| Greenmush ef - a tale of melodies - Only seen Memories but it was great. Ga-Rei -Zero- - Very good, though I wouldn't call it a masterpiece. Higurashi S2 - Great series, personally a 9 but I could see it at 10. Code Geass (both) - Agreed, though I gave S1 a 9. Aria the Animation - Very good, though I again wouldn't call it a masterpiece. It seems strange that you gave this a 10 though the next season isn't anywhere on your list, not even Plan to Watch. |
| Divinity_123 Elfen Lied- The anime was way too short. They should've adapted the entire manga completely into anime instead of omitting out many interesting/good parts. Plus the ending was changed. |
| Gintama - I don't know anything about it so I can't comment on it. Death Note - While very good, the manga was better. The third arc (Near/Mello) was rushed through in the anime, making Near's thought process feel like he just randomly knew the answers to everything. Death Note Rewrite - Wasn't this just a two hour retelling of the entire Death Note story more from Ryuk's point of view that was mostly made up of material from the original series? Who gives what's essentially a long recap episode a 10? LOL. |
| nx6 does not have any 10's...So I'll comment on his favorites. FLCL - I don't get what everyone likes about this. It bored me to say the least. Black Lagoon - Cool show, not a 10 for me but I can see it. Code Geass - Another cool show, I plan to rewatch it. TMoHS - Great show, been a while since I've seen it, though. Not a 10 for me but it's understandable. WttNHK - Cool show again. Very enjoyable mostly, but some parts were a bit dull for me. |
FloreteDec 31, 2009 2:29 AM
| Code Geass - I do not think its overrated so i totally agree with you on 10 :D Death note - it got lame after Clannad and Elfen Lied - ive heard they are very good and im planning to watch them soon :D |
| No sig :( |
| LotGH - ... I've had enough of Baman's rants so no comments. That's it? No other 10 huh? NOT EVEN BACCANO?!!??! =OOO |
 |
| Okay, so u like Mugen and Baccano :O No idea what's Baccano, but Champloo deserves every 1 point of those 10. ... am i doing it right? :s |
testProductDec 31, 2009 6:21 AM
  |
yuro said: no 10s at all? Oo Did you see my Anime list? I've given 10s to Baccano and Samurai Champloo! |
|
| suman ^^ i didnt refresh befor posting :3 ... happens >_< |
| |
yuro said: Okay, so u like Mugen and Baccano :O No idea what's Baccano, but Champloo deserves every 1 point of those 10. ... am i doing it right? :s Ok, you finally spot them. Baccano's cool. You need to watch it. Cowboy Bebop - Expected. Cat Soup - Heard it's really unique. FF Advent Children - It was good but not a 10... FMA - Looks overrated to me GTO - Supposedly a classic Mushishi - Nice. Deserves it. Nodame - Yes. Might deserve it. Soul Eater - err... Samurai Champloo - NOW you're talking! =D Too many 10s there dontcha think? |
|
k0k0 said: Ok, you finally spot them. Baccano's cool. You need to watch it. Cowboy Bebop - Expected. Cat Soup - Heard it's really unique. FF Advent Children - It was good but not a 10... FMA - Looks overrated to me GTO - Supposedly a classic Mushishi - Nice. Deserves it. Nodame - Yes. Might deserve it. Soul Eater - err... Samurai Champloo - NOW you're talking! =D Too many 10s there dontcha think? i leked soul eater mostly because of the translation :) AND there was a plot xD When i started watching FMA 3 years ago - it wasnt THAT popular and overrated as it is now. It still kicks Naruto's ass IMO x) |
| |
| Monster - havent watched it yet but i plan to, because many people have recommended it to me :D. It is hard to start such a long anime :P |
| No sig :( |
| I just recently changed my mind about code geass after rewatching it. from my point of view 10 is too much for this show. Though TTGL Yay that's good. Texhnolyze i don't have anything against it but it was somehow dragged wasn't it? |
| Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann - HELL yeah! Samurai Champloo - cant hide the truth x) Mushishi - the most beuatiful anime out there IMO Gintama OVA - oh i dont really know =\ i couldnt watch it when i found out it has no plot >_< Death Note - deff overrated IMO |
| |
| Dude...... You have 10s madness :D Anyway ill pick a few... Advent Children - an awesome movie, but definatelly not worth a 10 :D Cowboy Bebop - definitely Rurouni Kenshin - definitely too :D |
| No sig :( |
| Code Geass - I never watched it so I can't really say. Heard it is good though. Gurren Lagann - One of my favorites. :D Darker than Black - Not finished. I will finish one of these days. It's pretty good from the episodes I watched. Texhnolyze - Never watched it or heard of it until now but based on the summary, it looks interesting. |
