My Youth Romantic Comedy Is Wrong, As I Expected (light novel)
Available on Manga Store
New
Apr 28, 2015 5:59 AM
#1
In episode 4, he just gave a hint for the girl he likes, which is Y. However, in the light novel when he was about to confess he got cut off, with the initial being "Yu" (pretty vague) Do you guys think it's actually Yukino? |
Apr 28, 2015 6:03 AM
#2
Probable options: Yukinoshita Haruno, Yukinoshita Yukino Plausible options: Yumiko (Miura), Yuigahama Yui Improbable options: Yoshiteru (Zaimokuza) Impossible options: You, Your Mama |
Apr 28, 2015 6:04 AM
#3
Are they're an other characters whose name starts with Y? Because if not, who else would it be? They wouldn't go through the trouble of making it all mysterious and dramatic and whatever if it was just gonna end up being some random ass person we don't even know or care about. Edit: oh, like everybody's name starts with "yu" lol |
Apr 28, 2015 6:05 AM
#4
I misread that as Heymn How disappointing Have some Heyman cuteness |
הלב שלי כבר מת |
Apr 28, 2015 6:08 AM
#5
Most probably Yukino since he went out of his way a few times just to help her. |
Apr 28, 2015 6:18 AM
#6
My guess is on haruno |
My Reviews and Rants: http://bunny1ov3r.wordpress.com/ 痛就是爱 |
Apr 28, 2015 6:32 AM
#7
"Yukino wasn't chosen again"................a certain Yukinoshita Haruno said that in the first season. My guess is Haruno. |
Apr 28, 2015 7:23 AM
#8
Dragon_Slayer_X said: "Yukino wasn't chosen again"................a certain Yukinoshita Haruno said that in the first season. My guess is Haruno. I think so too. He's practically at her beck and call. |
Apr 28, 2015 12:29 PM
#9
I am currently convinced it is Haruno, although I could change my mind if a decent enough theory is made against it. |
指が折れるまで! |
Apr 28, 2015 12:30 PM
#10
Apr 28, 2015 10:29 PM
#11
even hayama likes hikigaya, maybe its you* hikigaya x hayama/ poor saika |
Apr 28, 2015 11:19 PM
#12
supracseduch said: Improbable options: Yoshiteru (Zaimokuza) Why do you think it is? |
Even when I was in crowd, I was always alone |
Apr 28, 2015 11:45 PM
#13
Hayama and Yukino were childhood friends (?) Hayama obviously admires Haruno Hayama makes sad face when he tells Hachiman that Haruno annoys/teases/messes with people she takes interest in. Pretty much implying that she has no interest in Hayama as a person. Yukino "wasn't chosen." So...might have had a crush on Hayama, but Hayama wanted Haruno instead..? >Does whatever Haruno tells him to. Her bitch. So yeah, definitely Haruno. |
Apr 29, 2015 3:21 AM
#14
Probably not Yumiko, was mentioned in LN by Tobe or Yui... forgot who said it lol |
Apr 29, 2015 7:27 AM
#15
Apr 29, 2015 8:10 AM
#16
moyang said: Probably not Yumiko, was mentioned in LN by Tobe or Yui... forgot who said it lol I think it was 8man He said something like Yumiko is a comfortable cover for you(Hayama). |
Apr 29, 2015 7:18 PM
#17
worldeditor11 said: Most probably Yukino since he went out of his way a few times just to help her. Are you reading the same novel as I am ? You know he did planned out the student council position to push to someone else right ? Dude is saving his own ass. He always watch yukino get slaughter and will just say ''now now enough''. And tell me how he help her at volume 9 and 10. Other than ignoring the rumors ? Jesus |
Sword in hand, a warrior clutches stone to breast. In sword etched he his fading memories In stone, his tempered skill By sword attested, by stone revealed. Their tale can now be told |
Apr 29, 2015 7:19 PM
#18
crezden said: yukino is the only girl he seemingly can't get close to at all, so i think it's her (plus the way he was talking sounded like he felt she was out of his reach) cause she hates pretentious people In the novel , its clear hayama likes haruno @@ |
Sword in hand, a warrior clutches stone to breast. In sword etched he his fading memories In stone, his tempered skill By sword attested, by stone revealed. Their tale can now be told |
Apr 29, 2015 7:26 PM
#19
Tommk said: You know he did planned out the student council position to push to someone else right ? Dude is saving his own ass. He always watch yukino get slaughter and will just say ''now now enough''. LOL Tommk said: And tell me how he help her at volume 9 and 10. Other than ignoring the rumors ? LOL Tommk said: Jesus Now now don't bring Jesus into this. Tommk said: In the novel , its clear hayama likes haruno @@ Very clear LOL. |
