Is It Wrong to Try to Pick Up Girls in a Dungeon? (light novel)
SAO or DanMachi?
Sword art online
14.0%
83
Dungeon ni Deai wo Motomeru no wa Machigatteiru Darou ka
50.4%
299
None
14.8%
88
Both
20.7%
123
593 votes
| Dungeon, for me, is far better than SAO. More entertaining, more engaging, more 'wow' moments, and it was just more fun. And Syr. Oh, yeah. She'd own anyone in SAO. Magic .50 caliber bullet. (You saw the hole in that tree, right?). I'll make sure I'm on her side. |
| The sword that takes life gives life |
TheGrandSage23 said: I love how you claim that it's a "non bias standpoint" when HaXXspetten said: I might have still sided with SAO but after the utter disaster of a cringeworthy drama that Mother's Rosario was.... ehhh I think I prefer Danmachi overall at this point. Also Bell and Hestia make up an infinitely better main duo than Kirito and Asuna (or Shino if you want) From a non bias standpoint. Sinon and Kirito were massively better than Hestia and Bell. Their interactions weren't cringeworthy and their chemistry was actually good. I can't even see how you can get that impression that Hestia/Bell were a better duo. 1) Kirito has 4 times the number of episode Bell has in your comparison. If you compare kirito's evolution after 13 episodes compared to Bell, Bell is actually better, from a... non bias standpoint. :) 2)You use purposely Hestia as a comparison to sinon, whereas you should use Lili if you want to compare with Sinon. and again, in 13 episodes only. Again, lili's evolution is far better than is Sinon in the first 13 episodes of the s2 from a... non bias standpoint again. :) |
 |
Zefyris said: TheGrandSage23 said: I love how you claim that it's a "non bias standpoint" when From a non bias standpoint. Sinon and Kirito were massively better than Hestia and Bell. Their interactions weren't cringeworthy and their chemistry was actually good. I can't even see how you can get that impression that Hestia/Bell were a better duo. 1) Kirito has 4 times the number of episode Bell has in your comparison. If you compare kirito's evolution after 13 episodes compared to Bell, Bell is actually better, from a... non bias standpoint. :) 2)You use purposely Hestia as a comparison to sinon, whereas you should use Lili if you want to compare with Sinon. and again, in 13 episodes only. Again, lili's evolution is far better than is Sinon in the first 13 episodes of the s2 from a... non bias standpoint again. :) "You purposely used Hestia as a comparison to Sinon" because it was part of the debate as Lili wasnt and even then saying Lili's evolution is better than Sinon's is objectively false. Using your argument GGO was Sinon's story. Lili's was wrapped up in 2 episodes at best and it was lackluster as most of this adaptation especially compared to the novels However the amount of episodes doesn't matter everytime. I've seen better characters in just 3 episodes because of how they are handled. This is not the case. Both bell and Kirito aren't even decent characters but Hestia and Bell are not better than Kirito and Sinon |
TheBigGuy said: TheGrandSage23 said: From a non bias standpoint. Sinon and Kirito were massively better than Hestia and Bell. Their interactions weren't cringeworthy and their chemistry was actually good. I can't even see how you can get that impression that Hestia/Bell were a better duo. In which way is the interaction between Bell and Hestia cringeworthy? Okay, she is a bit overprotective and overly jealous. But, that is understandable, because he was the first child of her familia and she is romantically interested in him. I like SAO also, but relationships are better handled in Danmachi in my opinion. 1) Because both Hestia and Bell aren't actually good characters 2) Hestia's personslity wears thin after 5 episodes. That's cringeworthy. If Hestia's character is there for being fanservice and their to be harem girl 101 then she has no use 3) they don't really have chemistry and barely have screentime "Relationships are better handled in Danmachi" Like I've said before Shit with sprinkles is still shit |
TheGrandSage23 said: TheBigGuy said: In which way is the interaction between Bell and Hestia cringeworthy? Okay, she is a bit overprotective and overly jealous. But, that is understandable, because he was the first child of her familia and she is romantically interested in him. I like SAO also, but relationships are better handled in Danmachi in my opinion. 1) Because both Hestia and Bell aren't actually good characters 2) Hestia's personslity wears thin after 5 episodes. That's cringeworthy. If Hestia's character is there for being fanservice and their to be harem girl 101 then she has no use 3) they don't really have chemistry and barely have screentime "Relationships are better handled in Danmachi" Like I've said before Shit with sprinkles is still shit Well said, what's interesting about Hestia anyway? I only saw in this 13 episodes "Bell-kun, Bell-kun" and her acts of jealousy. So can someone tell me WHAT IS INTERESTING IN HER PERSONALITY? cause I found none only traits of child - possesivness, overjealousy, recklesness and rushness to do stupid things" Only bad traits for me her good would be only "protectivness" nothing more... since all the other stuff she got is thanks to Bell. Her body isn't enough for me to fall for her, like you horny brats which I am sure can't get a girlfriend in real life, so you must fap to characters like her. Please don't disturb yourselves failures :] |
 |
