Attack on Titan
DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
| There's no justification for Eren being on fire. Even if it's a stylistic choice it's retarded and makes no sense. Why? Why did you set Eren on fire Mr. Araki? Levi using 3DMG was beyond stupid. The way they revealed the titan in the wall was utterly terrible and also makes no sense considering how that scene plays out in the manga. So, what, is everyone going to see it now? The only anime-original choice I liked in the episode was Annie's meth addict face. That was really well done. Of course it was semi-ruined by FIRE EREN hopping about but that's just how things are I suppose. All in all I'll give this adaptation a 6/10. Inconsistent. |
 |
Pipoko said: Amarrez said: Pipoko said: Amarrez said: Darklight0303 said: Amarrez said: I am so fucking mad right now, you have no idea. I've defended some of the changes the anime has made up to this point, but they just took a massive shit on the manga and I'm quite annoyed. Eren as some kind of wacky fire titan are you serious? Well, at least they still managed to get the reveal in at the end, even if it felt a bit pathetic. God damn it they fucking blew it. Was it really fire though? It could have been artistic license to show off the aura he's giving off? There was fire coming off his body. And he turned black. Did you see it? It was beyond retarded. The thing is, it was only a stylistic thing, it didn't make him stronger, nor change the outcome of the fight. Yes it did. Did you not see him throwing Annie around like a ragdoll after he went super saiyan (it hurts to type, but it's what happened)? And the retarded part where an INJURED LEVI has to stop him from EATING ANNIE. And the whole point of Eren's titan form is that it's supposed to be much more normal looking than the other shifters, not a god damn fire demi-god. The only part of this episode I liked was how they handled Annie climbing the wall, it was quite sympathetic. That's it. I also saw him throwing annie like a ragdoll in the forest fight. Yes, Levi went in, but that's their justification for doing the fire thing. Otherwise nothing else changed. They just wanted to give it a "final battle" vibe. I checked up with the manga chapter - most of the scenes Eren-titan is really drawn black-shaded compared to Annie. For comparison, in the forest fight they are approximately the same and the black shades on two of them are much less. Hello, chapter 50 ... |
zellami said: Pipoko said: Amarrez said: Pipoko said: Amarrez said: Darklight0303 said: Amarrez said: I am so fucking mad right now, you have no idea. I've defended some of the changes the anime has made up to this point, but they just took a massive shit on the manga and I'm quite annoyed. Eren as some kind of wacky fire titan are you serious? Well, at least they still managed to get the reveal in at the end, even if it felt a bit pathetic. God damn it they fucking blew it. Was it really fire though? It could have been artistic license to show off the aura he's giving off? There was fire coming off his body. And he turned black. Did you see it? It was beyond retarded. The thing is, it was only a stylistic thing, it didn't make him stronger, nor change the outcome of the fight. Yes it did. Did you not see him throwing Annie around like a ragdoll after he went super saiyan (it hurts to type, but it's what happened)? And the retarded part where an INJURED LEVI has to stop him from EATING ANNIE. And the whole point of Eren's titan form is that it's supposed to be much more normal looking than the other shifters, not a god damn fire demi-god. The only part of this episode I liked was how they handled Annie climbing the wall, it was quite sympathetic. That's it. I also saw him throwing annie like a ragdoll in the forest fight. Yes, Levi went in, but that's their justification for doing the fire thing. Otherwise nothing else changed. They just wanted to give it a "final battle" vibe. I checked up with the manga chapter - most of the scenes Eren-titan is really drawn black-shaded compared to Annie. For comparison, in the forest fight they are approximately the same and the black shades on two of them are much less. Hello, chapter 50 ... Gonna laugh my ass off if he goes fire mode next chapter |
