can accept criticism but from the looks of it, you're clearly trigged on all of the negative comments on GS season 2 here or else you wouldn't bash them and call them "Edgy", in ur og comments. Remember your first response? "Yo, why should you be anything but calm?" Because being calm shows you're mature enough to not get angry on seeing ppl criticizing or bashing your favorite stuff? Clearly a sign of a rational fan here. You're just like any of those edgy teenager fans who goes around the internet and insult ppl who dislike your favorite anime. Else we wouldn't be having this shit show in the first place. In short: lol, No U. |
Dec 26, 2018 2:34 PM
#43
Oh boi, i didn't even finish writing my last comment, and i already could imagine a "No u" type of response coming from you(at least youre not so braindead and aknowleaged it),and this type of surface level bs arguments you just made, because i could already understand the type of person you are from your replies,you are an open book on that.From what you wrote so far we can safly assume you don't have compresion and reading skills, and your either purposly or just seriusly missed the point,twisting anything i said in your favor,not even trying to be reasonable, consciusly or unconsiusly affected by your probable bias "Else we wouldn't be having this shit show in the first place" bhaizett said: O, rly? Goblin Slayer is far from your favorite you say? *Checks favorite manga and anime list* Oh what is that? Goblin Slayer I see? Clearly far from your favorite here. *Kek* "*kek*" oh come on,but.. Frazs said: the anime is far from my favorite,it has many flaws and many times i agreed to critcizsm of the show,i like the series so that's why even i took the time to respond to your sh*tty comment The manga is what i consider as "favorite", not the anime,the "franchise" if needed to be as clear as to speaking to a 5 years old,is what i love and is one of those which i enjoy a lot of,but it doesnt equal to favorite anime show. Moreover Mal stats tell you half truths,you can't know why i have certain scores,moreover if you base your arguments on those, well, thats something people like you would do. bhaizett said: it doesn't work like that, that logic is stupid, you are just reaching new lows on every sentece you make. When judging something,especially if you are criticizing it on a goddamn forum dedicated for its watchers, a normal thing would be trying to be as unbiased as possible,toxic people are unbiased? Make me laugh some more please. The toxic comments are here and there, but most of them, despite it's toxicity, it can be considered a valid point bhaizett said: most of the criticisms from the many replies are just an opinion of an individuals, you can't even accept that. It's not something like, "Rape in episode 1 makes the anime the worst of this season ever" or something like that. It's also far from being edgy compares to your reply. yeah sure, comments like those happen on every thread here on mal,not even shit like "ep1-4" where most hype bandwagoners still should have been in,but even in most recent ones. You wont ever understand the point i'm making, because your drawing line of a "valid opinion", which makes you think any mindless trashing is criticism, is too low, and not liking the show isn't an excuse,a normal human would say "i dont like this so i don't want waste my time following this, so i ignore at one point" normal people just drop the show with a bad review if the absolutly despise it, who gives a fuck, not like i care. But if you are still commenting about things you can't have a valid opinion because you don't care to analyse it and just hate it,making lazy and toxic biased shit no one should see,and not fans,im talking about normal watchers with working brains,is just wrong, how you still try to deny it is the problem itself. bhaizett said: Telling the ppl criticizing the shows "discrediting the community" is somewhat ironic coming from you who's actually discrediting the GS fans community by being a salty boi here. But im not talking about people actually criticizing the show,its many flaws and bloopers, those are fine, but you are not, you who defend cancer, and the same cancer im talking about,which you won't aknowleadge of as you are showing to be partly in. And i don't care about the "discrediting the fans community" its not like people who would disagree with what i said weren't in the field of already thinking who likes GS is "edgy,have rape fetish,shit taste" or some retard's vocabulary like that. bhaizett said: "Yo, why should you be anything but calm?" Because being calm shows you're mature enough to not get angry on seeing ppl criticizing or bashing your favorite stuff? Clearly a sign of a rational fan here. even specified as much as i could that it was referenced at a certain group, but trying to be fair won't help you cause i guess. bhaizett said: yo check out in what thread you are, and try actually reading what i said instead of instulting for the sake of it,in fact "add a proper diss" meant not making these lazy useless sentences that are completly off any track and won't make people take your argument seriuslygoes around the internet and insult ppl who dislike your favorite anime |
