Forum Settings
Forums

Does chinese animation lack productions of culture?

New
Does chinese animation lack productions of culture?
Pages (2) « 1 [2]
Yesterday, 7:58 AM

Offline
May 2018
12293
"Kung Fu Liaoli Niang" and "Yao Jing Zhong Zhi Shou Ce"

Never heard of those, they look somehow low budget.
Yesterday, 8:06 AM

Offline
Sep 2016
20839
Reply to MalchikRepaid
Zarutaku said:
Right, although unrestricted freedom is an utopia, and women of my taste are unicorns, but what does that have to do with the topic? lol


Your "the top unit that governs the lower ones" quote really makes me appreciate your sense of humor.
@MalchikRepaid Seems I was unintentionally funny, a good thing, I guess.
Yesterday, 8:15 AM
Offline
Dec 2022
4289
Jebidor said:
Reality shows that China tightens freedom of speech perhaps more than the Western left, but the economy is a little more free.


I think people in the West or pro-Western Asian countries often forget this aspect of China. It's that China treats Western style freedom as a dangerous thing.

China believes that Western style freedom is not a net positive to humanity. Why? It fears that Western style freedom is like a Huxleyan dystopia. China also believes that ignorance among the population is much worse than censorship. There is no need to pursue censorship actively if ignorance prevails in a society.

Overall, China and the West (including pro-Western countries in Asia, all of them failing badly) have very different models of governance in the first place. But why should the West impose its way of governance onto China? It's the 21st century. There shouldn't be any Western imperialism around the world by now.

Don't give me the "muh human rights" approach because the West is also the worst offender of human rights.
Yesterday, 8:22 AM

Offline
Sep 2016
20839
MalchikRepaid said:
China also believes that ignorance among the population is much worse than censorship.

I have trouble with making sense of this comparison, doesn't censorship promote ignorance?
Yesterday, 8:25 AM
Offline
Dec 2022
4289
Zarutaku said:
I can't make sense of this comparison, because censorship promotes ignorance.


Censorship will make people gradually more curious, so censorship is the direct opposite of ignorance in so many instances.

Censorship in China is more like "be careful with this particular kind of knowledge", not "you don't need to know about it".
Yesterday, 8:27 AM

Offline
Feb 2020
1425
Reply to detarameMAL
To explain:

deg said:
China bans pornography because the government considers it "spiritual pollution" that harms individuals and society, damaging physical and mental health, corrupting social morals, and undermining traditional Chinese cultural values. The ban aligns with broader Chinese censorship efforts aimed at controlling content that is seen as detrimental to national unity, social order, and traditional ethics.

This is true, but "spiritual" as used here does not have anything to do with religion; it's more like "corrupting the minds of the people."

Back when China was actually a communist country, some of the country's leaders got this idea that anything "Western," "bourgeoisie," and "indulgent" was "spiritual pollution" (精神污染). This would include obscenity, gambling, drugs, and so on, in addition to certain more liberal philosophies such as humanism. They thought that this spiritual pollution would undermine China's transition to a communist utopia: if the minds of the average people are polluted with capitalist ideas, how can we build a society where everyone lives in harmony? And, yes, this means that the notion of "spiritual pollution" is largely reactionary to Western progressive ideas at the time.

However, the term "精神污染" was never really defined clearly, since both conservative and progressive politicians were campaigning against this supposed bad thing. This is why it often seem very conservative, even though China was both secular and radically left at the time.

Nowadays, China is for all purposes not left-leaning or communist at all; it is instead rather conservative. So, "culture" and sexualization continue to be censored through this inherited notion of them being "bad for morals."

It's really interesting how what normally would be called "puritanism" by MAL users arose in a secular country through reactionary, anti-capitalist sentiments alone. I suppose Confucianism and Taoism didn't help either, but traditional values have collapsed just about everywhere else in the world when actually put up against with progressive ideas.
@detarameMAL Nothing weird. Puritanism was using some old tale written in the desert, when people shouldn't spend energy into what wouldn't keep them alive or carefully multiply, because food and water was hard to go by. Any culture planning on saving resources would promote it. Can people do debauchery and fun and do 996? I suppose you don't remember Confucianism is about stripping religion out of its magic and picking the practices that make sense.


Yesterday, 8:29 AM

Offline
Sep 2016
20839
Reply to MalchikRepaid
Zarutaku said:
I can't make sense of this comparison, because censorship promotes ignorance.


Censorship will make people gradually more curious, so censorship is the direct opposite of ignorance in so many instances.

Censorship in China is more like "be careful with this particular kind of knowledge", not "you don't need to know about it".
@MalchikRepaid Seems reasonable, but does that mean people in China are curious about the censored stuff, and does the government want them to be?
Yesterday, 8:33 AM
Offline
Dec 2022
4289
Zarutaku said:
@MalchikRepaid Seems reasonable, but does that mean people in China are curious about the censored stuff, and does the government want them to be?


It's more like "you know it, but don't talk about it in private or public spaces, time will tell that it will be reconciled eventually, but always oppose propaganda from Western countries and pro-American countries in Asia because these countries just want China to become weak again as they're using human rights and democracy as piss poor excuses".
Yesterday, 8:42 AM

Offline
Sep 2016
20839
Reply to MalchikRepaid
Zarutaku said:
@MalchikRepaid Seems reasonable, but does that mean people in China are curious about the censored stuff, and does the government want them to be?