zellami said: Pipoko said: Amarrez said: Pipoko said: Amarrez said: Darklight0303 said: Amarrez said: I am so fucking mad right now, you have no idea. I've defended some of the changes the anime has made up to this point, but they just took a massive shit on the manga and I'm quite annoyed. Eren as some kind of wacky fire titan are you serious? Well, at least they still managed to get the reveal in at the end, even if it felt a bit pathetic. God damn it they fucking blew it. Was it really fire though? It could have been artistic license to show off the aura he's giving off? There was fire coming off his body. And he turned black. Did you see it? It was beyond retarded. The thing is, it was only a stylistic thing, it didn't make him stronger, nor change the outcome of the fight. Yes it did. Did you not see him throwing Annie around like a ragdoll after he went super saiyan (it hurts to type, but it's what happened)? And the retarded part where an INJURED LEVI has to stop him from EATING ANNIE. And the whole point of Eren's titan form is that it's supposed to be much more normal looking than the other shifters, not a god damn fire demi-god. The only part of this episode I liked was how they handled Annie climbing the wall, it was quite sympathetic. That's it. I also saw him throwing annie like a ragdoll in the forest fight. Yes, Levi went in, but that's their justification for doing the fire thing. Otherwise nothing else changed. They just wanted to give it a "final battle" vibe. I checked up with the manga chapter - most of the scenes Eren-titan is really drawn black-shaded compared to Annie. For comparison, in the forest fight they are approximately the same and the black shades on two of them are much less. I know this is going to seem like a ridiculous excuse, but some of those chapters were very poorly scanlated and the leveling is way off. If you look at the Eren vs Annie fights in the volume raws they're the same colour. |
|
| I just realized that they had Mikasa pull Eren away from the titan instead of Armin. They're really pushing that ship, huh? |
|
| Season 2 needs to start with a remake of this episode. |
Amarrez said: zellami said: Pipoko said: Amarrez said: Pipoko said: Amarrez said: Darklight0303 said: Amarrez said: I am so fucking mad right now, you have no idea. I've defended some of the changes the anime has made up to this point, but they just took a massive shit on the manga and I'm quite annoyed. Eren as some kind of wacky fire titan are you serious? Well, at least they still managed to get the reveal in at the end, even if it felt a bit pathetic. God damn it they fucking blew it. Was it really fire though? It could have been artistic license to show off the aura he's giving off? There was fire coming off his body. And he turned black. Did you see it? It was beyond retarded. The thing is, it was only a stylistic thing, it didn't make him stronger, nor change the outcome of the fight. Yes it did. Did you not see him throwing Annie around like a ragdoll after he went super saiyan (it hurts to type, but it's what happened)? And the retarded part where an INJURED LEVI has to stop him from EATING ANNIE. And the whole point of Eren's titan form is that it's supposed to be much more normal looking than the other shifters, not a god damn fire demi-god. The only part of this episode I liked was how they handled Annie climbing the wall, it was quite sympathetic. That's it. I also saw him throwing annie like a ragdoll in the forest fight. Yes, Levi went in, but that's their justification for doing the fire thing. Otherwise nothing else changed. They just wanted to give it a "final battle" vibe. I checked up with the manga chapter - most of the scenes Eren-titan is really drawn black-shaded compared to Annie. For comparison, in the forest fight they are approximately the same and the black shades on two of them are much less. I know this is going to seem like a ridiculous excuse, but some of those chapters were very poorly scanlated and the leveling is way off. If you look at the Eren vs Annie fights in the volume raws they're the same colour. I know and I agree, but I am not offering an excuse for anything. It's just that one panel caught my attention, and you know no one was able to say how really Annie would look like in the anime, judging from the manga. So, this was it, really. I have yet to see the raw. Could you elaborate on the Levi part, because I will definitely agree with here. The major point of this chapter is that Eren can behave in his titan form, Hanji said it herself. Dragging the injured Levi to put breaks on Eren is hell of inconsistency. |
