New
Mar 22, 2014 11:21 AM
#1051
Monster Tenma had a gun in his hand, but he let Johan walk away. I just hated that, I don't like how they played it out as Johan being intimidating and I predicted that something like this would happen, ever since Tenma started his journey to kill Johan. It was just bullshit, especially considering that Tenma shouldn't have conflict and afraid to take a life, since he already killed that bodyguard (I forgot his name). So it was just played out as Johan being intimidating enough to walk away like that. To think Tenma disregarded everything in his life, to kill Johan, only to not be able to pull the trigger, when he has a perfect shot and just stare there, along with Anna. It's just so predictable, underwhelming and renders a good portion of his journey pointless. It made me completely lose interest on whether or not Johan is going to die, at any point in the series. I didn't finish Monster, but if Johan really controlled all those people, simply by his words, presence and because ''lol his a super evil genius'', then I really don't want to finish it. Meh. |
Mar 22, 2014 11:27 AM
#1052
IntroverTurtle said: Kaimon said: Why didn't he teach him anything other than a big rasengan you mean. There were tons of other frog jutsus he could have learned.Another one regarding Naruto Was there any specific reason why Jiraya didn't teach Naruto sage mode during their 2 1/2 years of training? That too. Seems like he learned more with Kakashi and Yamato than he did with Jiraya. |
Mar 22, 2014 11:33 AM
#1053
Kaimon said: IntroverTurtle said: Kaimon said: Why didn't he teach him anything other than a big rasengan you mean. There were tons of other frog jutsus he could have learned.Another one regarding Naruto Was there any specific reason why Jiraya didn't teach Naruto sage mode during their 2 1/2 years of training? That too. Seems like he learned more with Kakashi and Yamato than he did with Jiraya. They probably spent more time chasing girls around than doing any training. The way of the toad and all. |
"Let Justice Be Done!" My Theme Fight again, fight again for justice! |
Mar 22, 2014 11:38 AM
#1054
tsudecimo said: Monster Tenma had a gun in his hand, but he let Johan walk away. I just hated that, I don't like how they played it out as Johan being intimidating and I predicted that something like this would happen, ever since Tenma started his journey to kill Johan. It was just bullshit, especially considering that Tenma shouldn't have conflict and afraid to take a life, since he already killed that bodyguard (I forgot his name). So it was just played out as Johan being intimidating enough to walk away like that. To think Tenma disregarded everything in his life, to kill Johan, only to not be able to pull the trigger, when he has a perfect shot and just stare there, along with Anna. It's just so predictable, underwhelming and renders a good portion of his journey pointless. It made me completely lose interest on whether or not Johan is going to die, at any point in the series. I didn't finish Monster, but if Johan really controlled all those people, simply by his words, presence and because ''lol his a super evil genius'', then I really don't want to finish it. Meh. Spoiler regarding the bodyguard you haven't seen yet I assume He miraculously survives so Tenma's bullshit inner conflict about killing Johan doesn't end there and only gets worse. You're unfortunately not far off in your prediction regarding the rest of your spoiler tags either despite what some people who love the show/Johan think. |
Mar 22, 2014 12:00 PM
#1055
hybreezy said: tsudecimo said: Monster Tenma had a gun in his hand, but he let Johan walk away. I just hated that, I don't like how they played it out as Johan being intimidating and I predicted that something like this would happen, ever since Tenma started his journey to kill Johan. It was just bullshit, especially considering that Tenma shouldn't have conflict and afraid to take a life, since he already killed that bodyguard (I forgot his name). So it was just played out as Johan being intimidating enough to walk away like that. To think Tenma disregarded everything in his life, to kill Johan, only to not be able to pull the trigger, when he has a perfect shot and just stare there, along with Anna. It's just so predictable, underwhelming and renders a good portion of his journey pointless. It made me completely lose interest on whether or not Johan is going to die, at any point in the series. I didn't finish Monster, but if Johan really controlled all those people, simply by his words, presence and because ''lol his a super evil genius'', then I really don't want to finish it. Meh. Spoiler regarding the bodyguard you haven't seen yet I assume He miraculously survives so Tenma's bullshit inner conflict about killing Johan doesn't end there and only gets worse. You're unfortunately not far off in your prediction regarding the rest of your spoiler tags either despite what some people who love the show/Johan think. Makes sense, otherwise, why is the show is 74 episodes, when the story clearly doesn't need that many episodes. I feared for Tenma's inner conflict crap, since he started his journey. It just annoys me, if you are going to throw away anything in your life, just for the sake of one thing, and one thing only. Then you better get it done. Well that's sucks. I already lacked motivation but this gives me another reason to not continue watching Monster. I think I still have some interest left regarding Anna but idk. |
Mar 22, 2014 12:09 PM
#1056
tsudecimo said: hybreezy said: tsudecimo said: Monster Tenma had a gun in his hand, but he let Johan walk away. I just hated that, I don't like how they played it out as Johan being intimidating and I predicted that something like this would happen, ever since Tenma started his journey to kill Johan. It was just bullshit, especially considering that Tenma shouldn't have conflict and afraid to take a life, since he already killed that bodyguard (I forgot his name). So it was just played out as Johan being intimidating enough to walk away like that. To think Tenma disregarded everything in his life, to kill Johan, only to not be able to pull the trigger, when he has a perfect shot and just stare there, along with Anna. It's just so predictable, underwhelming and renders a good portion of his journey pointless. It made me completely lose interest on whether or not Johan is going to die, at any point in the series. I didn't finish Monster, but if Johan really controlled all those people, simply by his words, presence and because ''lol his a super evil genius'', then I really don't want to finish it. Meh. Spoiler regarding the bodyguard you haven't seen yet I assume He miraculously survives so Tenma's bullshit inner conflict about killing Johan doesn't end there and only gets worse. You're unfortunately not far off in your prediction regarding the rest of your spoiler tags either despite what some people who love the show/Johan think. Makes sense, otherwise, why is the show is 74 episodes, when the story clearly doesn't need that many episodes. I feared for Tenma's inner conflict crap, since he started his journey. It just annoys me, if you are going to throw away anything in your life, just for the sake of one thing, and one thing only. Then you better get it done. Well that's sucks. I already lacked motivation but this gives me another reason to not continue watching Monster. I think I still have some interest left regarding Anna but idk. Yeah I really didn't like Tenma at all as a character either even setting aside all the dumb things he does simply because "he's a good person" despite putting himself at risk due to being a fugitive. I'd almost say you might as well slowly grind it out just to see how it plays out since you've almost reached the point of being too time committed. But I don't recommend suffering through things either and you got like 30 episodes to go so coin flip I guess. |