 |
| Pokemon- I like the games but the anime is pretty "meh" too childish for me. Azumanga Daioh- I agree! it is an awesome anime! Tengen Toppa- I used to hate it but then I thought hard and discovered it is pretty cool :D |
 |
| ^ Death Note- Yeah, it's awesome though I prefer the manga |
| Hmm, I think i've commented on yours before already... I'll do it again. Gintama - I've heard it's really good and I DO plan to watch it but such a long runing series is hard to pick up (especially since it doesn't seem to have a fixed plot) Deathnote - Deserves it. It's awesome. [A 7 for Baccano! outrageous!] |
|
| Haruhi, DMC and NGE are all pretty good. Haruhi s2 and TTGL what? |
 |
| Woah at the 3 long blue bars. Evangelion - Is supposed to be great as far as I know Furi Kuri - It's ranked quite high here on MAL I've seen none of your 10s and the above are the onely ones i've heard of. But yeah, kudos to your few 10s in such a huge list. |
|
| Higurashi no Naku Koro ni - My favorite anime of all time. Freaking deserves it. Azumanga Daioh - Plan to watch on my list, looks like great fun. Maybe even better than Lucky Star. Dunno if it's ten's worth. 5 Centimeters per Second - Dunno. Seems good. ef - a tale of memories. - Plan to watch on my list, looks amazing. But it is SHAFT though, and I hate SHAFT. Kara no Kyoukai 5: Mujun Rasen - Dunno. |
 |
| Higurashi no Naku Koro ni and Kai- you've done a great job. Jigoku Shoujo Futakomori - I prefer the first season to it. |
We are the United. Even in defeat we stand united. |
| Well, i have watched only CG out of your 10s and I can say that it is a good choice. I am planning to watch the other three though. |
| No sig :( |
| CG, and especially R2, are terribly overrated and don't deserve half the praise they get. Texhnolyze I plan to watch. And Darker than Black was good and entertaining, but I don't think 10 worthy. The only 10 on your list I really agree with is TTGL. |
∞      ∞ |
| I think One Peice is a great anime, but a bit overrated and doesn't deserve the 10. I haven't even gotten past the exposition for FMA but I heard it was great. Apparentely all thr other series that have it deserve such good ratings. Not much else I can say, really. |
| Fire Emblem: Kakusei |
| Moogles -only 10 in completed is for Higashi no Eden? I personally disliked Eden massively, I find it overrated -GTO is under your favorites, that's a great series -Isaac and Miria are under your favorite characters, that's an awesome show too -I have not read nor seen Prince of Tennis, but I understand that it is some people's crack |
| -I haven't seen any of your 10s except TTGL which is really awesome anime, I think that you've made a good choice giving 10 :P -Rest of your 10s probably deserves such a good rating but I haven't seen them so I can't talk=D |
| Nanami -black lettering on a black character...bit hard to read -Hooray for Baccano! I didn't think the OVA was quite as good though -I read the Bus Gamer manga, not sure if the anime was significantly different, but I didn't think it was that good -eww, not a big Code Geass fan, I never watched the 2nd season -Cromartie High, high five! It's my favorite comedy anime -I've read some DMC,i t's pretty good, but it's starting to get old for me -I have liked what I have read of Hikaru no Go (which is the first 13 volumes I believe) -Mononoke was excellent, great choice -I did not care for the Peach Girl manga, too melodramatic -Sayonara Zetsubou Sensei, I liked the first season a lot too -TTGL! Yeah, as said above, we agree -Girl who Leapt Through Time, I kinda found this movie to be mostly average, and I especially disliked the ending which I felt was rushed -I've read some of the Wallflower manga, I quite like it, but it's not 10 material for me -haven't seen your other ones |
| TTGL - ofc!, one of my favorite animes :D love it Legend of the Galactic Heroes - I am suspecting that it is good but I cannot make myself watch such a long anime :P Metropolis - it was a good movie, but definitely not a masterpiece :P Don't know about the other ones |
| No sig :( |
| Algirdyz TTGL:yea i would probably give it a 10 once i finish the whole series, still epic for me Code Geass: 10, it deserves every point, one of the greatest creations in my anime history Texhnolyze:I havent seen the show but the Synopsis seems interesting |
Awesome Sig by Lailide |
