momokusheila said: Does Nineteen, Twenty-One count for Adult characters the characters are 19 and 21. I'd say it does, yeah. |
密室殺人はなぜ美しいのか。 |
| » Read a manga recommended to you by another Manga Reading Challenge participant Can someone please help me out with this one? Preferably something with at least 50+ chapters |
 |
| Hi, can you suggest a good one-shot? and » Read a manga recommended to you by another Manga Reading Challenge participant no shounen or shoujo demographic, and no ongoing. Thanks mateys. Just for the sake of my personal restrictions |
Stark700 said: I bet people are too intimidate by your huge list to respond huhu.» Read a manga recommended to you by another Manga Reading Challenge participant Can someone please help me out with this one? Preferably something with at least 50+ chapters I'll try anyway with two completely different manga suggestion : I would recommend reading Bambino! or Ai-Ren (not over 50 chapter for that one, but I have in the idea you could be interested by it , it have some similarities with Chobits, if it can raise your curiosity) Monstrum said: for the manga rec , I would say Tsumi to Batsu: A Falsified Romance or Kokou no Hito . For shorter manga than those , Doctor Du Ming (it's a Manhua) or HeadsHi, can you suggest a good one-shot? and » Read a manga recommended to you by another Manga Reading Challenge participant I try to give some profiled recommendation , but it's quite hard when you're not on the head of the other ^^ . If those rec are completely off and don't suit the both of you , I'll completely understand |
 |
| I was wonder if a story like My Girl would count for non-romantic relationship challenge. There are some romantic parts of the story but the main story is about the father/daughter bond and the relationships that they become involved in through chance meetings. I am not sure because there's some romance but it's not listed as romance in the genre section. |
momokusheilaJan 19, 2016 1:41 PM
  |
Dullboy said: Stark700 said: I bet people are too intimidate by your huge list to respond huhu.» Read a manga recommended to you by another Manga Reading Challenge participant Can someone please help me out with this one? Preferably something with at least 50+ chapters I'll try anyway with two completely different manga suggestion : I would recommend reading Bambino! or Ai-Ren (not over 50 chapter for that one, but I have in the idea you could be interested by it , it have some similarities with Chobits, if it can raise your curiosity) Thanks :> I'll probably give Ai-Ren a try. |
|
Ephemerals said: lequack said: I see Akira is on your PTW. Read the manga instead a lot of stuff has been skipped in the movie. [...] Thanks, I will read Akira then instead of watching the movie. I can second that the Manga is much more complete story wise. But if you have the chance/time/possibility try to take a look at both. They are both fine pieces of work. Also notice that the Manga exists in a colorized and a black/white version. |
| @Dullboy Wow, that looks a nice manga inspired by Dostoevsky's classic. Thanks. nonetheless, I'm still up for one-shot recommendations. Thanks in advance |
MikeMike said: Ephemerals said: Thanks, I will read Akira then instead of watching the movie. I can second that the Manga is much more complete story wise. But if you have the chance/time/possibility try to take a look at both. They are both fine pieces of work. Also notice that the Manga exists in a colorized and a black/white version. The manga is definitely a more complete story because getting 1200 pages into a 2 hr movie is impossible, but that opening scene in the anime is some of the best animated seqences put on film. It was just a bunch of good choices. |
momokusheila said: I was wonder if a story like My Girl would count for non-romantic relationship challenge. There are some romantic parts of the story but the main story is about the father/daughter bond and the relationships that they become involved in through chance meetings. I am not sure because there's some romance but it's not listed as romance in the genre section. Yes, it does count. Monstrum said: @Dullboy Wow, that looks a nice manga inspired by Dostoevsky's classic. Thanks. nonetheless, I'm still up for one-shot recommendations. Thanks in advance I'll try recommending Amon Game or Umwelt. Both Seinen. Amon Game is connected to the animated movie Cencoroll. I found the one-shot a little hard to follow, but I thought it was interesting. I liked Umwelt more, but I thought I'd give you options. |
密室殺人はなぜ美しいのか。 |
| So what happens now? :3 |
 |
| Can anyone recommend a 4-koma that is completed and fully translated? Most of the ones I know of are still ongoing.. |
"Be the change you wish to see in the world." ⛩️  |
| Azumanga Daioh is completed |
AudioTsunami said: Azumanga Daioh is completed Ah, I watched the anime already for that, but thank you. I'm good now. I should've just used the search engine on Batoto instead of looking individually on mangaupdates for completed 4komas. So much easier. |
"Be the change you wish to see in the world." ⛩️ |
Neex said: So what happens now? :3 You sure you really read that word by word? You sure you're not just scanning through it? |
Neex said: So what happens now? :3 Wow. Impressive! Well, I have to check over both forms and then you'll be added to the list of people who completed the challenge if everything is in order. |
密室殺人はなぜ美しいのか。 |
MikeMike said: Ephemerals said: Thanks, I will read Akira then instead of watching the movie. I can second that the Manga is much more complete story wise. But if you have the chance/time/possibility try to take a look at both. They are both fine pieces of work. Also notice that the Manga exists in a colorized and a black/white version. If that's the case I will make sure to try them both out. Thanks ^^ |
