| as for OP, I think KyoAni animating this would be very similar quality wise. Don't think it'd make that huge of a difference. |
| Music will probably be better |
Cestlavie_ said: Music will probably be better the music is already god tier though |
| I do not think this series matches the generally tone of most kyoani shows, and it is unlikely that frieren could have become low tier god if they were the ones animating it. |
 |
| If Kyoani did this: Scenery shots would look better... Music would be the same...since the music director for this show came from them anyway... The directing can only be matched if Naoko Yamada is the one handling this show... Im not sure about the action scenes since Dragonmaid S2 actually has good animation in its fight scenes when again its not their selling point... The sad & sentimental & deep emotional moments would be good if not better... Humor will be less funny especially when it involves a male to female interaction... We will have a hard time simping or cheering for the villains if Kyoani handled it... For some reason...Madhouse is better than Kyoani on that... |
" Kindness can sometimes lead you to trouble. "  |
Reply to tudututut
Cestlavie_ said:
Music will probably be better
Music will probably be better
kinda agree with u, for the OP and ED kinda wished that it was more folk vibe and less pop.
but nonetheless, yoasobi and milet drop some banger tho π
| @tudututut Something like Violet Evergarden OP wouldve been a better opening... Heck!!! The ED shouldve been the OP!!! |
" Kindness can sometimes lead you to trouble. " |
Reply to Cestlavie_
Music will probably be better
| @Cestlavie_ Music is done by same guy who worked on Violet Evergarden. |
| As Hitagi__Furude already mentioned above. It would have been visually and emotionally better. And would have more detailed facial expressions (even with those stoic faces). Nevertheless these are just what KyoAni is best at. I'm not sure about fighting scenes but when it comes to make characters naturally human and emotionally alive, I prefer KyoAni over any other studios. |
   π’πͺπ΄πΎπ»πͺ ππ²π·πΈπΆπΈπ½πΈ |
PoisonedSandwich said: Cestlavie_ said: Music will probably be better the music is already god tier though it's good but doesn't fit the show well imo |
 |
Reply to Friedrich-kyn
PoisonedSandwich said:
the music is already god tier though
Cestlavie_ said:
Music will probably be better
Music will probably be better
the music is already god tier though
it's good but doesn't fit the show well imo
| @Friedrich-kyn The music fit really well. |
| It would be even more PEAK. |
 |
eh, different tastes I guess |
|
| What if it was done by Shaft? |
 |
Reply to Piromysl
@ZXEAN It would have highest score even after it finishes airing.
| @Piromysl I don't think so. The director played a big role for it's success. Madhouse is an all-round studio and they brought their A-team for this project unlike KyoAni who are generally known for slice of life anime. |
Reply to Rafiikii
It all depends on the DIRECTOR.
Damn, these discussions are so weird. The KyoAni style people talk about is Naoko Yamadas style, a studio is just a tag. Warner Bros are not the reason Inception is a fantastic film, it is the personnel used for the movie.
Damn, these discussions are so weird. The KyoAni style people talk about is Naoko Yamadas style, a studio is just a tag. Warner Bros are not the reason Inception is a fantastic film, it is the personnel used for the movie.
| @Rafiikii You are 100% true. |
Reply to PoisonedSandwich
Cestlavie_ said:
Music will probably be better
Music will probably be better
the music is already god tier though
| @PoisonedSandwich what's god tier with the music? |
It just means that the music is very good |
| It wouldnt have been as good. Madhouse is the best |
Reply to OvergrownRover
The action wouldn’t look nearly as good
| @OvergrownRover Someone never watched Violet Evergarden, Dragon Maid, or Beyond the Boundary. |
| I think if KyoAni did this the color of everything will be a bit vibrant or at least less dull. Not that there's anything wrong with the show as is. And probably more camera angles? |
"Nobody could laugh at someone who's trying their hardest" -Machio- |
Reply to Rafiikii
It all depends on the DIRECTOR.
Damn, these discussions are so weird. The KyoAni style people talk about is Naoko Yamadas style, a studio is just a tag. Warner Bros are not the reason Inception is a fantastic film, it is the personnel used for the movie.