| greenmush I see lots of 10's. CG- I didn't like it. ES21- Haven't completed it, but definitely not a 10. Should've followed the manga completely (and don't get me started on the massive difference between the anime and manga art) Gintama- Yeah, it's awesome. Higurashi no Naku Koro ni Kai- I found it boring and disappointing KHR- The manga's better. The anime toned down on the blood. |
| lol. 39.3%? we really have different views in watching anime eh... Death Note: Nice. no need to tell more xD |
| Ouran HSHC, I also gave it a 10 ;) good show! Spirited Away - A masterpiece, sure alittle overrated but no qualms here Toki wo Kakeru Shoujo - never watched it but I've been meaning too since it looks really good, so i guess i agree? Nodame Cantabile - never watched it ef - a tale of memories - haven't watched it either but it looks good lolz mushishi - also haven't watched :P but also looks good :D Kanon !! I love Kanon, not as much as clannad but still really good, D: Gankutsou - havent watched it..but I've read the Count of Monte Cristo and it was a decent book :D Clannad after story, the first season was great but after story was simply amazing, probably the first anime which made me cry (in a good way) Baccano - I didn't give it a 10 but its a good show, Flying Pussyfoot forever :D!! |
 |
| FMA: brothehood/Soul Eater - You haven't even finished them yet ( and just 3 episodes of soul eater). Oh well, SE was great at the begining but I lost interest after the second half. Clannad afterstory - Can't say it doesn't deserve it. Though the whole fantasy ending killed me a little. CG - I can see that. Excellent anime, not of my taste though. Deathnote- Without a doubt. Howl's moving castle - I guess...dunno about a 10 but it definitely IS good. OHSHC - It was just enjoyable. Not a 10 IMO. Spirited Away - I agree. You judge too soon. How can you give a 10 to a series based on just the first episode? Anyway, if you don't change Baccano's score to a 10 when you finish it (and watch the OVAS too they continue a great side story) then i'll change my name. |
|
| @Jrittmayer Clannad AS - understandable CG s1 and R2 - Agreed Death Note - If only the second arc is as great as the first arc, Hayate the Combat Butler! - a good parody, I must say. But, I see no reason why it is a masterpiece. I cannot get some of the jokes. Ouran High School Host Club - a very good show, indeed. I like the way it develops and characters' backstories. Still, 10 is way too high for it. Esp, the reverse harem ending. Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood - I could hug you for giving it a 10. The rest I've not seen. |
| We are the United. Even in defeat we stand united. |
| Schtim -Yes, yes, YES to Baccano! I didn't find the OVA quite as good though. -ugh, Eden of the East, I find it massively overrated, I really disliked it -Paprika? I like Satoshi Kon, don't get me wrong, but I personally find Paprika to be his least good work. You should really watch Paranoia Agent -I need to rewatch Place Promised in Our Early days, I found it kinda average the first (and so far only) time I've seen it, but I get the feeling it'd be better on a 2nd viewing. -haven't seen the others |
| we really dont have the same taste in anime but its ok sayonara zetsubou sensei and Cromartie High school was given a high score so you are oj in my book. and also... thanks to classicalzanwa i now know that Piano no Mori has been made into a movie... |
| Sesam -Cro High is an epically awesome series, it's my favorite comedy anime ever -I've only seen the first season of Sayonara Zetsubou Sensei, some people tell me it goes downhill, some say it stays funny, I'm not really sure suffice to say I did enjoy the first season -looking at some of your 9s (since you don't have a lot of 10s): -Death Note, first half was good, wasn't as big on the 2nd half -I've liked what I've seen of FMA, which is the first half of the first series -Not a Miyazaki fan, really disliked Howl's and Spirited Away |
More topics from this board
» How would you react if the above user confessed to you? v5 ( 1 2 3 4 )Kunii - Jun 18 |
192 |
by Daniel_cr99
»»
9 minutes ago |
|
» Yes or No? v7 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Kunii - Sep 13, 2024 |
7658 |
by Daniel_cr99
»»
10 minutes ago |
|
» Give the user above a significant other from MAL v.13 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Kunii - Nov 27, 2024 |
2305 |
by JoshBoy
»»
11 minutes ago |
|
» Harshly judge the user above you based on their Last List Updates v.13 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )-DxP- - Jul 4, 2024 |
9026 |
by JoshBoy
»»
12 minutes ago |
|
» Would you watch it?Shizuna - 39 minutes ago |
2 |
by Otakupervert890
»»
18 minutes ago |