| --my heart's a hieroglyph, it speaks in tongues |
FlameWingman21 said: Neex said: So what happens now? :3 You sure you really read that word by word? You sure you're not just scanning through it? Yeah someone finished the anime challenge in a week too. Feels kinda lame but whatever man. If it's not legit than the only person who's cheated is herself. Now that the first person cleared it it's nice, because I can take my time with it and not be in an imaginary race to finish first. |
AudioTsunami said: FlameWingman21 said: You sure you really read that word by word? You sure you're not just scanning through it? Yeah someone finished the anime challenge in a week too. Feels kinda lame but whatever man. If it's not legit than the only person who's cheated is herself. Now that the first person cleared it it's nice, because I can take my time with it and not be in an imaginary race to finish first. There are some really long series on that list too.. :o |
HeNrYTG50 said: AudioTsunami said: Yeah someone finished the anime challenge in a week too. Feels kinda lame but whatever man. If it's not legit than the only person who's cheated is herself. Now that the first person cleared it it's nice, because I can take my time with it and not be in an imaginary race to finish first. There are some really long series on that list too.. :o Well, let's remember that the time we write down as sign up date might not be the day we started. Manga counts as long as it was started after January 1st and I think this list might be doable in 10 days or so. I think it's legit and I agree with AudioTsunami that if someone cheated, then they're doing it to themselves because this is a self-challenge. Either way, I really believe Neex is legit. |
密室殺人はなぜ美しいのか。 |
tsuyokunaru said: HeNrYTG50 said: There are some really long series on that list too.. :o Well, let's remember that the time we write down as sign up date might not be the day we started. Manga counts as long as it was started after January 1st and I think this list might be doable in 10 days or so. I think it's legit and I agree with AudioTsunami that if someone cheated, then they're doing it to themselves because this is a self-challenge. Either way, I really believe Neex is legit. That's true, the only thing I found that isn't really too important but counts, is that Neex read a LN, Utsuro no Hako to Zero no Maria.. :P So you could see about that. |
| @HeNrYTG50 I had just seen your message on Skype and was about to notify them lol |
密室殺人はなぜ美しいのか。 |
| Finishing all those in 2 weeks time is doable. I once read around 150 chapters (around 20 pages/chapter) in a night. Though to do that constantly is quite amazing. I think that normally anyone could only do that if they met a really interesting manga. Different case if one got fast reading speed. |
| Why should we care about how fast we complete this challenge? It's not like there's a prize for it. |
CodingSession said: Why should we care about how fast we complete this challenge? It's not like there's a prize for it. exactly. Unless you are first(for the braging rights to yourself) there's no benefit to completing it quickly. |
CodingSession said: Why should we care about how fast we complete this challenge? It's not like there's a prize for it. The prize is being able to do it again.. :D |
| I plan to use several titles that are on my on-hold list. How exactly am I to show that I've re-read them from the beginning in 2016? |
lubryka said: I plan to use several titles that are on my on-hold list. How exactly am I to show that I've re-read them from the beginning in 2016? You can mark them as re-read on your list actually (although I'm not sure if you can with ongoing titles since I've never tried to), though I don't mind going by honor system here. If you say you re-read them, I'll believe you. |
密室殺人はなぜ美しいのか。 |
tsuyokunaru said: lubryka said: I plan to use several titles that are on my on-hold list. How exactly am I to show that I've re-read them from the beginning in 2016? You can mark them as re-read on your list actually (although I'm not sure if you can with ongoing titles since I've never tried to), though I don't mind going by honor system here. If you say you re-read them, I'll believe you. I was considering marking them as re-read, but I've decided against it; after all, I'll be re-reading only the chapters I've finished before 2016, and not the whole series. So, thanks for the trust and let's go by honor system (I think I'll still put the re-reading dates somewhere in my sign-up post). |
| would anyone be kind enough to recommend a manga for me? It's the only challenge that I don't have one for, also, preferably one that it's too long thanks~! p.s: will literally read anything i just need something lol |
 |
yutaesol said: would anyone be kind enough to recommend a manga for me? It's the only challenge that I don't have one for, also, preferably one that it's too long thanks~! p.s: will literally read anything i just need something lol It's too long or isn't too long? xD Hoshi no Samidare |
| Vampires are non-human right?? I am just wondering because obviously I want to use it for the non-human main character challenge. |
|
| The twins from Ouran Host Club have auburn hair. So that could work. It's kinda reddish brown. The main character of Rouruni Kenshin has reddish brown hair as well. My rec is Ran to Haiiro no Sekai All You Need Is Kill. |
AudioTsunamiJan 23, 2016 6:27 AM
momokusheila said: Vampires are non-human right?? I am just wondering because obviously I want to use it for the non-human main character challenge. Yes, vampires count as non-human. |
