| Are you trying to beat the record of pointless threads? You're quickly catching up to Lupadim lol |
| 5 main aspects I base my ratings on: 1. Did DramaEnthusiast make a thread about it? 2. Is it better than Breaking Bad? 3. Did MellowJello recommend the shit out of it? 4. Has it caused a (very entertaining) shitstorm on MAL? 5. Is it actually good? Scratch the fifth point, it's not very relevant... |
| Believe me, this thread is going to get heated quite easily with all the FANaticS we have on MAL. |
| Aliis si licet, tibi non licet. |
| Threads keep on becoming lamer and lamer as time passes. |
miereneronaile said: I dont like any characters but yang, and he cant carry a 110 episode show entirely on his own. Don't worry, he doesnt! LoGH is in the top 5. So LoGH it is. FMA Brotherhood is good but I wouldn't put it in a top 5. I haven't watched Gintama, so I can't tell. I haven't seen Clannad After Story, but I've seen the beginning of Clannad which was very similar to LB that is nearer to a the worst 5 than the top 50 in my opinion, so I really have low expectations on Clannad After Story, and chances are high I would never watch it considering how I despice the first episodes of the prequel. I also tried to watch Steins;Gate but I fell asleep because nothing was happening, and the character weren't interesting enough for me. So yeah, LoGH. |
| LOGH any day of the week. Least Deserving Steins;Gate, not that it was bad, but FMA and Gintama are better and Clannad AS is more relevant for its genre than Steins;Gate is, imo. |
| I probably regret this post by now. |
| Inferno Cop. |
| deserves its place Legend of the Galactic Heroes - has an amazing an engaging plot, the best cast of characters ive seen on any anime so far, some epic death scenes an probably the best episode ive seen yet, dat ep 82 Steins gate - has a very good cast of characters an the second half is very engaging, the soundtrack is great, the animation very good animation... i cant find much flaws on this one neutral Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood - it s a very good anime but the start is rushed an uninteresting, im not talking about a couple of eps but like 10 of them, imo enough to not be deserving of its place but after that i loved so i can see it being in the top 5 doesnt deserve its place Gintama' - 50 episodes with 0 plot progression (except for a lame cameo of the main villain at the very end, probably as a reminder that he still alive), some boring "serious" arcs (the Elizabeth arc is imo the worst gintama arc yet), to make matters worse the jokes werent even funny an Gintama doesnt have much else going for it Clannad: After Story only liked about 5 eps, around ep 16-20, the rest was meh an the ending man that was terrible |
 |
| >Gintama >Plot progression Naruhodo. "The jokes weren't funny" - You should go ahead and post that in the unpopular opinions thread. |
 |
| Gintama |
 "Only one with the courage to shoulder the burden of their own fate can be called a hero.." |
Candor said: Gintama' silversaint said: When was Gintama about plot-progression? The series was always about the comedy, and that season had the best comedy (and animation) in the whole series). If you want plot-progression continue Enchousen, since you dropped it just before an arc with some major events.doesnt deserve its place Gintama' - 50 episodes with 0 plot progression (except for a lame cameo of the main villain at the very end, probably as a reminder that he still alive), some boring "serious" arcs (the Elizabeth arc is imo the worst gintama arc yet), to make matters worse the jokes werent even funny an Gintama doesnt have much else going for it He hates the characters, so there's not much point in him continuing watching the latest season, anyway. It's mind-boggling how these people can sit through nearly 300 episodes of a show that they hate. |
|
| All of them are out of place, except for clannad. The top 5 should obviously be: 1 - Clannad 2 - Clannad: AS 3 - One Piece 4 - Kaiji 5 - Trigun Anyone who thinks I am wrong is wrong. Now seriously: GTFO Gintama. |
 |
lupadim said: All of them are out of place, except for clannad. The top 5 should obviously be: 1 - Clannad 2 - Clannad: AS 3 - One Piece 4 - Kaiji 5 - Trigun Anyone who thinks I am wrong is wrong. Now seriously: GTFO Gintama. What happened to Hunter x Hunter? |
|