Apr 29, 2015 8:14 PM
#20
LOL JESUS JESUS LOL Its in the song already, get over with it. Please don't talk shit if you know nothing and start reading. Come up with some counter arguments or make a list of what hayama did to help her instead of being haruno's pet. Replying LoL does not solve anything @_@ |
Sword in hand, a warrior clutches stone to breast. In sword etched he his fading memories In stone, his tempered skill By sword attested, by stone revealed. Their tale can now be told |
Apr 30, 2015 5:52 PM
#21
He actually wanted to say "Y do you even care?" Jokes aside, I will be surprised if it's not Haruno. They have already given as many as 15 hints Y Haruno is the best bet. |
Stay Home and Wash Your Hands. Protect Yourself. Protect Your Loved Ones. Protect Your Community and Help Defeat Coronavirus. |
Apr 30, 2015 6:32 PM
#22
Tommk said: Please don't talk shit if you know nothing and start reading Replying LoL does not solve anything @_@ Please use spoiler button. Not everyone like read novels or mangas so stop think you are better just because you read the original story... |
Apr 30, 2015 8:12 PM
#23
Haou-Judai said: Tommk said: Please don't talk shit if you know nothing and start reading Replying LoL does not solve anything @_@ Please use spoiler button. Not everyone like read novels or mangas so stop think you are better just because you read the original story... then don't assume without a point. @_@ So far in this anime series, I don't remember hayama going out of the way to help yukinon ? Thus, that leaves to the novel, which leads to my post. |
FALLOUT4Apr 30, 2015 8:25 PM
Sword in hand, a warrior clutches stone to breast. In sword etched he his fading memories In stone, his tempered skill By sword attested, by stone revealed. Their tale can now be told |
Apr 30, 2015 8:37 PM
#24
Tommk said: Haou-Judai said: Tommk said: Please don't talk shit if you know nothing and start reading Replying LoL does not solve anything @_@ Please use spoiler button. Not everyone like read novels or mangas so stop think you are better just because you read the original story... then don't assume without a point. @_@ So far in this anime series, I don't remember hayama going out of the way to help yukinon ? Thus, that leaves to the novel, which leads to my post. If you want to reveal something from the novel, you can always use a spoiler tag. It shows a bit of consideration towards fellow fans who only follow the anime. :) [*spoiler]CONTENT[*/spoiler] Remove the * within [ ] |
Stay Home and Wash Your Hands. Protect Yourself. Protect Your Loved Ones. Protect Your Community and Help Defeat Coronavirus. |
Apr 30, 2015 8:40 PM
#25
Tommk said: worldeditor11 said: Most probably Yukino since he went out of his way a few times just to help her. Are you reading the same novel as I am ? You know he did planned out the student council position to push to someone else right ? Dude is saving his own ass. He always watch yukino get slaughter and will just say ''now now enough''. And tell me how he help her at volume 9 and 10. Other than ignoring the rumors ? Jesus Ignoring the rumours? I don't know what translation you read, he basically dispelled them at the cost of the status quo he so heartily maintained throughout the novels He always helped when it counted. Remember the camping arc when Yukino got into a fight with Miura? He clearly sided with Yukino then During the festival committee, when he saw that Yukino was being overworked, he stepped in and offered help which she refused And exactly what great woe was Yukino suffering from in volume 9? Her problems in vol 9 wasn't his business in the slightest. That was between her, Yui and 8man. Butting in would have been super bad and unnecessary of him. I'm not sure about this point, but IIRC he helped Yukino with campaign speeches in volume 8 When with Haruno, their shared past is obviously something that neither of them likes to talk about and so both try to brush that off when Haruno brings it up. What the fuck is he supposed to do when Haruno verbally dissects her sister anyway? Even Yukino can't talk back because some of it is truth, so he tries to alleviate the situation by 'now now enough' Didn't see even 8man doing anything then or with Yukimom when Yukino even looked to him for help A LoL speaks plenty when you act like you've read the novels and understand it better than any of us yet don't understand even the most cursory facts about it Tommk said: The hell does this even mean? Planned out the student council?You know he did planned out the student council position to push to someone else right ? To push someone else? At least use understandable language if you want to act all stuck up |