Mar 23, 2014 12:13 AM
#1057
ssjokg said: judals said: Nicobade said: judals said: Naruto, hidan arc: Hidan incapacitated Shikamaru, but spent time on the stab-self ceremony where he could have easily killed him directly. How is that a plothole or bs moment? It is already established that Hidan is a sadist and masochist and that he enjoys savouring his kills and performing his ritual so I don't see how it would be surprising that he does it again with Shikamaru. In general villains wasting time allowing to be defeated by the hero when they could have easily killed them earlier is usually BS but with a character like Hidan it makes sense. because of the "villain is a sadist and masochist and that he enjoys savouring his kills" cliche. and no. Yeah, there are few exceptions but this clearly isn't one. Why? If he's really a sado/masochist he'd not have stabbed himself once in the chest, but rather take it slow. Are you an M? I am not defending Hidan just wondering why you are so sure. Kaimon said: Because you need a "state of emergency" in order to learn any kind of new ability.101 for every battle shounen.Another one regarding Naruto Was there any specific reason why Jiraya didn't teach Naruto sage mode during their 2 1/2 years of training? I'm more of an S person but the point is if torturing him was really an excuse for such convenience, there need to be... Torture. As for Kaimon's post, that's actually 101 for life too but there WAS an emergency. That's the whole reason for training. |
Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
Mar 23, 2014 3:25 AM
#1058
The moment in Attack on Titan when Eren first gets "eaten" and then turns into a titan out of nowhere.. |
"Whatever happens, happens." - Spike Spiegel |
Mar 23, 2014 3:31 AM
#1059
g00dnight said: The moment in Attack on Titan when Eren first gets "eaten" and then turns into a titan out of nowhere.. From my perspective it was kinda foreshadowed back at the start of episode 2 (I think) where Eren's dad injects a screaming Eren with something special in that dream. Though I thought he was only going to gain Titan regeneration. Not many people talked about it after it was shown though... |
KVVMar 23, 2014 3:36 AM
Mar 23, 2014 3:33 AM
#1060
tsudecimo said: Monster Tenma had a gun in his hand, but he let Johan walk away. I just hated that, I don't like how they played it out as Johan being intimidating and I predicted that something like this would happen, ever since Tenma started his journey to kill Johan. It was just bullshit, especially considering that Tenma shouldn't have conflict and afraid to take a life, since he already killed that bodyguard (I forgot his name). So it was just played out as Johan being intimidating enough to walk away like that. To think Tenma disregarded everything in his life, to kill Johan, only to not be able to pull the trigger, when he has a perfect shot and just stare there, along with Anna. It's just so predictable, underwhelming and renders a good portion of his journey pointless. It made me completely lose interest on whether or not Johan is going to die, at any point in the series. I didn't finish Monster, but if Johan really controlled all those people, simply by his words, presence and because ''lol his a super evil genius'', then I really don't want to finish it. Meh. You really don't want to see the ending then and should probably drop it right now. |
Mar 23, 2014 3:34 AM
#1061
Use spoilers guys... Not everyone has watched it. |
5 main aspects I base my ratings on: 1. Did DramaEnthusiast make a thread about it? 2. Is it better than Breaking Bad? 3. Did MellowJello recommend the shit out of it? 4. Has it caused a (very entertaining) shitstorm on MAL? 5. Is it actually good? Scratch the fifth point, it's not very relevant... |
Mar 23, 2014 3:43 AM
#1062
g00dnight said: The moment in Attack on Titan when Eren first gets "eaten" and then turns into a titan out of nowhere.. Seriously? That is out of nowhere?It was foreshadowed,through an unknow drug in the first episodes and then shown again when he saved Armin and Mikasa from the cannon ball The only bullshit there is that it conviently caused memory loss back then. And really you mention about AoT(no I dont care about the score you gave) when you have Campione in favs? I would understand if you were reading the novel but the bullshit in the anime adaptation surpass those of SAO which you dropped. judals said: ssjokg said: judals said: Nicobade said: judals said: Naruto, hidan arc: Hidan incapacitated Shikamaru, but spent time on the stab-self ceremony where he could have easily killed him directly. How is that a plothole or bs moment? It is already established that Hidan is a sadist and masochist and that he enjoys savouring his kills and performing his ritual so I don't see how it would be surprising that he does it again with Shikamaru. In general villains wasting time allowing to be defeated by the hero when they could have easily killed them earlier is usually BS but with a character like Hidan it makes sense. because of the "villain is a sadist and masochist and that he enjoys savouring his kills" cliche. and no. Yeah, there are few exceptions but this clearly isn't one. Why? If he's really a sado/masochist he'd not have stabbed himself once in the chest, but rather take it slow. Are you an M? I am not defending Hidan just wondering why you are so sure. Kaimon said: Because you need a "state of emergency" in order to learn any kind of new ability.101 for every battle shounen.Another one regarding Naruto Was there any specific reason why Jiraya didn't teach Naruto sage mode during their 2 1/2 years of training? I'm more of an S person but the point is if torturing him was really an excuse for such convenience, there need to be... Torture. As for Kaimon's post, that's actually 101 for life too but there WAS an emergency. That's the whole reason for training. I dont think real life is so convinient. Not really?Akatsuki WAS after him but it wasnt really that serious at that time. It's weird because everyone else from his generation had a new move of sorts but he had what?A better trained body and a more powerful/compressed rasengan while he still needed help from clones....Great training.... |
Mar 23, 2014 3:47 AM
#1063
Keetriver said: g00dnight said: The moment in Attack on Titan when Eren first gets "eaten" and then turns into a titan out of nowhere.. From my perspective it was kinda foreshadowed back at the start of episode 2 (I think) where Eren's dad injects a screaming Eren with something special in that dream. Though I thought he was only going to gain Titan regeneration. Not many people talked about it after it was shown though... That was foreshadowing for something else and no sufficient enough for Eren's situation. It is a big asspull but a good one imo. |
Mar 23, 2014 3:58 AM
#1064