FrazsDec 26, 2018 2:46 PM
Dec 26, 2018 3:26 PM
#44
Frazs said: Oh boi, i didn't even finish writing my last comment, and i already could imagine a "No u" type of response coming from you(at least youre not so braindead and aknowleaged it),and this type of surface level bs arguments you just made, because i could already understand the type of person you are from your replies,you are an open book on that.From what you wrote so far we can safly assume you don't have compresion and reading skills, and your either purposly or just seriusly missed the point,twisting anything i said in your favor,not even trying to be reasonable, consciusly or unconsiusly affected by your probable bias "Else we wouldn't be having this shit show in the first place" bhaizett said: O, rly? Goblin Slayer is far from your favorite you say? *Checks favorite manga and anime list* Oh what is that? Goblin Slayer I see? Clearly far from your favorite here. *Kek* "*kek*" oh come on,but.. Frazs said: the anime is far from my favorite,it has many flaws and many times i agreed to critcizsm of the show,i like the series so that's why even i took the time to respond to your sh*tty comment The manga is what i consider as "favorite", not the anime,the "franchise" if needed to be as clear as to speaking to a 5 years old,is what i love and is one of those which i enjoy a lot of,but it doesnt equal to favorite anime show. Moreover Mal stats tell you half truths,you can't know why i have certain scores,moreover if you base your arguments on those, well, thats something people like you would do. bhaizett said: it doesn't work like that, that logic is stupid, you are just reaching new lows on every sentece you make. When judging something,especially if you are criticizing it on a goddamn forum dedicated for its watchers, a normal thing would be trying to be as unbiased as possible,toxic people are unbiased? Make me laugh some more please. The toxic comments are here and there, but most of them, despite it's toxicity, it can be considered a valid point bhaizett said: most of the criticisms from the many replies are just an opinion of an individuals, you can't even accept that. It's not something like, "Rape in episode 1 makes the anime the worst of this season ever" or something like that. It's also far from being edgy compares to your reply. yeah sure, comments like those happen on every thread here on mal,not even shit like "ep1-4" where most hype bandwagoners still should have been in,but even in most recent ones. You wont ever understand the point i'm making, because your drawing line of a "valid opinion", which makes you think any mindless trashing is criticism, is too low, and not liking the show isn't an excuse,a normal human would say "i dont like this so i don't want waste my time following this, so i ignore at one point" normal people just drop the show with a bad review if the absolutly despise it, who gives a fuck, not like i care. But if you are still commenting about things you can't have a valid opinion because you don't care to analyse it and just hate it,making lazy and toxic biased shit no one should see,and not fans,im talking about normal watchers with working brains,is just wrong, how you still try to deny it is the problem itself. bhaizett said: Telling the ppl criticizing the shows "discrediting the community" is somewhat ironic coming from you who's actually discrediting the GS fans community by being a salty boi here. But im not talking about people actually criticizing the show,its many flaws and bloopers, those are fine, but you are not, you who defend cancer, and the same cancer im talking about,which you won't aknowleadge of as you are showing to be partly in. And i don't care about the "discrediting the fans community" its not like people who would disagree with what i said weren't in the field of already thinking who likes GS is "edgy,have rape fetish,shit taste" or some retard's vocabulary like that. bhaizett said: "Yo, why should you be anything but calm?" Because being calm shows you're mature enough to not get angry on seeing ppl criticizing or bashing your favorite stuff? Clearly a sign of a rational fan here. even specified as much as i could that it was referenced at a certain group, but trying to be fair won't help you cause i guess. bhaizett said: yo check out in what thread you are, and try actually reading what i said instead of instulting for the sake of it,in fact "add a proper diss" meant not making these lazy useless sentences that are completly off any track and won't make people take your argument seriuslygoes around the internet and insult ppl who dislike your favorite anime Absolutely none of this is constructive. So do you guys think season two (if it does happen) is going to bem ore action driven or character driven cause I think they're going to start going on a character route myself. Also do you think they're going ot have him end up with anoyne? I mean I know they're hinting at it but I'm not sure and of course if you're ahead in the manga no spoilers without wornings thanks everyone! |