密室殺人はなぜ美しいのか。 |
| If you read manga, but drop it after 20 or 40 chapters, does it count? |
 |
ExTamplier said: If you read manga, but drop it after 20 or 40 chapters, does it count? You have to finish it or be up to the latest chapter if it is on-going, otherwise it doesn't count.. :) |
| I want to start off with easy difficulty, is it possible to change to a harder difficulty if I finish before the year ends? Or do I have to stick with that difficulty? |
henriiez said: I want to start off with easy difficulty, is it possible to change to a harder difficulty if I finish before the year ends? Or do I have to stick with that difficulty? You can change it as long as you don't declare it completed. You can even keep the difficulty as "unsure" or ??? if you want to be able to change it freely. It's only important that you clearly have a difficulty set and the number of items for that difficulty chosen when it's time to turn in your challenge. HeNrYTG50 said: ExTamplier said: If you read manga, but drop it after 20 or 40 chapters, does it count? You have to finish it or be up to the latest chapter if it is on-going, otherwise it doesn't count.. :) It's just like HeNrYTG50 says. It won't count. |
密室殺人はなぜ美しいのか。 |
tsuyokunaru said: henriiez said: I want to start off with easy difficulty, is it possible to change to a harder difficulty if I finish before the year ends? Or do I have to stick with that difficulty? You can change it as long as you don't declare it completed. You can even keep the difficulty as "unsure" or ??? if you want to be able to change it freely. It's only important that you clearly have a difficulty set and the number of items for that difficulty chosen when it's time to turn in your challenge. What if I read about 40 or so chapters of Toriko last year, but I'm catching up to it now, would that still count? Or would I have to read those 40 chapters again? |
henriiez said: What if I read about 40 or so chapters of Toriko last year, but I'm catching up to it now, would that still count? Or would I have to read those 40 chapters again? You'd have to re-read those 40 chapters, yeah. |
密室殺人はなぜ美しいのか。 |
| Can anyone recommend me a completed manga that serialized in 2014? This is for the "Read a manga that started serialization the year you joined MAL". I really need a completed, so I can finish it immediately. I've been trying to read this manga but I haven't seen a manga source with its last 2 chapters. |
| sup |
keimaconquesta said: Can anyone recommend me a completed manga that serialized in 2014? This is for the "Read a manga that started serialization the year you joined MAL". I really need a completed, so I can finish it immediately. I've been trying to read this manga but I haven't seen a manga source with its last 2 chapters. There's All You Need Is Kill.. :) I recommend it |
tsuyokunaru said: Thanks for this clarification! There's a manga that I'm planning to re-read from the beginning and then finally catch up, but did not know whether I could include it in the challenge.henriiez said: What if I read about 40 or so chapters of Toriko last year, but I'm catching up to it now, would that still count? Or would I have to read those 40 chapters again? You'd have to re-read those 40 chapters, yeah. |
 |
HeNrYTG50 said: Thanks for the recommendation! It was really good, it has become one of my favorites...keimaconquesta said: Can anyone recommend me a completed manga that serialized in 2014? This is for the "Read a manga that started serialization the year you joined MAL". I really need a completed, so I can finish it immediately. I've been trying to read this manga but I haven't seen a manga source with its last 2 chapters. There's All You Need Is Kill.. :) I recommend it |
| sup |
| I'd like a decent manga that has been completely scanlated in either English or Korean to fulfill the "read a manga recommended to you by another manga reading challenge participant" task. Genre isn't a concern, but it'd be sweet if you could base it off what I've read thus far: here. |
 |
Protagony said: After looking at your list, I suggest you check out Vampire Game. It is a really good manga and the story and characters get more interesting with each volume, in my opinion. I also like how it balances comedy and drama. It's completely translated in English. Hope you enjoy it :)I'd like a decent manga that has been completely scanlated in either English or Korean to fulfill the "read a manga recommended to you by another manga reading challenge participant" task. Genre isn't a concern, but it'd be sweet if you could base it off what I've read thus far: here. |
|
Kino_no_Tabi said: After looking at your list, I suggest you check out Vampire Game. It is a really good manga and the story and characters get more interesting with each volume, in my opinion. I also like how it balances comedy and drama. It's completely translated in English. Hope you enjoy it :) Thanks for the quick response! It's hard not to trust someone who shares a rather high manga compatibility with me, so I'll definitely be reading this one. |
|
More topics from this board
» How many chapters do you read a month?Rissio - Apr 4 |
27 |
by notPara
»»
5 hours ago |
|
» Do you ever skim through your Manga?zaganGao - Jan 23 |
28 |
by ProGoddess
»»
Yesterday, 5:12 AM |
|
» From all the ongoing (and on hiatus) manga, you can choose only one to eventually reach a conclusion. Which one would it be?Caciulacdlac - Apr 10 |
8 |
by ProGoddess
»»
Yesterday, 5:06 AM |
|
» Ur fav mangaAoust_Adenca - Mar 10, 2023 |
23 |
by ProGoddess
»»
Yesterday, 5:00 AM |
|
» Have an amazing art in manga but not in animekirA_-_ - Apr 15 |
11 |
by 10vely
»»
Yesterday, 4:39 AM |