tsudecimo said: Keetriver said: g00dnight said: The moment in Attack on Titan when Eren first gets "eaten" and then turns into a titan out of nowhere.. From my perspective it was kinda foreshadowed back at the start of episode 2 (I think) where Eren's dad injects a screaming Eren with something special in that dream. Though I thought he was only going to gain Titan regeneration. Not many people talked about it after it was shown though... That was foreshadowing for something else and no sufficient enough for Eren's situation. It is a big asspull but a good one imo. If THAT wasn't foreshadowing Eren being special in some way then what does it foreshadow? Does it come up in the manga or something? |
Mar 23, 2014 3:59 AM
#1065
tsudecimo said: Keetriver said: g00dnight said: The moment in Attack on Titan when Eren first gets "eaten" and then turns into a titan out of nowhere.. From my perspective it was kinda foreshadowed back at the start of episode 2 (I think) where Eren's dad injects a screaming Eren with something special in that dream. Though I thought he was only going to gain Titan regeneration. Not many people talked about it after it was shown though... That was foreshadowing for something else and no sufficient enough for Eren's situation. It is a big asspull but a good one imo. You mean about the basement? So he gets an injection when he gets the key Surely you wouldnt think that it was for THAT, but when THAT happens you cant say that it happened randomly just because he is the MC,you know the reason so it isnt an asspull. |
Mar 23, 2014 4:27 AM
#1066
Keetriver said: If THAT wasn't foreshadowing Eren being special in some way then what does it foreshadow? Does it come up in the manga or something? It wasn't sufficient. It could have meant anything, it does not foreshadow what becomes of Eren, it only gives grounds for an explanation to it, and foreshadow that Eren's father and the basement are connected to the secrets of the titans The emphasis about that flashback scene was the basement. If it was really about Eren then His father would have said ''you will survive with this son, it will protect you'' or something along those lines. But his father emphasized that Eren should go to the basement with the key etc. I wouldn't know if they finally reached the basement or if Eren's dad become relevant again, because I stopped reading the very boring manga. It's just an asspull. But I think it's a good one, because of it's dramatic effect. It created a lot of excitement and it was utterly unpredictable. Sure, from a critical point of view, that can be considered 'bad' writing, but it entertained the audience. It could have achieved both, if it was better foreshadowed, but that might have made it less unpredictable |
Mar 23, 2014 4:37 AM
#1067
ssjokg said: tsudecimo said: Keetriver said: g00dnight said: The moment in Attack on Titan when Eren first gets "eaten" and then turns into a titan out of nowhere.. From my perspective it was kinda foreshadowed back at the start of episode 2 (I think) where Eren's dad injects a screaming Eren with something special in that dream. Though I thought he was only going to gain Titan regeneration. Not many people talked about it after it was shown though... That was foreshadowing for something else and no sufficient enough for Eren's situation. It is a big asspull but a good one imo. You mean about the basement? So he gets an injection when he gets the key Surely you wouldnt think that it was for THAT, but when THAT happens you cant say that it happened randomly just because he is the MC,you know the reason so it isnt an asspull. Its not like it was like "bullshit" in a badway, just more like wtf and incredibly random. |
"Whatever happens, happens." - Spike Spiegel |
Mar 23, 2014 4:41 AM
#1068
g00dnight said: ssjokg said: tsudecimo said: Keetriver said: g00dnight said: The moment in Attack on Titan when Eren first gets "eaten" and then turns into a titan out of nowhere.. From my perspective it was kinda foreshadowed back at the start of episode 2 (I think) where Eren's dad injects a screaming Eren with something special in that dream. Though I thought he was only going to gain Titan regeneration. Not many people talked about it after it was shown though... That was foreshadowing for something else and no sufficient enough for Eren's situation. It is a big asspull but a good one imo. You mean about the basement? So he gets an injection when he gets the key Surely you wouldnt think that it was for THAT, but when THAT happens you cant say that it happened randomly just because he is the MC,you know the reason so it isnt an asspull. Its not like it was like "bullshit" in a badway, just more like wtf and incredibly random. Well again I dont see how it is random or how the injection could be about something else like tsudecimo says. If tte viewers did pay attention to the scene then they would know that it was because of that. |
Mar 23, 2014 4:42 AM
#1069
ssjokg said: g00dnight said: ssjokg said: tsudecimo said: Keetriver said: g00dnight said: The moment in Attack on Titan when Eren first gets "eaten" and then turns into a titan out of nowhere.. From my perspective it was kinda foreshadowed back at the start of episode 2 (I think) where Eren's dad injects a screaming Eren with something special in that dream. Though I thought he was only going to gain Titan regeneration. Not many people talked about it after it was shown though... That was foreshadowing for something else and no sufficient enough for Eren's situation. It is a big asspull but a good one imo. You mean about the basement? So he gets an injection when he gets the key Surely you wouldnt think that it was for THAT, but when THAT happens you cant say that it happened randomly just because he is the MC,you know the reason so it isnt an asspull. Its not like it was like "bullshit" in a badway, just more like wtf and incredibly random. Well again I dont see how it is random or how the injection could be about something else like tsudecimo says. If tte viewers did pay attention to the scene then they would know that it was because of that. Good point |
"Whatever happens, happens." - Spike Spiegel |
Mar 23, 2014 4:46 AM
#1070
tsudecimo said: Keetriver said: If THAT wasn't foreshadowing Eren being special in some way then what does it foreshadow? Does it come up in the manga or something? It wasn't sufficient. It could have meant anything, it does not foreshadow what becomes of Eren, it only gives grounds for an explanation to it, and foreshadow that Eren's father and the basement are connected to the secrets of the titans The emphasis about that flashback scene was the basement. If it was really about Eren then His father would have said ''you will survive with this son, it will protect you'' or something along those lines. But his father emphasized that Eren should go to the basement with the key etc. I wouldn't know if they finally reached the basement or if Eren's dad become relevant again, because I stopped reading the very boring manga. It's just an asspull. But I think it's a good one, because of it's dramatic effect. It created a lot of excitement and it was utterly unpredictable. Sure, from a critical point of view, that can be considered 'bad' writing, but it entertained the audience. It could have achieved both, if it was better foreshadowed, but that might have made it less unpredictable Dude. Eren's father specifically states that Eren gained a "power" in the god damn flashback scene. http://i.imgur.com/P73oIT2.jpg http://i.imgur.com/DLhv4jx.jpg |