It's more like "you know it, but don't talk about it in private or public spaces, time will tell that it will be reconciled eventually, but always oppose propaganda from Western countries and pro-American countries in Asia because these countries just want China to become weak again as they're using human rights and democracy as piss poor excuses".
MalchikRepaid said:
always oppose propaganda from Western countries and pro-American countries in Asia because these countries just want China to be weak again

That's the first time I heard about this accusation, sounds like propaganda itself, to be fair.
Yesterday, 8:47 AM
Offline
Dec 2022
4289
Zarutaku said:
That's the first time I heard about this accusation, sounds like propaganda itself, to be fair.


As a person with a Chinese heritage, I sense this all the time. If that's worse, wait until you read this. I don't talk to South Korean men because they often say in public "let's kill Chinese people" or "the only good Chinese is dead Chinese" in Korean.
Yesterday, 8:58 AM

Offline
Sep 2016
20839
Reply to MalchikRepaid
Zarutaku said:
That's the first time I heard about this accusation, sounds like propaganda itself, to be fair.


As a person with a Chinese heritage, I sense this all the time. If that's worse, wait until you read this. I don't talk to South Korean men because they often say in public "let's kill Chinese people" or "the only good Chinese is dead Chinese" in Korean.
MalchikRepaid said:
I don't talk to South Korean men because they often say in public "let's kill Chinese people" or "the only good Chinese is dead Chinese" in Korean.

Sounds extreme, they probably do that because the Chinese government supports their northern archenemy.
Yesterday, 8:59 AM
Offline
Dec 2022
4289
Zarutaku said:
Sounds extreme, they probably do that because China supports their northern archenemy.


Not really. It's more complicated than that and this is not a good place to explain this.
Yesterday, 2:23 PM

Offline
Sep 2024
81
I know for a lot of people here the whole notion of culture is basically limited to (child) porn. But that's a you problem, not a china problem
10 hours ago

Offline
Jul 2019
4558
Reply to Zarutaku
MalchikRepaid said:
always oppose propaganda from Western countries and pro-American countries in Asia because these countries just want China to be weak again

That's the first time I heard about this accusation, sounds like propaganda itself, to be fair.
@Zarutaku, I would say it's a rhetoric that's not without historical grievances. China at the turn of the 20th century suffered sovereignty crises, internal strife, and traumatic incidents one after another. The historical events that unfolded have had a profound impact on the Chinese people and their perception of what a government should do on its own soil to preserve its sovereignty. It's something that's exposed to every Chinese person via school or family.

The degree to which these historical events can be (sometimes turned) into nationalist ideals varies from person to person. But every Chinese person is at least taught the insights from that period to the current state of China. I, for one, while were exposed to these historical events, they were then tempered by my family to ensure not to develop a pure nationalistic view. And I think this is very much the main contemporary attitude of the Chinese people in the mainland, for example.

Yes, I do agree it's propaganda, but it's not without truth.




-[ ~♫~ ll Credit ]-
10 hours ago

Offline
Jul 2019
4558
Reply to Zarutaku
MalchikRepaid said:
I don't talk to South Korean men because they often say in public "let's kill Chinese people" or "the only good Chinese is dead Chinese" in Korean.

Sounds extreme, they probably do that because the Chinese government supports their northern archenemy.
@Zarutaku, extreme or not, Chinese and Koreans don't exactly see eye to eye goes way back beyond just simple supporting North or South of the Korean peninsula.




-[ ~♫~ ll Credit ]-
9 hours ago

Offline
Jul 2022
102
Reply to LordSozin
@Zarutaku, extreme or not, Chinese and Koreans don't exactly see eye to eye goes way back beyond just simple supporting North or South of the Korean peninsula.
@LordSozin Why because the old imperial dynasty fought against them before ? But so did the Mongol and Manchu. Emperor Tang Taizhong was an ambitious Emperor not surprised he wanted to conquer Goguryeo.
6 hours ago

Offline
Sep 2016
20839
Reply to LordSozin
@Zarutaku, I would say it's a rhetoric that's not without historical grievances. China at the turn of the 20th century suffered sovereignty crises, internal strife, and traumatic incidents one after another. The historical events that unfolded have had a profound impact on the Chinese people and their perception of what a government should do on its own soil to preserve its sovereignty. It's something that's exposed to every Chinese person via school or family.

The degree to which these historical events can be (sometimes turned) into nationalist ideals varies from person to person. But every Chinese person is at least taught the insights from that period to the current state of China. I, for one, while were exposed to these historical events, they were then tempered by my family to ensure not to develop a pure nationalistic view. And I think this is very much the main contemporary attitude of the Chinese people in the mainland, for example.

Yes, I do agree it's propaganda, but it's not without truth.
@LordSozin Understandable, but grudges based on historical events shouldn't be perpetuated, they hinder reconciliation and other peaceful developments.
Zarutaku6 hours ago
Pages (2) « 1 [2]

More topics from this board

» How would you explain "Romance for a male audience" to a western (Mostly American) audience? ( 1 2 )

thewiru - Aug 30

71 by TransferUser »»
3 minutes ago

» People who missed out on real life romance, Does that change how you feel about romance anime?

TheBlockernator - Yesterday

11 by Nirinbo »»
8 minutes ago

» Best ed and op song this season

nishant0 - 6 hours ago

7 by YN_ON »»
15 minutes ago

» 💪Who is Greatest Husbando? | Nominate Husbando for a ! Tournament !

Whiteingale - 2 hours ago

9 by Nefregar »»
15 minutes ago

» Is it true that Shonen Jump is desperate to get a new long running series?

MegaMan1 - 10 hours ago

5 by SwamperT100 »»
22 minutes ago
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login