Damn, these discussions are so weird. The KyoAni style people talk about is Naoko Yamadas style, a studio is just a tag. Warner Bros are not the reason Inception is a fantastic film, it is the personnel used for the movie.
| @Rafiikii True enough. But I heard KyoAni mostly uses in-studio staff (as in not outsourcing to, say, DR. Movie) like a lot of studios do so shows produced by KyoAni generally have more consistent quality. Still it depends on the director and the individual staff who are working on a show. |
| "Nobody could laugh at someone who's trying their hardest" -Machio- |
Reply to Yuu_Kanzaki
I think if KyoAni did this the color of everything will be a bit vibrant or at least less dull. Not that there's anything wrong with the show as is.
And probably more camera angles?
And probably more camera angles?
| @Yuu_Kanzaki If KyoAni worked on this project they would have focus more on slice of life and nullified the action scenes. |
ZXEANDec 7, 2023 9:27 PM
| It's already Violet Evergarden. But if KyoAni took this, at worst, it would be called a VE clone. |
Reply to ZXEAN
@Yuu_Kanzaki If KyoAni worked on this project they would have focus more on slice of life and nullified the action scenes.
| @ZXEAN Not necessarily. Maid Dragon and Violet have great action scenes, though the two are exceptions. |
| "Nobody could laugh at someone who's trying their hardest" -Machio- |
Reply to Rafiikii
It all depends on the DIRECTOR.
Damn, these discussions are so weird. The KyoAni style people talk about is Naoko Yamadas style, a studio is just a tag. Warner Bros are not the reason Inception is a fantastic film, it is the personnel used for the movie.
Damn, these discussions are so weird. The KyoAni style people talk about is Naoko Yamadas style, a studio is just a tag. Warner Bros are not the reason Inception is a fantastic film, it is the personnel used for the movie.
| @Rafiikii Kyoto Animation is actually pretty much the only case in the industry where you *can* perceive a strong studio identity, so it wouldn't be "disrespectful" to praise them as a team instead of going through every single staff member imo |
Reply to Rafiikii
nwssx said:
@Rafiikii Kyoto Animation is actually pretty much the only case in the industry where you *can* perceive a strong studio identity, so it wouldn't be "disrespectful" to praise them as a team instead of going through every single staff member imo
@Rafiikii Kyoto Animation is actually pretty much the only case in the industry where you *can* perceive a strong studio identity, so it wouldn't be "disrespectful" to praise them as a team instead of going through every single staff member imo
Kyoani and to some extent Trigger and Ufotable. I know, but when people talk about studios good efforts, it rarely is. Most of the giants like MAPPA, Cloverworks, Toei, etc have selected teams and directors they finance. Praising a studio to feels almost like praising the software you use to make the anime.
You praise a studio for aquiring a work, but the team are the ones who make the product. It's the same where people praise Elon Musk for anything good Tesla or SpaceX
| @Rafiikii true that, most of the time people will judge based on the building's name instead of the key people behind their projects, the animators themselves aren't particularly happy about that, especially when they aren't affiliated with those buildings, it's not the case of the likes of KyoAni or Trigger but it's just sad |
| I would fucking barf. Believe me when I say, it will have so much fucking lighting shenanigans you'll think its a fucking video game with garbage Ambient Occlusion and HDR implementation. Thank fucking god this wasnt done by Kyoani staff. |
| Keep scrolling |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Sousou no Frieren Episode 4 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )KANLen09 - Sep 29, 2023 |
368 |
by enthusiastperson
»»
2 hours ago |
|
Poll: » Sousou no Frieren Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )KANLen09 - Sep 29, 2023 |
718 |
by enthusiastperson
»»
5 hours ago |
|
Poll: » Sousou no Frieren Episode 18 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )Stark700 - Jan 12, 2024 |
234 |
by Kattonat_
»»
9 hours ago |
|
Poll: » Sousou no Frieren Episode 11 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Nov 17, 2023 |
305 |
by CookieTrees
»»
Dec 30, 2025 5:15 AM |
|
Poll: » Sousou no Frieren Episode 28 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )anime-prime - Mar 22, 2024 |
1091 |
by GetsugaTenshouu
»»
Dec 27, 2025 10:20 AM |