antonnMar 23, 2014 4:51 AM
Mar 23, 2014 4:52 AM
#1071
antonn said: Dude. Eren's father specifically states that Eren gained a "power" in the god damn flashback scene. http://i.imgur.com/DLhv4jx.jpg The flashback scene you linked, was shown after Eren survived, it was when they was about to get shot at. The original flashback before Eren's asspull, didn't have the word 'power' in it. |
Mar 23, 2014 4:59 AM
#1072
tsudecimo said: Keetriver said: If THAT wasn't foreshadowing Eren being special in some way then what does it foreshadow? Does it come up in the manga or something? It wasn't sufficient. It could have meant anything, it does not foreshadow what becomes of Eren, it only gives grounds for an explanation to it, and foreshadow that Eren's father and the basement are connected to the secrets of the titans The emphasis about that flashback scene was the basement. If it was really about Eren then His father would have said ''you will survive with this son, it will protect you'' or something along those lines. But his father emphasized that Eren should go to the basement with the key etc. I wouldn't know if they finally reached the basement or if Eren's dad become relevant again, because I stopped reading the very boring manga. You mean to tell me that Eren's father, a doctor and an important figure in the walls as made clear within the first 4 episodes, tearfully injecting Eren with a serum and disappears, could mean anything?! That is easily enough to tell us that Eren has changed biologically, and the effects revealed after the 5th episode or so. |
Mar 23, 2014 5:02 AM
#1073
Keetriver said: tsudecimo said: Keetriver said: If THAT wasn't foreshadowing Eren being special in some way then what does it foreshadow? Does it come up in the manga or something? It wasn't sufficient. It could have meant anything, it does not foreshadow what becomes of Eren, it only gives grounds for an explanation to it, and foreshadow that Eren's father and the basement are connected to the secrets of the titans The emphasis about that flashback scene was the basement. If it was really about Eren then His father would have said ''you will survive with this son, it will protect you'' or something along those lines. But his father emphasized that Eren should go to the basement with the key etc. I wouldn't know if they finally reached the basement or if Eren's dad become relevant again, because I stopped reading the very boring manga. You mean to tell me that Eren's father, a doctor and an important figure in the walls as made clear within the first 4 episodes, tearfully injecting Eren with a serum and disappears, could mean anything?! That is easily enough to tell us that Eren has changed biologically, and the effects revealed after the 5th episode or so. Personally during the episode when he got injected with the serum I probably wasnt listening and thought he's dad went insane or some shit and was trying to molest him |
"Whatever happens, happens." - Spike Spiegel |
Mar 23, 2014 5:05 AM
#1074
Personally during the episode when he got injected with the serum I probably wasnt listening and thought he's dad went insane or some shit and was trying to molest him wuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh???!!! lol... |
Mar 23, 2014 5:06 AM
#1075
THe serum was obviously something unrelated to the plot.His father was crying because Eren was being bitch because of influenza vaccination. |
Mar 23, 2014 5:14 AM
#1076
tsudecimo said: antonn said: Dude. Eren's father specifically states that Eren gained a "power" in the god damn flashback scene. http://i.imgur.com/P73oIT2.jpg http://i.imgur.com/DLhv4jx.jpg The flashback scene you linked, was shown after Eren survived, it was when they was about to get shot at. The original flashback before Eren's asspull, didn't have the word 'power' in it. Wasn't aware when something is foreshadowed then explained in detail to the viewer that it's considered an asspull. Might as well rename the mystery genre to "asspull". |
Mar 23, 2014 5:14 AM
#1077
Keetriver said: You mean to tell me that Eren's father, a doctor and an important figure in the walls as made clear within the first 4 episodes, tearfully injecting Eren with a serum and disappears, could mean anything?! That is easily enough to tell us that Eren has changed biologically, and the effects revealed after the 5th episode or so. Important figure? what? that wasn't established in the first four episodes. Nor is it in anyway relevant to the titans themselves, since nothing have been revealed about the wall at the point in time. Yes it could mean anything. It gives the writer freedom, to pull everything out of his ass. It could mean that Eren is immortal or invincible or something that could control him etc. Anybody can draw tons of conclusion from that scene. It doesn't in any way, specifically foreshadows the fact that Eren will become a titan http://i.imgur.com/DLhv4jx.jpg ^ This flashback would have been actually foreshadowing for what becomes of Eren, but it was shown after the fact. antonn said: http://i.imgur.com/P73oIT2.jpg I'm assuming, that you are saying that Eren just forgot about the 'power' part. This doesn't make it any less of an asspull. Eren's power wan't foreshadowed, only the basement was empathize on, in that scene. |
Mar 23, 2014 5:21 AM
#1078
antonn said: Wasn't aware when something is foreshadowed then explained in detail to the viewer that it's considered an asspull. Might as well rename the mystery genre to "asspull". It wasn't foreshadowed, that's my point. Something is called an asspull for the lack of foreshadowing to an important plot development before it occurs, not after it. It doesn't matter if it was explained in full detail, after the events occured. It has no relation to whether or not it's an asspull. It wasn't explained in detail anyway. ''The power ought to be useful by then'' that's vague and doesn't explain How that serum can give 'power' and make people titan shifter How is that explanation in detail exactly? |
Mar 23, 2014 5:22 AM
#1079
Again: Of course the injection was something totally unrelated to the plot. tsudecimo said: Yes it could mean anything. It gives the writer freedom, to pull everything out of his ass. It could mean that Eren is immortal or invincible or something that could control him etc. Anybody can draw tons of conclusion from that scene. So everyone can guess that he would receive some power,in a show about fighting Titans, in which the first Titans appeared out of nowhere.Then how is the most obvious power an asspull when we can even deduce that the Titans were man made? |
ssjokgMar 23, 2014 5:27 AM
Mar 23, 2014 5:30 AM
#1080