DeigerApr 30, 2015 8:47 PM
- My creativity is plummeting. - |
Apr 30, 2015 9:49 PM
#26
Deiger1111 said: Tommk said: worldeditor11 said: Most probably Yukino since he went out of his way a few times just to help her. Are you reading the same novel as I am ? You know he did planned out the student council position to push to someone else right ? Dude is saving his own ass. He always watch yukino get slaughter and will just say ''now now enough''. And tell me how he help her at volume 9 and 10. Other than ignoring the rumors ? Jesus Ignoring the rumours? I don't know what translation you read, he basically dispelled them at the cost of the status quo he so heartily maintained throughout the novels He always helped when it counted. Remember the camping arc when Yukino got into a fight with Miura? He clearly sided with Yukino then During the festival committee, when he saw that Yukino was being overworked, he stepped in and offered help which she refused And exactly what great woe was Yukino suffering from in volume 9? Her problems in vol 9 wasn't his business in the slightest. That was between her, Yui and 8man. Butting in would have been super bad and unnecessary of him. I'm not sure about this point, but IIRC he helped Yukino with campaign speeches in volume 8 When with Haruno, their shared past is obviously something that neither of them likes to talk about and so both try to brush that off when Haruno brings it up. What the fuck is he supposed to do when Haruno verbally dissects her sister anyway? Even Yukino can't talk back because some of it is truth, so he tries to alleviate the situation by 'now now enough' Didn't see even 8man doing anything then or with Yukimom when Yukino even looked to him for help A LoL speaks plenty when you act like you've read the novels and understand it better than any of us yet don't understand even the most cursory facts about it Tommk said: The hell does this even mean? Planned out the student council?You know he did planned out the student council position to push to someone else right ? To push someone else? At least use understandable language if you want to act all stuck up Oh please the reason why he helped yukino in her campaign speeches was just not to enter the campaign . Its pretty clear that he don't want to be the student council president if you actually read properly. Second, as for the rumors, he just dispelled it to maintain his status quo, he is always putting a facade. Hayama main motive in the entire novel is to protect his face and maintain his image. I won't call that as helping yukino. Seems like a good guy, but isn't. As with Haruno, did u even see a time where he helped yukino in any of their conversation (Not just once, but many times ) ? Don't avoid this topic, the only thing he did is shake it off and laugh it off. Some of it is the truth but does that mean all of it is ? Favoritism or obedient ? So basically from your conver, the only time when he help is the camp ? That's called always helped when its counted ? Ey lmao, read your entire conver, and tell me the only time he helped was the small matter at the camp. That's basically my point. not sure we are reading the same novel or not |
FALLOUT4Apr 30, 2015 9:57 PM
Sword in hand, a warrior clutches stone to breast. In sword etched he his fading memories In stone, his tempered skill By sword attested, by stone revealed. Their tale can now be told |
Apr 30, 2015 10:02 PM
#27
As for Hayato's action in the anime, people like you did not really notice that he got them involved in order to not be asked to be school president? He basically used MC again. The gesture was nothing but a slight compensation to the shit he had to go through cause of him that very same day. start thinking instead of just reading. But that's just me, judging things. but you probably understand the novel to missed out that point . smh |
