WhiteTestament said:Yeah, but the writing, foreshadowing and characters of AoT are levels above this one, it's not even close. This introduction of an evil guy who can enter multiple pictures at the same time and possess people like it's nothing seems to be there just for shock value.
Obviously there will be a reason since this guy seems to know Cheng ("the game is reset" or whatever it said at the end) and it has been just vaguely hinted by LiuRen (when he refers that it's someone else doing the killing) but it still feels so badly put together with almost no tought behind.
In this first season we dont know why our MCs can time travel, how they do it and furthermore Cheng seems definitely stupid more than in instance. Lu tells him every single episode that he has to go with the script, change nothing, don't go overboard and yet, Cheng fails every single time. The explanation of multiple alternate reality created by him is just... put there. And that's the reason for the double attack of LiuRen (or whoever is possessing him) against LuGuang in the studio and Cheng inside Xu's body.
AOT has like 25 episodes of the first season for introduction and world-building, next 12 episodes for some small reveals and the whole 22 episodes of ss3 for big reveals. How can it be compared to an 11 episode Anime with 3/4 of total runtime is drama of multiple people and only last 3 episodes actually focuses on the overaching story??? Steins;Gate would have suffered the same issue if it has ended after the first 12 episodes.WhiteTestament said:As for Emma... I get it, her course of life has been changed by that single message that Cheng sent in EP1, that is why her parents come visit her at the city and why she rushes toward the station meeting LiuMin... but I still dont get it. Why would she want to kill herself? Just because she can't text back her parents? It seems idiotic and beyond laughable.
First episode introduced that she has always been under pressure of abusing and overworking, eats dirty food and can't have proper sleep. Later, her CFO got arrested for financial fraud. As his assistant, Emma more or less was involved and lost her job and could never work in that field ever again. In the last episode, it also revealed she actually knew about his affair but just happened to turn a blind eye to it for the bribe. She acknowledged that she has degenerated into a bad person, no different than her CFO. Because of her self-esteem, she was in great torment, thinking about her parents just make her more depressed. That's why when she confronted Xiaoshi, she was bawling her eye out "Could you help me go back to square one? Then I can start over". Her phone broke here was just the last straw that led to her suicide. Isn't it too hard to understand?WhiteTestament said:What I don't get is... in the first EP LuGuang is perplexed at the end to find out that Emma died later that night, so Cheng actually is the reason for her death, even if throghout the season we are costantly reminded that the past cant be changed. Death can't be changed, there are nodes that would occur no matter what, so thats why she wants to kill herself?
The past WhiteTestament said:As for the animations they are serviceable.. I guess? It's like watching an animated webtoon and thats fine. There are a lot of reused scenes and screenshots toward the end. The budget should have been pretty tight I think.
The character designer is a Korean so indeed, it does looks like an animated webtoon. If you talk about the reused scenes and screenshots in Xiaoshi and Emma's conversation then it was used for the narrative purpose, not because of a tight budget, just look at the OP, ED and the animation in episode 3.WhiteTestament said:I still think this is way overrated and that there are a lot of time travel or thriller anime that are actually good/great compared to this.
I wanted really to like it but not everything is for everyone.
I don't get why you keep forcing it to be thriller and saying it's bad when the show was meant to be drama and mystery in the first place.