I don't think that there was ample enough foreshadowing to justify Eren's transformation as not being random but it isn't an asspull. You must consider that an asspull is more than just lack of foreshadowing but also the way in which it is used. Asspulls are used when writers have written themselves into a corner and don't have a more reasonable way of resolving a situation hence the plot point that they are using to resolve is pulled out of their ass. Eren's transformation could be considered an asspull because it brings Eren back into the story when we were led to believe that he was dead. However that single scene with Eren dreaming about his father holding him down and injecting him is enough to signify that there is something deeper in Eren's story that will need to be explained and resolved in the future. This same logic cannot be applied to just any plot point like the mystery of the identities of the Colossal and Armoured Titan since those can be found out by a different character while the father injection is something personally affecting Eren and can only be solved with Eren in the story.This is not sufficient foreshadowing for him transforming into a Titan specifically but what this means is that the author most likely had no intention of permanently killing off Eren since he purposefully provided foreshadowing for some storyline which hadn't been dealt with by Eren's supposed time of death. What this means is that even though he hadn't provided a decent amount of foreshadowing beforehand, it is clear that the author planned the Titan transformation or something of the sort and didn't pull it out of his ass. |
BelovyMar 23, 2014 5:37 AM
Mar 23, 2014 5:35 AM
#1081
Kaimon said: IntroverTurtle said: Kaimon said: Why didn't he teach him anything other than a big rasengan you mean. There were tons of other frog jutsus he could have learned.Another one regarding Naruto Was there any specific reason why Jiraya didn't teach Naruto sage mode during their 2 1/2 years of training? That too. Seems like he learned more with Kakashi and Yamato than he did with Jiraya. But how is that a plothole or asspull? it just shows that Jiraya and Naruto were slacking compared to the other people. |
''We don't know what kind of people we truly are until the moment before our deaths. As death comes to embrace you, you will realise what you are. That's what death is, don't you think?'' - Uchiha Itachi |
Mar 23, 2014 5:38 AM
#1082
Nicobade said: I don't think that there was ample enough foreshadowing to justify Eren's transformation as not being random but it isn't an asspull. You must consider that an asspull is more than just lack of foreshadowing but also the way in which it is used. Asspulls are used when writers have written themselves into a corner and don't have a more reasonable way of resolving a situation hence the plot point that they are using to resolve is pulled out of their ass. Eren's transformation could be considered an asspull because it brings Eren back into the story when we were led to believe that he was dead. However that single scene with Eren dreaming about his father holding him down and injecting him is enough to signify that there is something deeper in Eren's story that will need to be explained and resolved in the future. This is not sufficient foreshadowing for him transforming into a Titan specifically but what this means is that the author most likely had no intention of killing off Eren since he purposefully provided foreshadowing for some storyline which hadn't been dealt with by Eren's supposed time of death. What this means is that even though he hadn't provided a decent amount of foreshadowing beforehand, it is clear that the author planned the Titan transformation or something of the sort and didn't pull it out of his ass. You are thinking of/describing Deus Ex Machina, not an asspull. Eren's situation wasn't a Deus Ex Machina because the author purposely wrote him in that situation, in order to make the reveal dramatic, big and exciting and wasn't simply driven in a corner and thought of a random way to solve it. But he however, didn't implement enough foreshadowing for that event, hence why it's an asspull. ''An Ass Pull is a moment when the writers pull something out of thin air in a less-than-graceful narrative development, violating the Law of Conservation of Detail by dropping a plot-critical detail in the middle, or near the end of their narrative without Foreshadowing. In cases where a character suddenly gets a new skill without explanation. An Ass Pull used to resolve an unwinnable situation for the protagonists is a Deus ex Machina.'' He might have planned it in his head, from chapter 1, for all we know but he didn't foreshadow or give hints to the audience of it's possibility. That scene, could be counted as the author planning to let Eren live, because of unresolved issues regarding him and he is the MC anyway, but it doesn't count as planning for Eren to be a titan. Eren could have survived because of that serum, since it's purpose was unknown, and in that way you can say it was planned and not from thin air and was just a plot armor, but not him being a titan, that was just an asspull. This kinda reminds of Netero vs The King conclusion and why it's an asspull and not a Deus Ex Machina. |
tsudecimoMar 23, 2014 5:51 AM
Mar 23, 2014 5:42 AM
#1083
tsudecimo said: Nicobade said: I don't think that there was ample enough foreshadowing to justify Eren's transformation as not being random but it isn't an asspull. You must consider that an asspull is more than just lack of foreshadowing but also the way in which it is used. Asspulls are used when writers have written themselves into a corner and don't have a more reasonable way of resolving a situation hence the plot point that they are using to resolve is pulled out of their ass. Eren's transformation could be considered an asspull because it brings Eren back into the story when we were led to believe that he was dead. However that single scene with Eren dreaming about his father holding him down and injecting him is enough to signify that there is something deeper in Eren's story that will need to be explained and resolved in the future. This is not sufficient foreshadowing for him transforming into a Titan specifically but what this means is that the author most likely had no intention of killing off Eren since he purposefully provided foreshadowing for some storyline which hadn't been dealt with by Eren's supposed time of death. What this means is that even though he hadn't provided a decent amount of foreshadowing beforehand, it is clear that the author planned the Titan transformation or something of the sort and didn't pull it out of his ass. You are thinking of/describing Deus Ex Machina, not an asspull. Eren's situation wasn't a Deus Ex Machina because the author purposely wrote him in that situation, in order to make the reveal dramatic, big and exciting and wasn't simply driven in a corner and thought of a random way to solve it. But he however, didn't implement enough foreshadowing for that event, hence why it's an asspull. ''An Ass Pull is a moment when the writers pull something out of thin air in a less-than-graceful narrative development, violating the Law of Conservation of Detail by dropping a plot-critical detail in the middle, or near the end of their narrative without Foreshadowing. In cases where a character suddenly gets a new skill without explanation. An Ass Pull used to resolve an unwinnable situation for the protagonists is a Deus ex Machina.'' This kinda reminds of Netero vs The King conclusion and why it's an asspull and not a Deus Ex Machina. Lets see. A show about fighting Titans. First Titans appear out of nowhere and specifically attack only humans for no real reason. MC gets injected with something that surely is important to the plot,like giving him a power. What more do you need to think that the Titans were created by humans and that the injection would turn him into a Titan? |
Mar 23, 2014 5:56 AM
#1084