Polychrome said: lupadim said: All of them are out of place, except for clannad. The top 5 should obviously be: 1 - Clannad 2 - Clannad: AS 3 - One Piece 4 - Kaiji 5 - Trigun Anyone who thinks I am wrong is wrong. Now seriously: GTFO Gintama. What happened to Hunter x Hunter? Forgot it exists. Ok, instead of Trigun, can be Hunter x Hunter. But HxH 2011 is decaying so much. This, or maybe my mind changed after watching Clannad and I start to expect too much from anime. |
|
miereneronaile said: lupadim said: Polychrome said: lupadim said: All of them are out of place, except for clannad. The top 5 should obviously be: 1 - Clannad 2 - Clannad: AS 3 - One Piece 4 - Kaiji 5 - Trigun Anyone who thinks I am wrong is wrong. Now seriously: GTFO Gintama. What happened to Hunter x Hunter? Forgot it exists. Ok, instead of Trigun, can be Hunter x Hunter. But HxH 2011 is decaying so much. This, or maybe my mind changed after watching Clannad and I start to expect too much from anime. The fact you forgot it should pretty much instantly show you it doesnt deserve a spot in your top 5 /shrug.. Nah, it deserves. I kind of forget constantly about anime that are still airing. |
|
Candor said: That's what I'm wondering, how he reached this far.Polychrome said: When was Gintama about plot-progression? The series was always about the comedy, and that season had the best comedy (and animation) in the whole series). If you want plot-progression continue Enchousen, since you dropped it just before an arc with some major events. He hates the characters, so there's not much point in him continuing watching the latest season, anyway. It's mind-boggling how these people can sit through nearly 300 episodes of an episodic show that they hate. i was expecting some sort of response from some gintama fans, anyways i dont remember saying that i hate all the characters, i like Kamui (even though he hasnt done anything amazing so far), Katsura an a few more... i do hate some like Kagura an particularly Shinpachi who is one of the most f*cking annoying characters ive had the misfortune of encountering, how i got there? 1 episode a week isnt much is it? its not something id do again though an i dont care about completing it even if theres only a few eps left since im sure that theres going to be more Gintama soon |
|
miereneronaile said: lupadim said: miereneronaile said: The fact you forgot it should pretty much instantly show you it doesnt deserve a spot in your top 5 /shrug.. Nah, it deserves. I kind of forget constantly about anime that are still airing. /Shrug, if you say so. The idea of 'forgetting' one of my top 5 anime is simply incomprehensible to me. If you watch only one episode of such anime each week, it is comprehensible. BTW, this happened: http://prntscr.com/1wu7tx |
AversaOct 12, 2013 12:16 PM
|
| I'm pretty sure you already made this topic before, meh. They are all shit as in they doesn't deserve to be that high. It's beyond me why any of them are this high especially FMA:B and Gintama. Initially I was okay and I can understand why Gintama is loved. The comedy is getting better and the characters are great especially Gin-san but the more I watch the more I notice that the stories are so fucking terrible, I'm talking about those little story arcs that come once in a while. They feel like they were some stories that was rejected by Shounen Jump and the author of Gintama just mixed them up and added comedy to them, so generic, cliche and predictable. I'm gonna go ahead and skip the next ''serious'' arc, Gintama shines in their everyday funny episodes. Steins gate: Kurisu does not deserve 7117 favorites. LOGH: I guess it is there because some people made troll accounts to up vote it. It's ranked high in the first place because of how MAL rating system works and because it's just doesn't look appealing to so many people in so many levels. No wonder it only has 29,871 members. Clannad: AS: Mediocre shit. .-. Stop the shit quote towers. |
 |
miereneronaile said: People with Naruto as a favorite calling those shows undeserving blows my mind. That is all. Yeah let's play the ''you have x in you favorites therefore y'' that's always fun and totally valid :3 Remove the quote towers from your previous posts please. |
|
| I can't really comment on LOGH, but as for the other 4, they don't even deserve top 50. |
Dubs>subs. Breaking Bad>Anime Comic books>manga 99% of Anime is Garbage |