Sword in hand, a warrior clutches stone to breast. In sword etched he his fading memories In stone, his tempered skill By sword attested, by stone revealed. Their tale can now be told |
Apr 30, 2015 10:10 PM
#28
NudeBear said: Hayama and Yukino were childhood friends (?) Hayama obviously admires Haruno Hayama makes sad face when he tells Hachiman that Haruno annoys/teases/messes with people she takes interest in. Pretty much implying that she has no interest in Hayama as a person. Yukino "wasn't chosen." So...might have had a crush on Hayama, but Hayama wanted Haruno instead..? >Does whatever Haruno tells him to. Her bitch. So yeah, definitely Haruno. |
May 1, 2015 12:53 AM
#29
Deiger1111 said: Tommk said: worldeditor11 said: Most probably Yukino since he went out of his way a few times just to help her. Are you reading the same novel as I am ? You know he did planned out the student council position to push to someone else right ? Dude is saving his own ass. He always watch yukino get slaughter and will just say ''now now enough''. And tell me how he help her at volume 9 and 10. Other than ignoring the rumors ? Jesus Ignoring the rumours? I don't know what translation you read, he basically dispelled them at the cost of the status quo he so heartily maintained throughout the novels He always helped when it counted. Remember the camping arc when Yukino got into a fight with Miura? He clearly sided with Yukino then During the festival committee, when he saw that Yukino was being overworked, he stepped in and offered help which she refused And exactly what great woe was Yukino suffering from in volume 9? Her problems in vol 9 wasn't his business in the slightest. That was between her, Yui and 8man. Butting in would have been super bad and unnecessary of him. I'm not sure about this point, but IIRC he helped Yukino with campaign speeches in volume 8 When with Haruno, their shared past is obviously something that neither of them likes to talk about and so both try to brush that off when Haruno brings it up. What the fuck is he supposed to do when Haruno verbally dissects her sister anyway? Even Yukino can't talk back because some of it is truth, so he tries to alleviate the situation by 'now now enough' Didn't see even 8man doing anything then or with Yukimom when Yukino even looked to him for help A LoL speaks plenty when you act like you've read the novels and understand it better than any of us yet don't understand even the most cursory facts about it Tommk said: The hell does this even mean? Planned out the student council?You know he did planned out the student council position to push to someone else right ? To push someone else? At least use understandable language if you want to act all stuck up Helping out campaign speech = Helping yukinon genuine. Are you retarded ? I'm not sure whether you are reading the same novel or are you desperate in finding points. As for the main point of this post, it's obvious hayama likes haruno. Stop derailing the thread |
Kappa-ingMay 1, 2015 1:01 AM
Actually glad that nepal is facing disaster |
May 1, 2015 12:55 AM
#30
Tommk said: As for Hayato's action in the anime, people like you did not really notice that he got them involved in order to not be asked to be school president? He basically used MC again. The gesture was nothing but a slight compensation to the shit he had to go through cause of him that very same day. start thinking instead of just reading. But that's just me, judging things. but you probably understand the novel to missed out that point . smh and this |
Actually glad that nepal is facing disaster |
May 1, 2015 3:15 AM
#31
Hmm, two idiots spewing nonsense in the same thread. Oh well, I will take the bait. First off, the initial mentioned by Hayama, "Yu". What does it mean? Who does it refer to is the key in deciding who does Hayama likes. Let's use this post to get our list of candidates shall we? supracseduch said: Probable options: Yukinoshita Haruno, Yukinoshita Yukino Plausible options: Yumiko (Miura), Yuigahama Yui Improbable options: Yoshiteru (Zaimokuza) Impossible options: You, Your Mama Now, since both improbable and impossible options are close to zero in terms of possibility, it is safe for us to leave those two options out. This leaves us with only two options. supracseduch said: Probable options: Yukinoshita Haruno, Yukinoshita Yukino Plausible options: Yumiko (Miura), Yuigahama Yui "Yu". If people asked you to name a person with only her/his initial, which name would you use, her/his family name or her/his given name? Again, I assume based on my own observations and logic that most sensible people will always refer to their given name rather the family name. Myself included and I think most of you will be the same. In both mediums, Hayama refer Yukinoshita Haruno as Haruno, so why would he suddenly refer Haruno as Yukinoshita by using the inital "Yu"? This just doesn't make any sense. Unless Hayama is as retarded as fender/spacebar/undecisive/bandwagon user here, the chances of this happening is extremely rare. Then there is the point where Hayama clearly differentiate those two sisters as well, mixing them up by using their family name as an initial, making it even more unlikely. This inevitably leaves us with only 3 characters, Yumiko, Yui and Yukino for us to choose from. Anything further than this is just plain assumption since no one actually knows who the girl is but at least we do know who isn't. This is what I am trying to prove here that nobody knows for sure. Though I will admit all of these are based on my reasoning using my given knowledge in LNs so there is a chance I might be wrong. Unless you think I am not reading the same novel as you are or possessing the reading comprehension ability akin to those of a 6 year-old or both, you may think I am full of shit. Like the user named Tommk so to speak. He called me out several times to present my evidence while claiming Haruno is the one without presenting anything himself. What's more, he even avoided questions posted before him and chose to apply more claims without any basis whatsoever. Like "he is always putting a facade.". Or even "Its pretty clear that he don't want to be the student council president if you actually read properly." for example. Big words I say but no actual examples to support his claims. Hayama is always putting a facade what? How on earth you can reach that conclusion? You claimed so with no concrete support to follow through your statement. Are you implying you are just making things up as you go? Or maybe you know "But that's just me, judging things." again excuse? Till now, Tommk is still spewing shit he ate from McD without backing up since his first post in this thread as I will prove now. No worries as it is spoiler free. Tommk said: Are you reading the same novel as I am ? Started off with questioning my ability to read and comprehend literature. A pitiful insult in other words. Totally a great way to start up a proper discussion. Tommk said: You know he did planned out the student council position to push to someone else right ? I will spare questioning your writing ability as I am more concerned with your source of information. Nowhere in both the anime and the LN provide such information. Again, spewing nothing but shit. Dieger asked you this but you reply vaguely by just going roundabout the main issue. Tommk said: Dude is saving his own ass. He always watch yukino get slaughter and will just say ''now now enough''. Yup, slaughtered by Haruno that is. Both of them to be more accurate. How the hell you expect him to save Yukino when he can't even save himself? No, Hayama is not Hachiman and there is the admiration including superiority factor as well. Hachiman even admitted he can't deal with Haruno and usually keep quiet throughout their conversation. Is Hachiman any different compared to Hayama? No. Tommk said: Oh please the reason why he helped yukino in her campaign speeches was just not to enter the campaign . Its pretty clear that he don't want to be the student council president if you actually read properly. Oh please, the possibility of him running as a student council president is near zero anyway. Why would he become a student council president when he was loaded with club activities being a president of the soccer club? All three members admitted Hayama is not a viable candidate despite his ability due to his busy schedule and aforementioned responsibilities. That's why Yukino planned to ran as a candidate. Hayama doesn't need to do anything because people will be against it, especially the teacher-adviser of soccer club and its members. So, why would he need to do anything in the first place when he knows that he already can't given the