Foreshadowing is overrated. It seems nowadays as a cowardly way for a show that doesn't try to be daring, never going in brave new directions. Not everything new is an asspull. And I don't believe for one day that preemptively announcing an asspull is better than explaining it coherently afterward. Foreshadowing can be good to ease something complex into a show. When even the simplest ideas call for it then it just means the writer is slow and isn't a quick thinker. Ironically opposie to what FS is supposed to show. But leave it to MAL to fuck up the meaning of it. |
Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
Mar 23, 2014 6:00 AM
#1085
ssjokg said: tsudecimo said: Nicobade said: I don't think that there was ample enough foreshadowing to justify Eren's transformation as not being random but it isn't an asspull. You must consider that an asspull is more than just lack of foreshadowing but also the way in which it is used. Asspulls are used when writers have written themselves into a corner and don't have a more reasonable way of resolving a situation hence the plot point that they are using to resolve is pulled out of their ass. Eren's transformation could be considered an asspull because it brings Eren back into the story when we were led to believe that he was dead. However that single scene with Eren dreaming about his father holding him down and injecting him is enough to signify that there is something deeper in Eren's story that will need to be explained and resolved in the future. This is not sufficient foreshadowing for him transforming into a Titan specifically but what this means is that the author most likely had no intention of killing off Eren since he purposefully provided foreshadowing for some storyline which hadn't been dealt with by Eren's supposed time of death. What this means is that even though he hadn't provided a decent amount of foreshadowing beforehand, it is clear that the author planned the Titan transformation or something of the sort and didn't pull it out of his ass. You are thinking of/describing Deus Ex Machina, not an asspull. Eren's situation wasn't a Deus Ex Machina because the author purposely wrote him in that situation, in order to make the reveal dramatic, big and exciting and wasn't simply driven in a corner and thought of a random way to solve it. But he however, didn't implement enough foreshadowing for that event, hence why it's an asspull. ''An Ass Pull is a moment when the writers pull something out of thin air in a less-than-graceful narrative development, violating the Law of Conservation of Detail by dropping a plot-critical detail in the middle, or near the end of their narrative without Foreshadowing. In cases where a character suddenly gets a new skill without explanation. An Ass Pull used to resolve an unwinnable situation for the protagonists is a Deus ex Machina.'' This kinda reminds of Netero vs The King conclusion and why it's an asspull and not a Deus Ex Machina. Lets see. A show about fighting Titans. First Titans appear out of nowhere and specifically attack only humans for no real reason. MC gets injected with something that surely is important to the plot,like giving him a power. What more do you need to think that the Titans were created by humans and that the injection would turn him into a Titan? Gotta agree with this. Any more foreshadowing and the twist would have been way too obvious. That flashback was enough to suggest that the injection had some effect on Eren, but it still didn't give it away. I'd say it struck a good balance, something that the second twist in Shingeki no Kyojin failed to achieve. The identity of the female titan was apparent from the first time she was shown and yet it was treated like the mystery of the century. |
5 main aspects I base my ratings on: 1. Did DramaEnthusiast make a thread about it? 2. Is it better than Breaking Bad? 3. Did MellowJello recommend the shit out of it? 4. Has it caused a (very entertaining) shitstorm on MAL? 5. Is it actually good? Scratch the fifth point, it's not very relevant... |
Mar 23, 2014 6:04 AM
#1086
geralt said: ssjokg said: tsudecimo said: Nicobade said: I don't think that there was ample enough foreshadowing to justify Eren's transformation as not being random but it isn't an asspull. You must consider that an asspull is more than just lack of foreshadowing but also the way in which it is used. Asspulls are used when writers have written themselves into a corner and don't have a more reasonable way of resolving a situation hence the plot point that they are using to resolve is pulled out of their ass. Eren's transformation could be considered an asspull because it brings Eren back into the story when we were led to believe that he was dead. However that single scene with Eren dreaming about his father holding him down and injecting him is enough to signify that there is something deeper in Eren's story that will need to be explained and resolved in the future. This is not sufficient foreshadowing for him transforming into a Titan specifically but what this means is that the author most likely had no intention of killing off Eren since he purposefully provided foreshadowing for some storyline which hadn't been dealt with by Eren's supposed time of death. What this means is that even though he hadn't provided a decent amount of foreshadowing beforehand, it is clear that the author planned the Titan transformation or something of the sort and didn't pull it out of his ass. You are thinking of/describing Deus Ex Machina, not an asspull. Eren's situation wasn't a Deus Ex Machina because the author purposely wrote him in that situation, in order to make the reveal dramatic, big and exciting and wasn't simply driven in a corner and thought of a random way to solve it. But he however, didn't implement enough foreshadowing for that event, hence why it's an asspull. ''An Ass Pull is a moment when the writers pull something out of thin air in a less-than-graceful narrative development, violating the Law of Conservation of Detail by dropping a plot-critical detail in the middle, or near the end of their narrative without Foreshadowing. In cases where a character suddenly gets a new skill without explanation. An Ass Pull used to resolve an unwinnable situation for the protagonists is a Deus ex Machina.'' This kinda reminds of Netero vs The King conclusion and why it's an asspull and not a Deus Ex Machina. Lets see. A show about fighting Titans. First Titans appear out of nowhere and specifically attack only humans for no real reason. MC gets injected with something that surely is important to the plot,like giving him a power. What more do you need to think that the Titans were created by humans and that the injection would turn him into a Titan? Gotta agree with this. Any more foreshadowing and the twist would have been way too obvious. That flashback was enough to suggest that the injection had some effect on Eren, but it still didn't give it away. I'd say it struck a good balance, something that the second twist in Shingeki no Kyojin failed to achieve. The identity of the female titan was apparent from the first time she was shown and yet it was treated like the mystery of the century. I dont think the author intended for it to be some great mystery.Manga or Anime you had to be blind to not get it. It is just that the chars that could guess her identity, didnt want to think about it. Thats my opinion.It could also be that the writer though that the drawings were really bad for us to figure it out. |
Mar 23, 2014 6:07 AM
#1088