| logic behind this thread: "it doesn't deserve its place cuz I don't like it. The top 5 on MAL should be the my top 5 favorite" and because of this logic, I say screw the top 5 except for Steins;Gate |
Hoshino_MariaOct 12, 2013 8:13 AM
| The more deserved? Gintama' easily |
 |
pralan said: The more deserved? Gintama' easily Pretty much it |
| Gutalala ~~ sudalala "It would be great to live as a human" -Meruem, King of the Ants |
MajinSaga said: I can't really comment on LOGH, but as for the other 4, they don't even deserve top 50. You can't really judge when the only one you've seen is FMA Brotherhood |
| I think Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood, Clannad After Story, and Steins;Gate all deserve to be top 5. As for the order, I believe Steins;Gate should be number 1, Brotherhood number 5, and After Story as number 2. That's just how I would rank them. I can't comment on the other 2 because I haven't seen them, but I think Gintama is probably overrated from what I've heard, and the little I have seen. |
 |
JD2411 said: MajinSaga said: I can't really comment on LOGH, but as for the other 4, they don't even deserve top 50. You can't really judge when the only one you've seen is FMA Brotherhood Not on the list doesn't mean I haven't watched it. Quit being such a tool. |
Dubs>subs. Breaking Bad>Anime Comic books>manga 99% of Anime is Garbage |
| 1. FMA Brotherhood: Well written for what it is but still nothing exceptional. 2003 is better. 2. Gintama': Haven't seen it 3. Steins;Gate: Fun but very flawed. Least deserving of its spot from what I've seen 4. Clannad AS: Most deserving of its spot from what I've seen but still overrated. Kanon is better 5. LOGH: Haven't seen it, probably overrated So my vote goes for Clannad AS |
 |
| Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood and Steins;Gate for sure. |
 |
| I think all of them deserve to be rated high. If I go the opposite, the one I think should isn't justified to be in the spot is Gintama'. I don't believe it's very much better than the first series, I wouldn't mind if it was near the first series though. |
     Short of the day: Monotonous Purgatory(MAL) ✰Public Domain Club | One Piece Club✰ |
Paul said: Inferno Cop. The fact that there a shows ranked higher than this shows how truly flawed MAL's rating system is. |
 |
RapiDSnake said: TOP 5: 1- Dragon Ball Z 2- One Piece 3- Naruto Shippuden 4- Hunter X Hunter 5- Gintama ---------------------------------------------------------- Don't fucking compare a 12 episode Anime with an ongoing Anime that has at least 10 time the amount of episodes. Come at me bro. I wasn't aware that Hunter X Hunter had at least 120 episodes, |
|
RapiDSnake said: TOP 5: 1- Dragon Ball Z 2- One Piece 3- Naruto Shippuden 4- Hunter X Hunter 5- Gintama ---------------------------------------------------------- Don't fucking compare a 12 episode Anime with an ongoing Anime that has at least 10 time the amount of episodes. Come at me bro. None of the top 5 has 12 episodes though? |
|
| Legend of the Galactic Heroes is probably the only justified one. FMA: Brotherhood is really good, but number 1? Come on.... All of the other shows in the top 5 definitely do not deserve the spot (except Gintama, I'm not sure what to think of it). But, based on a large consensus of tastes, some may deserve higher spots. |
| получить деньги моего друга |
drinkbeer said: i feel odd seeing Logh in the top 5. maybe because old anime isn't my cup of tea however i suppose it must be a pretty good anime since its in the top 5. as for the rest i am fine with it. but i feel that one piece should be the #1 LOL at one piece as number 1. |
Dubs>subs. Breaking Bad>Anime Comic books>manga 99% of Anime is Garbage |
| FMA:B is a fantastic show to be sure, but wouldn't say it's worth #1, top 10 is definitely justified at least. I've only seen about a third of Gintama's first season so I can't say much for the episodes that far in but as far as I understand it only gets better so it probably deserves to be pretty high, however for what is almost purely a comedy to be #2 seems very overkill to me. Steins is probably the most deserved one of the top 5, it's such a perfect story that you can't really dislike it, also the characters are amazing. After Story's not really what I would call objectively amazing, however the emotional impact towards the end is so insane that it'll always be what you think of first when it comes to series of its kind. Have not seen Ginga but if it's true that it's the Star Wars of anime, then it probably should be quite high up there. Rough rearrangment would from my perspective would prob be like this, but I can't really say if LotGH should be higher or not, but it wouldn't surprise me if it should. 1. Steins;Gate 2. Clannad: AS 3. FMA:B 4. Ginga Eiyuu Densetsu 5. Gintama' |