circumstances? It's the matter of he can't do it rather he don't want to do it so to speak. Tommk said: Hayama main motive in the entire novel is to protect his face and maintain his image. I won't call that as helping yukino. Seems like a good guy, but isn't. Uh huh. Everyone has some image to maintain and expectations to be fulfilled, not just Hayama. By your logic, no one is helping Yukino. Not even Hachiman considering he too has an image to maintain and obligations as a club member. Tommk said: As with Haruno, did u even see a time where he helped yukino in any of their conversation (Not just once, but many times ) ? Don't avoid this topic, the only thing he did is shake it off and laugh it off. Some of it is the truth but does that mean all of it is ? Favoritism or obedient ? The one who is avoiding the topic is you. You are cherry-picking on the fact whether Hayama helped Yukino or not whenever a situation involves Haruno. Both Yukino and Hayama admire Haruno since they were kids and believe they can't surpass her as a person. As such, Haruno is like some sort of an idol to them. Haruno is aware of this fact and tend to tease them about it. Can they do anything about it? Not really because both Yukino and Hayama know it as truth and attempt nothing to deny it. Tommk said: So basically from your conver, the only time when he help is the camp ? That's called always helped when its counted ? Ey lmao, read your entire conver, and tell me the only time he helped was the small matter at the camp. That's basically my point. No, your point basically amounted to nothing. You have proven nothing and presented nothing to support your theory on why Haruno is a more likely candidate than Yukino. First is the Kawasaki case. Second is the summer camp. Third is the festival committee(the anime omitted the part where Hayama actually wanted to visit Yukino when she was absent from school). Fourth is the camping speech. Small matter? Can't be classified as helping? When you consider a person went out of his way just to assist another person is not helping, I don't know what is. Tommk said: not sure we are reading the same novel or not What a tenacious guy he is! Maybe this is an assumption, but you know, this Tommk user might be reading the wrong novel altogether. Or maybe he can't read. Man, I don't know because most of the information I have provided here are easily obtained from the anime itself. |
May 1, 2015 4:59 AM
#32
I don't know, but wouldn't it be fun if were like this: Hayama (the popular guy) confesses to Yui, Yui declines saying she has someone she likes, Yui confesses directly and starts dating 8man (the loner). It would go something like this: sometimes being popular doesn't mean you have luck with love (love I mean the person you like) |
May 1, 2015 5:27 AM
#33
This topic made me read the wikia of Hayama. Haruno and Hayama call each other by their first name. It was mentioned in the light novel that he and Yukino look up to her. Haruno would also watch over them when both of their family are on business. Hayama is open towards her as much as he is open towards Hachiman. Dear LN readers, is this right? |
"I wasn’t a victim so things like pity and compassion weren’t necessary. Even though I was the one who arrogantly said that." |
May 1, 2015 6:18 AM
#34
i_fauzee said: This topic made me read the wikia of Hayama. Haruno and Hayama call each other by their first name. It was mentioned in the light novel that he and Yukino look up to her. Haruno would also watch over them when both of their family are on business. Hayama is open towards her as much as he is open towards Hachiman. Dear LN readers, is this right? Yup. Although I'm not sure what being open actually means here. If it means showing his true self/being honest, then yeah, Haruno knows exactly what kind of person Hayama is. |
May 1, 2015 8:01 AM
#35
nitro_cyanide said: Dragon_Slayer_X said: "Yukino wasn't chosen again"................a certain Yukinoshita Haruno said that in the first season. My guess is Haruno. I think so too. He's practically at her beck and call. Yup, this is correct i agrree, |
May 1, 2015 8:42 AM
#36
shanimebib said: If you want to reveal something from the novel, you can always use a spoiler tag. It shows a bit of consideration towards fellow fans who only follow the anime. :) [*spoiler]CONTENT[*/spoiler] Remove the * within [ ] Is there even any point in this spoiler bbcode? People is going to read anyway. |