Geralt, the second twist was not supposed to be a twist, it was a "is this what I think it is" and "hell yeah that's what I thought". so it's not so much predictable as it is the writer himself involving the readers. |
Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
Mar 23, 2014 8:58 AM
#1089
SaSa-Zoldyck said: I think he mentioned it as a BS moment. BS moments don't have to be a plot hole, asspull, or inconsistency.Kaimon said: IntroverTurtle said: Kaimon said: Why didn't he teach him anything other than a big rasengan you mean. There were tons of other frog jutsus he could have learned.Another one regarding Naruto Was there any specific reason why Jiraya didn't teach Naruto sage mode during their 2 1/2 years of training? That too. Seems like he learned more with Kakashi and Yamato than he did with Jiraya. But how is that a plothole or asspull? it just shows that Jiraya and Naruto were slacking compared to the other people. |
Short of the day: Monotonous Purgatory(MAL) ✰Public Domain Club | One Piece Club✰ |
Mar 23, 2014 11:08 AM
#1090
geralt said: ssjokg said: tsudecimo said: Nicobade said: I don't think that there was ample enough foreshadowing to justify Eren's transformation as not being random but it isn't an asspull. You must consider that an asspull is more than just lack of foreshadowing but also the way in which it is used. Asspulls are used when writers have written themselves into a corner and don't have a more reasonable way of resolving a situation hence the plot point that they are using to resolve is pulled out of their ass. Eren's transformation could be considered an asspull because it brings Eren back into the story when we were led to believe that he was dead. However that single scene with Eren dreaming about his father holding him down and injecting him is enough to signify that there is something deeper in Eren's story that will need to be explained and resolved in the future. This is not sufficient foreshadowing for him transforming into a Titan specifically but what this means is that the author most likely had no intention of killing off Eren since he purposefully provided foreshadowing for some storyline which hadn't been dealt with by Eren's supposed time of death. What this means is that even though he hadn't provided a decent amount of foreshadowing beforehand, it is clear that the author planned the Titan transformation or something of the sort and didn't pull it out of his ass. You are thinking of/describing Deus Ex Machina, not an asspull. Eren's situation wasn't a Deus Ex Machina because the author purposely wrote him in that situation, in order to make the reveal dramatic, big and exciting and wasn't simply driven in a corner and thought of a random way to solve it. But he however, didn't implement enough foreshadowing for that event, hence why it's an asspull. ''An Ass Pull is a moment when the writers pull something out of thin air in a less-than-graceful narrative development, violating the Law of Conservation of Detail by dropping a plot-critical detail in the middle, or near the end of their narrative without Foreshadowing. In cases where a character suddenly gets a new skill without explanation. An Ass Pull used to resolve an unwinnable situation for the protagonists is a Deus ex Machina.'' This kinda reminds of Netero vs The King conclusion and why it's an asspull and not a Deus Ex Machina. Lets see. A show about fighting Titans. First Titans appear out of nowhere and specifically attack only humans for no real reason. MC gets injected with something that surely is important to the plot,like giving him a power. What more do you need to think that the Titans were created by humans and that the injection would turn him into a Titan? Gotta agree with this. Any more foreshadowing and the twist would have been way too obvious. That flashback was enough to suggest that the injection had some effect on Eren, but it still didn't give it away. I'd say it struck a good balance, something that the second twist in Shingeki no Kyojin failed to achieve. The identity of the female titan was apparent from the first time she was shown and yet it was treated like the mystery of the century. The identity of the female titan was not so apparent the very first instant she showed up, but it was made so later on, and at that point the authors made no show of hiding it. Most of the people saying it was were simply manga readers. First of all, there was more than 1 blonde in the squad. What gave it away as Annie was the fighting stance (which was revealed in the following episodes, and after which the authors did not try to hide it), not the hair colour. |
"Let Justice Be Done!" My Theme Fight again, fight again for justice! |
Mar 23, 2014 8:00 PM
#1091
Naruto Shippuden Deidara used a gigantic self-destruction technique. Sasuke survived the resulting city-sized explosion by summoning and mind-controlling a massive snake to shield him, when he was explicitly described as being nearly out of chakra just a few panels before. Any one of those techniques would have required a vast amount of chakra, never mind both. Sasuke managed to do all this in the time it took for the explosion to reach him. After it had already started. Just a few feet from him. |
Mar 23, 2014 9:19 PM
#1092
Forgetfulness said: D0FLAMINGO said: Naruto Shippuden Deidara used a gigantic self-destruction technique. Sasuke survived the resulting city-sized explosion by summoning and mind-controlling a massive snake to shield him, when he was explicitly described as being nearly out of chakra just a few panels before. Any one of those techniques would have required a vast amount of chakra, never mind both. Sasuke managed to do all this in the time it took for the explosion to reach him. After it had already started. Just a few feet from him. I don't think they ever say that the genjutsu was cast on the snake at that very moment. For all we know he could have cast that jutsu a long time ago We don't know exactly how much chakra Sasuke truly had or how much it cost him The only truly BS thing from that event would be how Sasuke did that one technique so quickly, but even then it might be possible Well in order to summon the snake he had to use a lot of chakra even if the snake was already under a genjutsu(which I doubt). Remember Naruto trying to summon the frog in the first part, he had to borrow chakra from the kyuubi. Even if they had more chakra now as teens it still sounds difficult if he was out of chakra. |
Short of the day: Monotonous Purgatory(MAL) ✰Public Domain Club | One Piece Club✰ |
Mar 23, 2014 9:51 PM
#1093
It's an asspull, and it's already been mentioned. |
Mar 23, 2014 11:19 PM
#1094
IntroverTurtle said: SaSa-Zoldyck said: I think he mentioned it as a BS moment. BS moments don't have to be a plot hole, asspull, or inconsistency.Kaimon said: IntroverTurtle said: Kaimon said: Why didn't he teach him anything other than a big rasengan you mean. There were tons of other frog jutsus he could have learned.Another one regarding Naruto Was there any specific reason why Jiraya didn't teach Naruto sage mode during their 2 1/2 years of training? That too. Seems like he learned more with Kakashi and Yamato than he did with Jiraya. But how is that a plothole or asspull? it just shows that Jiraya and Naruto were slacking compared to the other people. Hmm, I still don't see how that is a BS moment. From a story point of view it makes sense that Jiraya would take Naruto out of the village, a village that isolated him, blamed him for the 9 tails attack and have fun travelling around. Naruto needed a loving family/adult more then a flashy jutsu at that time and Jiraya being his godfather was the closest thing to a family. Atleast thats my take on the whole deal. |