  |
MajinSaga said: http://fc02.deviantart.net/fs71/f/2011/325/3/d/luffy_is_become_pirate_king_by_hamid91-d4gvfqx.jpgdrinkbeer said: i feel odd seeing Logh in the top 5. maybe because old anime isn't my cup of tea however i suppose it must be a pretty good anime since its in the top 5. as for the rest i am fine with it. but i feel that one piece should be the #1 LOL at one piece as number 1. |
Short of the day: Monotonous Purgatory(MAL) ✰Public Domain Club | One Piece Club✰ |
| Gintama doesn't deserve being in the top 100 from what I've watched. |
Xinisterad said: Gintama doesn't deserve being in the top 100 from what I've watched. How much you watched?, until 20-50 episodes is shit, so that is accurate |
|
| Honestly, I think that it really depends on what you enjoy, but being who I am, I would say that FMA: Brotherhood and LotGH deserve to be in the top five (Even though I am a huge fan of Steins;Gate). FMA: Brotherhood has such a well crafted story with so many emotions floating around it. There's heavy moral themes, relations to dehumanization, strong characters, a very deep plot, and more twists that a fucking curly fry. It's a very well-rounded anime that holds: Comedy, Action, Drama, Psychological Influence, Supernatural, and Fantasy as a few of its most prominent genres, and it represents them well. LotGH Is a well-crafted anime with brilliant characters, depth, and an ingenious plot-line. I would recommend this anime to almost anyone (Given that I assumed they'd try it), and I think that it definitely deserves the spot it's at. Alright, time for the others. Steins;Gate is one of my all-time favorite anime, but it is more of a top 15 anime in my mind. It has quite a slow start, and a few plot holes that kind of tear it apart, so I'd like to see it bumped down at least a little bit. Clannad: After Story I've never really been a fan of the Clannad series, for it tended to just lump a bunch of mix-and-matched plot devices together into a "drama" in an attempt to attract many different fans. Leading to people like me disliking it on the basis that the writing cam across as rushed, poorly thought-through, and full of ass-pulls. In Clannad: After Story, the only real thing they do is try to cover up these detrimental writing flaws with a tearjerking story. I would rather see this in the 150-200 spot than anything else, but that's just my two cents. Gintama' is not my kind of humor at all. It's redundant, dry, and requires way too much cultural understanding to get through. I'd prefer to see something like DMC in it's place. That may just be me though. Yeah, that's about it. |
| It's natural for a person to deny he's a failure as a human being. That's why he searches for somebody who is more miserable than himself. That's why so much animosity exists on the internet. Those who aren't able to find a more miserable person, turn to the internet and call other people losers, even though they've never met. Just to make themselves feel superior. isn't that pathetic? There's a sense of security that comes from speaking badly of someone else. But that isn't true salvation. — Tatsuhiro Satou YandereTheEmo said: The only thing more pathetic than quoting someone you know nothing about, is quoting yourself. |
More topics from this board
» What are or is your favorite Anime song? ( 1 2 )ApfelMyName - May 18 |
81 |
by WatchTillTandava
»»
2 minutes ago |
|
» How would you "Zero to hero" someone into anime? ( 1 2 )thewiru - Oct 26 |
63 |
by thewiru
»»
5 minutes ago |
|
» How to care about, recognize and appreciate writing, cinematography, animation, etc? ( 1 2 )thewiru - Oct 26 |
78 |
by Lucifrost
»»
6 minutes ago |
|
» Anime that was never fully adapted but you wish had continued?Vic270 - Today |
33 |
by WatchTillTandava
»»
7 minutes ago |
|
» Do you know any characters that people misunderstand?RobertBobert - Oct 23 |
42 |
by mr_linear
»»
17 minutes ago |