Dec 26, 2018 3:36 PM
#45
hiimnewbenice said: Absolutely none of this is constructive. So do you guys think season two (if it does happen) is going to bem ore action driven or character driven cause I think they're going to start going on a character route myself. Also do you think they're going ot have him end up with anoyne? I mean I know they're hinting at it but I'm not sure and of course if you're ahead in the manga no spoilers without wornings thanks everyone! Personally, from what I saw and heard, I think it will be more character driven and less action oriented. And maybe some ship tease here and there...personally, just let him end with one or none, either go redeemed character arc or full edge mode arc. Just go with one or another or goes both ways, I'm fine with both as long as the anime didn't ruined it with another half-assed adaptation. |
Dec 26, 2018 4:31 PM
#46
@Frazs I wasn't gonna make another reply on this seeing how much you look like any other of those angry lil' GS fanbois on the previous comment. But since you made some good point, I'll response with less insults and more actual talk. Frazs said: the anime is far from my favorite,it has many flaws and many times i agreed to critcizsm of the show,i like the series so that's why even i took the time to respond to your sh*tty comment The manga is what i consider as "favorite", not the anime,the "franchise" if needed to be as clear as to speaking to a 5 years old,is what i love and is one of those which i enjoy a lot of,but it doesnt equal to favorite anime show. Moreover Mal stats tell you half truths,you can't know why i have certain scores,moreover if you base your arguments on those, well, thats something people like you would do. Alright, if you think the manga is a 10, that's fine. I can see that. But then, maybe consider that giving the anime a score 10/10 is a bit far-fetched and contradictive to what you wrote? Just sayin'. As for the toxicity, let's acknowledge that, we both are toxic. Your first comments are kind of ironically enough, toxic in itself. And I'll admit, being sarcastic isn't exactly far from toxicity either. As for the criticism on the anime itself. As far as I'm concerned, most of the points of criticism towards anime is still valid, and toxic doesn't have to mean it's pure hate. Some do contain some degree of cynicism, but most sure aren't that high to even consider toxic, compares to us. But I reckon I can't say the same to you because what I meant by toxicity is most likely different than yours. Frazs said: it doesn't work like that, that logic is stupid, you are just reaching new lows on every sentece you make. When judging something,especially if you are criticizing it on a goddamn forum dedicated for its watchers, a normal thing would be trying to be as unbiased as possible,toxic people are unbiased? Make me laugh some more please. Okay, I'll admit this is my bad for trolling. I should've rephrased the sentence to something like "Regardless of how pessimistic it looks, the criticism towards the anime from most of the replies is not really that negative to be considered toxic." if you re-read. It's actually really not, maybe a few but mostly not to be considered edgy like you said anyway. Frazs said: yeah sure, comments like those happen on every thread here on mal,not even shit like "ep1-4" where most hype bandwagoners still should have been in,but even in most recent ones. You wont ever understand the point i'm making, because your drawing line of a "valid opinion", which makes you think any mindless trashing is criticism, is too low, and not liking the show isn't an excuse,a normal human would say "i dont like this so i don't want waste my time following this, so i ignore at one point" normal people just drop the show with a bad review if the absolutly despise it, who gives a fuck, not like i care. But if you are still commenting about things you can't have a valid opinion because you don't care to analyse it and just hate it,making lazy and toxic biased shit no one should see,and not fans,im talking about normal watchers with working brains,is just wrong, how you still try to deny it is the problem itself. Depends on who has more evidence backed-up in their argument. In the case of the rape, I don't find it as much big of a deal, other than the shock factor, I don't have a quarrel about it. I normally