Daw11 said: Season 2 needs to start with a remake of this episode. Season 2 doesn't need to start at all. What we need is SnK: Titanhood. |
|
| Worst ending ever. 1/10 dropped. |
Amarrez said: Daw11 said: Season 2 needs to start with a remake of this episode. Season 2 doesn't need to start at all. What we need is SnK: Titanhood. So just cause of one episode they should remake the whole first season. >_> That's being unreasonable and you know it. |
| Damn! That fight was fucking brutal! I loved it! They made some small changes and re arranged some events, but that's alright. It was right move, this is the end of the season after all. And it will be at least least one year until next one, so this finale is well done. |
 |
Darklight0303 said: Amarrez said: Daw11 said: Season 2 needs to start with a remake of this episode. Season 2 doesn't need to start at all. What we need is SnK: Titanhood. So just cause of one episode they should remake the whole first season. >_> That's being unreasonable and you know it. They're going to need to retcon about half of this episode to do a second season. Also, wasn't the whole point of Levi's character in these chapters the fact that even though he wants to, he can't avenge his comrades due to his injury? Lol, no, let's just have him be the Deus Ex Manlet and save the day. Fujoshit pandering if I've ever seen it. |
|
| Anyone who thinks at least, know that they would change something. I expected more from the last episode, but everyone expected more, think well, this anime was great, I honestly don't know what I expected... but I expected some thing... I think this is the problem, this anime was so good, we expected something even better... but whatever... I want a second season. 10/10 I will not change anything only because this episode. The entire anime compared to other animes I have seen lately, was much better. Now I continue reading the manga. I'm waiting for chapter 50... I can't wait for read this :) |
| english isn't my native language... ;) |
Amarrez said: Snip Then why make Titanhood when only one episode needs to be fixed? >_> |
| 7/10, subpar adaption Too many (bad) fillers, horrible pacing, disappointing production values. I know WIT had several problems, especially time issues, but this doesn’t make things better. |
Darklight0303 said: Amarrez said: Snip Then why make Titanhood when only one episode needs to be fixed? >_> Any excuse to get Araki's ass off the staff. |
|
| Rating 5/5 by default. Can't wait to watch later on. |
 |
Surysasuri said: 7/10, subpar adaption Too many (bad) fillers, horrible pacing, disappointing production values. I know WIT had several problems, especially time issues, but this doesn’t make things better. if u think was all that bad watch naruto maybe u'll change your mind being myself a manga reader i enjoyed the episode even with the few changes |
The spider is watching |
| My God! Some things people bitch and complain about and reasonings it's just....Sad....So sad *agonizing facepalm* It's not that Eren can't control his Titan form. He can't control himslef. I'm sure you people noticed by now, and those who read manga that Eren might not be quite right in the head. When he's consumed with rage, there's no stopping him. That guy has some legit psycho problems xD He can control his titan form in a sense that he'a able to stay conscious while transformed. Unlike the first time he transformed on his own ( to fix breach in the wall) where he was basically asleep. |
|
Yuushin7 said: My God! Some things people bitch and complain about and reasonings it's just....Sad....So sad *agonizing facepalm* It's not that Eren can't control his Titan form. He can't control himslef. I'm sure you people noticed by now, and those who read manga that Eren might not be quite right in the head. When he's consumed with rage, there's no stopping him. But in the manga he did control himself during this fight, it was a major turning point for his character. That was the whole god damn point. However, clearly Eren's character boils down to "HURR MAD AS HELL". |
|
| Needs mawr Bert |
 |
| Should've at least had Erwin or someone else cut Eren out of the titan instead of Levi since he's supposed to be hurt. |
 |
| Okay, so could someone sum up for me what did they change, since it looks like a whole fandom is raging? I'm not able to watch this ep right now but I'm curious ;o |