Signature removed. Check your inbox |
May 2, 2015 7:56 PM
#37
aLotQuestion said: Only those who dont mind being spoiledshanimebib said: If you want to reveal something from the novel, you can always use a spoiler tag. It shows a bit of consideration towards fellow fans who only follow the anime. :) [*spoiler]CONTENT[*/spoiler] Remove the * within [ ] Is there even any point in this spoiler bbcode? People is going to read anyway. Which is obviously most people, but i beg to differ |
- My creativity is plummeting. - |
May 2, 2015 8:19 PM
#38
It could be Yukino that Hayama likes, she have good scores, she's rich, also a great worker during the whole event in season 1. It could also be Haruno, but I doubt it, because when someone ask who you like, you'd use their first name as in Yukino or Yui, I'm not sure if it works like that in Japan. Yukino also an elite and a high class person, I think Hayama would be attracted to such girls. Hayama's entire harem seems to always giving him unnecessary attraction, while he could like Yukino because she's cold and different from most girls. |
May 4, 2015 11:20 PM
#39
It's Haruno, clear as day. A direct quote from Hayama in the LN Not a spoiler happened at the training camp “Things would probably have turned out better if Yukinoshita-san had been like her sister.” If it isn't obivious now, then i don't know what will convince you.... |
May 5, 2015 11:42 AM
#40
Jun 19, 2015 10:54 PM
#41
Haruno. . . Reason being when Hikagaya was with Yui during the festival and they met she stated "So Yukino wasn't picked again, huh?" It also means 'in my honest opinion' Yukino did indeed have a thing for Hayama. It also caused the mood to go bad which caused her to get shunned back in her younger days. Also Hayama constantly tells 8-man he isn't the nicest guy as so he did something terrible to the girl who was in love with him. Haruno in general doesn't see Hayama that way even though she has him wrapped around her finger and would come at her beckon call. The way this will go is 8-man will definitely be with Yukino as he can understand her trauma and is always on the mark when he and Haruno are talking about her. I feel bad for Yui, but she doesn't really need Hachiman and she knows that better than anyone else as she observes the two. I like how psychological the story is concerning 'youth' it puts life into it and does a good job with it. That's what I believe. Also Yukino doesn't trust Hachiman as it is much more cruel and can also be dealing with trampling over Yui for our hero 8-man. Her body language is key and knowing just that much gives a hint. |
NukigeJun 19, 2015 11:03 PM
Jun 20, 2015 2:39 AM
#43
supracseduch said: Probable options: Yukinoshita Haruno, Yukinoshita Yukino Plausible options: Yumiko (Miura), Yuigahama Yui "Yu". If people asked you to name a person with only her/his initial, which name would you use, her/his family name or her/his given name? Again, I assume based on my own observations and logic that most sensible people will always refer to their given name rather the family name. Myself included and I think most of you will be the same. In both mediums, Hayama refer Yukinoshita Haruno as Haruno, so why would he suddenly refer Haruno as Yukinoshita by using the inital "Yu"? This just doesn't make any sense. Unless Hayama is as retarded as fender/spacebar/undecisive/bandwagon user here, the chances of this happening is extremely rare. Then there is the point where Hayama clearly differentiate those two sisters as well, mixing them up by using their family name as an initial, making it even more unlikely. This inevitably leaves us with only 3 characters, Yumiko, Yui and Yukino for us to choose from. Anything further than this is just plain assumption since no one actually knows who the girl is but at least we do know who isn't. This is what I am trying to prove here that nobody knows for sure. Though I will admit all of these are based on my reasoning using my given knowledge in LNs so there is a chance I might be wrong. Unless you think I am not reading the same novel as you are or possessing the reading comprehension ability akin to those of a 6 year-old or both, you may think I am full of shit. Like the user named Tommk so