tries to stay on the neutral ground. Which to be fair, I find the anime okay. Maybe if the animation and art styles is more expressive like in the manga, I would've like it more. And if you want my honest opinion? No, I don't want season 2 of Goblin Slayer if it's gonna ended up another half-assed product from a studio who, I know can do better. I'd rather wait for the TL of the manga or read the LN. But maybe some of the problems I find in the anime is also occurs in the manga like the harem which i find unnecessary and serves nothing to the plot at all. Let him go with cow girl whose relationships is established well enough or just let him go solo because I'm tired of the harem tropes in where it doesn't belong. Something like that, the rest of the stuff is serviceable. It's not that dark & gritty to me though, I really don't see that. Frazs said: But im not talking about people actually criticizing the show,its many flaws and bloopers, those are fine, but you are not, you who defend cancer, and the same cancer im talking about,which you won't aknowleadge of as you are showing to be partly in. And i don't care about the "discrediting the fans community" its not like people who would disagree with what i said weren't in the field of already thinking who likes GS is "edgy,have rape fetish,shit taste" or some retard's vocabulary like that. No, I'm pretty sure I'm not defending cancer. I already pointed out many times that their criticism is not cancer. At least not by my standard because it's clear at this point that we let our biases affect our opinion so that's that. And we can't decide that for themselves. Either go look for someone to tell you who's the cancer here or stop talking about this point entirely. I'm also not saying every fans of GS is an edgy teenager who goes around badmouthing ppl just because they're criticizing their favorite series. I know ppl who likes Goblin Slayer and is a rational people who's calm even when ppl is shitting on what they like. And look, if you don't want ppl to calls you an edgy fanboi. Maybe next time don't leave a bad first impression by calling others edgy first. bhaizett said: "Yo, why should you be anything but calm?" Because being calm shows you're mature enough to not get angry on seeing ppl criticizing or bashing your favorite stuff? Clearly a sign of a rational fan here. Frazs said: even specified as much as i could that it was referenced at a certain group, but trying to be fair won't help you cause i guess. You kinda comes off as one on the first two comments, but I'll take it back since this reply is actually not bad. Frazs said: yo check out in what thread you are, and try actually reading what i said instead of instulting for the sake of it,in fact "add a proper diss" meant not making these lazy useless sentences that are completly off any track and won't make people take your argument seriusly And I did just that? We cool now? |
Dec 26, 2018 8:01 PM
#47
bhaizett said: hiimnewbenice said: Absolutely none of this is constructive. So do you guys think season two (if it does happen) is going to bem ore action driven or character driven cause I think they're going to start going on a character route myself. Also do you think they're going ot have him end up with anoyne? I mean I know they're hinting at it but I'm not sure and of course if you're ahead in the manga no spoilers without wornings thanks everyone! Personally, from what I saw and heard, I think it will be more character driven and less action oriented. And maybe some ship tease here and there...personally, just let him end with one or none, either go redeemed character arc or full edge mode arc. Just go with one or another or goes both ways, I'm fine with both as long as the anime didn't ruined it with another half-assed adaptation. I agree completely with the one or none sentiment quite frankly I don't really think there needed to be this many girls for him to potentially fall for but I'm not mad at it. It may make certain dynamics between different characters more interesting later on. I personally like where most of this story is going and now even the other guild members are getting more into this. So many interesting possibilities! |
Dec 26, 2018 8:25 PM
#48
The good thing to take away from this is the anime only adapted two volumes of the light novel series. So they will have plenty of material to adapt from if they go forward with a second season. Light novel series is already at Volume 9 in Japan. |
Dec 26, 2018 8:56 PM
#49