''We don't know what kind of people we truly are until the moment before our deaths. As death comes to embrace you, you will realise what you are. That's what death is, don't you think?'' - Uchiha Itachi |
Mar 23, 2014 11:25 PM
#1095
D0FLAMINGO said: Naruto Shippuden Deidara used a gigantic self-destruction technique. Sasuke survived the resulting city-sized explosion by summoning and mind-controlling a massive snake to shield him, when he was explicitly described as being nearly out of chakra just a few panels before. Any one of those techniques would have required a vast amount of chakra, never mind both. Sasuke managed to do all this in the time it took for the explosion to reach him. After it had already started. Just a few feet from him. I would argue that the whole fight taking place was a BS moment. Why would Deidera want to fight Sasuke and go as far as committing suicide when the person he had a beef with is still around?! makes no sense to me! |
''We don't know what kind of people we truly are until the moment before our deaths. As death comes to embrace you, you will realise what you are. That's what death is, don't you think?'' - Uchiha Itachi |
Mar 23, 2014 11:25 PM
#1096
SaSa-Zoldyck said: He's known about Naruto since he was a fetus in his mother's uterus, he could have been doing that for the first 13 years of his life when Naruto actually had no friends. The purpose of them going on that journey was as stated to train Naruto so he can protect himself against the Akatsuki who were going to be active again in 2 years(hence the amount of time they were gone for). And Naruto had many friends in the village and people were warming up to him so he didn't need to leave the village for 2 years.Hmm, I still don't see how that is a BS moment. From a story point of view it makes sense that Jiraya would take Naruto out of the village, a village that isolated him, blamed him for the 9 tails attack and have fun travelling around. Naruto needed a loving family/adult more then a flashy jutsu at that time and Jiraya being his godfather was the closest thing to a family. Atleast thats my take on the whole deal. |
Short of the day: Monotonous Purgatory(MAL) ✰Public Domain Club | One Piece Club✰ |
Mar 23, 2014 11:45 PM
#1097
IntroverTurtle said: SaSa-Zoldyck said: He's known about Naruto since he was a fetus in his mother's uterus, he could have been doing that for the first 13 years of his life when Naruto actually had no friends. The purpose of them going on that journey was as stated to train Naruto so he can protect himself against the Akatsuki who were going to be active again in 2 years(hence the amount of time they were gone for). And Naruto had many friends in the village and people were warming up to him so he didn't need to leave the village for 2 years.Hmm, I still don't see how that is a BS moment. From a story point of view it makes sense that Jiraya would take Naruto out of the village, a village that isolated him, blamed him for the 9 tails attack and have fun travelling around. Naruto needed a loving family/adult more then a flashy jutsu at that time and Jiraya being his godfather was the closest thing to a family. Atleast thats my take on the whole deal. They don't need to travel to train Naruto, he could have done that in Konoha like Kakashi did. Naruto had many friends? he had a few but the majority of the villagers hated him up until the pain invasion. Yeah Jiraya claimed that they would train and that was the reason they were allowed to leave the village but we know now that they hardly trained for anything. That suggest that the whole training part of the journey was just an excuse, thats why I believe that he wanted to take Naruto away from the village and have fun with his ''son'' who he neglected for years. I forgot most of the early parts of series but the kid really looked happy in the flashbacks with Jiraya. |
''We don't know what kind of people we truly are until the moment before our deaths. As death comes to embrace you, you will realise what you are. That's what death is, don't you think?'' - Uchiha Itachi |
Mar 24, 2014 12:26 AM
#1098
SaSa-Zoldyck said: IF it is like this then it still is a BS moment since Jiraiya ignores a very important threat to Naruto.IntroverTurtle said: SaSa-Zoldyck said: He's known about Naruto since he was a fetus in his mother's uterus, he could have been doing that for the first 13 years of his life when Naruto actually had no friends. The purpose of them going on that journey was as stated to train Naruto so he can protect himself against the Akatsuki who were going to be active again in 2 years(hence the amount of time they were gone for). And Naruto had many friends in the village and people were warming up to him so he didn't need to leave the village for 2 years.Hmm, I still don't see how that is a BS moment. From a story point of view it makes sense that Jiraya would take Naruto out of the village, a village that isolated him, blamed him for the 9 tails attack and have fun travelling around. Naruto needed a loving family/adult more then a flashy jutsu at that time and Jiraya being his godfather was the closest thing to a family. Atleast thats my take on the whole deal. They don't need to travel to train Naruto, he could have done that in Konoha like Kakashi did. Naruto had many friends? he had a few but the majority of the villagers hated him up until the pain invasion. Yeah Jiraya claimed that they would train and that was the reason they were allowed to leave the village but we know now that they hardly trained for anything. That suggest that the whole training part of the journey was just an excuse, thats why I believe that he wanted to take Naruto away from the village and have fun with his ''son'' who he neglected for years. I forgot most of the early parts of series but the kid really looked happy in the flashbacks with Jiraya. |
Mar 24, 2014 12:53 AM
#1099
I just finished recently Mayo Chicki and the past 2-3 episodes felt like bullshit episodes....almost like.....fillers! |
"Love is a drug to our brain , it stops the thinking function and when you realize it wether you acomplish it or not you'll enter in one of the 3 withdrawal states : happy , sad or anger. Once this drug gets hold of you you'd better be prepaired beforehand." - Me |
More topics from this board
» Aside from L and Detective Conan, who are the best detectives and inspectors in anime?TheBlockernator - Sep 15 |
48 |
by ProudElitist
»»
39 minutes ago |
|
» Let's go, Rainbow Crown! Waifu War Hair Color-Edition! (Rainbow Crown Quarterfinals) ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )TheMinkalex - Aug 15 |
569 |
by Sheol01
»»
45 minutes ago |
|
Poll: » Will the new demon slayer movie become the highest grossing non-English language movie of all time?Old_School_Akira - Yesterday |
15 |
by FZREMAKE
»»
46 minutes ago |
|
» Why are Miyazaki's movies considered good?swirlydragon - Yesterday |
15 |
by SgtBateMan
»»
46 minutes ago |
|
» Upcoming Dubbed Anime ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Kenny_Stryker - Dec 17, 2017 |
3909 |
by jorel262
»»
47 minutes ago |