to speak. He called me out several times to present my evidence while claiming Haruno is the one without presenting anything himself. What's more, he even avoided questions posted before him and chose to apply more claims without any basis whatsoever. Like "he is always putting a facade.". Or even "Its pretty clear that he don't want to be the student council president if you actually read properly." for example. Big words I say but no actual examples to support his claims. Hayama is always putting a facade what? How on earth you can reach that conclusion? You claimed so with no concrete support to follow through your statement. Are you implying you are just making things up as you go? Or maybe you know "But that's just me, judging things." again excuse? Till now, Tommk is still spewing shit he ate from McD without backing up since his first post in this thread as I will prove now. No worries as it is spoiler free. + nice opinion im prefer Y = Yukino simple Because He's Always There in every "big event" except from "genuine think" |
abgJun 20, 2015 2:48 AM
Jun 20, 2015 3:19 AM
#44
Supracseduch: it may be a translation difference since I have not gotten to that point in the novek yet, but if the original question was the first letter of the person's name, then Haruno is an equally likely choice. Names are written with surname first in Japan, so "What is the first letter of her name?" for Haruno is Yu for Yukinoshita Haruno. Hayama refers to Haruno by first name only to people he knows who Haruno is. Since it is uncertain if his usual rat pack knows Haruno, he will also not refer to her by first name either. |
Jun 20, 2015 10:17 AM
#45
it was actually yoko yamashita from the other class. the reason why hayama doesnt want to talk about is for yoko to have a peaceful student life. |
internet is a cruel mistress |
Jun 20, 2015 11:00 AM
#46
Jun 21, 2015 11:48 AM
#47
One of the Yukinoshito sisters, probably Haruno. |
One day we will come upon each other, and for that day my claws, teeth, ears, hands and hair are at the ready. |
Jun 21, 2015 7:49 PM
#48
I had really hoped that Hayama would become a serious rival for Hikki. I know this is targeted towards males but its really odd that even though the heroines are suppose to be super cute/beautiful, popular, perfect, etc and the guy is suppose to be "dweeb", somehow its always him developing the harem while the girls are pretty much stuck with only him. I do kinda understand why the authors do this though, even when they don't want to. They know that if they make a serious rival for a heroine, the virgin-hunting nerds would form a death-cult for her. Sometimes, she doesn't even have to show interest in other guy (in which case, it wouldn't be a serious rival anyways), but if she does show some interest, she's doomed. |
Dec 4, 2016 12:08 AM
#49
Yukino , i think. He said "Y" and he calls haruno by name, so yeah, yukino. |
Sep 25, 2018 3:02 AM
#50
I don't know whom he likes but he has such a liar personality though even though his communication skills are good. He couldn't even solve his own problems and that's why He is heavily relied under Hikigaya. Girls may fall for him for his looks but only the real ones will know how insecure and inferior he is when it comes to solving problems. I can say that He likes Yukino as They went to Elementary class together, but he has no spine to confess it. I'd prefer Totsuka/Yoshiteru rather than Hayato as the deuteragonist Male Character. |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Yahari Ore no Seishun Love Comedy wa Machigatteiru. Zoku Episode 8 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - May 21, 2015 |
668 |
by muimaniac
»»
May 14, 8:47 PM |
|
Poll: » Yahari Ore no Seishun Love Comedy wa Machigatteiru. Zoku Episode 13 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Jun 25, 2015 |
1002 |
by venbals
»»
Mar 29, 10:59 AM |
|
Poll: » Yahari Ore no Seishun Love Comedy wa Machigatteiru. Zoku Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Jun 18, 2015 |
556 |
by venbals
»»
Mar 29, 1:08 AM |
|
Poll: » Yahari Ore no Seishun Love Comedy wa Machigatteiru. Zoku Episode 6 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - May 7, 2015 |
421 |
by venbals
»»
Mar 16, 9:12 PM |
|
» Help me understand the whole drama ( 1 2 )GuidSMR - Apr 4, 2023 |
65 |
by NaughtySempai
»»
Feb 26, 8:34 PM |