hiimnewbenice said: Absolutely none of this is constructive. So do you guys think season two (if it does happen) is going to bem ore action driven or character driven cause I think they're going to start going on a character route myself. Also do you think they're going ot have him end up with anoyne? I mean I know they're hinting at it but I'm not sure and of course if you're ahead in the manga no spoilers without wornings thanks everyone! Anime adaptation reached till the second latest manga chapter(29) which both adapt 2 volumes of the LN, if an improbable second season would come out,with hints from the last chap(30)(which starts the adaptaion of the third volume), info from the actual volume 3 would tell,and the fact that the plot becomes more and more about Goblin Slayer rehabilitation it would be mostly about characters interaction and development. While the Light novel has 8 volumes out and dude isn't paired with anyone still (no reference about the specific development within), so it would be some just some midway development,which would feel akward to adapt. And we have seen how with 12eps they barely adapted the surface content from two volumes. Moreover at this point as whitefox already treated the series as an easy money-low effort machine,further season is just unthinkable,even just for the sake of making it.The main problem being that the story is actually characters driven from the start,or overall more balanced, in contrast to the studio which made it look closer to being mindless action driven(not putting much effort even into making that part), cutting lots of important content from every goddamn character.for example the Protagonists at the start of volume 3 should be guild girl and cow girl, which are really strongly developed and loved characters in the manga, but in the anime they are the weakest and least cared about,a miracle would be needed for a new season to be considerable worth watching by the public(composed mostly by anime-onlys) and be worth producing by a studio, there's simply no much ground to work on, as the current one spread salt on its soil. Saying this is out of place but manga side getting quicker releases is what we could mostly and should actually be hoping for really,for the best of the series thats it... |
Dec 26, 2018 9:36 PM
#50
[quote=Frazs message=56572674] hiimnewbenice said: Moreover at this point as whitefox already treated the series as an easy money-low effort machine,further season is just unthinkable,even just for the sake of making it.The main problem being that the story is actually characters driven from the start,or overall more balanced, in contrast to the studio which made it look closer to being mindless action driven(not putting much effort even into making that part), cutting lots of important content from every goddamn character.for example the Protagonists at the start of volume 3 should be guild girl and cow girl, which are really strongly developed and loved characters in the manga, but in the anime they are the weakest and least cared about,a miracle would be needed for a new season to be considerable worth watching by the public(composed mostly by anime-onlys) and be worth producing by a studio, there's simply no much ground to work on, as the current one spread salt on its soil. Saying this is out of place but manga side getting quicker releases is what we could mostly and should actually be hoping for really,for the best of the series thats it... That's interesting I didn't know a lot of that. I agree having the guild girl and the cowgirl be the main protagonists for the next season would be strange due to how little they're currently cared about. They're definitely seen as interesting characters by some especially the cowgirl but they're not quite that loved (which is kind of sad because there's SO MUCH potential there). I also agree that a lot of the character development is happening very very slowly. A part of me feels like they're doing it that way to make it feel more human. In many shows I see characters develop so fast it almost makes no sense and takes me out of the experience because it's too unreal. At the same time from a storytelling perspective, it's going a bit too slow but I am excited to see how everyone develops. I just hope they don't spend so much time with all these other characters (like all the people in the guild for example) that they lose sight of the main people and never develop them in the show. I may read the manga or go look at the LN for this one I'm curious to see the differences. |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Goblin Slayer Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Dec 29, 2018 |
380 |
by AnnaRoseMarie
»»
Sep 11, 8:46 PM |
|
Poll: » Goblin Slayer Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Oct 6, 2018 |
998 |
by ReiKhaos
»»
Jul 3, 4:46 PM |
|
Poll: » Goblin Slayer Episode 2 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Oct 13, 2018 |
386 |
by AbyssD
»»
Jun 17, 7:18 AM |
|
Poll: » Goblin Slayer Episode 4 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Oct 27, 2018 |
313 |
by Shumerlak
»»
May 6, 3:36 PM |
|
Poll: » Goblin Slayer Episode 3 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Oct 20, 2018 |
303 |
by Shumerlak
»»
May 6, 3:15 PM |