Yamada-kun to 7-nin no Majo Chapter 197 Discussion

finestseeker17 said:
I really like the cover for this chapter. Maybe, the mangaka should work on a fantasy story next. Although, I don't mind reading another school-life manga.

I've always liked Shiraishi since the early chapters of this manga. Even though I like Nene more, I still like Shiraishi. But, lately I couldn't help but think that her character is too good to be true. I mean, in the past, she just seems like a cool and kind, but also cute socially awkward girl that really loves studying. Her "ignorance" or "innocence" (I'm using the quotation marks because I'm not sure how to describe it lol) about many things are really funny. Maybe, it's a bit overused. But now, I really couldn't understand her anymore, she's very very kind, really unselfish, and yet after all this time, she also still has this "ignorance" and "innocence" to her. That's why I couldn't help but think that maybe she's hiding something from us (I know, it's a bit of a stretch lol, but I couldn't help it). Meh.. maybe that's just why so many people love her and my taste is just on the opposite side. Nene for life!

Anyway, in the end, Shiraishi didn't even answer Yamada about when she wrote that "body-swap" note on her journal. Yeah yeah, the answer is easy probably she realized it earlier and wrote it immediately or maybe she already got some intels from Takuma or maybe she just had an intuition or predicted it.

That is a Light Yagami level of internal dialogue by Yamada lol. Perhaps, Yamada is secretly bright. This chapter, we could see that Yamada's really good on sports. I dunno why he & Ushio were being a loner prior to the incident with Nancy. They could've just joined a sports club..

Please ignore me, I just overthinked too much lol. By the way, another school trip is coming soon.

DropofVenus said:
Shiraishi is the best girl in the series but I do believe she is infact hiding something. It was mentioned in a previous chapter forever ago by the guy with the cane that she has not told him something yet. Moreover the chapters that had her at Yamada's house may have been her trying to find the courage to tell him her secret (or she just wanted to spend some time with him). I think it has something to do with how to re-obtain his lost memories but she may be holding back for Himekawa's sake. The lost memories need to be revealed soon since this arc is taking so many detours. Yamada was shown heading to the teachers office and probably meeting Shiraishi is the past. Himekawa was shown expressing that she felt that Yamada was in love with someone else (which is clearly Shiarishi). As with Nene still loving Yamada even before and after memory loss. Yamada and Shiraishi are still drawn to each other in both past and present. Yamada's fling with Himekawa was sincere but we will have to wait and see what the truth is. I would not mind Shiraishi showing a little selfishness now and again as she did when she was sulking alone at home when he looked into her past. Its clear she loves and trusts Yamada but sometimes can't help but to act a little selfish now and again. I liked this chapter but it confuses me on shiraishi's intentions even more. I do not want all the memories beforehand (first books of the manga) to be left forgotten by everyone. I think Yoshikawa is filling us with a lot of filler while trying to think about how to get around a memory plot hole.

finestseeker17 said:
@ludokresh
I thought we still need 2 more witches, or am I wrong? Let's see: Masamune, Yuri, Takuma, Hikaru, and Alex. Did I miss someone?

Anyway, they couldn't do a ceremony with the same set of witches, right? So, if they change any of the members, they could do it several times. Or am I wrong? I recall Nene said that she and the witches from 1st part of this series + an ugly-looking senior lol were called for a meeting in the altar room. So, I assume they were gathered there to do a ceremony with Yamazaki. And yet later, they could still hold a ceremony with Yamada, but without the ugly-looking senior lol.

If I'm right, then the male witches (warlocks) aren't just a gimmick lol. You could do it with different witches, but you couldn't do it if it's a mix between witches and warlocks XD. If I'm wrong, then they could just hold a ceremony right now with the mix between Takuma's and Nancy's witches.

By the way, the story aren't really going anywhere since that chapter where we saw Himekawa's crying and said that Yamada's crush was not her. It's the same as always. This manga is hanging by a thread in my mind. It's still about whether that girl was Urara or not! If it was Urara, without a good explanation on why Nene's so in love with Yamada, then I'll review my score on this series for sure.

ludokresh said:
mmmmmmmmm yes my friend, you're forgetting Kurosaki Jin lol... only one warlock left to track down. So, another yankee-kun ending, simply epic ROFL XD....

ludokresh said:
Mmmm i don't think yamada can hold a ceremony using witches from different groups (but since this author seems to want to drag this thing on even further, who knows lol ). Like i said some chapter ago, if it is the Urara, then all this has been a walking in circles; if it isn't her..mmm....well...mmmm

ludokresh said:
sheeeeeiitttttttt man!!!!!!! another awful ending lol

"yoshikawa reading discussions" : muhahahaha, i got them to like my story, now it's time to screw the manga (actually, it lready is, but it'd be the cherry on the cake, the grand finale) and laughing at them.... XD.

ludokresh said:
man, anything is better than Nisekoi..

finestseeker17 said:

Lol I hope she won't troll us. For me, it's still debateable whether this series is already ruined or not. Yeah, maybe those detours and fillers are a bit annoying. But, for me overall it's still good. It's hanging by a thread, but for now, it's still good lol.


There was a time brother.. when Nisekoi was good. Currently, I rate it 6, but I always a have feeling that I'll rate it 4 when it's over lol.

ludokresh said:
for me, when yamada kun started until chapter 90-91 it was good, it's been all.downhill from there.
First arc: 1-90 very good----i rate it 9
second arc: 90-180----- rate it 6
current arc: rate it 4 or maybe 5

i keep reading it because i've passed the point of no return, i've read over 180 chapters and no matter how shitty it gets (something tells me it will get even shittier, a disturbance in the Force if you will), i must see that awful ending XD LOL

damnshettodesu said:
if was not for Nene who here will still reading this manga?? lol

finestseeker17 said:

Lol.. don't start it, bruh! Shiraishi's fanboys are as many as we are. Currently, they're just lurking underground and don't post as much. I bet if the mangaka gives us a Nene end *cough*best end*cough*, there will be a riot in the final chapter's discussion thread lol. I don't mind it tho... :p This manga is pretty popular, almost 39000 users. So, it'll be fun to see the reactions.

damnshettodesu said:

It gonna end like YanMegane with the editor get bored of ur shit again and give us a bad shitty fast ending.

if was not for Nene who here will still reading this manga?? lol

damnshettodesu said:
Bruh, bring em to Nene team is ez



mangaka-kunt draw dis just for Nene~

finestseeker17 said:

If only it was that easy my brother. Anyway, you picked an awesome pic there. That is perfect! Lol.

But, seriously, it's either gonna end with a troll and weird ending or it's gonna be Shiraishi ending. But, there's still a possibility for Nene. Let's hang on to that!

ludokresh said:
yeah, like yamada waking up in the school infirmary and realizing that everything was just a dream:

yamada: where's shiraishi
nurse: oh, you're wake, you mean the blonde girl?
yamada: yeah:
nurse: let's just say that she didn't end up well after that fall
---then roll the credits...

seriously though, i hope Nene wins.. she's da best XD <3 <3