Ningen Shikkaku General Discussion

Agramon said:
I only find 2 chapters of the series, does anyone know where i can read the whole thing?

Agramon said:
Lucky you.

waalex11 said:
I don't remember exactly how I felt about the anime adaption, and I've never read the novel yet, so I can't compare, but having now read the first manga adaption and just learning that this is also an unfaithful flawed adaption to the original novel is somewhat disappointing.

If I ever read it, I'm not sure how much I would truly like it from its plots of Youzou's life, but I think it's at least decent, and intriguing to me at first from his psychology of being fake and lying to how conflicted he truly feels, and how he goes about life.
The first manga adaption was mediocre, even if it had some good elements to the tone and his mentality, on occasion.

This second manga adaption is "better", but frankly also mediocre.
The flow of the story flows- not flawlessly, but more naturally compared to the first adapation. The plots are clearer, but I was right to think that adaption also lacks the full depth of the novel since it didn't have every thought of Youzou, and having read a thread on here, skipped out on other events.

I think the overall atmosphere and aesthetic and the art of his imagination, then later delusion is at least decent, and arguably very good, but for me... without more insight to his mindset of the people he meets, it felt amiss when comparing to the good of the first adaption.

My biggest critiscm of the first adaption was that it didn't feel believable.
Now I understand better that it was because it was poorly paced and condensed to the timeline by completely skipping out on proper introduction and passage of time.
I'm still not sure how I feel about Youzou's life is in judging how good or bad it is as a story since I haven't experience the source novel, but even though this adaption feels better than the first, it's still flawed for not revealing the full core of the novel. 4/10.