Alzea said: Okay, so could someone sum up for me what did they change, since it looks like a whole fandom is raging? I'm not able to watch this ep right now but I'm curious ;o I'll try to sum up all the changes from memory, both good and bad. Mostly bad. - Mikasa doesn't discover the titans in the wall. It happens later when no one is around to see it. Hanji, Armin and Pastor Nick do not learn of it. - Eren turns into a fire titan. - Levi uses 3DMG despite his injury to cut Eren out of his titan when he attempts to eat Annie (another change). - Before she turns into a crystal, Annie cries. - Instead of being thrown up to Annie by an in control Eren, Mikasa just uses 3DMG to zip up to Annie instead. There were more, but I've forgotten. The wall reveal and fire shit is the main prickly point, and rightfully so. |
|
Amarrez said: This was in both anime and manga.- Before she turns into a crystal, Annie cries. |
|
Amarrez said: Alzea said: Okay, so could someone sum up for me what did they change, since it looks like a whole fandom is raging? I'm not able to watch this ep right now but I'm curious ;o I'll try to sum up all the changes from memory, both good and bad. Mostly bad. - Mikasa doesn't discover the titans in the wall. It happens later when no one is around to see it. Hanji, Armin and Pastor Nick do not learn of it. - Eren turns into a fire titan. - Levi uses 3DMG despite his injury to cut Eren out of his titan when he attempts to eat Annie (another change). - Before she turns into a crystal, Annie cries. - Instead of being thrown up to Annie by an in control Eren, Mikasa just uses 3DMG to zip up to Annie instead. There were more, but I've forgotten. The wall reveal and fire shit is the main prickly point, and rightfully so. Annie DID cry before the crystal thing in the manga. Also, some characters were switched, Jean was attacking the crystal Annie was in rather than some random Scouting Legion guy and being stopped by Levi rather than Hanji. |
stAtic91 said: Amarrez said: This was in both anime and manga.- Before she turns into a crystal, Annie cries. You're right, but the entire sequence was very different. link removed (chapter 33, page 41) Mod Edit: Please do not link to images on manga reading sites but upload them somewhere else. |
LunaSep 28, 2013 12:06 PM
|
| Now that's a friggin' fail. So sad to give the anime 7/10, but can't help it, they've ruined some of the best moments in the manga. |
| I can see beauty where others see ugliness. That either makes me an artist or a person of very poor taste (с) |
| its nice to watch a lot of people go "rage mode" like Eren after worshiping this anime a lot. OH THE INEVITABILITY OF EXPECTATION. |
| Simplistic beauty can't be appreciated by someone who looks for something grand in everything he watch. |
| Oh alright, Eren not throwing Mikasa is a real bummer. |
| The fire scene was just not right imo. And the wall reveal felt more like a puzzle coming together in the manga. I really wish this series had around 20 episodes and kept a standard pacing. |
| So, What do you think is on the other side? |
| I didn't really like some of the changes they made in this episode, but an amazing series nonetheless. I'm really gonna miss it, and season 2 can't come any sooner. |
| Huh, by not watching it, just reading what you say the worst thing seems to be - Mikasa doesn't discover the titans in the wall. It happens later when no one is around to see it. Hanji, Armin and Pastor Nick do not learn of it. a bit of anti-climatic and they might have problems in s2 but oh well. Thanks for the answers, I'll probably watch it in two days or so and see for myself. Fire-mode Eren sounds funny (but this show or at least this fight shouldn't be funny).Also fangirl mode on: does this mean my baby Hanji gets less screen time? ;__; |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin Episode 24 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Sep 21, 2013 |
921 |
by _akshatts_
»»
4 hours ago |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin Episode 21 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Aug 31, 2013 |
991 |
by kzen_sno
»»
May 10, 10:38 PM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin Episode 3 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )VioLink - Apr 20, 2013 |
851 |
by ozrodger46
»»
May 6, 7:21 AM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin Episode 2 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )VioLink - Apr 13, 2013 |
1035 |
by ozrodger46
»»
May 6, 7:15 AM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Apr 6, 2013 |
1554 |
by bohhhh_ciao
»»
Apr 30, 6:54 AM |