TheGrandSage23 said: Zefyris said: I love how you claim that it's a "non bias standpoint" when 1) Kirito has 4 times the number of episode Bell has in your comparison. If you compare kirito's evolution after 13 episodes compared to Bell, Bell is actually better, from a... non bias standpoint. :) 2)You use purposely Hestia as a comparison to sinon, whereas you should use Lili if you want to compare with Sinon. and again, in 13 episodes only. Again, lili's evolution is far better than is Sinon in the first 13 episodes of the s2 from a... non bias standpoint again. :) "You purposely used Hestia as a comparison to Sinon" because it was part of the debate as Lili wasnt and even then saying Lili's evolution is better than Sinon's is objectively false. Using your argument GGO was Sinon's story. Lili's was wrapped up in 2 episodes at best and it was lackluster as most of this adaptation especially compared to the novels However the amount of episodes doesn't matter everytime. I've seen better characters in just 3 episodes because of how they are handled. This is not the case. Both bell and Kirito aren't even decent characters but Hestia and Bell are not better than Kirito and Sinon in 13 episodes, Sinon hasn't evolved as much as Lili did. Again, you're taking sinon on the whole course of S2. (and even then, it's very arguable). Sinon wasn't part of the debate either. It was Asuna. YOU brought Sinon as a comparison. I say okay, but then compare her to Lili instead. Because this is a far more logical choice considering the position both characters were.(in trouble, saved by the mc and falling in love but without being seen by the mc as a love target, and so on). More episode= more time for development. Stop being extremely BIASED while claiming you're not, this is unsightly. |
|
| Like some ppl stated earlier this topic shouldn't even be created. If you want to know which is better check score ratings of both, even this doesn't really matter as both of the shows are pretty good in their genre, except some boring characters without development or too much focus on 1 of the characters. |
|
LastChapter said: Now let's head off to the Shokugeki no Souma board and make a "Shokugeki no Souma or Gintama" thread. Better yet, "JoJo or Fairy Tail." >.> If it's similar to Gintama I'm going to watch it :D  |
 |
| Overlord |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| I prefer DanMachi. I loved the first half; first season of SAO, after that it just went downhill. For me, I felt DanMachi the same as I did with SAO's first season's half, and it continued throughout the whole series. So yeah, DanMachi! Edit: Although, I hope to see Bell man up a bit more if there were be a second season. |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| Danmachi a shit. |
 |
| They're both plebtraps but if I had to pick, danmachi. |
| DanMachi, simply as (unlike SAO) you can't wright an entiere book about its plot hloes and why they make no sence |
| DanMachi for many reasons. SAO wasn't the least exciting to watch compared to DanMachi which has a nice plot, interesting characters, better fights/foes and just a lot more in general. The only thing I'd change about DanMachi would be the whole Harem crap. But SAO is a whole different story, it's a nolife experiment gone bad. The whole adventure in it is so fake and if anyone has ever worked on game development (even better on VR games) knows that this story has 100000 flaws. |
nastyolroshiNov 1, 2015 1:03 AM
| "Have faith in the Lord Fifth, gain eternal life! When the Lord Fifth appears, who dares to cause strife!" |
teflonpan said: DanMichi is basically SAO lite. I really liked both anime but I think SAO covered a lot more ground and went way more in-depth even in just the first thirteen episodes. Are you suggesting that DanMachi should evolve more than it already did in that first season? If that's the case, I disagree with ya. The whole season was already rushed and skipped a lot of things that were mentioned in the LN between Volumes 1-5. Also how exactly does SAO cover a lot more ground in the first 13 Episodes? If SAO would end at the 13th Episode the whole story would fall apart and almost everything would stay unanswered. SAO maybe worked better because it was a given that it would get an additional 12 episodes at that point. I can't see how DanMachi is SAO lite version. The only thing they have in common is Dungeon Exploration. Other than that, they are completely different. |
nastyolroshiNov 1, 2015 1:21 AM
| "Have faith in the Lord Fifth, gain eternal life! When the Lord Fifth appears, who dares to cause strife!" |
| If I had to pick one I'll say DanMachi, cause I can't do SAO lol but I prefer neither in all honesty lol |
| Both are pretty bad |
 |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Dungeon ni Deai wo Motomeru no wa Machigatteiru Darou ka Episode 11 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )Stark700 - Jun 12, 2015 |
239 |
by Zotezha
»»
Sep 8, 10:12 PM |
|
Poll: » Dungeon ni Deai wo Motomeru no wa Machigatteiru Darou ka Episode 2 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )belatkuro - Apr 10, 2015 |
281 |
by Someone813
»»
Jun 1, 9:07 PM |
|
Poll: » Dungeon ni Deai wo Motomeru no wa Machigatteiru Darou ka Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )belatkuro - Apr 3, 2015 |
467 |
by mortelenta
»»
May 25, 6:23 AM |
|
Poll: » Dungeon ni Deai wo Motomeru no wa Machigatteiru Darou ka Episode 8 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - May 22, 2015 |
423 |
by MaciasA-15
»»
May 11, 5:38 PM |
|
» danmachi 10th anniversary visualdeg - Apr 4 |
6 |
by Abdur-Rauf
»»
Apr 4, 8:49 PM |